Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why child benefits is means tested in England?Do you agree?

306 replies

ddshocker · 17/02/2022 08:55

Just that really? Why is it means tested in the U.K.? Do you think this is fair considering the financial abuse some women can be suffer even if their dh is a high learner!
In Ireland it's not means tested at all and it is double the U.K. amount...why is the U.K. so adamant in making it unfair!?

OP posts:
rainbowzebra05 · 17/02/2022 09:36

The current system isn't fair. My husband earns over the threshold so we don't get it. I earn £7K in total per year. Something based on total household income would be much fairer.

SherryPalmer · 17/02/2022 09:35

By the way, for households where one parent is a low earner and the other a high earner, it is best that the low earner does claim it. Claiming it for a child under 12 gives you NI credits for that year - valuable if your earnings might not give full NI credits. The higher earner has to do a tax return and what you are not entitled to is clawed back that way.

You don’t need to take the CB payments and have the higher earner do the tax return - there’s a box on the form you can tick so you just receive the NI credits.

ddshocker · 17/02/2022 09:34

@00100001 I think that's an extreme scenario to be honest but that person would also pay 180k in tax per year! I agree 20quid a month is nothing to them really but the way it's means tested is unfair to a lot of people

OP posts:
EarringsandLipstick · 17/02/2022 09:34

@MilkTwoSugarsThanks

Do you think this is fair considering the financial abuse some women can be suffer even if their dh is a high learner!

Lol. Like financially abused women would ever see that child benefit Hmm

IME

I did.
EarringsandLipstick · 17/02/2022 09:33

@Meandthesky

YABU

someone earning a six figure salary shouldn’t be entitled to benefits!

And if someone was being financially abused there’s no guarantee they would be able to keep child benefit separate anyway so it still wouldn’t help them

I see your point.

However I was financially abused. I was in a terrible situation where he was spending every penny.

The child allowance came to me - it's automatically registered to the mother in Ireland - and was a guaranteed €420 per month. I was able to keep it separate, and it allowed me to feed my children (marriage has now ended).

I could not at the time tell anyone what was happening.

As it was Ireland the money wasn't means tested. If I was in the UK, or we had a means tested system, I would not have got it.

It is so important that it remains a universal payment, even acknowledging that rich families who don't need it also receive it.

MumsMetHer · 17/02/2022 09:33

Not means tested might be nice, but I'm not sure it's a priority when the country's finances are in the current state!

However, means testing should definitely be based on the income of both parents rather than one, to make it fairer.

And whilst we're doing that, let's start allowing married couples the option of joint tax returns, as nearly all other countries do.

Dishwashersaurous · 17/02/2022 09:33

And please keep claiming it if one partner is not working because of the national insurance credit for your state pension.

meditrina · 17/02/2022 09:31

It was much simpler when it was a universal entitlement

I think that instead of the (frankly shitty and unfair) way they chose to limit it by tax bracket rather than household income, they should have kept it universal, but allow value to dwindle. And put resource into the other family benefits

That wouid also have the benefit of reducing the likelihood of gaps in NI record.

And the soft benefit of people feeling that every now and again they get something back.

I also think that independent taxation of adults was a worthwhile and hard-win thing. and was disappointed to see the first steps to re-merge

PrescriptionOnlyMedicine · 17/02/2022 09:30

I don’t object to the means testing but the way it is worked out is unfair as previous posters have said. I’m a low earner but my OH isn’t so we stopped claiming. If it was based on household income we’d probably still get it.

lanthanum · 17/02/2022 09:30

By the way, for households where one parent is a low earner and the other a high earner, it is best that the low earner does claim it. Claiming it for a child under 12 gives you NI credits for that year - valuable if your earnings might not give full NI credits. The higher earner has to do a tax return and what you are not entitled to is clawed back that way.
Note also that it's a sliding scale, so earning over £50k means only that you don't get all of it.
Lastly, where there is financial abuse, it can move some money to the lower earner's control.

MarrymeTomHardy · 17/02/2022 09:30

As a sole parent who earns over the threshold I think it is unfair.
A couple who both earn a little less than me can claim.
Another punishment for being a single parent through no fault of my own...
Also no CMS as ex went self-employed to avoid it Hmm

Onlywomengivebirth · 17/02/2022 09:29

Of course it should be means tested. I don’t understand the argument that it’s for the child, not the parents. By that logic a child’s entire childhood should be funded by the state, not the parents. Which is obviously ludicrous.

Isonthecase · 17/02/2022 09:29

The other one that really frustrates me is the cap for the tax free childcare. For a person earning £99k going to £101k you lose money as you lose £2k a year per child and that £2k extra is taxed at 40% already. Means there's no point earning £100-£110 k as we'd actually be worse off. I know it's not as much of a problem as the similar effect seen at the lower end of the scale but for me it just shows the slightly bonkers tax system we have to endure in this country. Why does it have to be so complicated?!

Hoardasurass · 17/02/2022 09:28

@ddshocker yes it is means tested in all of the UK however your title says England.
I believe that it should be means tested, though I think that instead of going on a single wage ie if I parent earns over £50000 it should be on the entire family income as currently you can have 1 parent working for £50000+ and supporting the whole family on that wage who gets reduced or no child benefit yet you can have both parents earning £49999.99 so a combined income of £99999.98 and they will still be entitled to full child benefit which is both morally wrong and clearly unfair

Dishwashersaurous · 17/02/2022 09:27

And I agree that there should be consistency in the system. Either household assessment or individual assessment for everything not a mix and match approach

Michellexxx · 17/02/2022 09:27

Changing the methods of means testing is fair. But again I think it one person is staying at home and not working, then you shouldn’t be entitled to it. A household with 2 parents working and earning 60k, should be entitled.

The problem arises though, that it becomes a very convoluted process to means test once you start introducing more aspects. So then it’s more expensive to implement too.

LittleBearPad · 17/02/2022 09:26

@Dishwashersaurous

It undermines the universal nature of the state, and removes more people from thinking thatnthey are part of the state.
I’m quite happy to pay for the state. I use education and healthcare for example. I know I’m part of the state.

But I don’t need the state to give me £33 a week for my children.

ddshocker · 17/02/2022 09:26

@HopefulProcrastinator you can now avail of other options in pregnancy in Ireland now...it has changed.

OP posts:
Lockdownbear · 17/02/2022 09:26

Every other benefits is means tested as a couple / household unfair that CB is done differently.

00100001 · 17/02/2022 09:26

YABU

Why does the family bringing in £400k a year need an extra £20 a week?

Sowhatifiam · 17/02/2022 09:25

But the combined salary means both parents are working, so more likely to need childcare etc. the other household could earn more if the other person went out to work too. You don’t benefit from being able to afford to only have one parent out at work

So…single parent families? Is it fair that I earn £60k as a single parent and can’t claim it but a household with two parents on £30k each can? Don’t I need childcare too?

You really need a bit of a rethink.

Dishwashersaurous · 17/02/2022 09:24

It undermines the universal nature of the state, and removes more people from thinking thatnthey are part of the state.

Isonthecase · 17/02/2022 09:23

I agree that it should be based on household income. I also think the money saved could be far better spent on childcare loans - we do student loans so why can't we offer those to help people (predominantly women) maintain their careers with young kids?

mumda · 17/02/2022 09:22

It'd be interesting to hear what parents think about the idea of an increase in the tax code for Parents for each child as an alternative.

So you'd pay less tax rather than getting a benefit.

Obvious flaw is parents would only see a benefit if they have an income.

usernotfound0000 · 17/02/2022 09:22

I do think it should be means tested but I think it should be on household income and not individual as is the current way. We don't claim it as DH earns over £50k but I only earn £16k, wheras some families could have a combined income greater than ours but still be able to claim it.