Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why child benefits is means tested in England?Do you agree?

306 replies

ddshocker · 17/02/2022 08:55

Just that really? Why is it means tested in the U.K.? Do you think this is fair considering the financial abuse some women can be suffer even if their dh is a high learner!
In Ireland it's not means tested at all and it is double the U.K. amount...why is the U.K. so adamant in making it unfair!?

OP posts:
Chocolatehorse · 17/02/2022 10:05

Slightly off topic but those who are just over the threshold should check if they can still claim it as it based on taxable income after deductions such as pension contributions. In our household the higher earner put more into pension so that we are below the threshold and can claim the full amount. The lower earner can then put less in the pension pot and keep more of their earnings. We see the pension pot as a shared asset so it'll be shared in the future.

SnipSnipMrBurgess · 17/02/2022 10:04

That's a ridiculous statement.

luxxlisbon · 17/02/2022 10:02

The cap should be relative to household income not an individual salary, however I do think it’s fine that there is a cap. I don’t think child benefit does anything to help women who are financially abused, that isn’t what it is there for and no upper limit wouldn’t really go any way to meaningfully help anyway.

dementedpixie · 17/02/2022 10:02

@HalfShrunkMoreToGo

We're in the position where I'm on more that £50,000, DH is on significantly less than £50,000 so we can't claim it but other households with a combined income of 99,000 could so in that sense it is unfair.
You can claim it. Anyone can claim it. The higher earner would have to pay some or all of it back depending on how much they get paid. Between £50 and £60k you only pay some back and the once you get to £60k it would all get paid back.

We opted out of payment once dh started earning over £60k.

sassbott · 17/02/2022 10:00

Nb. I use ‘rich’ in my PP as that verbiage that drives further divisiveness. Vs. Poor.

It’s awful. And I fear of what more the government will do in this area to remove even more.

Lockdownbear · 17/02/2022 10:00

If they want to use it as a means of population control then cap it at 2 kids. Kids aren't cheap and very often people just above the thresholds do struggle.

Finding work that is "school hours" is easier said than done and often the SAHP is at home because of the irregular and long hours the higher earner works, including people who travel for work away from home for either 1 or 2 nights a week or people who are away for a month at a time with oil industry or at sea.

Ozanj · 17/02/2022 09:59

@AhNowTed

Uk residents look away now..
Ireland? If so I’d expect double the amounts considering the stance on abortion up until recently. Any country that forces women to have babies they don’t want should be paying 100% of the costs.
OchonAgusOchonOh · 17/02/2022 09:59

I'm in Ireland and there is a suggestion in some quarters that it should be taxed. I think that is a reasonable compromise.

That said, they'll never do it. The "stay at home" lobby is very strong here and they would lose too many votes.

sassbott · 17/02/2022 09:58

@ddshocker this narrative that people also have against ‘rich’ claiming CB. The proportion of people who earn £400k (as a PP threw out) is tiny. People need to understand that this saved very little, infact I remember reading that the cost of administering/ implementing it cost far in excess of what the government saved.

It’s a political tool. Being used to create divisiveness. Rich families are judged for their excess and private schools. Benefit claimants are judged for relying on the state.
Rich feel aggrieved at how much tax they pay and how little they utilise it, driving more of a wedge within society.

Keep us infighting between us so we don’t look at what the politicians are doing. How convenient.
Decouple a part of the population (whom because it’s based on income you could argue have influence because of their income) from benefits, is that demographic then going to fight for the benefits system? Or shrug and say ‘not my problem’ when benefits are eroded further?

How more people cannot see this and blithely trot out ‘the high earners don’t need it’. No we don’t, you’re right. But our voices and votes should matter when it comes to provisions for those most vulnerable in society. You can’t have it both ways.

AhNowTed · 17/02/2022 09:57

Uk residents look away now..

To ask why child benefits is means tested in England?Do you agree?
Sockpile · 17/02/2022 09:57

When my children were young things were tight financially and I really relied on my child benefit. As I was in receipt of child benefit I also felt that I was making some financial contribution to the household.

A few years ago we were no longer entitled. I still claim it and DH has to file a tax return to pay it back. In part it’s out of principle, child benefit is often paid to a SAHM who has no other income of her own and it can be the only financial independence they have.

AchillesPoirot · 17/02/2022 09:56

It is uk wide. At the current time that includes Northern Ireland Hmm

Ozanj · 17/02/2022 09:56

@saleorbouy

KarmaStar But did it go to poorer families. The "rich" are heavily taxed too paying over a third of their salary in taxes. People with higher income allowance have financial woes too, it's a bit naive to think they don't. People with jobs ànd mortgages can still loose their homes if they fail to keep up payments. This rich v poor narrative is a bad perspective to take.
True. People earning above 125k a year pay 60% tax and lose their taxable allowances. That is mors tax than the salaries that those under the CB benefit limit earn in a year. It has been argued previously that if anything child benefit should be extended and targetted to the highest earners because it’s their kids who are statistically also going to become high earners / high tax payers.
dementedpixie · 17/02/2022 09:56

@00100001

YABU

Why does the family bringing in £400k a year need an extra £20 a week?

Eh, you start paying back at £50k not £400k
OnaBegonia · 17/02/2022 09:56

YABU it should be means tested.
A bugger concern in the benefits system is self employed ppl on UC, the rule is that even if you earn little they will assume you've earned 40hrs x NMW and assess your entitlement as such, so expecting ppl to live on imaginary money., so no ppl earning £50k don't need £20pw

Mundra · 17/02/2022 09:55

That is correct @ozanj

Michellexxx · 17/02/2022 09:54

[quote Hoardasurass]@ddshocker yes it is means tested in all of the UK however your title says England.
I believe that it should be means tested, though I think that instead of going on a single wage ie if I parent earns over £50000 it should be on the entire family income as currently you can have 1 parent working for £50000+ and supporting the whole family on that wage who gets reduced or no child benefit yet you can have both parents earning £49999.99 so a combined income of £99999.98 and they will still be entitled to full child benefit which is both morally wrong and clearly unfair[/quote]
But the non working parent could just get a job? The family with both parents working probably have to pay a lot extra childcare rtc so it isn’t fair to benefit from having a stay at home parent, and another on a high wage

qualitygirl · 17/02/2022 09:54

I'm in Ireland and I have a friend with 4 dc (one set of twins) her dh is a TWAT he only gives her enough for groceries and that's it! She gets €700 per month in child benefits...it is her LIFELINE!!

Mundra · 17/02/2022 09:53

Or what @sassbottand @FourTeaFallOut have been saying in the time it took me to post.

Ozanj · 17/02/2022 09:53

Child benefit if claimed by a SAHP counts towards your state pension. That’s why I believe it’s encouraged you claim it even if you have to pay it back.

dementedpixie · 17/02/2022 09:52

@ddshocker

Is it not means tested In Scotland and wales then?
Yes its the same in Scotland. There is a high income benefit charge if you claim the money and earn over £50k. Once you reach £60k and still get the CB then it all needs to be paid back. The CB is paid back through a self assessment tax return done by the higher earner.

You can still claim it if you earn over £50k but some or all will need to be paid back

Chewbecca · 17/02/2022 09:52

It was removed as a cost saving exercise.

I think people's incomes as individuals were considered rather than household to encourage both parents to work.

If it was done on household income and one parent earned £50k, there would be a disincentive for the second parent to earn £10-£20k.

ddshocker · 17/02/2022 09:51

@Polyanthus2 they do not promote large families, maybe in the past but not now.

OP posts:
MayMorris · 17/02/2022 09:51

@Mundra

It should not be means tested. It's not about the sums of money involved, or the need, it's about buy-in to the social contract whereby those earning contribute via taxation to the whole of society and everyone benefits. People that don't benefit start to think they're not part of society and resent contributing, hence *@KosherDill*'s comments.

I'm fairly sure kosherdill will be benefiting from other people's children paying taxes to keep society afloat once they have retired, even if they don't have children themselves. Not to mention the fact that those supermarket workers, order pickers, NHS staff, power station workers etc etc are actually other people's children...

It's essentially a tax allowance that recognises the increased costs to a household that contains children, or at least that's what it used to be.

This. It was one of the trade offs when NI was originally introduced. It is really interesting that when I was younger it was called child ALLOWANCE, and seen as an allowance to offset tax and NI against additional cost of having children The government at some point (not sure which flavour and when) changed the name to child BENEFIT and thereby began the process of chipping away at attitudes that accepted this was an offset allowance for anyone with children no matter what your income
saleorbouy · 17/02/2022 09:51

KarmaStar
But did it go to poorer families. The "rich" are heavily taxed too paying over a third of their salary in taxes.
People with higher income allowance have financial woes too, it's a bit naive to think they don't. People with jobs ànd mortgages can still loose their homes if they fail to keep up payments.
This rich v poor narrative is a bad perspective to take.