Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MP's will debate changing the Gender Recognition Act

163 replies

Witheringtong · 16/02/2022 22:10

On Monday 21 February, MP's will debate reforming the Gender Recognition Act.
committees.parliament.uk/committee/326/petitions-committee/news/160946/reform-of-the-gender-recognition-act-to-be-debated-by-mps/

Where do you stand? Since there are only 2 voting options the vote can't reflect all the possible options so you might have to add a comment.
Personally, I dont see how safeguarding or sex based rights can be upheld as long as people can change their legal sex marker. I'm also opposed to convicted sex offenders or violent offenders being able to change their legal details, let alone be places in a women's prison.

AIBU - The GRA should be changed to make it easier for any person to change their legal sex markers, name and birth certificate.

YANBU - The GRA should not be changed.

OP posts:
Artichokeleaves · 17/02/2022 15:36

What about the male manager of a womens refuge service with massive skin in the game who has taken a women's post and insists that any females entering the service must 'reframe their trauma' and have their beliefs adjusted to male centric service before being permitted help? And who has female people unable to go into refuges and staying in dangerous, lifethreatening situations (common for females but very rare for TW based on evidence given to the Scots govt) because they cannot face a mixed sex environment and their trauma and their needs mean nothing compared to the nurtured and prioritised needs of a male person?

As one leader in the field said on Women's Hour not long ago mentioning two women on her caseload who refused to come to the centre because males were there; this is inevitably going to end in female lives lost.

We have females who have been raped in prisons and mental health wards in the name of male freedom of choice and valuing their identity.

But 'trans people benefit' ?

Not at this bloody cost. No.

Artichokeleaves · 17/02/2022 15:29

it’s trans people who benefit

Only the male ones. The right to access all female areas is a male benefit, not a trans benefit.

Does that benefit justify the cost to female people?

Why are the male people in this situation more valuable and important than the female ones? Do you see how this has just become sex discrimination and quite frankly male supremacism that it is even being considered debatable that some females to lose all access to any resources, facilities and services in order that males can have total freedom of choice from all the resources, facilities and services?

What do we do with the females now unable to access women's resources, services and facilities? How can those women's facilities etc be called 'inclusive' when the job of a women's facility/service is to be accessible to all women and all protected characteristics? (There's nine. Not one. No matter what Stonewall says.)

Can those male people's needs be met in other ways than stripping all female resources away from female people with the heavy cost to female equality, access, inclusion, dignity, safety and autonomy, and the basic human right to not be used as a support animal regardless of consent?

Let's look at some real live current cases:

the MNetter for example who is currently trying to deal with having no access to her local rape crisis service, LA funded, because while transwomen have no less than three different groups to choose from for help with their rape (mens, LGBT+ and women's which is a mixed sex group) females get one option: it's mixed sex. The service absolutely refuses to provide a female only group, even in another building. This is inexcusable dog in the manger selfishness and intolerance. This political position would see female rape victims without support than permit them service where they can be in a female only group. Saying 'no' to male people and 'female people have rights and needs and lived experience too' is 'hate'. Confused

What about the MNetter who was homeless in a tent with injuries for months because her trauma prevented her accessing a women's shelter because they were all mixed sex, and her trying to explain that her needs meant she could not enter such a space involved her being lectured on how the male people came first, their trauma and needs mattered, and if she did not service their need she got nothing.

Are we in bloody Gilead or what?

It is not women who have destroyed all the good will here by providing endless experience of the realities of this political agenda.

PseudoplasticFluid · 17/02/2022 15:05

it’s trans people who benefit

It's males who benefit, at the expense of women and children.

JaninaDuszejko · 17/02/2022 14:50

Are we all writing to our MP about this? You can write you own letter or there's a proforma here: www.womensrights.network/gra-debate

WorriedMumsDontSleep · 17/02/2022 14:49

Repealed. Dreadful law that should never have been allowed to happen. Just shows how low women are In the pecking order that it ever went through.

FOJN · 17/02/2022 14:38

it’s trans people who benefit

Transgender people might but transexuals absolutely do not, in fact they will be harmed by self ID and many do not support it.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 17/02/2022 14:35

it’s trans people who benefit

I think that's the point, women and children don't, males do.

Witheringtong · 17/02/2022 14:33

Single sex spaces and services exist and are legal for a reason. Why aren't third spaces an acceptable solution?

OP posts:
brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 17/02/2022 14:28

@Beowulfa

Ask yourself who benefits from self ID? It's not women and children, is it?
it’s trans people who benefit
StormyWindow · 17/02/2022 13:45

@AfraidToRun

Thanks for the statistics. They're helpful.

I meant I'm just generally uncomfortable around men in all spaces because I always feel threatened (trauma history) so I don't know if my own feeling is an appropriate measure to use to steer my opinion. If that makes any sense. I'm not sure it does but it is helpful to see other people's views and I'm taking it all in.

If only one woman felt threatened by male bodied people in women only spaces due to trauma history would that make it ok? Does she not matter? Don't you matter? And sadly you are far from the only one who feels that way because of past experiences with men, do we not matter either? There is no good argument (except money and women managed it when they had to campaign for women's loo's etc) against third spaces, a gender neutral option for anyone who 'doesn't mind' who they share with or feels unsafe in the facilities for their biological sex. That way no one has to feel or be unsafe, so it's worth considering exactly why the trans lobby don't want that, they want access to women's spaces and nothing less.
Artichokeleaves · 17/02/2022 13:30

@maddy68

It should certainly be debated. That's the point of democracy.
It certainly should, I wholly agree.

However also worth reminding MPs when contacting about this that this petition (pro self ID) has reached the number needed for a debate.

Any attempt to put up a petition against self ID (I know from Twitter at least one woman who has attempted this more or less purely to check) results in the petition immediately being removed as 'hate speech'.

Women are being expected to join this 'debate' with sellotape over their mouths, and both hands tied behind their backs.

bishophaha · 17/02/2022 13:19

@AfraidToRun

Thanks for the statistics. They're helpful.

I meant I'm just generally uncomfortable around men in all spaces because I always feel threatened (trauma history) so I don't know if my own feeling is an appropriate measure to use to steer my opinion. If that makes any sense. I'm not sure it does but it is helpful to see other people's views and I'm taking it all in.

Oh, I see Flowers

and good point. There is a lot of "well I don't feel uncomfortable with a male next to me in the loos" bandied about as well - those people are less considerate about whether their own feeling is a good measure!

I would imagine certain spaces are worse and I think it's these we want to protect.

FOJN · 17/02/2022 13:15

I voted YANBU but I really think the GRA should be repealed. We should never permit lies to be enshrined in law. This would resolve the issue for detransitioners and close the loophole which makes DBS checks dependent on the honesty of GRC holders.

In the absence of a universally agreed definition of gender identity it should be protected as a belief, non believers should not face punitive action.

Protection for gender reassignment should be maintained as per the EA 2010 but with clarification on what reassignment means. Protection for transitioning individuals with dysphoria needs to be meaningful and not open to anyone who simply says, "I identify as...".

Protections for single sex spaces/services/ participation in sport should be reinforced to protect the rights of women.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 17/02/2022 13:14

There's no such thing as "changing gender". They mean sex, in a sort of disembodied way. If "gender" and sex were separate they wouldn't need to access female spaces, because they are about sex.

Whatsnewpussyhat · 17/02/2022 13:05

I've said this before but either a person can change their gender or they can't. If our society says it's possible to change gender from that assigned at birth then that should be the end of the matter - people should be free to choose their gender and access resources that they would otherwise be barred from, whether it's changing rooms, prisons or elite sport

Can you explain what a 'gender' is?
Nothing is 'assigned at birth'. Sex is observed. Male or female. Simple.

If a few people want to define themselves by outdated, social sex role stereotypes, that's fine. It doesn't change their sex though. And following the stereotypes of the opposite sex isn't breaking stereotypes it is enforcing them further by redefining women to mean a performance of femininity.

People are free to dress how they want and call themselves by whatever name they choose but no, males should not have access to anything female only just because they make an impossible claim of womanhood.

Women should not have their sex class and all safeguarding removed just because a few males demand 'inclusion'.

maddy68 · 17/02/2022 12:59

It should certainly be debated. That's the point of democracy.

Beowulfa · 17/02/2022 12:57

Ask yourself who benefits from self ID? It's not women and children, is it?

Ohsugarhoneyicetea · 17/02/2022 12:54

The GRA should be repealed, its nonsense. You cannot change your sex, its a legal fiction that is causing untold damage in society. Gender diversity within the sexes should be celebrated, not fantasised into non existence. So utterly backwards to suggest being gender stereotype non-conforming changes the sex you are. Its an embarrassment to humanity.

AfraidToRun · 17/02/2022 12:40

Thanks for the statistics. They're helpful.

I meant I'm just generally uncomfortable around men in all spaces because I always feel threatened (trauma history) so I don't know if my own feeling is an appropriate measure to use to steer my opinion. If that makes any sense. I'm not sure it does but it is helpful to see other people's views and I'm taking it all in.

lifeturnsonadime · 17/02/2022 12:16

no gendered crime

Crimes and violence against women and girls is not because of gender but because of sex. This is the problem when language has been deliberately mangled.

If a trans woman is attacked it will not be for the same reason as if a woman is attacked. It is impossible for a person to change sex.

I'm uncomfortable with the GRA in any form now, because the notion of 'living as the opposite sex' is so ill defined and can only be based on gender stereotypes.

Adhering to stereotypes doesn't mean a person has changed sex and should not give them access to women's sport, prizes and roles or safe spaces. They are not women. The GRA is a legal fiction which expands the definition of a woman to more than adult human female. This is to the expense of women and girls. I know it also applies to the definition of man before anyone pipes up but men are less likely to be harmed by women who identify as men turning up in their spaces.

PseudoplasticFluid · 17/02/2022 12:11

[quote Jackjack0962]YADNBU.

Contact your MP to make them aware it should be repealed. Really easy form to complete.

www.womensrights.network/gra-debate[/quote]
Thanks Jack. This is really helpful. I will share amongst friends and across social media.

bishophaha · 17/02/2022 12:10

I would be uncomfortable being in a single sex space with a man but I'm uncomfortable in non-single spaces too

I'm not deliberately being dense but what is the difference between these?

AfraidToRun · 17/02/2022 12:07

I really don't know what to think. I would be uncomfortable being in a single sex space with a man but I'm uncomfortable in non-single spaces too so how do I know what is an appropriate amount of uncomfortableness and what should be protected? Everything? Nothing? Something in between?

I guess I think focusing on threat isn't enough, it's more than that but I can't work any of that out either. It's just a big mess of my own personal experiences, biases, beliefs, wishes, upgrowing (massive gender stereotypes I'm still undoing the damage from). I don't have any answers and don't know if I'm even asking the right questions. I think I'd prefer a world where we all treated as equals because we were equal and there were was no gendered crime but by the very nature of being human that will never be the case.

Artichokeleaves · 17/02/2022 12:05

Wont you think of the children, right wing moral panic script point by point

Feel free to call women whatever names you feel you have to. Sticks and stones etc.

Jackjack0962 · 17/02/2022 12:04

YADNBU.

Contact your MP to make them aware it should be repealed. Really easy form to complete.

www.womensrights.network/gra-debate