Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Did my friend try to scam me?

161 replies

didshedidntshe · 16/02/2022 17:10

I’ll try and keep this as short as possible.. I live in a flat share with 2 girls, Chloe and Molly. Our contract states that we have to have a clean at the end of each year, also we are all moving out so need an end of tenancy clean.

Molly said that she would deal with arranging the clean, which cost £150, so £50 each. The clean was communal areas only, we have a hallway, bathroom and an open plan kitchen/lounge. On the day of the clean, Molly text us to say that the cleaners had been there for 6.5 hours, and we had only paid for 4 hours, so it would be an extra £60 (£20 each), I said this seemed excessive for what is basically 3 rooms.. but whatever, Molly advised that it was a deep end of tenancy clean so would take longer, fair enough. Once it was done, Molly sent over some photos, I noticed that there was a mans reflection in one of the photos but I just assumed maybe it was one of the cleaners, although they were wearing smart shoes which I don’t think cleaners would wear..

I got home later in the day and saw some litter outside our flat (cloths and empty bottles of cleaning stuff), When I walked in I could tell that the floors hadn’t been cleaned, and as I walked into the lounge I saw that all the furniture and everything was in completely random places.. it wasn’t even like they had tried to put stuff back in a logical place, the sofas were left in the middle of the room, the cutlery drawer left wide open and was a complete mess with it all just chucked in there, I found pasta and coffee pots in the boiler cupboard, the tv was left all unplugged and not where it should be etc, the whole place was a mess to be honest, if I hadn’t known that a clean had taken place I probably would have thought we had been robbed. Chloe and I spent an hour putting everything back in the right place and tidying up. I then looked round the rest of the flat, and the toilets looked like they had had bleach put in them, but no scrubbing or anything done, there were still marks on the floor that were easily washed off, the coffee table still had dust on it etc

I messaged Molly to say that the place was left in a mess and we’ve spent an hour putting stuff back in the right place and that the floors hadn’t been cleaned and said she should speak to the company about not paying the extra money we were charged and she got really defensive, saying that the floors were wet when she picked the keys up and she said ‘give them a break it was only £70 each’ which isn’t the point in my opinion ..

I then asked if she could send us the receipt for the clean, because our landlord would want to see it, so she sent me it and I then left a bad review on the companies trust pilot. The company responded to my review saying please can you contact us as we have no record of you, so I contacted them and gave them the name of my flatmate and our address etc, and they said they had no record of my address, so I sent them a copy of the invoice and they said that although the invoice had their logo on it, it wasn’t there’s as it was a totally different format to there invoices and the website written on the invoice wasn’t there’s, but was a dead site.

I messaged Molly to tell her all this, and she responded saying that her boyfriend who works at an estate agents had booked it through his work, so that would be why the company had no record of it… which doesn’t make any sense to me. She then said she would get her boyfriend to speak with them if we still want to complain. Just to double check, I went back to the company and gave them the name of Molly’s boyfriend and company he works at, and they said that no there was still no record and that they don't work with estate agents. I didn’t say anything more to molly because we are/were good friends and I didn’t want to be accusatory but I thought it was all pretty weird. Molly said she would ask her boyfriend to contact the company with our complaints and I kept chasing her for an update on this, each time she replied, it was clear that she had had no involvement in arranging the clean and hadn’t even been to the flat after it was finished.

Molly then sent me a screenshot of a message she received from her boyfriend saying ‘I’ve fucked up, we use a software to create all our invoices for cleans done on properties and I’ve mixed up your clean with another one that was done on the same day. Please apologise to her for me, and I’m going to try and get the money back from the cleaners as they want more business done with his company’

Again this makes zero sense to me.. because why would the estate agents be making invoices for cleaning companies, surely the cleaning companies would make their own invoices and send them to the estate agents. Anyway she then sent another screenshot where he said that the actual company was reimbursing us the full amount.

I find this all really bizarre, so I called up the correct company but they refused to speak to me and said I had to go through our ‘agent’ (mollys boyfriend), I then got my male friend to call up and the lady told him that a clean was done at my flat but only one room..

I am basically thinking, Molly paid for her room to be cleaned, then her boyfriend quickly ‘cleaned’ the rest of the flat, and they pocketed the money? Then once I kept on at them they panicked and just sent the whole lot back...

Sorry it’s long but what do you think..

OP posts:
whataboutbob · 16/02/2022 19:54

Are you all 3 still in the flat together? If so be very careful, don’t leave back cards etc hanging around, or anything with bank details, cash, valuables etc. If you have to leave them with a trusted friend/ parent When I flatshared as a student one flatmate went rogue under the influence of a sociopathic boyfriend, she tricked one other ( over trusting) flatmate in to revealing her PIN number and emptied her account. She then disappeared, dropping out of uni. It was really upsetting and weirdly I was so ashamed of the whole situation I told no one, as if it reflected badly in me to have lived with such a dishonest person.

MGMidget · 16/02/2022 19:50

I am wondering about his habits as an estate agent and whether end-of-tenancy cleans have been charged for using his ‘cleaning company’ invoices. Maybe he (and your friend) thought a well-practiced habit of his would also work on you?

didshedidntshe · 16/02/2022 19:47

@MissAmbrosia

Surely you have an end of tenancy clean when you've moved out? The whole thing sounds a bit mad to me.
Yeah I missed out this bit because it's long and useless information, basically Molly is moving in with her boyfriend early and ending her tenancy early, whereas Chloe and I are waiting until the tenancy actually ends. Because of this, I didn't want to be in a situation where Molly moves out and doesn't have to contribute to the clean, so the landlord agreed to have the clean done now when Molly moves out and not at the very end of the tenancy
OP posts:
rifling · 16/02/2022 19:46

Well done you for getting your money back although it hurts when you realise that someone you consider a friend is quite willing to scam you - been there and it was a rude awakening!

didshedidntshe · 16/02/2022 19:44

@Momijin

What a bitch! If I needed the money, I would suggest to my flatmates that I would do the cleaning for the cost of getting a cleaner.

The cheek to ask for extra and then do a shit job! At least if she had done a great job for what it would cost a professional, then fair enough.

Yep, and annoying thing is she earns more than both me and Chloe, and her boyfriend comes from a rich family
OP posts:
Walkingalot · 16/02/2022 19:41

Sounds like she was talked into this by her boyfriend, even so, that's awful behaviour. There are good and honest people in this world and maybe she was one of them until she met this creep. Good on you for being savvy enough to suss this all out and get your money back.

MissAmbrosia · 16/02/2022 19:40

Surely you have an end of tenancy clean when you've moved out? The whole thing sounds a bit mad to me.

Twilight7777 · 16/02/2022 19:39

Definitely scammed

Momijin · 16/02/2022 19:38

What a bitch! If I needed the money, I would suggest to my flatmates that I would do the cleaning for the cost of getting a cleaner.

The cheek to ask for extra and then do a shit job! At least if she had done a great job for what it would cost a professional, then fair enough.

Tiddlywinkly · 16/02/2022 19:36

A weird amount of effort for relatively little monetary gain! Anyway you got your money back thankfully and found out her true colours.

THEDEACON · 16/02/2022 19:23

Glad you got your money back but yes Molly definitely tried to scam you and Chloe

Opus17 · 16/02/2022 19:22

She needs ditched! Horrible person

LoisLane66 · 16/02/2022 19:21

She's no friend and a liar to boot. I'd sack her. You don't need 'friends' like that...or, if you do, then you must IMO, be grasping at straws.

LemonSwan · 16/02/2022 19:21

Wow, pretty shady behaviour

KylieCharlene · 16/02/2022 19:13

She THOUGHT you were stupid.
She knows now that you're not.
I bet she feels like a right idiot for trying to pull this off. There again, people like her probably don't feel in the same way as the rest of us.

Chimchiminie · 16/02/2022 19:13

@billy1966

What a tawdry end to a three year friendship...for a couple of hundred pounds.

It tells you 100% how she viewed you, and who she is.

Avoid.

Exactly

billy1966 · 16/02/2022 19:12

@Mumoftwoinprimary

I would send Molly the following:-

“Hi Molly, I thought about it and realised that the cleaning company just returning our money isn’t good enough. They obviously tried to scam us. They are disgusting thieves. If they tried to scam us then they probably steal from everyone. Imagine if it was a vulnerable person that they scammed?

I have tried to phone them to discuss and they will only talk to Jack. I think that we should request compensation for all the hassle they put us through. What do you think? Maybe £50. If Jack doesn’t want to have the difficult conversation then I’m happy to have it - he just has to tell them to talk to me. I am quite happy to tell them exactly what I think about thieves, how disgusting they are and how I wonder how they can sleep at night!

Best

Did she”

Do this.

Perhaps add, "these scamers need to be reported to the police. I can give the police Jack's number and his office address. I can't bear the thought of them scamming an eldey or vulnerable person"

Mumoftwoinprimary · 16/02/2022 19:09

I would send Molly the following:-

“Hi Molly, I thought about it and realised that the cleaning company just returning our money isn’t good enough. They obviously tried to scam us. They are disgusting thieves. If they tried to scam us then they probably steal from everyone. Imagine if it was a vulnerable person that they scammed?

I have tried to phone them to discuss and they will only talk to Jack. I think that we should request compensation for all the hassle they put us through. What do you think? Maybe £50. If Jack doesn’t want to have the difficult conversation then I’m happy to have it - he just has to tell them to talk to me. I am quite happy to tell them exactly what I think about thieves, how disgusting they are and how I wonder how they can sleep at night!

Best

Did she”

fromdownwest · 16/02/2022 19:02

There is scamming your mates, then there is drawing up a fake invoice, impersonating another company and obtaining money by deception.

Legally know as fraud.

Lilolily · 16/02/2022 18:59

Yeah, Molly isn’t your friend and her boyfriend should be done for fraud.

didshedidntshe · 16/02/2022 18:55

@DoctorManhattan

Definitely a scam.

I had a very similar situation some years back when I lived in a house share with 2 other guys, whom I considered friends. One of them had jealousy issues about a girl I was seeing and I could feel our friendship waning as he was often short with me and kept making sly comments. In our last week of tenancy I moved out early (work travel reasons) and handed my key back to the Landlord. The guys subsequently contacted me to say the oil tank needed refilled before we all left, they arranged to have it done and told me over the phone that my share was £xxx amount. It seemed high and I didn’t think we’d used that much oil but transferred the money to them anyway. Anyway I got back from travel a few days later and although I hadn’t planned to ever be in our house share again, I realised I’d forgotten something and had to go back for it. The guys were both working so I rung landlord who agreed to let me in at lunchtime for it. Nipped into the living room to get what I needed and there was an invoice for the oil lying open on the coffee table for all to see - it was substantially lower than they had said so I had effectively paid for theirs and also made them a nice little bit of profit in the process.

What followed was 2 weeks of excuses and finger pointing at the oil company and various other lies. I eventually threatened police and got my money back.

Wow wtf, did you ever have a feeling before that they weren't really good people? Looking back, There's been a few times where she's done or said really bitchy things and I've just pushed it to the back of my mind and told myself that's not who she really is but clearly I was wrong!
OP posts:
billy1966 · 16/02/2022 18:54

@SarahProblem

If you're in touch with Molly's family/wider friendship group I'd be annoyed/petty enough to tell everyone.

These things don't just happen once.

Great point @SarahProblem, these things are not a once off.

What sort of person even comes up with something like this?

caranations · 16/02/2022 18:54

INV0001? lol

BakedTattie · 16/02/2022 18:52

Ditch Molly. She’s tried to steal from you.

What’s Chloe’s take on it?

FlipFlapFlop123 · 16/02/2022 18:51

Regarding your end of tenancy clean you mentioned, I know I have definitely read somewhere that this isn`t a thing any more. I would check that out and you might have save yourself some money.

Swipe left for the next trending thread