Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why child benefits is means tested in England?Do you agree?

306 replies

ddshocker · 17/02/2022 08:55

Just that really? Why is it means tested in the U.K.? Do you think this is fair considering the financial abuse some women can be suffer even if their dh is a high learner!
In Ireland it's not means tested at all and it is double the U.K. amount...why is the U.K. so adamant in making it unfair!?

OP posts:
LumpenProletariat · 17/02/2022 12:56

@shouldistop

Means testing might be fair but the current method isn't.

A couple earning £49k each so £98k can claim it and not pay any back but a couple earning £51k and £10k for example can't.

Totally agree, it's outrageous.
ClariceQuiff · 17/02/2022 12:54

@OnlyFoolsnMothers

I agree - if the threshold is £50k people receiving this are already more affluent than I am, which is annoying. It should only be paid to people in genuine need now you know how I feel paying increased social care when asset rich elderly protect their kids inheritance- do you object to schools?
I agree with you about the asset rich elderly.

I don't object to schools - children need educating - and state schools will pick that up for the genuinely needy. If anything schools need more funding to reduce wealth divide in the future - everyone should have the chance of a good education, not just those who can go private or afford to move to the catchment area of an outstanding state school.

WombatChocolate · 17/02/2022 12:53

No tax and benefit system is perfect. There’s always a balancing of ensuring benefits are well targeted (to those who need them) against ensuring good levels of take-up and low admin costs and preventing fraud.

The current system ensures families with no earner above £50k qualify. That’s the main aim. For them, it’s easy to qualify and apply and for the government crucially it’s cheap to administer which is vital as it’s a low level benefit anyway, so high admin costs can negate the benefits of it.

Yes, those with one earner on £62k won’t qualify for anything, whilst a household on £99k split evenly probably will. But the giv knows the £60k household have £60k and so their ‘need’ isn’t that great. They might feel it’s unfair, but need is the key issue and the current policy ensures households with less than £60k will definitely get some. Purpose achieved.

Yes, it would be good if they could save the expenditure going to households with £60k to £99k. It would mean there was more cash to spend on those that need it. But the cost of administering it would probably exceed the amount of cash given in these benefits. That has to be considered. It’s the key reason it’s as it is. The government always has to accept it will spend some money on benefits to those who don’t really need them, and that the ‘cost’ of that is worth it because it means a cheap admin method can be used and ultimately and overall the gain and net benefit exceeds the costs. It’s about the bigger picture, not individuals who might be getting a benefit they might not need.

Who doesn’t like the current policy? Is it those on low incomes who are suffering poverty? No. Because those people receive it. Who doesn’t like it? It’s those with a high earner (over £60k) who doesn’t like to think of other families who have more cash than them (2 earner households) getting it. Does the government care that they feel a bit disgruntled? No, the purpose of the benefit isn’t to even up incomes of the affluent, but the provision of the benefit to those under £60k. Is it achieving that? Yes, Job done. People feeling a bit out -out - unfortunate side effect, but nothing the governments concerned about.

dementedpixie · 17/02/2022 12:52

[quote shouldistop]@dementedpixie how does that help household income if it's being paid back in tax? [/quote]
It depends how much over the threshold and which threshold they mean. If its between £50 and £60k they get to keep some.

bluelavender · 17/02/2022 12:52

Some services should be universal regardless of income- like education and the NHS.

I think it was a big mistake to remove child benefit as a universal benefit. Some families have large incomes, but these families may also have large housing and childcare costs. If a family really doesn't need it then donate it (and it would be great if we could have a wider culture of giving).

It's deeply annoying for families at the threshold, as to claim you have to file a tax return. It's a weird area of tax policy where we base it in household rather than individual income, and where individuals within a household become required to disclose their income to each other (of course, in many households partners freely discuss what they earn with each other, but some don't)

Raising children is expensive; and a universal child benefit provides an important sense that we are all together in a wider society- the challenge on how best support children in low income households should be in addition to this

Gwenhwyfar · 17/02/2022 12:51

@Dishwashersaurous

It undermines the universal nature of the state, and removes more people from thinking thatnthey are part of the state.
I think you're right here. To keep public support for benefits we need some of them to be more or less universal. This is how you get support for high tax and high welfare in countries like Scandinavia - everyone can see the benefit.
stimpyyouidiot · 17/02/2022 12:48

That's what I mean though. It's pretty pointless to claim when we basically have to pay it back. He's taxed enormously already.

shouldistop · 17/02/2022 12:48

@dementedpixie how does that help household income if it's being paid back in tax?

dementedpixie · 17/02/2022 12:45

@stimpyyouidiot

My h earns just over threshold. I earn about 10k a year. I could really do with the CB as loads of his money is taxed away and pays for all bills/commute etc. seems mad a household can earn 99,999 and still get it.
You CAN claim it. He would have to pay some or all of us back via self assessment tax return.
londonmummy1966 · 17/02/2022 12:44

It is really unfair - I had to stop work as I was really ill and wasn't in a situation where I could look after the children. DH earned over the threshold but other couples who were both working could have earned more and still claimed it. I was lucky as I had insurance to make up the shortfall but many other families in our situation would not have been so fortunate.

I also don't see why funds to benefit children are means assessed when a number of people I know on final salary pensions of £250k+ get winter fuel allowance and free public transport......

stimpyyouidiot · 17/02/2022 12:43

My h earns just over threshold. I earn about 10k a year. I could really do with the CB as loads of his money is taxed away and pays for all bills/commute etc. seems mad a household can earn 99,999 and still get it.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 17/02/2022 12:39

I agree - if the threshold is £50k people receiving this are already more affluent than I am, which is annoying. It should only be paid to people in genuine need now you know how I feel paying increased social care when asset rich elderly protect their kids inheritance-
do you object to schools?

WombatChocolate · 17/02/2022 12:38

Of course it didn’t used to be means tested but universal for all regardless of income. It was far too expensive that way.

Governments do have to choose how to target their limited resources. I think that’s absolutely right.

The reason it’s administered as it is, is because of the huge costs of doing it based on household income. Taxes and NI etc are all based on individual income. There are no records of household income….so to gather than info would cost hugely and probably cost more than the benefit it could deliver. Admin costs are usually the reason why seemingly odd ways to collect or issue benefits are used.

It is frustrating to think a household with £99k split evenly between 2 earners gets it but the household with a single earner on £60k doesn’t. But the reason I give above is why. There is also an element if ‘rewarding’ people for working. If 2 adults work, they each get a tax free allowance, whereas with all income coming from 1 earner, even if a high earner there’s just the 1 allowance.

sassbott · 17/02/2022 12:38

It should only be paid to people in genuine need.

Hmmm. And this is where the slippery slope downwards descends into the rabbit hole. Who determines the criteria/ thresholds for ‘need?’

A conversation that didn’t exist when it was universal.

I dunno, I’d be more worried about the mecanism that underpins this and how it could be further used in the context of ‘need’ rather than the current amounts and whether you deem someone is too affluent or not.

forinborin · 17/02/2022 12:37

I am more annoyed that everything here seems to be linked to the receipt of child benefit.

I have never claimed it as above the threshold, but then discovered that (a) the child maintenance service needs to see that you claim the child benefit in your name, otherwise they cannot ascertain automatically that you are eligible and you need to wait until it is your turn on the loooooong waiting list for "manual" processing (b) the school needs to see the child benefit letter to ensure the children live with you, the court order is apparently not sufficient.

It is bizarre how many admin things are linked to being in receipt of a non-universal benefit.

Lockdownbear · 17/02/2022 12:36

[quote Monopolyiscrap]@Lockdownbear I think you are very out of touch if you think schools supply all the books kids need.[/quote]
I've never heard of any kids in the UK having to purchase school books. Nor have I heard of schools renting them out.
Which schools or areas have you heard of it happening in?

Brainwave89 · 17/02/2022 12:34

This impacts us. Whilst I do not want to pay more tax, I equally cannot see why on my salary I should get child allowance.

CharacterForming · 17/02/2022 12:33

50K is not a high income for a four person household.
It's about 37 net for a single earner household or 41 net for a dual year earner household. Median net income for a household of that size is 41K according to the IFS so a 50K single earner household is below average.

ifs.org.uk/tools_and_resources/where_do_you_fit_in
I'm on my phone so can't sanity check their methodology back to the original ONS household data tables - anyone with time on their hands on a laptop feel free to check.
www.gov.uk/government/statistics/family-resources-survey-financial-year-2019-to-2020/family-resources-survey-financial-year-2019-to-2020#income-and-state-support-1

ClariceQuiff · 17/02/2022 12:30

@KosherDill

As a taxpayer i don't mind helping families in true financial insecurity but don't want to be paying my hard-earned wages so much more affluent households than mine get a cash handout merely for producing offspring.
I agree - if the threshold is £50k people receiving this are already more affluent than I am, which is annoying. It should only be paid to people in genuine need.
1forward2back · 17/02/2022 12:27

I think it is dreadful that it’s based on one salary. So a single mum earning over £70k doesn’t get it, but two people earning 45 do…

CorneliusVetch · 17/02/2022 12:21

We are high earners and I don’t think we should be able to receive it. There is such pressure on public finances at the moment.

Whenever something is means tested it is always hard to know where to draw the line. I am sure there are some who are only just over the threshold that rely on the money. Equally I know several people who claim it that are putting it into an account for their child when they’re 18. Yes, I know that they will be spending money on their child in the meantime, but for me, that is not a good use of public funds at a time when we are knocking £20 off universal credit.

Monopolyiscrap · 17/02/2022 12:15

@Lockdownbear I think you are very out of touch if you think schools supply all the books kids need.

LittleBearPad · 17/02/2022 12:14

If it gets wrapped into household income then it will be absorbed into universal credit and disappear for many of the people who do get it.

It’s more honest if this is done tbf

Lockdownbear · 17/02/2022 12:13

@SnipSnipMrBurgess thats good to hear that schools are able to rent books out, I have also heard of schools assisting with sales, to enable people to buy cheaper/ recoup some cost.
But it's something that bugs me on MN when people compare UK benefits and stuff to other countries without looking at the full picture, ie who's paying for what.

OnwardsAndSideways1 · 17/02/2022 12:07

I am a single parent and the current system is very unfair. My overall household income is actually lower than the UK average as I have only one wage, but I lose it if I go over £50k whereas couples can earn up to 50k each and still retain it.

I don't feel on over 50k I necessarily need child benefit, but I would like the system to be fair to single parents and to take household income into consideration.

Swipe left for the next trending thread