Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why child benefits is means tested in England?Do you agree?

306 replies

ddshocker · 17/02/2022 08:55

Just that really? Why is it means tested in the U.K.? Do you think this is fair considering the financial abuse some women can be suffer even if their dh is a high learner!
In Ireland it's not means tested at all and it is double the U.K. amount...why is the U.K. so adamant in making it unfair!?

OP posts:
TheRealityCheque · 17/02/2022 09:50

Child Benefit should not be means tested because it should not exist at all.

It was originally bought in to encourage more people to have children after war had decimated the population. It's completely unnecessary now.

It should be frozen at current levels for those currently entitled to it, but got rid of for new claimants in a years time, to allow those who currently budget for it to not lose out.

BuggerOffAndGoodDayToYou · 17/02/2022 09:49

I don’t mind the idea of means testing it but means test it PROPERLY. My DCs are too old now anyway but a few years ago. DH was over the threshold where he had to pay back about 50% of the CB I received. I work in a school so only 39 weeks per year and actually earning so little that I paid about £50 tax for the whole year. Next door BOTH on just under £50k pa still got full CB!

A means tested benefit should be calculated on total HOUSEHOLD income.

Witheringtong · 17/02/2022 09:48

No its not right. It used to be paid directly to the mother, so at least some women had the chance of keeping the money.

Polyanthus2 · 17/02/2022 09:48

I would say Ireland is a Catholic country that encourages large families - this contributes to that.
Supporting large families is a good thing.

ddshocker · 17/02/2022 09:47

@sassbott that is a very good point!

OP posts:
Mundra · 17/02/2022 09:47

It should not be means tested. It's not about the sums of money involved, or the need, it's about buy-in to the social contract whereby those earning contribute via taxation to the whole of society and everyone benefits. People that don't benefit start to think they're not part of society and resent contributing, hence @KosherDill's comments.

I'm fairly sure kosherdill will be benefiting from other people's children paying taxes to keep society afloat once they have retired, even if they don't have children themselves. Not to mention the fact that those supermarket workers, order pickers, NHS staff, power station workers etc etc are actually other people's children...

It's essentially a tax allowance that recognises the increased costs to a household that contains children, or at least that's what it used to be.

MayMorris · 17/02/2022 09:47

@shouldistop

Means testing might be fair but the current method isn't.

A couple earning £49k each so £98k can claim it and not pay any back but a couple earning £51k and £10k for example can't.

This. I was sole earner in our family, just above limit for child benefit. My husband was not able to work due to severe mental illness for over 20 years. We claimed no benefits - we could have got PIP. for him potentially but the assessment process would have been impossible for him due to it triggering hallucinations. If we’d both been earning half that amount each we’d have still been able to claim We had one at uni, and one doing GCSE when it was taken away. It hit us quite hard as about the same time I was getting pay freezes at work I really resented that I was working with people where both they and their spouse were in work, earning say £5000 or even less than me and still got child benefit. In fact people could earn almost twice out family income and still receive it . It was a crap way of dealing with this. It came about because they clawed back through tax system which just doesn’t cope with family income , just personal income. It was lazy thinking and cheap implementation . They didn’t do a proper assessment on fall out with families like ours where disability means one parent can’t work (even if to look after a child with disability), and the other parent has to work to make up for that loss of income, I know there are a lot of families on far less than my sole income at just above the cutoff. And yes benefits should be targeted at them. I do think that there should have been a sliding scale , not an absolute cut off point, and that somehow someone could have come up with a better system to take household income into account,
stickysellotape · 17/02/2022 09:46

I agree that it’s unfair how two adults earning 49k each in a household can get it.

Where I am in the uk, it was all organised when you went to register the birth, which means that mothers will get it.

My DH earns over the threshold but I still choose to claim it, one so my NI contributions are paid and two, because I need that money for the children each month. My DH has to pay it all back at the end of the tax year but I’d rather it that way.

sassbott · 17/02/2022 09:45

Also. How do I now feel about benefits in general? How invested/ knowledgeable am i? Do I know / understand about the erosions/ impacts to families and how worrying certain trends are? No. I don’t. Why? Because I’ve completely been removed (by the government) from that narrative. And it suits them that that is what has happened.

That’s the bigger picture that people are missing.

ddshocker · 17/02/2022 09:45

@Theskullcupofdoom I am half asleep I am rereading it again and I get what you are saying now so ignore my second message 🤣

OP posts:
saleorbouy · 17/02/2022 09:44

Personally I don't think it should be means tested.
The current system is unfair in its distribution in that a couple each earning 50k (100k household income) would still receive the allowance but a single earner taking 55k would not.
I reality the cost of administration in means testing likely outways the return. A person earning £51K would pay £7900 income tax and £4880 NI, a total tax bill of £12780.
The proportion of child allowance is therefore small and obviously on higher salaries would be proportionally less.
As the only benefit I ever received I was saddened by the new unfair assessment of means testing as a single income household with SAHM.
It also does allow an income to a parent if there is financial abuse within a household too.

KarmaStar · 17/02/2022 09:44

Yabu.
Freeing up the cash so it can go to families who need it for essentials rather than being used as pocket money by the rich is sensible.

sassbott · 17/02/2022 09:44

@FourTeaFallOut

It did use to be a universal benefit. Then they made it means tested and, when set against the increase in administration costs, saved very little but it was a useful tool to set about a political narrative in which those who do receive benefits were then treated with contempt and suspicion.

What followed was an erosion of child tax credits and disability allowances.

Basically, when the middle classes are untethered from an investment in a particular system then it becomes far more economically and politically vulnerable.

We can't unbolt that horse, but that's were society took the biggest hit.

This. CB was the only benefit I used to receive and once it was means tested I stopped claiming as obviously it would be a clawback via my self assessment.

People aren’t looking at the wider macro impact of removing a whole portion of society from this mecanism. Do I need £x per week per child? No. But has it decoupled me from ‘benefits’ per se? Does that have a downstream impact? Yes.

If I was childless, I’d be incandescent that my taxes pay other peoples CB and that my taxes go towards schools. Imagine giving tax breaks to those without children. Then think about the wider impact that has on society when those who don’t claim benefits view whose who do.

All of these are levers that the government could now choose to apply. In my view all it will do is send us further down the slopes of judgement against those who claim benefits.

ddshocker · 17/02/2022 09:43

@Theskullcupofdoom I just reread your statement?

The U.K. is made up of England,Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland. Why are you saying that the U.K. is NOT England Scotland and Wales?

OP posts:
tentative3 · 17/02/2022 09:43

I think it's right that it's means tested but agree that the system is flawed.

BobbinHood · 17/02/2022 09:41

Or actually get rid of it entirely. The universal credit system is the means tested for families on low income so arguably to really target support then only that should be used.

Actually I agree with this. It should either return to being non means tested or it should be targeted better through the benefits system.

ddshocker · 17/02/2022 09:41

@Theskullcupofdoom I know what the U.K. includes...

I said England in my title, I then wrote my piece and forgot to change the title to the U.K.

I didn't mention Northern Ireland because I was just asking a quick question, Hmm

OP posts:
Theskullcupofdoom · 17/02/2022 09:38

@ddshocker

Is it not means tested In Scotland and wales then?
Again, England, Scotland and Wales are not the UK. The UK includes Northern Ireland.
Fretfulmum · 17/02/2022 09:38

YANBU. it should be based on total household income. There has to be a threshold somewhere though. But a family could still be struggling living off £100k in London and the South East so it’s not that simple.
Older people get non means tested winter fuel benefit, I think families should get the child benefit regardless

TrueBuys · 17/02/2022 09:37

It's unfair, as a single parent I earn £60k and get no child benefit. But a couple each earning £49k, so £98k in total, do get child benefit.

MuddlingMackem · 17/02/2022 09:37

YANBU.

As far as I know it was introduced as family allowance to be paid to the mother as too many fathers kept the mothers short of housekeeping.

And even those in high earning families can be victims of financial abuse, so no, it should not be means tested, and it should not be called a benefit, it should go back to being an allowance.

AchillesPoirot · 17/02/2022 09:36

It’s means tested in the UK. This also includes Northern Ireland.

FourTeaFallOut · 17/02/2022 09:36

It did use to be a universal benefit. Then they made it means tested and, when set against the increase in administration costs, saved very little but it was a useful tool to set about a political narrative in which those who do receive benefits were then treated with contempt and suspicion.

What followed was an erosion of child tax credits and disability allowances.

Basically, when the middle classes are untethered from an investment in a particular system then it becomes far more economically and politically vulnerable.

We can't unbolt that horse, but that's were society took the biggest hit.

Dishwashersaurous · 17/02/2022 09:36

Or actually get rid of it entirely. The universal credit system is the means tested for families on low income so arguably to really target support then only that should be used.

Child benefit used an odd proxy.

See also the recent council tax rebate for energy bills, as a proxy to get money to people who need it but are above the means testing threshold

HalfShrunkMoreToGo · 17/02/2022 09:36

We're in the position where I'm on more that £50,000, DH is on significantly less than £50,000 so we can't claim it but other households with a combined income of 99,000 could so in that sense it is unfair.