Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

for getting fed up with people shutting down debate...

81 replies

SueBaroo · 02/01/2008 09:45

... because they are offended?

It seems to be some unspoken rule nowadays that if someone doesn't agree with what is being said, instead of actually defending their position, they can just whine a bit about their feelings and guilt everyone into backing off?

It doesn't always work (especially on MN, with the high-proportion of marvellously ball-breaking opinionated folk) but it's a cheap trick and it winds me up. AIBU for wanting to tell people who try it to buck up? Should I be more squishy about feeeeeelings?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ThrowbackTo07 · 10/11/2022 23:37

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

theBOD · 02/01/2008 15:33

on a similar vein i hate people who shut down debate using reverse racism/sexism/all other ism's.

lazarou · 02/01/2008 15:29

Lol, LEM. I think that comment will be haunting me forever now.

HairyIrene · 02/01/2008 15:26

lol madamez bizarre gardening accidents etc..

SueBaroo · 02/01/2008 15:17

It's called Taking Great Personal Offence by Proxy. TGPOP for short.

OP posts:
lucyellensmum · 02/01/2008 15:15

By lazarou on Wed 02-Jan-08 12:07:53
Oh and it really annoys me when someone copies and pastes a part of someone elses post and pulls them up on it in a horribly smug fashion.

Yes, that sort of thing pisses me off too - especially because im always doing it.

Resolution 566, no more cutting and pasting.

VictorianSqualor · 02/01/2008 15:14

And then, said poster that would get offended comes along and says 'actually, I don't take offence at that at all' BUT you're still accused by all and sundry of being insensitive towards them

madamez · 02/01/2008 15:02

The other thing is people who get screeeeeeemingly self-righteously 'offended' on behalf of other people, either bollocking you for being heartless and thoughtless because you didn't, er, actually KNOW that some or other poster gets anquish-related bleeding haemorrhoids if anyone mentions SId off CBeebies in anything other than a positive light....(this is often used to bash newbies right off the board. We don;t always know the entire personal history of anyone who says anything witless, more to the point why should we farking care?), or trying to say that some subjects just musn;t be discussed, at all, ever, because they're so upsetting.

lazarou · 02/01/2008 14:09

Haven't we all though fio, sometimes deliberately and sometimes not.

candypandy · 02/01/2008 14:03

that's a bit twatty you didn't have to read it
I SUPPOSE I COULD SHOUT
then i wouldn't mind being told to shut up
but then i never shout in RL

FioFio · 02/01/2008 13:56

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

lazarou · 02/01/2008 13:52

shut up

SueBaroo · 02/01/2008 13:50

crikey, I've just scared myself with that impression.

OP posts:
candypandy · 02/01/2008 13:50

i was told to just shut up once
i thought that was a bit twatty
i mean nobody has to read it

SueBaroo · 02/01/2008 13:49

laz, twas just a general thing - online and off. My SIL runs a masterclass in it.

"But you're damaging your children by not bringing them up in the way I think you should, and just because you've thought it through, researched it and totally committed yourself to it, I am going to take it personally and assume you're doing it because I told you something different"

SIL sticks fingers in ears

"la la la, no, don't explain, I know I'm right, and now I actually think I'm going to cry. Dh, talk to them, because I just can't"

OP posts:
littlelapin · 02/01/2008 13:47

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

VictorianSqualor · 02/01/2008 13:43

Thanks Madamez, 'lost all their lovers in bizarre gardening incidents' has just amde me spit my OJ all over my keyboard, as if it wasn't fucked enough already from mince pie crumbs.

lazarou · 02/01/2008 13:38

Anyway Sue, which particular thread are you referring to? Or is this just in general?

VeniVidiVickiQV · 02/01/2008 13:28

How you doin......?

SueBaroo · 02/01/2008 13:27

Ah, but it doesn't just happen online, though.

OP posts:
Vacua · 02/01/2008 13:26

why do I miss all these excitements - where do they take place? or does it just go over my head?

madamez · 02/01/2008 13:26

SOme people just are petulant self-obsessed ignorant twats, who can't take any disagreement without screaming, spitting the dummy and threatening to get the moderators, their mummy, their lawyers and their therapists involved. I usually find robust derision the best way of dealing with them. Particularly the type who go, oh you can't say that to me, I'm tho thenthtive/got ingrown toenails/lost all my lovers in bizarre gardening accidents.....

The bottom line is that whatever some stranger calls you in an online debte doesn;t matter. THey can't come round your house and duff you up. Laugh it off or stick to the cute kitten forums instead.

SueBaroo · 02/01/2008 13:23

oo, now I sound like Joey Tribiani.

OP posts:
SueBaroo · 02/01/2008 13:22

I do get very fed up with people shutting down debate though, and making a discussion about themselves, rather than the issue at hand.

------

Now that's what I'm talking about.

OP posts:
VeniVidiVickiQV · 02/01/2008 13:20

I think it is perfectly acceptable to express feelings about a situation - it can often add to a debate, rather than shut it down. Also, I think it is quite possible to continue a debate and be sensitive to someone else's feelings regarding a topic.

The problem lies in whether sensitivity is used, particularly when it is apparent that someone is upset, and it has been acknowledged that they are upset. Or whether someones response to a debate is to simply say "you are all nasty bitches" or similar - to which there is no reasonable response.

I do get very fed up with people shutting down debate though, and making a discussion about themselves, rather than the issue at hand.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.