Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MP's will debate changing the Gender Recognition Act

163 replies

Witheringtong · 16/02/2022 22:10

On Monday 21 February, MP's will debate reforming the Gender Recognition Act.
committees.parliament.uk/committee/326/petitions-committee/news/160946/reform-of-the-gender-recognition-act-to-be-debated-by-mps/

Where do you stand? Since there are only 2 voting options the vote can't reflect all the possible options so you might have to add a comment.
Personally, I dont see how safeguarding or sex based rights can be upheld as long as people can change their legal sex marker. I'm also opposed to convicted sex offenders or violent offenders being able to change their legal details, let alone be places in a women's prison.

AIBU - The GRA should be changed to make it easier for any person to change their legal sex markers, name and birth certificate.

YANBU - The GRA should not be changed.

OP posts:
Artichokeleaves · 21/02/2022 16:08

This was dismissed as being ridiculous.

Quite.

It would be equally ridiculous to believe that once women's rights are eradicated and uncooperative females just no longer allowed inclusion or access that in some way presents inconvenience to males, that this agenda will be done. We are still on the thin end of the wedge.

We also need a government capable of realising that the age of fair play and standards is long gone (have you met our PM?) and law now has to be made in the full expectation of some manipulative wanker seeing how far they can push and break it and exploit it without the faintest trace of conscience.

This is in a nutshell why female people need sex based rights. Male people will not be reciprocal in care and respect, or in allowing them equality or permitting access without it being embedded in law and there being consequences involved for breaching them. Rather like car theft, burglary and speeding. The political lobby who brought us to this position have demonstrated repeatedly and vigorously that they don't do good will, kindness or equality.

babyjellyfish · 21/02/2022 16:04

IIRC one reason the GRA was passed to allow same sex couples to marry before this was legalised, as they became, in the eyes of the law, a heterosexual couple - but I might be over simplifying.

It was.

Trans people got the right to marry someone of the same sex over a decade before gay people did, but this never seems to get mentioned when they are talking about how they are the most discriminated against people ev-ah.

NancyDrawed · 21/02/2022 15:59

@Slothtoes

How did it even get passed? Surely that’s a reason to repeal it. How can you have legislation about a concept that isn’t actually defined.
During the debates (I'll see if I can find the relevant Hansard bits) some MPs commented about it being bad law and what would happen if a man wanted to compete in women's sports etc. This was dismissed as being ridiculous.

IIRC one reason the GRA was passed to allow same sex couples to marry before this was legalised, as they became, in the eyes of the law, a heterosexual couple - but I might be over simplifying.

Also it was only ever expected to be something that affected a very small number of people (less than 5000) rather than the hundreds of thousands that now identify as trans of some flavour or another (thanks to Stonewall's definition)

Artichokeleaves · 21/02/2022 15:49

@Slothtoes

How did it even get passed? Surely that’s a reason to repeal it. How can you have legislation about a concept that isn’t actually defined.
It is an example of incredibly bad law making.

Rather being demonstrated by two court cases coming back with conflicting answers because the terms were never defined. (Largely incase male people were upset by the definition.)

babyjellyfish · 21/02/2022 15:20

@Slothtoes

How did it even get passed? Surely that’s a reason to repeal it. How can you have legislation about a concept that isn’t actually defined.
I assume parliament was distracted by Iraq and fox hunting and forgot how babies are made.
Slothtoes · 21/02/2022 15:04

How did it even get passed? Surely that’s a reason to repeal it. How can you have legislation about a concept that isn’t actually defined.

babyjellyfish · 21/02/2022 07:13

The GRA should not be amended to make it easier for people to change their legal gender.

It should be amended to define the words and concepts that it actually uses, and to stop using the words "male" and "female" as though they were gender identities.

Slothtoes · 21/02/2022 07:09

I wish there was a third option to vote for on this AIBU, to repeal the GRA. I think the only way to sort this out is to repeal the GRA and then all people can rely equally on the Equality Act that we already have.

Slothtoes · 21/02/2022 01:17

It is PEAK MALE PRIVILEGE to "identify" as a woman when you are not a woman. It's also IMO an expression of sexism.

This and everything else you said, VioletLemon. I completely agree about why it’s so insulting but can’t express it as clearly as you have. Thank you.

Also, it’s an even peakier peak male privilege to eroticise that identification as a woman because of the shame of ‘being a woman’ rather than being a man. And the thrill of ‘transgression’. Which is part of it for some men.

And is why I’m completely uninterested in how anyone ‘identifies their gender’, I’ll always see biological sex. Meaning that I don’t want any men in women’s and girls’ spaces. I don’t want us to be the unwitting props to male sexualised ideas while we’re undressed, getting changed or using the women’s toilets, FFS.

I have no idea why it is acceptable to anyone to expect women to have to deal with all that. When men don’t have any of the same issues to deal with in their toilets or their changing rooms. It’s textbook sexism.

Apparently women’s widely-held wishes and privacy and dignity and personal safety are completely dispensable with because we are just women. Sexist. And whereas men must get whatever they want, even when what they want is horrible for other people. Sexist again. Even when it puts women at greater risk of sexual assault (as mixed sex toilets have been proven to do). All of that is sexist AF.

Slothtoes · 21/02/2022 00:46

EnOeuf thank you and if you’re ‘a dinosaur’ for thinking that way, then I am too. But you know what, none of us are ‘dinosaurs’ in the sense of having uselessly outdated and rare ideas though.

All the kids in my family, for example, know perfectly well that you can’t actually change from one sex to the other unless you use magic, which doesn’t really exist. They know that there’s nothing wrong with wearing what you comfortable or asking for your preferred haircut or whatever. They know that people who make s big fuss about things like toys or clothes or hairstyles being ‘just for girls’ or ‘just for boys’ are silly people.

The female kids also feel very strongly about not having boys and men around when girls are toileting and changing. They hate getting changed in the primary classroom for PE with the boys around and hate boys or men being anywhere nearby when they use the toilet.

This is a normal healthy stage of development as far as I’m concerned. It will help them to keep them safe in the future as they get more independence from their parents. Well, it will provided the rest of society doesn’t fuck it up for them by taking away single sex toilets and changing rooms and then lying to them that there’s no problem with doing that. Sad

VioletLemon · 19/02/2022 18:18

Yes! It is PEAK MALE PRIVILEGE to "identify" as a woman when you are not a woman. It's also IMO an expression of sexism.

When a male leans toward stereotypical "female" associated dressing, style, make up habits they then have to self identify as a woman.

I don't understand why they can't remain male and wear these clothes, style etc. Eddie Izzard opting in and out of "girly" expressions is the ultimate male privilege and completly sexist at the same time.

These ideas around what it means to be female went out with the arc. So, why is it OK for MEN to perpetuate them. I don't understand and apologies if this doesn't make sense, I find it all so upsetting and frightening.

I feel like this perception of "feeling female" involves women not being allowed to be in positions of power, authority and depicts us as fluffy, cute, vapid and non threatening. Stepford women..

PonyPatter44 · 19/02/2022 18:06

@Ionlydomassiveones

“It’s hard AF being trans, why make it harder ?”

It’s hard AF being a woman when men can just say they’re a woman and take away hard won protections, dignities and safety.

Exactly this. If anyone wishes to call me a TERF for suggesting that sex-based womens rights should not be eroded,bring it on.
JellySaurus · 19/02/2022 17:59

But I don’t understand why we can’t just have blokes who like wearing make up and dresses and all that so I’m very much a dinosaur.

Welcome to the fellowship of dinosaurs 🦕

The only things assigned at birth are stereotypes and prejudices. And as gender is nothing but stereotypes and prejudices, you could well say that gender is assigned at birth. But sex is not. Sex is established at conception and observed at birth (or before). Sex is entirely factual and inflexible. Gender OTOH is not.

ENoeuf · 19/02/2022 17:52

Oh thanks. I just wanted to answer that point because it’s bad enough really. I feel quite out of touch but I just don’t understand the whole assigned at birth stuff and why sex is flexible rather than factual. But I don’t understand why we can’t just have blokes who like wearing make up and dresses and all that so I’m very much a dinosaur.

Slothtoes · 19/02/2022 16:01

Sorry ENoeuf I wasn’t having a pop at you personally- just the whole shockingly misogynistic shitshow of it all. Sad

ENoeuf · 19/02/2022 14:40

I don’t think we should be issuing new birth certificates unless intersex is a factor, so I was purely correcting your point that there was no way back. Not advocating for how it’s done.

Slothtoes · 19/02/2022 13:24

And what that quotation says above, (including the nonsensical ‘birth gender’ idea) and giving the option of obtaining a second GRC, doesn’t solve the problem at all.

So a natal woman to legally be a natal woman, needs to live as the opposite sex for however long, and have a panel review her application, and have total administrative secrecy everywhere about her GRC status. That all seems like a complete minefield. Is the previous secrecy about the first GRC now not relevant any more? How can this possibly work in practice?

No one should have to hold a new GRC just to get rid of their first GRC.
Why can’t the GRC holder just say that they changed their mind, and want to revert to their birth sex? That gender identity is just an idea, and is an idea that they’ve changed their mind about. As we should all be free to do in our lives with any important decisions that we make. GRA treats detransitioned GRC holders shamefully. It should be repealed. It’s illogical and discriminatory.

Slothtoes · 19/02/2022 13:12

Yes apparently there is a way out of a GRC if the holder says they’ve committed ‘fraud’ in the original application, meaning that they didn’t actually meet the GRA criteria all along. But not all detransitioning people, very understandably, would be comfortable with having to use that reason.
Presumably their previous feelings were very sincerely held, none of this is trivial.

ENoeuf · 18/02/2022 20:35

@Slothtoes

From the official guidance:

3.6 Legally reverting to your birth gender
If a person in receipt of a full GRC wishes to revert to their birth gender they must make an application for a GRC and meet the requirements of the GRA in the same way they did when making their previous application.

Artichokeleaves · 18/02/2022 18:54

It's not terribly clear why changing your legal sex should be cheaper than any other similar piece of government bureaucracy. (As well as permitted in the first place).

Or faster. Or less beaurocratic. For example parents waiting for EHCPs, people applying for PIP and benefits, severely ill children waiting weeks for even an initial contact from CAMHS.... it's not a race to the bottom, obviously, but why should one group be treated more favourably than any other?

NecessaryScene · 18/02/2022 18:45

I agreed with what Liz Truss said, digitise the process, make it cheaper and more transparent.

Although as someone highlighted on Ovarit the other day, the potential end result is weird stuff like it being much more expensive to change your name on a passport than to change your name+sex.

This was in Australia - apparently name changes are free with a sex change, but cost $400 without a sex change.

So a cunning life hack would be to change your name+sex twice to save money. Although it wasn't clear whether there was an proper process to change your sex to your real sex - similar to some confusion here...

It's not terribly clear why changing your legal sex should be cheaper than any other similar piece of government bureaucracy. (As well as permitted in the first place).

Slothtoes · 18/02/2022 18:08

And to link that back to GRA- there is no way once you have a GRC that you can give it back. It’s a one way ticket. What sort of consent is it, to change legal sex, if you can never change it back? That’s not what consent is. ‘You’ve made your bed, now lie in it’, is not consent.

Goes to show how poorly thought through and hugely discriminatory (to detransitioned women) and unfit for purpose the GRC is. GRA should be repealed after a legal route has been provided for anyone with a GRC who wants to reverse it to be able to do that and legally return to their birth sex.

Slothtoes · 18/02/2022 18:03

Great posts JellySaurus and Nemorth and I would add that women who have detransitioned from identifying as transgender or NB are also a group with very little tailored support available to them. On top of that they say they get aggro or ostracism or just airbrushed out and omitted as if they don’t exist from the prevailing narrative.

If detransitioners are properly acknowledged, their experiences would really pick a hole in the whole political rhetoric around this.

It shows how not actually person centred and caring and supportive or ‘kind’ or ‘inclusive’ this movement is.
It’s all just politics. Anyone who changes their mind about being trans or NB and/or who wants to talk about living with extremely difficult side effects from the physical ‘treatments’ they have been given for their gender dysphoria, seems like just an inconvenience to ignore until they stop talking and go away.
It’s really cynical, and it’s upsetting to know how conditional this whole movement is. That’s how you can tell that it’s all about male sexual rights at it’s heart. It’s clearly a political campaign, with goals that take precedence over (particularly female) individuals’ needs and experiences.

Nemorth · 18/02/2022 15:41

The GRA was brought in to ensure that those people who has transitioned (and I suppose the implication is a full transition by means of operations and hormones) were able to marry.

Now we have equal marriage rights the GRA should be repealed. It's not needed.

The protected characteristics are all legally definable in law.

Those people who now identify as trans can changes their name, passports, driving licenses, dress how the please, love who they want and remain protected by the PCs of sex and gender reassignment (and any others that might be relevant).

There is really any need for a GRC anymore.

TheKeatingFive · 18/02/2022 15:11

It’s hard AF being trans, why make it harder ?

Why on earth should we be denying biological realities to make people's lives 'easier'?