Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MP's will debate changing the Gender Recognition Act

163 replies

Witheringtong · 16/02/2022 22:10

On Monday 21 February, MP's will debate reforming the Gender Recognition Act.
committees.parliament.uk/committee/326/petitions-committee/news/160946/reform-of-the-gender-recognition-act-to-be-debated-by-mps/

Where do you stand? Since there are only 2 voting options the vote can't reflect all the possible options so you might have to add a comment.
Personally, I dont see how safeguarding or sex based rights can be upheld as long as people can change their legal sex marker. I'm also opposed to convicted sex offenders or violent offenders being able to change their legal details, let alone be places in a women's prison.

AIBU - The GRA should be changed to make it easier for any person to change their legal sex markers, name and birth certificate.

YANBU - The GRA should not be changed.

OP posts:
Theeyeballsinthesky · 17/02/2022 10:50

Wonder how long before this gets reported by the monitors & gets shunted off to the naughty corner

The GRA is bad law for many reasons and should be repealed but as it won’t be, no I don’t think men should be able to self ID as a woman because women are adult human females and men however they present & even if they have surgery (must don’t) can’t ever be that. They were born male & male they stay

Hankunamatata · 17/02/2022 10:45

Medical forms definitely need genetic sex and chosen sex.

bishophaha · 17/02/2022 10:44

@balalake

I am OK with changes to the current process, but anything should retain protection for women's only spaces, where the person who has or wishes to change from being male to female has not undergone reassignment surgery.
I see where you're coming from but I think it's unethical to require that some people undergo major surgery' as a requirement to access spaces. It won't be medically suitable for all people. Therefore it should simply be split by 'male' and 'female' and everyone should accept that this will include people with a huge variety of inner feelings and appearance/dress.
GCAcademic · 17/02/2022 10:43

Wont you think of the children, right wing moral panic script point by point

Yawn. Characterising mothers as right-wing pearl clutchers, misogyny, point by point.

bishophaha · 17/02/2022 10:42

If they want to replace the current definitions of 'woman' and 'man' then at the very least they should clarify precisely what the 'new' definitions are proposed to be.

I've been asking for several years what the proposed definitions are and no-one can say (or wants to say).

There is an underlying, unexamined assumption in a worryingly large number of people that being female = being feminine (and male/masculine) that is utterly false and people need to concentrate on not conflating these.

JustAnotherPoster00 · 17/02/2022 10:37

@Georgeskitchen

Would any of you be comfortable with your 12 year old daughter in a changing room showering with a naked full bodied adult male?

Didn't think so!!

Wont you think of the children, right wing moral panic script point by point
JustAnotherPoster00 · 17/02/2022 10:36

@SunniDelite

Woman encounters large man in ladies loos. Woman is scared. Woman phones security or police. They can't do anything because he self-id's as a woman and the woman is just being transphobic. Already happening around the world. YANBU.
Woman encounters large bearded man in ladies loos, Woman is scared, Woman phones security or police, They cant do anything because he is a FTM and the woman is just being transphobic.

Always about the toilets and always about MTF, who checks peoples underwear when they go in now? Never been asked what I have in my underwear to be granted access to any toilets Hmm

balalake · 17/02/2022 10:33

I am OK with changes to the current process, but anything should retain protection for women's only spaces, where the person who has or wishes to change from being male to female has not undergone reassignment surgery.

Georgeskitchen · 17/02/2022 10:29

Would any of you be comfortable with your 12 year old daughter in a changing room showering with a naked full bodied adult male?

Didn't think so!!

SunniDelite · 17/02/2022 10:07

Woman encounters large man in ladies loos. Woman is scared. Woman phones security or police. They can't do anything because he self-id's as a woman and the woman is just being transphobic. Already happening around the world. YANBU.

Witheringtong · 17/02/2022 09:59

@brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr
''So would you also be against people self identifying as gay, sexual orientation also being a protected characteristic?''

Lesbians are no longer welcome at Pride for being same sex attracted. IDK why you brought up gay people, they are also affected by self ID.

Should white people identify as black, or able bodied people identify as disabled? I dont think so. Its insulting, even if the person who does it hasn't taken up resources they arent entitled to.

OP posts:
AlexaShutUp · 17/02/2022 07:59

Yes exactly. I have no issue actually with someone self identifying as trans. My issue is with people identifying as a member of the opposite sex.

GCAcademic · 17/02/2022 07:52

Trans people aren’t pretending to be trans „for a day“ either.

No one has said they aren’t trans. What we are saying is that being trans does not make you the opposite sex. The analogy with gay people does not work here at all.

ohhooh · 17/02/2022 07:45

@brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr

So would you also be against people self identifying as gay, sexual orientation also being a protected characteristic?

It’s hard AF being trans, why make it harder ?

Someone identifying as gay isn't really the same thing in my eyes, because that doesn't impact in the same way.

I don't think that fact it's hard "af" being trans according to you should mean that women should just shut up and put up, personally I don't think someone should just be able to self identify as a women and get access to spaces / services meant for women just by saying they are one. The use of the word woman needs to be specific, imo not meaning someone who decides they are one.

It's peak male privilege in my eyes that men decide they want to become women, and all of us who were born as a woman are meant to just accept this and let them into services / spaces just because they are saying they're a woman. It's entitled.

FourTeaFallOut · 17/02/2022 07:14

It's so rude to further enshrine in law that a woman is a bunch of regressive stereotypes that can be opted in to with a simple declaration of pink brain and pink feelings. It's a damaging and offensive lie that betrays our sex.

JellySaurus · 17/02/2022 06:28

@Fungirls

We cannot turn back time and actually developing better legislation could address a lot of concerns. For example how do people legally de-transition? Currently there is no mechanism to allow Keira Bell (and others) to legally de-transition.

Legally distinguish between “full transition” and “gender fluid”. For example, Eddie Izzard uses “boy mode” and “girl mode” but as far as I’m aware has not legally transitioned. A lot of people may fit in this category and the law needs to set out how they should be treated e.g. can a person be misgendered if they swap genders depending on the day of the week.

Legal protection of children who suffer body/gender dysphoria from having medical treatment that cannot be fully reversed e.g. puberty blockers, surgery etc. (as determined by independent rigorous scientific studies).

Legally reinforcing and expanding existing sex based provisions such as sports, schools, prisons etc.

Legal definitions e.g. sex = male or female, gender = ?, woman = adult human female, transphobia etc. so everyone has the same understanding. Changing existing legislation to be clear if it relates to biological sex or gender e.g. gender pay gap becomes sex pay gap.

Legal right not to be outed (no pronouns,) .

Legally requiring public bodies (may be wider) to record biological sex, GRC sex and gender and being clear which is being used when publishing statistical analysis etc. This is important to ensure preventative healthcare is inclusive I.e. trans men are invited for regular smears etc. and other service provisions are accurately planned and targeted.

Including Maya’s ruling so biological sex is a defined belief and therefore a protected characteristic.

Etc………

That would be nice.

Unfortunately 'Legal right not to be outed' is completely irreconcilable with all those aims to protect anything sex-based.

Whatsnewpussyhat · 17/02/2022 00:56

We are also still waiting for anyone to give us a clear, consistent, logical, measurable definition of what 'trans' now means.

It used to be clear. Medically diagnosed transsexuals with dysphoria. They are who were meant to be protected under gender reassignment This is no longer allowed.

Now it is whatever every individual claims it is. Even trans people can't seem to agree on a definition!

It now includes part time cross dressers, males with no dysphoria, people who make no changes to their appearance but still claim to have a thing called a 'gender identity' and students who identify as cats and emojis ffs.

So, what exactly now needs protecting that wouldn't fall under religious belief? Because that is all the new gender identity ideology is.

TheMarzipanDildo · 17/02/2022 00:52

“It’s hard AF being trans, why make it harder ?“

Imagine you were a male sex offender who targeted women and was about to go to prison. What’s to lose from identifying as a woman and going to women’s prison? Is that not a fucked up idea?

Women have been sexually assaulted by male bodied people in prison.

Clymene · 17/02/2022 00:40

The GRA is a terrible law and it should be repealed.

There is no need for any complexity about identities being enshrined in law. Identify however you want and you should never be discriminated against because of it.

Enough4me · 17/02/2022 00:36

Sexual stereotyping, sexual harassment and sexual abuse are all real... but denied and minimised as they don't fit the new ideology.

Whatsnewpussyhat · 17/02/2022 00:33

So would you also be against people self identifying as gay, sexual orientation also being a protected characteristic?

Gay people don't need to self identify as gay. And yes, sexual orientation is a protected characteristic which defines gay as same SEX attracted.
Claiming lesbian now means 'gender' attracted is homophobic bullshit.

SEX is also a protected characteristic. Funny how that one gets ignored though.

Enough4me · 17/02/2022 00:32

Trans do pick and choose. Eddie Izzard chooses what to be and isn't one identified label. He highlights how this isn't real (like sex and sexuality), it simply isn't being, but is pretending.

AlexaShutUp · 17/02/2022 00:25

So would you also be against people self identifying as gay, sexual orientation also being a protected characteristic?

It’s hard AF being trans, why make it harder ?

I don't understand your analogy with gay people.

As far as I can see, "self identifying" as gay doesn't put anyone else at risk or encroach on anyone else's rights. Indeed, it is hard to see how anyone could be considered gay if they didn't self identify as such.

The trans issue is different because there is a risk to others, no matter how small. If men could identify themselves as trans women in order to get access to single sex spaces for women, the rights of women are impacted. Surely you can see that this is different?

I genuinely don't want trans people to suffer, but I don't want their rights to encroach on mine or on the rights of other women.

I don't have strong feelings about people self identifying with regard to gender as I still don't actually know what gender actually is. I don't get the concept of "feeling like a woman". However, I don't think gender, whatever it is, should be confused with sex, and I do not think that men should be able to self identify as anything in order to get access to women's spaces. It isn't safe.

ashitghost · 17/02/2022 00:24

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

sst1234 · 17/02/2022 00:22

Oh yes this is absolutely what they should be debating. Every other problem that we pay our politicians to solve has been solved. Right?