Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Pissed off with this "Guardian's" gem?

86 replies

PeskyBaboon · 16/02/2022 15:34

Arwa Mahdawi got royally irritated by the WSJ piece titled " HERE'S WHY I'LL BE KEEPING MY SHOES ON IN YOUR SHOELESS HOME". The piece, designed to be light-hearted, was "light-hearted in a deliberately irritating way" (sic!). Now she's properly, self-righteously peeved as the piece is way more than she could handle. Namely, it's "imperialist", borders on "hate crime" as "an overwhelming number of people suggested that ONLY A WHITE-PRESENTING PERSON could have written" such a thing. Being a paragon of cleanliness and godliness herself, with an immaculate sense of personal hygiene and social probity, Arwa's taken up the challenge and relieved herself publicly expressing her disgust in the following: "DEAR WHITE PEOPLE READING THIS, I'M GOING TO SAY THIS AS DELICATELY AS POSSIBLE BUT I'M AFRAID YOU HAVE SOMETHING OF A REPUTATION WHEN IT COMES TO CLEANLINESS." Then, she less subtly goes on with the bang of: "When you are a non-white person who has to deal with stereotypes about 'dirty foreigners' it can be irritating, to say the least, TO SEE PRIVILEDGED WHITE PEOPLE REVEL IN BEING DISGUSTING. Still "irritated", see? And still talking HYGIENE, naturally. These white, disgusting barbarians not taking their shoes off and tossing their filthy suitcases on beds. And then the fascists REVEL in it. So utterly revolting it makes our poor Arwa gag, no less. White shoes, white feet and white suitcases ad nauseam. But fear NOT, all you "dear white people", all's not lost here, there's still hope. She ends up with this gloriously uplifting finale: "BUT YOU KNOW WHAT? I'M NOT GOING INTO THE RACIALISED ASPECTS OF HYGIENE DISCOURSE HERE". Oh, well. You just did. In case, anyone's still in doubt on this one, Arwa's ready to help and clarify: "IF WHITE PEOPLE WANT TO BE GOOD ALLIES, IT'S TIME TO TAKE A STAND! BUT NOT IN YOUR DIRTY SHOES, OBVIOUSLY."
I won't be knocking on Arwa's door anytime soon, mind you. Neither to take my shoes off nor to be her "good ally" and "take a stand". She clearly doesn't need "allies". She manages on her own beautifully by the looks of it. Primarily, by NOT GOING into THE RACIALISED ASPECTS OF ANYTHING she's currently pissed off with.
On a more serious note: I just find this article both really depressing and utterly stupid. Or maybe there's something profoundly wrong with me now? Please, do not hesitate to have a go. I'm Polish, I can take it...

OP posts:
StillWeRise · 16/02/2022 18:15

although it's not a great article the point it alludes to is valid- a frequent element of racism involves white people describing non white people as dirty/smelly/unhygienic etc. As well as being insulting (and racist) I can imagine non white people finding this a bit much given many habits of white people - outdoor shoes inside being a good example, but wiping with dry toilet paper being another. I can only agree that these are not good practices. Even though I'm white.

phishy · 16/02/2022 18:11

She’s talking about celebrities, OP.

You keep quoting her out of context.

PeskyBaboon · 16/02/2022 18:09

Calling someone else barbarian is hyperbole & exaggeration & licencia poetica just for effect, so I must not take it soooooooooo seriously and literally. Ok, thank you for that. I feel well instructed. On the other hand, when the author says about herself "having to deal with stereotypes about 'dirty foreigners' and seeing privileged white people revel in being disgusting" I should absolutely take every word literally, with grave seriousness and grateful she was so generous as to share her thoughts on the matter. I now know where my place is. Thank you.

OP posts:
phishy · 16/02/2022 18:05

@BellatricksStrange

To be fair, anything Arwa Mahdawi writes is entitled, victimy shit.
Any examples or are we just supposed to take your (unreliable) word for it]?
BellatricksStrange · 16/02/2022 17:59

To be fair, anything Arwa Mahdawi writes is entitled, victimy shit.

phishy · 16/02/2022 17:58

I’ve just read the WSJ article and the Guardian response to it, and I think OP is affronted that a brown person has had the temerity to voice an opinion about cultural differences related to white people.

The fact of the matter is that on TV white people do walk around homes with shoes and lie on beds with their shoes on. You don’t see this on Asian programming for instance, so it’s bound to become a stereotype that white people walk around with shoes in their homes.

Arwa has written what she herself calls a lighthearted piece about how white society often portrays foreigners are dirty whilst normalising shoes on beds, which other cultures perceive as dirty.

All you have done is demonstrate your white fragility, OP.

mumwon · 16/02/2022 17:54

Are Japanese regarded as white in this? How does that work?

Suspect6 · 16/02/2022 17:39

So that was a fun 5 minutes

It was, wasn’t it? Smile

Thoosa · 16/02/2022 17:33

She is using hyperbole to make a point. Her statement isn’t intended to be taken literally. Her use of the word “barbarian” is exaggerated, hyperbolic, not literal.

The problem is, it’s not a great piece stylistically and the journalist in question is usually quite earnest so confusion was inevitable. Again, the OP was equally confusing. So that was a fun 5 minutes and the WSJ article is still behind a paywall so no getting to the root of it all without coughing up. 🤷🏻‍♀️

Suspect6 · 16/02/2022 17:30

@PeskyBaboon

If someone in a national newspaper says and I quote "dear white people, you have something of a reputation when it comes to cleanliness", I ask myself - as a former domestic cleaner - where's your justification, any evidence that warrants such a sweeping statement? Has the author spent a day of her life cleaning other peoples' houses for a living? Scrubbing their toilets and sinks and god knows what? White or otherwise? Just a thought... So much for "lived experience".
She is using hyperbole to make a point. Her statement isn’t intended to be taken literally. Her use of the word “barbarian” is exaggerated, hyperbolic, not literal.
PeskyBaboon · 16/02/2022 17:25

If someone in a national newspaper says and I quote "dear white people, you have something of a reputation when it comes to cleanliness", I ask myself - as a former domestic cleaner - where's your justification, any evidence that warrants such a sweeping statement? Has the author spent a day of her life cleaning other peoples' houses for a living? Scrubbing their toilets and sinks and god knows what? White or otherwise? Just a thought...
So much for "lived experience".

OP posts:
Thoosa · 16/02/2022 17:22

It does seem a bit OTT, but so, TBH, does your OP.

MrsTerryPratchett · 16/02/2022 17:20
Grin
Bellalastrasse · 16/02/2022 17:20

Nope, me too @MrsTerryPratchett
Feel like singing it, too

MrsTerryPratchett · 16/02/2022 17:18

@user1493494961

Let it go.
Am I the only one hearing this as Elsa?

I'll get my coat.

user1493494961 · 16/02/2022 17:17

Let it go.

EishetChayil · 16/02/2022 17:16

Eh? Are you quite well, OP?

Suspect6 · 16/02/2022 17:12

*not - not dotBlush

Suspect6 · 16/02/2022 17:12

Btw. I did not find the article offensive in the slightest

Then why, according to the title of your post, did the article “piss you off”? You say the article was depressing and utterly stupid but dot offensive yet it clearly made you angry?

Abhannmor · 16/02/2022 17:05

Arwa is a bit of a moanyhole in general I find. I actually prefer to go shoeless indoors. But the rest of it she can shove.

Aspiringmatriarch · 16/02/2022 17:02

Hello Pesky and welcome to Mumsnet 👋
I actually found the article quite funny. Glad you've calmed down now. Smile

user1478172746 · 16/02/2022 17:01

If you are Polish, you would not wear outer shoes inside anyway. You would have slippers for that. ;)

PeskyBaboon · 16/02/2022 17:00

Btw. I did not find the article offensive in the slightest, I took an interest in this Guardian's piece for another reason as well: when I came to the UK in 2003, for the first 2 years I worked as a cleaner for £3.50/hour all over London. I cleaned peoples' houses/flats for a living. I have seen a thing or two, never called anyone or thought of anyone barbarian though. Met some very kind and lovely people, some less kind or lovely. Which, incidentally, has got nothing (I still hope) to do with race.

OP posts:
Suspect6 · 16/02/2022 16:58

@Staffy1

It didn’t start with race, it started with hygiene. If it wouldn’t be ok to replace white people with another race in the article, which it wouldn’t, then it’s not ok or misunderstood.
The author of the Guardian article says “ But, you know what? I’m not going into the racialised aspects of hygiene discourse here.”

Which is what she had just done in her article, the article was about the racialised aspects of hygiene. It’s ironic, maybe hyperbole (but not so much, really)

CorrBlimeyGG · 16/02/2022 16:53

Staffy, you're completely proving the author's point. It was a tongue in cheek piece that you've taken to be 'a lecture to white people'. Are you this sensitive about actual racism?