Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To move house for this reason?

60 replies

glastoforever · 16/02/2022 21:07

We have a two year old DS.
We have a house that we have lived in for 8years that we renovated and we absolutely love it.
We want to try for another baby and will need a bit more room.

Options are - move house or do a loft conversion.

Issues are - the main issue is the schools. DH and I both from this town and we both went to same secondary school in the north of the town where schools are much better (but more expensive area).
We live in the south of the town and the schools here really aren't great. Much bigger and it has some real rough estates around.

We love our home and our preference would be to stay put and go in to the loft.

How easy is it to get in to a primary school outside of your catchment?

Re - secondary schools out of catchment, would we have a case to say my DH and I went to our favoured school and were both prefects there - does it work like this? I'd love our DS to go there too. It's only a 15 minute drive but is the other side of town.

We are really torn. Our house is perfect for us in every way except school catchment.

OP posts:
Calmdown14 · 16/02/2022 22:18

It sounds like the house was perfect for you as a couple and as a very young family but is never going to be ideal long term.
You need an estate agent opinion on value now and potential value with a loft conversion. If it's not worth doing financially don't bother.
It sounds like you'd be better trying to move in next year or so. Start scoping other options for areas while you still have some time

Ikeptgoing · 16/02/2022 22:12

My DCs went to the local catchment secondary school m which is clearly second best to the highest performing one in our area, and mine are academic. But this secondary school was inclusive and offered extension studies and mine are top 25 in the year. So they have so far got excellent GSCEs and hit the leader boards, in the county for top marks. Because school impressed me how they catered inclusively for good students and learning development students. A bigger range- so whilst performance charts were lower it reflected a wider range . I knew they'd support my DCs and stretch them and loved the fact they had two teams for rugby and other sports, so was far more inclusive, unlike the top performing school who had one team and you made the cut or not .

Ultimately if they'd done the stats showing the range, this second best school performed as equally well for the highest performing pupils and significantly better for those facing additional challenges than the school more invested in their stats and telling pupils not to take course if they wouldn't pass it well.

HamCob · 16/02/2022 22:08

OP, if the school you are considering is a good school in a nice area it is likely to be oversubscribed. This doesn't stop you from applying but if you're out of catchment you will be pretty much bottom of the list
Also consider if you did get an place, how you would get them to school every day. Assuming it's too far to walk, is there a bus route? Can you commit to lifts twice a day - not really ideal in terms of independence.
Your child will also possibly be leaving behind all of their primary school friendships as they will most likely attend the catchment school.

For what it's worth we were in a similar situation and decided to move to the better area. I didn't want the uncertainty hanging over us and I also wanted DC to attend a feeder school so that they would have friends. Ideally we would have moved before DC started school but it didn't quite pan out that way!

Ikeptgoing · 16/02/2022 22:04

You've had good advice on here OP

It s lovely that you love your house and think you could extend it up into the lift to make it work for your second baby if you get pg

Schoo catchments are the thing though, as other PPs have said you need to check out if your preferred schools take out or catchment or are over subscribed, they can only tell you previous years stats not whether you have a quiet or a bumper year.

If you want to guarantee a school place in your preferred primary or secondary schools you do need to look at moving. Most houses in good schools areas cost more than those is less favoured ones. In our area, we have great schools but the favoured highest performing secondary school have houses £150k more for the same level of house than the second performing school. That's a whole level of expensive! It's over subscribed so no one out or catchment will get offered a place . Primary schools here are much of a muchness... unless you live in the cheapest area or town where the 2 primaries under perform, So I'm trying to explain that sometimes you have to compromise in the house if a particular school is important to you and secondary school catchments may be your deciding factor, if they are generally usually over subscribed.

It sounds like you have a lovely home.

Ime going to a school out or catchment means you aren't near your school friends and it can be lonely for a child who ends up having to travel or be driven. That walk to school if you can school locally is important and the friends they make, if they live nearby , is easier for play dates. Those are the things that matter also for your DCs.
I hope you can find a compromise. Are the local schools good enough? They don't need to be the best or the best, unless you have a ridiculously academic child who won't be stretched enough

willithappen · 16/02/2022 21:59

How rude of those mocking OP for asking
Plenty private schools or other countries have something similar where previous ties can help. Plus only being 15 minutes away. It's worth mentioning anything to try state your case

Ignore the rude comments OP. Some people love to find anything to pick at or mock someone for. As a first time mum it's very easy to not know all the ins and outs and other people should be more sensitive and kinder to that - whether first time mum or not.

(Mentioning prefect is to point to the fact they were good, well behave students I presume so not OP gloating)

MichaelAndEagle · 16/02/2022 21:57

It doesn't sound like it really is the perfect house for you if you dislike the area so much.

Reluctantadult · 16/02/2022 21:54

Ah op, bless you but no. If you have a hunt on the schools website they will have published their admissions criteria. It's usually siblings first priority then distance from the school as the crow flies. They might have a catchment map. If you speak to them they might be able to tell you if they've been over or under subscribed for the last few years and if there's a trajectory they seem to be on with that.

Re the house, I think that unfortunately I would look to move. I would prioritise a better school. But you should look at your local school first, maybe you'll really like it.

altiara · 16/02/2022 21:53

It's not a crime to be unfamiliar with admissions criteria for schools when your child is only 2...

Sorry you're getting such a hard time OP.

OP can google and quite easily find out far more information on the admissions policy in her area as well as the distance for the last child placed.

OP, you list so many negatives about the area and not liking the neighbourhood children etc Why would you not just move and bring your child up in an area where you will allow them to make friends and go out to the park.

mimos4 · 16/02/2022 21:51

Op, some harsh answers here, which isn't fair. You might want to post on a parenting board next time rather than AIBU (lots of people just looking for a fight).

qualitygirl · 16/02/2022 21:45

If you were in Ireland you could apply wherever you want @glastoforever it's very different here...

glastoforever · 16/02/2022 21:45

@BessieFinknottle thank you. I have literally no idea. I don't have nieces or nephews of school age yet or friends with kids that age either so it's all completely new.

You know sometimes you wish you had never asked Hmm

OP posts:
BessieFinknottle · 16/02/2022 21:44

It's not a crime to be unfamiliar with admissions criteria for schools when your child is only 2...

Sorry you're getting such a hard time OP.

katieg03 · 16/02/2022 21:43

Check your council criteria. You'll also be responsible for getting the children transport outwith your area. No connections or prefect, house captain status is going to be remotely considered.

Jamnation · 16/02/2022 21:41

Going out of catchment can be tricky with siblings. Depending on the criteria you might be able to get one child in out of catchment, but not necessarily both or all of them. Round here all in-catchment children get a place over out of catchment siblings. Having a 4 and 6 year old at schools at the opposite ends of town would be a PITA. But the admissions criteria should be clearly laid out and we found LA admissions team quite helpful.

DorothyZbornakIsAQueen · 16/02/2022 21:40

Re - secondary schools out of catchment, would we have a case to say my DH and I went to our favoured school and were both prefects there - does it work like this?

Yes - in 9 years time, when your ds goes to high school, please be sure to write on your from that you and your husband were prefects a couple of decades previous.

You will go to the top of the list.

VodselForDinner · 16/02/2022 21:39

Unfortunately, being a prefect won’t help with schools outside of your catchment.

But definitely put it on your CV. It really helps when job hunting, especially if you mention that you’re a double-prefect household.

Redlorryyellowduck · 16/02/2022 21:37

@glastoforever I wasn't being rude, I was asking if you genuinely believed you had a chance. The reason I asked is because your question was so absurd, I assumed you were joking.
Surely better someone on an anonymous forum asks, than let you call the admissions officer and you listen to them piss themselves laughing down the phone to you?

User839516 · 16/02/2022 21:37

Oh OP I think @Shadappayourface was being sarcastic…

BessieFinknottle · 16/02/2022 21:36

@GeneLovesJezebel

No, you having been to that school makes no difference.
See, it sometimes does, depending on where you live. I think everyone here is assuming the OP is in the UK (as am I tbh ), but she actually didn't say. I'm in Ireland and a parent being a past pupil would push the child way up the list for many schools.
Heronwatcher · 16/02/2022 21:32

The school will publish its admissions criteria on its website. As others have said, the council will have a website which shows the distance of the last admitted child last year. True this might change over time but it’s unlikely to get bigger unless you’re in an area of massive population change (like parts of London during the pandemic), another school gets built and is sought after, or the school gets much worse.

glastoforever · 16/02/2022 21:31

Thanks @Shadappayourface - I'm still in contact with several teachers there and also involved in some sports there so I do have strong links.

Everyone has made feel really stupid though for asking 🤣

OP posts:
Comedycook · 16/02/2022 21:30

@Shadappayourface

I got my children into the best school in our area because the school remembered that I got an A* in History there 15 years earlier so it's definitely worth a go seeing if they accept your children on the basis of being a prefect.
Grin
Shadappayourface · 16/02/2022 21:30

I got my children into the best school in our area because the school remembered that I got an A* in History there 15 years earlier so it's definitely worth a go seeing if they accept your children on the basis of being a prefect.

Comedycook · 16/02/2022 21:28

would we have a case to say my DH and I went to our favoured school and were both prefects there - does it work like this?

Oh dear... cannot believe you even asked this?!

No, it doesn't work like that at all.

glastoforever · 16/02/2022 21:27

@bitchinofhitchen good point, thanks.

I love our house but the local kids make me nervous. DH and I were lucky enough to both be raised in the countryside and we are virtually town centre where we are. It's not somewhere I can ever imagine letting our kids go and play out (though of course I'm sure they will if we were to stay here).... so much to think about. Wish I could pick our house up and move it!

OP posts: