Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MP's will debate changing the Gender Recognition Act

163 replies

Witheringtong · 16/02/2022 22:10

On Monday 21 February, MP's will debate reforming the Gender Recognition Act.
committees.parliament.uk/committee/326/petitions-committee/news/160946/reform-of-the-gender-recognition-act-to-be-debated-by-mps/

Where do you stand? Since there are only 2 voting options the vote can't reflect all the possible options so you might have to add a comment.
Personally, I dont see how safeguarding or sex based rights can be upheld as long as people can change their legal sex marker. I'm also opposed to convicted sex offenders or violent offenders being able to change their legal details, let alone be places in a women's prison.

AIBU - The GRA should be changed to make it easier for any person to change their legal sex markers, name and birth certificate.

YANBU - The GRA should not be changed.

OP posts:
JellySaurus · 18/02/2022 15:06

Ah the balanced MN trans debate where FTM don't exist

Funny, isn't it, how TRAs and MRAs are entirely oblivious to the fact that we meanie TERFs include a whole swathe of trans-identifying people in feminism. Couldn't possibly because transmen are female, could it?

Transwomen are invaders attempting to colonise womanhood. For whatever reason and however 'genuine' they are in their beliefs.

Women, children, the elderly and all other vulnerable populations are the casualties of this invasion.

Transmen are collateral damage.

TRAs and MRAs do not give a monkey's about the well-being of girls trying to escape toxic patriarchalism.

Girls sucked into the trans ideology are physically and emotionally harmed by it. Far more harm comes to them than to boys.

We know transmen exist and we have huge concern for their well-being.

ParsleySageRosemary · 18/02/2022 12:49

I’d be interested in talking to more FtM. They are the majority of trans.

The ones I have met have all either been teenagers who are experimenting with the latest fad, bluntly for little more reason than it is the latest fad. Alternatively I’ve met some who are badly scarred by experiences with men, and have a lot in common with others fighting for womens rights against male violence.

We are not helping such people by surrendering what rights we have and forgetting the awareness of male violence that has been achieved.

VickyEadieofThigh · 18/02/2022 12:32

@ohhooh

I think it's tough but YANBU. I don't think anyone should just be able to "self identify" as something that is a protected characteristic (if that's the right phrase?).
This. Exactly this.
balalake · 18/02/2022 12:18

@PseudoplasticFluid I agree we have to recognise that changing from a man to a woman is very different, and seemingly also less commonplace.

Realityisreal · 18/02/2022 09:46

It is so good to see this being openly discussed outside of the Sex and Gender pages. The more voices in the discussion the more likely we are to identify both possible threats and solutions.

JellySaurus · 17/02/2022 23:42

On the prison issue, what do we do with female prisoners who sexually assault women? Or men who sexually assault men? Do we put homosexual sex offenders in different prisons because there is a threat?

Prisoners who are a particular risk to other prisoners, or are at particular risk from other prisoners, are segregated from those other prisoners within the same estate. Male prisoners who are considered at risk or a risk are segregated within a male prison. A male prisoner who presents a risk to other male prisoners is not placed in a female prison to keep the other male prisoners safe! A male prisoner who is at risk of assault from other male prisoners is not placed in a female prison to keep him safe!

334bu · 17/02/2022 23:36

"AfraidToRun

On the prison issue, what do we do with female prisoners who sexually assault women? Or men who sexually assault men? Do we put homosexual sex offenders in different prisons because there is a threat?"

What has this to do with putting male prisoners in female prisons? The 0.8% of sex offenders who are female can be accommodated in female prisons and the 99.2% who are male can be dealt with in special units within the male prison estate.

redglobox · 17/02/2022 22:43

It should be repealed. The state shouldn't help people to disguise and lie about their sex. It puts women and children at risk and perpetuates the fantasy that it's possible to change sex.

Isthatthebestyoucando · 17/02/2022 22:34

@AfraidToRun

On the prison issue, what do we do with female prisoners who sexually assault women? Or men who sexually assault men? Do we put homosexual sex offenders in different prisons because there is a threat?

I completely understand the instinct that the idea of transwomen entering female spaces feels like a threat. I haven't really resolved how I feel about it. I wonder if I'm biased and I need to explore further about what I really feel, educate myself and then reconsider.

There is not a threat from homosexual people being in prisons for their own sex. Sexual assault and rape are violent crimes and completely separate from attraction, straight men still rape men because male offending patterns, violence, power and control. Female sex offenders are rare. There was a Swedish study that concluded that male offending patterns do not change at all with transition, trans women carry no less risk to a woman than any other male, 58% of males identifying as women in the male prison estate have one or more convictions for a rape or sexual assault vs 18% of the rest of the men. Please do not bring lesbians and gay men into this.
PseudoplasticFluid · 17/02/2022 19:38

@JustAnotherPoster00

Ah the balanced MN trans debate where FTM don't exist and any utterance from a TRA is taken as gospel that all MTF think exactly the same and that all women who don't ascribe to their GC views are nothing more than handmaidens with no freedom of thought and no agency of their own
Ah, here we go again, same old same old. Transmen, the type of female that trans activists suddenly notice and drag in with the whatabouterry to bolster their argument. And just like any other female, they discard when they've finished with them.

Transmen don't post the same risks to women. Thats because they are biological females.

Transwomen however post the same high risk to women that males do. Thats because they are biological males.

Let's not pretend this is anything other than what it is.

A men's rights movement.

SunniDelite · 17/02/2022 19:14

JustAnotherPoster00 Thu 17-Feb-22 10:36:45

"SunniDelite

Woman encounters large man in ladies loos. Woman is scared. Woman phones security or police. They can't do anything because he self-id's as a woman and the woman is just being transphobic. Already happening around the world. YANBU."

Woman encounters large bearded man in ladies loos, Woman is scared, Woman phones security or police, They cant do anything because he is a FTM and the woman is just being transphobic.

Always about the toilets and always about MTF, who checks peoples underwear when they go in now? Never been asked what I have in my underwear to be granted access to any toilets hmm

@JustAnotherPoster00
So what? Woman should still feel able to report it... And toilets? because that's the only single sex space that some older and elderly women use. We don't want our young peoples' sports, clubs, meetings and changing rooms colonised with people with p3nis's either. We don't want people born male taking our scholarships, prizes, achievements, and places in boardrooms and shortlists. They exist for a reason- because we are disadvantaged by our sex in that we have babies, feed babies, care for children, need flexible working, earn less because we often work part-time, need time off to care for people, have periods, have menopause, etc, etc......

lifeturnsonadime · 17/02/2022 19:13

@JustAnotherPoster00

Ah the balanced MN trans debate where FTM don't exist and any utterance from a TRA is taken as gospel that all MTF think exactly the same and that all women who don't ascribe to their GC views are nothing more than handmaidens with no freedom of thought and no agency of their own
Who has said FTM don't exist? I specifically mentioned FTM earlier in the thread but said that this doesn't pose the same risk to males in single sex spaces.

Frankly if just one woman is uncomfortable with the removal of single sex provision that is enough women. No matter how many women with agency and thought of their own don't care about the erosion of rights, I have not given them the authority to remove my rights to be considered independent of males who identify as women or to have single sex spaces.

Women's rights as a whole are not theirs to give away to males with special identities.

Artichokeleaves · 17/02/2022 19:10

@JustAnotherPoster00

Ah the balanced MN trans debate where FTM don't exist and any utterance from a TRA is taken as gospel that all MTF think exactly the same and that all women who don't ascribe to their GC views are nothing more than handmaidens with no freedom of thought and no agency of their own
This gets so boring.

As repeatedly stated on the thread this is not a TQ+ issue, because the issue here, for females, on a women's rights forum, is the issue of male people wanting unimpeded access to all female spaces regardless of impact on females, with a really staggering lack of care.

It is hardly just one, is it? Find me, please, any TRA with a divergent view on this? Because Stonewall, Mermaids, GIRES, Twitter, GLP..... I haven't seen a single one speaking out against this appalling anti-female agenda.

And women who prioritise care and consideration for males and their access to female spaces, and see females as acceptable collateral damage and talk about kindness and inclusion while excluding females from any facilities so males can have access to all the facilities and have their preferred choice? No. I don't use name calling, I'm not twelve, but I don't have a lot of respect for that position, nor a belief that someone who could dismiss female needs and not want solutions that work for all instead of just for males know enough about the issues, or have thought them through far enough. Because the only other possible reason is some fixed sex based belief that male people are intrinsically of higher value than female ones. Which is absolutely bloody tragic.

JustAnotherPoster00 · 17/02/2022 19:04

Ah the balanced MN trans debate where FTM don't exist and any utterance from a TRA is taken as gospel that all MTF think exactly the same and that all women who don't ascribe to their GC views are nothing more than handmaidens with no freedom of thought and no agency of their own

lifeturnsonadime · 17/02/2022 18:56

who medically aren't a clear sex

No one isn't medically a clear sex. At least this has nothing to do with gender identity. As far as I know DSD people, in the post part, don't want to be caught up or used in these battles.

Most women would advocate for third spaces for people who don't want to use the services for their sex. This isn't enough for the TRAs though. Nothing apart from complete capitulation is enough.

doublemonkey · 17/02/2022 18:24

It's becoming more and more obvious that the Gender Recognition Act should not be changed and is fit for purpose as it is.

Artichokeleaves · 17/02/2022 18:12

Women should not have their sex class and all safeguarding removed just because a few males demand 'inclusion'.

This.

Nor should women's spaces, resources and facilities become inaccessible and excluding of women so that TW can have their preferred choice of space.

Women don't want all the spaces. They want some facilities and resources left accessible to meet women's needs. The TQ+ lobby will not tolerate it. They are absolutely intolerant, exclusionary and oblivious to intersectionality or kindness or anything else but total male ownership and control of all women's spaces. Women will get what crumbs they're given and shut up or else.

And women are the ones accused of being 'hateful'.

itsgettingweird · 17/02/2022 17:59

@Whatsnewpussyhat

I've said this before but either a person can change their gender or they can't. If our society says it's possible to change gender from that assigned at birth then that should be the end of the matter - people should be free to choose their gender and access resources that they would otherwise be barred from, whether it's changing rooms, prisons or elite sport

Can you explain what a 'gender' is?
Nothing is 'assigned at birth'. Sex is observed. Male or female. Simple.

If a few people want to define themselves by outdated, social sex role stereotypes, that's fine. It doesn't change their sex though. And following the stereotypes of the opposite sex isn't breaking stereotypes it is enforcing them further by redefining women to mean a performance of femininity.

People are free to dress how they want and call themselves by whatever name they choose but no, males should not have access to anything female only just because they make an impossible claim of womanhood.

Women should not have their sex class and all safeguarding removed just because a few males demand 'inclusion'.

Explained how I feel but better than I did Grin
itsgettingweird · 17/02/2022 17:58

I'm absolutely for having sex and gender recognised separately.

I do think there needs to a third option for those who medically aren't a clear sex.

But you cannot change sex. On the basis it's a biological assignment and the hormones etc as well as physical characteristics are part of that.

It's a very complex area of discussion and topic of debate.

But I mostly have concerns that all the teaching of this is schools from a young age is encouraging more gender stereotypes rather than making everyone feel comfortable to be who they are.

Slothtoes · 17/02/2022 17:35

MPs need to know what a massive vote loser anything short of GRA repeal is for them. Neither of the ‘promote self ID’ or ‘do nothing’ positions will actually work for us. Women’s safety, dignity and privacy does matter. I’ll adapt some of the excellent posts on this thread for content.

Monitaurus · 17/02/2022 16:42

Clear as always *artichokeleaves” . We cannot tolerate this invasion of boundaries any longer. Please can everybody who agrees 3nsure that our MPs know where we stand. They usually say no ne is bothered by this and no one ever raises their concerns. Sometimes when we have written, their admin staff throw our comments way so they never get seen. Please stand up and be counted.

Slothtoes · 17/02/2022 16:31

I’d need this poll to include a ‘repeal’ option to be able to vote for it. The GRA is a sexist, badly conceived, nonsensical and outdated piece of law.
Live how you want to live, be happy, that’s great. But we all have a sex, and nobody can ever change their sex. Thinking otherwise is really not helping anyone.

JellySaurus · 17/02/2022 16:23

Same-sex marriage is not the only reason the GRA was created. It was also a result of the ECHR deciding that it was unreasonable for a state to be willing to pay for medical procedures which gave a person body features that appeared similar to the sexual characteristics of the other sex, but then 'out' them by retaining the correct sex markers on their documentation.

The GRA is entirely incompatible with single sex exemptions.

Whatsnewpussyhat · 17/02/2022 16:21

As long as males get their chosen identity validated who gives a fuck about the sex based reality of women and girls eh?

Every single female disadvantaged or harmed by males who self ID into every single sex space, service, sport, prison is nothing but collateral damage.

To remove female legal protections, and even our right to name ourselves as a separate and distinct sex class so we can advocate solely for female needs is pure misogyny.

Male supremacy and entitlement at it's finest.
If they want it they take it.
If they can't have it we aren't allowed it.
If we put up boundaries they destroy them.

We are 50% of the fucking planet. Being swept aside and ignored to accommodate male feelings.

jeaux90 · 17/02/2022 15:40

I think the GRA should be scrapped now same sex marriage is lawful.

However, I doubt it will be. A legal fiction will be allowed to continue.

I agreed with what Liz Truss said, digitise the process, make it cheaper and more transparent.

BUT the gates need to remain.

More importantly I want the single sex exemptions sured up, we need better legal guidance for organisations so that single sex services and spaces are non debatable.