Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

for getting fed up with people shutting down debate...

81 replies

SueBaroo · 02/01/2008 09:45

... because they are offended?

It seems to be some unspoken rule nowadays that if someone doesn't agree with what is being said, instead of actually defending their position, they can just whine a bit about their feelings and guilt everyone into backing off?

It doesn't always work (especially on MN, with the high-proportion of marvellously ball-breaking opinionated folk) but it's a cheap trick and it winds me up. AIBU for wanting to tell people who try it to buck up? Should I be more squishy about feeeeeelings?

OP posts:
HairyIrene · 02/01/2008 12:04

agree op, wt
i do think alot of it is not reading properly all the thread, and worse,not stating this at the start
vs the tone and context is sooo important too i second that
i get annoyed when posts are clearly not being read
what is the point then??

lazarou · 02/01/2008 11:40

I actually shut the computer down earlier (a rare event) so that i could do other things, but then ds2 turned it back on. It must be a sign to keep on posting, obviously.

lucyellensmum · 02/01/2008 11:30

i know what you mean lazarou, but i think to an extent that is the nature of the beast. I tend to respond to OPs and then realise that what i have said has already been said twenty times already - i could resolve, i guess, to read a few of the most recent posts before spouting off, yep new years resolution 564! You do of course realise that NYR no one was too stay away from mumsnet until my house was clean

VictorianSqualor · 02/01/2008 11:29

AND something mentioned on another thread recently, fisking.
If you are going to take someones post and answer every part of it by breaking it down, fair enough, but do not ignore the whole tone and point of the post by doing it, or what's the bloody point??????

lazarou · 02/01/2008 11:26

Yes personal attacks are out of order. Opinions are not. Also, loads of people jumping on someone for an opinion. Rahter than letting it lie and moving on, everyone wants a piece of the action.

lucyellensmum · 02/01/2008 11:25

i athink we all say things on here that we wouldnt in real life. I moan about things that i wouldnt even bother to open my mouth about. I also talk about serious problems in my life. I have however, learnt to be very choosy where i post things. If it is something i feel upset over, unless i feel the world in his wife will come through with a resounding YANBU i definately dont post on this part of the board.

I do worry sometimes that people take my inarticulate replies as personal attacks, but for the record, i love you all and if that seems too personal - tough

VictorianSqualor · 02/01/2008 11:19

What really constitues being 'out of order' though?

Personal attacks, yes, but often someone will just be voicing their opinion and because someone else sees their opinion as offensive it becomes an insult and blah blah blah.

I've started posting on threads where my opinion is different from the majority only to stop posting because no-one will even consider my points, and just tell me I'm being offensive!

What kind of debate is that really?

colditz · 02/01/2008 11:18

It's a bit like the accusations of bullying though, isn't it?

By accusing someone of being a bully, you are invalidating any protest they put up against the accusation. Protestations are met, from the active-aggressive posters, with "Well you're protesting so much you must be a bully" and from the passive-aggressive posters with "well, I feel^ bullied!"

People are using their feelings as a weapon, and it's not nice. I often feel distressed, depressed, miserable, joyous, angry and bemused. That's my deal, nobody else's, and certainly nobody here!

SueBaroo · 02/01/2008 11:18

Yes, but a vicious attack isn't the same as a strong opinion, and it's already covered in the MN 'no personal attacks' policy.

I can't believe you would all be so unpleasant about the sounds a woman makes when she is so vulnerable! Where is your sisterhood? You should encourage her uninhibited enjoyment, rather than trying to oppress her. If you can't say anything nice, don't say anything at all.

(now, aren't you glad that's not MN policy? )

OP posts:
lazarou · 02/01/2008 11:12

But usually if someone is out of order, genuinely, then most people will defend the poor victim. Sorry about the word 'victim' i couldnt think of an alternative. I hate that word too. 'Victim' eugh!

Nightynight · 02/01/2008 11:09

yes it is true, Sue, but the converse has also happened - if someone attacks quite viciously, and the attacked one dares to protest about a personal attack, then the attacker laughs "Crybaby"
God, it is sooo much like separating my children. just as well MummynetTowers is on hand to adjudicate.

lapinewyear · 02/01/2008 10:50

Classic thread WT!

yeeeep... YEEEEEP!!!!

(Kewc, I will sort it, thanks for letting me know)

WanderingTrolley · 02/01/2008 10:38

I'm still giggling at 'you come too loudly'

differentYearbutthesamecack · 02/01/2008 10:35

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

pinetreedog · 02/01/2008 10:09

I browsed through that thread looking out for someone telling you how nasty you were being to th eneighbours and that you should stop being such an auld cow.

But it is just pure sexy filth. You deceptor

lazarou · 02/01/2008 10:07

Your description of the sex noises is most amusing.

WanderingTrolley · 02/01/2008 10:04

Why I'm Very Cross Today

Yes, I've known people in tears on here. From there, it descends to cries of 'playground bitches' and 'quiche/cleek/creak etc'

Ah, that's better.

wannaBe · 02/01/2008 09:59

agree totally. if people don't like the answers they will get then don't raise the issue.

and it especially baffles me on here as this is a website, so peple have the option to not read posts if the "debate" hasn't gone their way.

"in tears" do people actually cry about things they read on a website? really? or am I just a hard bitch

lazarou · 02/01/2008 09:59

Sometimes when you post somethnig in jest someone will take it the wrong way and you just want to say 'oh bloody lighten up' but you know the guilt trip will go on and other people will come and say 'don't tell to lighten up, blah blah blah' and then you have to leave before you say something really offensive

Saggarmakersbottomknocker · 02/01/2008 09:56

polie polite FGS!

Saggarmakersbottomknocker · 02/01/2008 09:56

PMSL @ WT's 'not in a good way'.

Yes I agree.

Get a farkin grip.

bahKewcHumbug · 02/01/2008 09:56

my neighbours were away for Xmas and New Year - no shaggin the neighbours for me [dull emoticon]

bahKewcHumbug · 02/01/2008 09:54

lapin - my secret santa gift has just been returned to me as the label got damaged in post and couldn't be read (thankfully I had a reply address on it). Can you email whoever my recipient was and apologise profusely, I will resend tomorrow. I'm so gutted they didn't get it for Xmas .

lazarou · 02/01/2008 09:54

You were shagging your neighbours?!

Dior · 02/01/2008 09:54

Message withdrawn

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.

Swipe left for the next trending thread