Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MP's will debate changing the Gender Recognition Act

163 replies

Witheringtong · 16/02/2022 22:10

On Monday 21 February, MP's will debate reforming the Gender Recognition Act.
committees.parliament.uk/committee/326/petitions-committee/news/160946/reform-of-the-gender-recognition-act-to-be-debated-by-mps/

Where do you stand? Since there are only 2 voting options the vote can't reflect all the possible options so you might have to add a comment.
Personally, I dont see how safeguarding or sex based rights can be upheld as long as people can change their legal sex marker. I'm also opposed to convicted sex offenders or violent offenders being able to change their legal details, let alone be places in a women's prison.

AIBU - The GRA should be changed to make it easier for any person to change their legal sex markers, name and birth certificate.

YANBU - The GRA should not be changed.

OP posts:
Whatwouldscullydo · 17/02/2022 12:03

I have seen posts on twitter which say that if children can consent to gender surgery which they can in a lot of the world, then the age of consent for children to have sex should be lowered

Wasn't there also opposition to a bill outlawing FGM because it might make it harder for trans people to get surgery ?

Whatwouldscullydo · 17/02/2022 12:01

But they are oftenpretendingto be the opposite sex. Which is physically impossible

I always say that they are angry at the wrong people.

I mean really someone should have entered the prices fully informed that its not up to the rest of the world to he responsible fir their well being. No one is obliged to ply along with them. That the same restrictions apply as per their sex along with everyone else.

Plus we'd mostly turned a blind eye to the less than 5000 people with a grc. It was lobby groups that expanded the definition to include basically everyone. Of course that wasnt going to go unnoticed. But instead of being angry at being lied to and having everything stuffed up by greedy lobby groups. Somehow it's our fault Hmm

lifeturnsonadime · 17/02/2022 11:58

@PseudoplasticFluid

Wont you think of the children, right wing moral panic script point by point

Yes how very right wing of me to not want an adult male to get their penis out in front of my daughter.

The left are sooo enlightened these days....

The TRAs want to break down boundaries.

I have seen posts on twitter which say that if children can consent to gender surgery which they can in a lot of the world, then the age of consent for children to have sex should be lowered.

But yes it's all just pearl clutching.

PseudoplasticFluid · 17/02/2022 11:53

Wont you think of the children, right wing moral panic script point by point

Yes how very right wing of me to not want an adult male to get their penis out in front of my daughter.

The left are sooo enlightened these days....

PseudoplasticFluid · 17/02/2022 11:48

Trans people aren’t pretending to be trans for a day“ either.

But they are often pretending to be the opposite sex. Which is physically impossible. This is the problem when people change what they perceive to be gender, and then demand the rights of the opposite sex. Gender and sea aren't the same thing. Yet the two are conflated, effectively destroying safeguards and rights for women and children.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 17/02/2022 11:42

What is it about declaring oneself to be a woman that changes a male person's male privilege, socialisation and behaviour?

What exactly do you define a "transwoman" as?

MummBRaaarrrTheEverLeaking · 17/02/2022 11:42

@Whatsnewpussyhat

We are also still waiting for anyone to give us a clear, consistent, logical, measurable definition of what 'trans' now means.

It used to be clear. Medically diagnosed transsexuals with dysphoria. They are who were meant to be protected under gender reassignment This is no longer allowed.

Now it is whatever every individual claims it is. Even trans people can't seem to agree on a definition!

It now includes part time cross dressers, males with no dysphoria, people who make no changes to their appearance but still claim to have a thing called a 'gender identity' and students who identify as cats and emojis ffs.

So, what exactly now needs protecting that wouldn't fall under religious belief? Because that is all the new gender identity ideology is.

This.

Women's prisons, refuges, rape crisis centres, sports, opportunities and awards, changing rooms and yes even the poxy loos for the "we just want to pee" brigade, are not a fucking free for all for anyone who feels like it.

These things are for females, the rights our mothers, grandmothers, great grandmothers and beyond fought bloody hard for. And just like that, taken away.

This is not about transsexuals. This is way past that. This is about males, fully functioning cock and balls males, who think it's their bloody right to insert themselves into every part of female life and have the a typical male aggression response when anyone says no.

There's a creepy video from such a person, smugly singing (badly) about how if lesbians won't sleep with them, then they're transphobes. "Cis lesbians I'm talking to you. You won't get a pass when we're through" the lyrics go.

THAT is who the 'be kind' brigade want in women's spaces. It's not Hayley Cropper, it's Barbie Kardashian, who near ripped out a woman's eyelids, has expressed their wish to cause more harm to women and is where? A women's prison, because "gender identity" It's that man in the US who changed his name to something like Princess Zoe Love, went to a women's prison, preyed on someone unable to properly consent, so rape. Then upon release changed back to a man again.

You open up women's spaces to everyone, THIS is who gets let in. And instead of going "hang about, we don't want this, this needs consideration and balance" activists scream bigot and transphobia and those in power back right off with "it's complicated, it's divisive, it's both sides"

It's why this matter is STILL ongoing, after years, because nobody wants to take the responsibility of telling a bunch of male bullies NO.

Antsgomarching · 17/02/2022 11:40

@AfraidToRun

On the prison issue, what do we do with female prisoners who sexually assault women? Or men who sexually assault men? Do we put homosexual sex offenders in different prisons because there is a threat?

I completely understand the instinct that the idea of transwomen entering female spaces feels like a threat. I haven't really resolved how I feel about it. I wonder if I'm biased and I need to explore further about what I really feel, educate myself and then reconsider.

Women don’t commit the level of sexual violence men do. Something like 50% of identified transwomen in prisons either require maxi security (so utterly dangerous) or are sex offenders. 20% of the general male population are sex offenders. Thats quite high. 3% of the female prison population are sex offenders. The problem is males will always have a physical advantage over a female, it renders female prisoners locked in with male prisoners very vulnerable. The threat is amplified as it were.
Ereshkigalangcleg · 17/02/2022 11:40

I completely understand the instinct that the idea of transwomen entering female spaces feels like a threat. I haven't really resolved how I feel about it. I wonder if I'm biased and I need to explore further about what I really feel, educate myself and then reconsider.

If you just think they are male, which they are, it becomes so much clearer.

Artichokeleaves · 17/02/2022 11:36

@AfraidToRun

On the prison issue, what do we do with female prisoners who sexually assault women? Or men who sexually assault men? Do we put homosexual sex offenders in different prisons because there is a threat?

I completely understand the instinct that the idea of transwomen entering female spaces feels like a threat. I haven't really resolved how I feel about it. I wonder if I'm biased and I need to explore further about what I really feel, educate myself and then reconsider.

On the prison issue:

If female prisoners are being assaulted by other female prisoners how does adding male prisoners many with a history of being serious sex offenders into the mix? Is this a case of if women are getting assaulted anyway then whatever, a few more doesn't matter?

What is the difference in experience between a sexual assault from a female and a male? Rape can only be committed by a male. One of the males who has been caught assaulting female prisoners through self ID was in prison in the first place for raping a female patient in the mental health female ward the rapist had self identified onto. The damage caused by the rape has left her too injured to be able to have children.

What is the frequency and significance of statistics of female on female assault compared to male on female? 99% isn't it? Committed by males?

What is the frequency of lesbians sexually assaulting other women? Isn't this a rather homophobic strawman conflating possible sexual attraction with assault and harm?

Fgs what is the matter with people? There is no frigging excuse at all for making male people happy by providing them with non consenting female bodies undressing and vulnerable around them, and it relies on appalling male supremacism that male wishes matter more than female people being afraid, harassed, stripped of dignity, stripped of privacy, assaulted and raped. There are many, many other ways to care for TW prisoners without stuffing every female prisoner on an altar for them.

Iamclearlyamug · 17/02/2022 11:33

@Ionlydomassiveones

“It’s hard AF being trans, why make it harder ?”

It’s hard AF being a woman when men can just say they’re a woman and take away hard won protections, dignities and safety.

This!
DomesticatedZombie · 17/02/2022 11:32

The GRA either needs to be repealed or the EA tightened up massively. Birth certs shouldn't be falsifiable. Single sex exemptions should be straightforward and well supported.

Whatwouldscullydo · 17/02/2022 11:31

Neither.

We don't need it any more now that same sex marriage is legal.

Laws should reflect reality.

bishophaha · 17/02/2022 11:29

I haven't really resolved how I feel about it. I wonder if I'm biased and I need to explore further about what I really feel, educate myself and then reconsider.

It is a hard thing to come to a conclusion about - wherever you draw the line you feel you are 'excluding' someone.

I guess think about a) what your definition of 'transwoman' is and
b) what situations you would feel comfortable allowing a male person into a female prison, and then how far away from e.g. Stonewall's objectives this is (unless the situation is 'if the male person simply declares they are a woman' in which case, you're with Stonewall!) and how this could work, whether the line could be argued, whether the line is a fair and ethical 'requirement'.

There's an interesting discussion here
hollylawford-smith.org/hitching-glitterbeard-carts-to-transsexual-wagons/

Artichokeleaves · 17/02/2022 11:27

It’s hard AF being trans, why make it harder?

Way, way too simplistic, and however unhappy and hard things are for male people, the answer cannot ever be to sacrifice females and their rights, access and equality as some kind of consolation prize. That is a batshit, wholly unacceptable reason to do the harm that females have and are suffering.

This was a truly stupid piece of legislation, it has messed with safeguarding, record keeping, female access and equality, harm to females and to children, messed with the impartiality of police and justice, been exploited for appalling political capture and bias, it has exposed really ugly levels of misogyny in the UK and created a precedent that reality can be a matter of choice instead of objective fact if you come from a powerful, male led group. It was created for very bad reasons, it's original purpose is gone, it has been repurposed, and it needs repealing.

AfraidToRun · 17/02/2022 11:12

On the prison issue, what do we do with female prisoners who sexually assault women? Or men who sexually assault men? Do we put homosexual sex offenders in different prisons because there is a threat?

I completely understand the instinct that the idea of transwomen entering female spaces feels like a threat. I haven't really resolved how I feel about it. I wonder if I'm biased and I need to explore further about what I really feel, educate myself and then reconsider.

Waspie · 17/02/2022 11:08

@Auntieobem

Gender shouldn't be a legal issue. Laws should be based on sex and biological reality, not some made up sense of gender based on social stereotypes.
Agree with this.

And also with Antsgomarching's post immediately afterwards. Gender is nothing to do with either biological sex or sexuality.

bishophaha · 17/02/2022 11:06

Making things difficult for (and by extension discriminating against) "genuine" transgender people is the wrong way to go about it.

Also, there is no concept in law (or in gender speak) of 'genuine' or not genuine transgender people.
To say you are transgender is to BE transgender.

bishophaha · 17/02/2022 11:05

If our society says it's possible to change gender from that assigned at birth

Genders aren't assigned at birth, though.
Please don't conflate sex and gender - it's not helpful to any discussion!

People often say that certain sexes 'match' certain genders but won't say how or why. So this is another thing that needs to be clearly set out in any debate about sex and gender.

bishophaha · 17/02/2022 11:03

[quote ohhooh]@bishophaha

Therefore it should simply be split by 'male' and 'female' and everyone should accept that this will include people with a huge variety of inner feelings and appearance/dress.

Why should women just accept that they can't have spaces or services just for them? Why should they just accept that anyone can say what they want to access these services or spaces?
It's a step backwards. [/quote]
Not sure if you're using a different definition of women from me.

Female spaces should have female people in them, however masculine they feel/look/dress, whether they have had a mastectomy or hysterectomy or not, whether they love shopping and makeup or not, whether they think they have a gender or not.

It's far easier to split by natal sex than to try and fiddle around 'but this person can go in the opposite space if they've had THIS surgery, but not that surgery' etc.

And obviously all decent people would be happy to stick with this as natal sex isn't a judgment about anything about you.

And obviously this is only where there is a need for single-sex spaces for the purposes of dignity and safety, etc, not in general life (eg I'm not proposing separate pavements for men/women).

Antsgomarching · 17/02/2022 11:00

Gender identity isn’t the same thing as being gay. Gay people weren’t asking for special rights which impinged on other peoples rights, they were asking to be left alone. The comparison doesn’t work, some trans people are asking for rights which would allow them to impinge on the rights of women and girls to single sex spaces. They already have all the rights their sex entitles them to.

loos yup, but also rape crisis centres, prisons, hospital wards, being able to choose the sex of your hcp or perhaps your elderly mum needs care which includes intimate care and she would feel her dignity is undermined by being cared for by someone she sees as male, womens only shortlists etc etc there is also evidence that you are more likely to be assaulted in mixed sex spaces. Thats not moral panic.

From The Times

Unisex changing rooms are more dangerous for women and girls than single-sex facilities, research by The Sunday Times shows. Almost 90% of reported sexual assaults, harassment and voyeurism in swimming pool and sports-centre changing rooms happen in unisex facilities, which make up less than half the total.

Gender-neutral changing is growing as councils seek to cut staff costs and cater to transgender people. But one MP said it risked becoming a “magnet” for sex offenders and increased the danger to women and girls.

Also no I don’t want to share my spaces with biological males, why should I? I’m not a support human.

It’s narcissism, you see this in womens sport. Trans women who compete against women know they are doing so unfairly they know they have an advantage and all I can think only a complete narcissist would struggle to understand this isn’t appropriate.

I don’t care if people identify as trans or ask me to use particular pronouns, I’m happy to oblige (I may eye roll at the more ridiculous examples, but y’know you do you as long as you aren’t being a pain in the ass”)and genuinely believe people should be free to express themselves how they choose without fear (barring the MAP lot, they are just grim). I care about the rights of women. I’m not obliged to put biological males above women in respect to safeguarding and fairness.

Auntieobem · 17/02/2022 10:56

Gender shouldn't be a legal issue. Laws should be based on sex and biological reality, not some made up sense of gender based on social stereotypes.

MorningStarling · 17/02/2022 10:56

I voted YABU.

I've said this before but either a person can change their gender or they can't. If our society says it's possible to change gender from that assigned at birth then that should be the end of the matter - people should be free to choose their gender and access resources that they would otherwise be barred from, whether it's changing rooms, prisons or elite sport.

The risk to women is a separate issue. It's already illegal to harass or intimidate people, it's already illegal to sexually assault or abuse people. What needs tightening up is the prevention and punishment aspect. Making things difficult for (and by extension discriminating against) "genuine" transgender people is the wrong way to go about it. We don't ban muslims from going to busy places because a few will do so to kill people, we spend a fortune on identifying, tracking and preventing those few problem cases. Likewise, rather than banning transgender women (because it's only transgender women that seem to be feared) from services designed for women, we should prevent the few who will abuse their access from doing so.

Of course, if society decided it was not possible to change gender then the whole question would become irrelevant. Personally I tend to favour this route, I think it's possible to feel you're of the "wrong" gender, but that doesn't automatically mean you're able to change it. (That's just my view - society has decided otherwise, and perhaps with evidence I will change it.)

ohhooh · 17/02/2022 10:55

@bishophaha

Therefore it should simply be split by 'male' and 'female' and everyone should accept that this will include people with a huge variety of inner feelings and appearance/dress.

Why should women just accept that they can't have spaces or services just for them? Why should they just accept that anyone can say what they want to access these services or spaces?
It's a step backwards.

bishophaha · 17/02/2022 10:54

Might get my bingo card ready for the actual debate - will be interesting to see who actually turns up.
Bet you anything there is inconsistent conflating of "sex" and "gender".
"Gender" and "gender identity" won't be defined in a non-circular way.
Ignorance of the fact that female people across the world and throughout history are the victims of violence and sexual violence because of their sex and not what sort of things they like/their character/their dress sense.