Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why child benefits is means tested in England?Do you agree?

306 replies

ddshocker · 17/02/2022 08:55

Just that really? Why is it means tested in the U.K.? Do you think this is fair considering the financial abuse some women can be suffer even if their dh is a high learner!
In Ireland it's not means tested at all and it is double the U.K. amount...why is the U.K. so adamant in making it unfair!?

OP posts:
Didyousaynutella · 17/02/2022 14:16

We are obsessed with means testing in this country rather than having universal benefits. Until we stop with this obsession people will always have unfair cliff edges and lose out.

We are better off now but when our first born was little DHearned just over the threshold and I earned a low wage. So we were both working (incurring all the costs that come with that ) and missing out despite having lower total household incomes than others we knew that could claim.

OfstedOffred · 17/02/2022 14:11

I thought the way it is claimed regardless then clawed back through tax on higher earner protected women suffering financial abuse?

I think it's fair that its means tested.DH and I earn loads, it is stupid enough that we get the 15h childcare without adding CB.

shouldistop · 17/02/2022 14:10

@Franticbutterfly

We claim it to ensure my NI is paid but pay it all back. I work 22.5 hours as admin in the NHS, husband is in a managerial role.
If you work 22.5 hours a week then surely your NI is paid anyway?
dementedpixie · 17/02/2022 14:10

@Franticbutterfly

We claim it to ensure my NI is paid but pay it all back. I work 22.5 hours as admin in the NHS, husband is in a managerial role.
You could claim and not get the payment and still get NI credits. Plus would you not get the NI element as you are working and paying NI?
Franticbutterfly · 17/02/2022 14:08

We claim it to ensure my NI is paid but pay it all back. I work 22.5 hours as admin in the NHS, husband is in a managerial role.

EarringsandLipstick · 17/02/2022 13:47

@LowlandLucky

My ex husband earned a good wage but i rarely saw a penny of it other than a monthly big shop, i used every single penny of my then family allowance on my children, i really don't know what i would have down without it. It paid for every item of clothing and footwear and also paid for school trips.
I hear you Lucky. Me too.
EarringsandLipstick · 17/02/2022 13:45

@Polyanthus2

I would say Ireland is a Catholic country that encourages large families - this contributes to that. Supporting large families is a good thing.
I haven't read to the end of the thread so k hope someone else has picked up on the daft & pejorative post

It's not the 1950s. Ireland no more encouraged large families than anywhere else. We are diverse, multi-ethnic & multi-cultural so while there are many Catholics, that doesn't influence social policy as it might have.

It's truly amazing what uninformed nonsense people will write.

BobbinHood · 17/02/2022 13:44

Absolutely. Are there any lawyers about? Would this policy stand up in court?

IANAL but what makes you think it wouldn’t? Plenty of other things can be seen as ‘unfair’ to single parents or single earner households - e.g. the personal allowance system means 2 people with a salary of £50k total pay less tax than one person with a salary of £50k.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 17/02/2022 13:44

I don't object to schools - children need educating - and state schools will pick that up for the genuinely needy. If anything schools need more funding to reduce wealth divide in the future - everyone should have the chance of a good education, not just those who can go private or afford to move to the catchment area of an outstanding state school
see if you extend this thinking child benefit should go to all, or the threshold needs to be far higher. It should be given to all children, just like state school is offered to all children.

ddshocker · 17/02/2022 13:18

@Itsalmostanaccessory I have explained what happened. I didn't mean to use England in my title. I don't assume they are interchangeable.

OP posts:
Gwenhwyfar · 17/02/2022 13:12

@caringcarer

Personally I just wish they would give all children free school meals regardless of age and free school uniform. That way all children would genuinely benefit.
They will provide free school meals to children in Wales regardless of parental income soon. Personally, I wonder whether they should have sorted out the nutrition of those meals first, for some children it might be less healthy than their current packed lunch.
Gwenhwyfar · 17/02/2022 13:06

[quote apprenticewage]@me4real 8i can't imagine a billionaire wasting 30 minutes of their time applying for fucking child benefit. They would earn more in that 30mins in interest off of their savings/investments.

For instance if there was £100 lying on the pavement bill gates wouldn't bother wasting his time picking it up as he would earn more in that second it took him to pick it up...[/quote]
They have staff to do it don't they.

Itsalmostanaccessory · 17/02/2022 13:05

In your title, you said England.
If your OP, you said UK.

As if they are interchangeable. They are not.

England is not the UK. If you're talking about england then says england. But if you're talking about the UK then say the UK, dont just call us all England.

LumpenProletariat · 17/02/2022 13:05

@CayrolBaaaskin

I think the rules are unfair in the way they affect single parents. We don’t get it if we have one income over 50 but dual income households have the benefit of a much higher threshold or same threshold but parent at home to save childcare costs
Absolutely. Are there any lawyers about? Would this policy stand up in court?
dementedpixie · 17/02/2022 13:05

The policy is

  • one parent can not earn more than 49k
  • if a one parent family earns more than 49k they do not qualify for child benefit
  • if a two parent family earns 49k each, they can qualify for child benefit

In all those cases you can still claim CB. If there is a higher earner over £50k in the household then some or all of the CB would be paid back via self assessment by the higher earner. Between £50 and £60k you'd pay back a proportion and once you go over £60k it would all be paid back

Gwenhwyfar · 17/02/2022 13:05

@Gonnagetgoing

I don't know much about CB myself but I recall in late 80s a couple I knew with 2 young children (under 5), she was a close friend - they didn't need it at all and she said she used her CB for her hair colour/cut appointments!
If she was a STAHM with no income, I don't think this is necessarily wrong.
LumpenProletariat · 17/02/2022 13:03

@EarringsandLipstick I see your point. I knew someone else whose husband was very financially controlling. The mother was able to have some money to feed and clothe the kids.

CayrolBaaaskin · 17/02/2022 13:02

I think the rules are unfair in the way they affect single parents. We don’t get it if we have one income over 50 but dual income households have the benefit of a much higher threshold or same threshold but parent at home to save childcare costs

whywouldntyou · 17/02/2022 13:01

@KosherDill

As a taxpayer i don't mind helping families in true financial insecurity but don't want to be paying my hard-earned wages so much more affluent households than mine get a cash handout merely for producing offspring.
This. My DH and my wages combined don't meet the threshold (don't get CB as grown up kids) but we should pay so households on double our income can? Pah!

When I were young... you got CB for the oldest child only. Once they reached 18 it stopped and went down to next youngest and so on. So my parents got 18 years for my DSis then 3 years for me. Stopped completely after that (obviously). AND you get free childcare - we got nothing! (Didn't want to disappoint the baby boom bashers)

LumpenProletariat · 17/02/2022 13:01

@00100001

YABU

Why does the family bringing in £400k a year need an extra £20 a week?

The policy is
  • one parent can not earn more than 49k
  • if a one parent family earns more than 49k they do not qualify for child benefit.
  • if a two parent family earns 49k each, they can qualify for child benefit.
Gwenhwyfar · 17/02/2022 13:00

@DomPom47

I don’t understand why child benefit is means tested but the winter fuel allowance for the elderly is not.
Because old people are more likely to vote Conservative.
shouldistop · 17/02/2022 13:00

@dementedpixie yes but I assume the pp meant £60k. Also if you're over £50k you then have to put the money aside and fill in a self assessment which not everyone can do.

stimpyyouidiot · 17/02/2022 12:59

50k would be about 37 take home because of tax and NI.

LumpenProletariat · 17/02/2022 12:59

@DaffodilDandilion

I know of a few families with reasonable earners who don’t need the child benefit and just put it into a savings account every month. I can see why they’ve tried to means test it because I don’t think the government should be funding a savings account for someone’s first car or whatever. I think the current system of means testing is wrong though and penalises single parents.
Yep.. single parents who are mostly women. Why is this policy not considered prejudicial towards women? I don't understand why it cannot be subject to court proceedings as it seems to be a policy which discriminates largely against women.
stimpyyouidiot · 17/02/2022 12:58

Also, If someone earns 60k - after tax and NI they'd probably bring home about 44k.

Swipe left for the next trending thread