Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To move house for this reason?

60 replies

glastoforever · 16/02/2022 21:07

We have a two year old DS.
We have a house that we have lived in for 8years that we renovated and we absolutely love it.
We want to try for another baby and will need a bit more room.

Options are - move house or do a loft conversion.

Issues are - the main issue is the schools. DH and I both from this town and we both went to same secondary school in the north of the town where schools are much better (but more expensive area).
We live in the south of the town and the schools here really aren't great. Much bigger and it has some real rough estates around.

We love our home and our preference would be to stay put and go in to the loft.

How easy is it to get in to a primary school outside of your catchment?

Re - secondary schools out of catchment, would we have a case to say my DH and I went to our favoured school and were both prefects there - does it work like this? I'd love our DS to go there too. It's only a 15 minute drive but is the other side of town.

We are really torn. Our house is perfect for us in every way except school catchment.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Pythonesque · 17/02/2022 01:23

I have some sympathy for the OP. Back when I was at school - non UK but not dissimilar education system - there were a small number of selective school "remnants" of a largely dismantled system. They mostly had strict catchments, so entry was based on exam + catchment. The exception was that if you had a parent who had attended a particular school you could also apply to go there even if living outside catchment. Where I lived wasn't actually in area for any selective school, and since our only native-born parent grew up in a different city we were stymied.

Famousinlove · 16/02/2022 23:56

If that worked surely everyone would say they were a prefect back in the day, i doubt they have a database to check whether you were or not

KimDeals · 16/02/2022 23:49

@glastoforever to the best of my knowledge (living in England but not from U.K. and correct me if I’m wrong other people!) the school have no ‘say’ in who gets in. Places are managed by your local authority and offered by them, not the school.

The school can help you with understanding the catchment area though. It’ll be on their websites. And it’ll be on your local authority website.

But the brunt of it is, you need to know the school you want to get in to, then move into the catchment. Good to start asking around about schools early and have your long goal for schools in sight.

KimDeals · 16/02/2022 23:45

@VodselForDinner

Unfortunately, being a prefect won’t help with schools outside of your catchment.

But definitely put it on your CV. It really helps when job hunting, especially if you mention that you’re a double-prefect household.

OUCH! That made me howl Grin
sadeyedladyofthelowlandsea · 16/02/2022 23:40

OP, it really does depend on your LA - our best/most oversubscribed schools change catchment area every year depending on how many children are within it. One middle school used to pretty much guarantee a place at the best high school - so hundreds of parents bought houses for that middle school catchment area, only to miss out on the high school catchment because it had become so oversubscribed that the catchment became smaller.

Usual criteria is 1) Catchment, 2) Older sibling already at the school, and 3) Other extenuating circumstances, such as difficult background, SEN provision, religion, etc. Both of my DC are at my old high school - the fact that I was a star pupil there 25yrs ago wasn't a factor.

hibbledibble · 16/02/2022 23:38

I would visit your local schools before discounting them. Especially primary.

Parental ties to a school doesn't play a role for admissions in England for state schools. It may do for private schools however.

BlankTimes · 16/02/2022 23:23

OP, Please consider that just because the secondary school is amazing now, that doesn't mean it will still be amazing when your children are old enough to attend.

There could be several changes of Headteacher before your children attend that school, each Head will structure the school how they want it to be, but that doesn't guarantee that each change will only bring improvement.

You need to keep tabs on what's available for your childrens' education and be prepared to be flexible about it.

Obimumkinobi · 16/02/2022 23:21

99% of everything on MN could be googled but I guess OP was just looking for some human interaction. I don't suppose she'll make that mistake again, eh?

DorothyZbornakIsAQueen · 16/02/2022 23:04

Nice pile on MN! Whilst OP was busy being a school prefect were you all busy being the school bitches?!

No, I was wistfully wishing I was a prefect so in a couple of decades time, I could use my teenage status to get my child into my high school 🙄.

Come on, anyone could just google this on their local council education pages, regardless of whether they know anyone with children or not.

Obimumkinobi · 16/02/2022 22:57

Nice pile on MN! Whilst OP was busy being a school prefect were you all busy being the school bitches?!

OP - Whilst I agree it may not he a common experience, my friend got her 2 kids into a popular state school, which was in the next county, solely because she had attended it many years earlier. She wasn't a star student or a brilliant scientist and her children had no special requirements or talents.

I have also seen school entry requirements which make exceptions for the children of staff (both teaching and admin staff). I know you are already involved with school on a voluntary basis, so perhaps this is something you could think about developing in the future?

All the best with figuring this out xx

Wigeon · 16/02/2022 22:57

Assuming you’re in England and talking about state schools, it really really depends on a) the particular local authority and b) the exact area you’re in.

No where in the state system will have parental ties as a criterion.

State schools in my area don’t have a fixed catchment. The furthest distance a child is admitted from varies from year to year, depending on how many children apply to that school that year.

However, because I live in a built up area, where many schools are over subscribed, there are usually only a limited number of local primaries (could be 1-4, depending on exactly where you live) which you stand any chance of getting into, and it’s worse for secondary because there’s some which are semi selective state.

As others have said, you need to get on your local authority’s school admissions website and start researching what are the rules in your area.

Saz12 · 16/02/2022 22:39

Living somewhere that factored in your parents’ long ago successes in your current opportunities would be almost as bad as only having the opportunities if your parents could pay for them.

FantasticFebruary · 16/02/2022 22:38

Ignore the bitchy posts. You have no family/friends with school age children, this is the first time you've had to consider it, funnily enough this is a parenting website, you'd think asking questions like this wouldn't attract ridicule, but this is AIBU and some people think it's gives them the right to be bitchy & unhelpful. Their issue, not yours!!

T00Ts · 16/02/2022 22:35

I have a feeling the poster has deregged.

EatYourVegetables · 16/02/2022 22:34

Did you mean to be so rude?

I have never actually seen this used IRL, just suggested on MN. Thank you OP for the experience Grin

Paddingtonthebear · 16/02/2022 22:33

Haven’t read the full thread but you need to get on the council website and see what schools cover each postcode area. We are house hunting at the moment and need to consider our secondary school options. We are prioritising access to decent schools (via catchment) over the actual house itself.

Ikeptgoing · 16/02/2022 22:33

Just to mention that my (PFB) DC also got a bursary for his Russel group high performing uni as he came from deprived area and I'm low income LP. Even though the school (second best mind!) was great and he went to a fab post 16 college. He got 9s and A*| across the board. Good students do well if they have 'good enough' schools and colleges.

FantasticFebruary · 16/02/2022 22:32

If I was your age & in your situation I'd look at moving to the catchment if the senior school you both went to & ensure its catchment for good primaries.

You're bound to have made good money doing your place up, so hopefully can afford another diet-upper in the better location.

Living where you feel happy to let the kids play out/in neighbours/have neighbours kids around to play us great.

Walking to school is lovely too. Wrangling two small kids in the car & school parking is a living bloody nightmare. I'd move for that reason alone!!

You & DH turned this house into a home you love, you can do it again!!

You can make

Ikeptgoing · 16/02/2022 22:28

@T00Ts

would we have a case to say my DH and I went to our favoured school and were both prefects there

😂 ask them. Tell us what they say.

Bless you OP that you think this is relevant 20+ years later

Unless you were legendary ...

T00Ts · 16/02/2022 22:26

would we have a case to say my DH and I went to our favoured school and were both prefects there

😂 ask them. Tell us what they say.

halulat · 16/02/2022 22:25

You need to look at admissions criteria and although it's a long way off, check if theschools have been oversubscribed or not and for how many years. This will show you those cal admission pattern.
I would also consider how far away it is- I didn't go to my local school so as a teen, had to rely on a lot of parent lifts to see friends out of school.

Mellowyellow222 · 16/02/2022 22:23

Ah OP this thread cheered me up!

Please do a little research. Instead of asking strangers on the internet look up the admission policy of the school.

As others have said it is highly unlikely being a prefect will be listed.

Darbs76 · 16/02/2022 22:20

If you want the good schools chances are you will need to move. Most schools are over subscribed and I’m afraid they don’t care if you were a prefect or not, the criteria must be followed

Momicrone · 16/02/2022 22:20

I've never considered schools when moving, has always been for other reasons, all my kids are thriving, if your house is great, stay

episcomama · 16/02/2022 22:18

We moved. We absolutely loved our house, location and the neighbors but the local state schools were rough.

We moved about 4 miles away to a different school district. While our new house is fine, we don't love it the way we loved the old one...but moving house was the best decision we've ever made! The schools are exceptional and that really is the most important thing.

Don't bother renovating - move.

Swipe left for the next trending thread