Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Father requesting more days with children.

162 replies

Meme43 · 16/02/2022 14:50

Hello,
So I separated 8 years ago (divorced 3 years), and my 3 children have had regular contact with their father…staying roughly 3 nights every 10 days. I have always worked around his schedule to accommodate it recently he has more spare time and is requesting to have the children stay 4 nights one week two nights the following. I don’t agree to this but am I within my rights to say no?

OP posts:
BuanoKubiamVej · 17/02/2022 08:46

Impossible to say whether you are being reasonable given that you don't actually include any reasons in your OP so YABU for that.

YABU for posting and then disappearing without answering any questions in the replies.

The decision about the change in schedule should be based on what is in the children's best interests. Not what's most desirable for either parent. Both of you need to be grownup about this and put your kids needs first. I imagine the 3 days in 10 was due to your Ex having a job with a 10 day shift rotation pattern, and he has now either retired or got a job with hours that work on a fixed weely schedule. In which case it makes plenty of sense to revisit the arrangement to a schedule that gives the kids a more reliable pattern based on a fortnightly cycle rather than a 10 day pattern. However, the pattern does need to be reasonable for everyone concerned - needs to cover enabling the kids to continue with any clubs and extracurricular activities that they do, and give both parents reasonable shares of weekends and weekdays. So if his proposed pattern is to have them on Friday and Saturday nights every weekend and Thursday and Sunday nights too on alternate weekends that would be totally unreasonable because they would never get weekends with their mum. Two nights M-Th every week plus alternate weekends would be perfectly ok if it's compatible with kids other activities. With agreement for a set number of weeks per year where the pattern is paused to allow each parent to take the kids on holiday for a full week.

Antsgomarching · 17/02/2022 08:44

If the kids want to go let them, he’s their dad and if he’s a decent father than they will get something from this.

liveforsummer · 17/02/2022 08:26

@ilovemyboys3

Personally I feel children need one home with the resident parent. I wouldn't want to live in two houses with two of everything. When I grew up I had separated parents. I wouldn't of wanted to live 50/50. I lived with my mum and stayed with my dad 3 nights in 14. I wouldn't of wanted anymore. It's not what's best always for children; it's what they want and what suits them. They may walk to and from school to their mums; their friends may all live by their mums. If they are suddenly at their dads and isolated from their friends and clubs and school then that's not good either. I agree with OP on this one.
But you have no idea if any of the examples you've given are the case for the OP and you have no idea if the dc feel the same as you. My dc would be happy to see their dad more if the circumstances were different and part of it could be mid week. They have friends at their dads too and they have 2 of everything for the current 4 days a month too as it's a pain brining stuff back and forward then realising they've left something behind that they then can't get for a fortnight
liveforsummer · 17/02/2022 08:22

@maddening

If he was trying to get every weekend then no, and i doubt a court would grant that, you both need Leisure time with the dc.

If he wanted the weekend week 1 and then 2- 3 week nights the next week and lives sufficiently close to the school so they can continue with their current schedule with extra curricular activities (and he would facilitate that) and they could continue with friendships outside of school (and he would facilitate that) and there has been no history of dv, any type of abuse etc and the kids would actively want this option if allowed then a court would likely agree imo.

What is his proposal and what are your objections?

Yes I agree with this. My ex won't do any of the weekdays as he can't do the school run and won't do the club runs so every other weekend it is. No way I'm giving up the small bit of leisure time we have among the chaos of the school and working week. As it is I have to cram all their clubs in to the week as he won't facilitate them at the weekend either. If he was prepared and able to do school, clubs, homework I'd absolutely arrange for him to have them in the week some nights too
maddening · 17/02/2022 07:31

If he was trying to get every weekend then no, and i doubt a court would grant that, you both need Leisure time with the dc.

If he wanted the weekend week 1 and then 2- 3 week nights the next week and lives sufficiently close to the school so they can continue with their current schedule with extra curricular activities (and he would facilitate that) and they could continue with friendships outside of school (and he would facilitate that) and there has been no history of dv, any type of abuse etc and the kids would actively want this option if allowed then a court would likely agree imo.

What is his proposal and what are your objections?

Wingingit15 · 17/02/2022 07:29

@Rebornagain sigh. Seriously? Casting RPs as viewing their kids as a cash cow is so insulting

Rebornagain · 17/02/2022 07:18

As always with the majority of these cases this will be about money from the RP point of view.

Why wouldn't seeing their dad more be good for the children?

I would bet if there was no money involved the children would be at the NRPs more

mycatisannoying · 17/02/2022 07:05

Christ, I'd bloody love this. Instead it's 2 nights out of 14.

FortVictoria · 17/02/2022 07:01

I guess the OP didn’t like lots of posters suggesting that it was okay for dad to see more of the kids………

worriedatthemoment · 16/02/2022 20:52

@ilovemyboys3 what if all you says applies to dads house more ? Or the kids actually want to spend more time at Dads

ilovemyboys3 · 16/02/2022 20:28

Personally I feel children need one home with the resident parent. I wouldn't want to live in two houses with two of everything.
When I grew up I had separated parents. I wouldn't of wanted to live 50/50. I lived with my mum and stayed with my dad 3 nights in 14. I wouldn't of wanted anymore.
It's not what's best always for children; it's what they want and what suits them. They may walk to and from school to their mums; their friends may all live by their mums. If they are suddenly at their dads and isolated from their friends and clubs and school then that's not good either.
I agree with OP on this one.

2catsandhappy · 16/02/2022 20:14

Are the newly suggested arrangements over school holidays too?

lovescaca · 16/02/2022 20:05

Why should u get more days than him?

SD1978 · 16/02/2022 20:02

When you say you currently make the arrangements, is it the same nights every week/ 10 days. If he is stating he can now have the kids for double the amount of time, is this permanent, or could be temporary. If he goes back to three days a week, how would that affect you, with work, or wouldn't it? How old are the kids? What would they like to do? Would more time mean you could work more? There's lots of factors, and a blanket no because it doesn't suit you, doesn't mean it's not worth looking at

Nowhereelsetogo90 · 16/02/2022 19:57

[quote worriedatthemoment]@wombleflump no experience but it also shouldn't be assumed that mums should get the most time as it is on here , once old enough the child should get the say, but its wrong that many on here automatically think its the dads that see them less
And the few I know who do 50/50 or close too , kids are happy as they have two loving parents who they want to spend time with but who are also flexible with changes if dc need them , plus when done from a young age they don't know very much different [/quote]
Agreed. My DSD has no issues at all with it! All parents and stepparents are flexible and she has a stable base in both homes. If she gets older and doesn’t like it then that’s fine we will look at how to change it to best suit her needs. I’d say the only way this wouldn’t work is if the parents live miles apart - part of the reason it works for us is that we live ten mins from each other so can facilitate school/clubs/friends/relatives.

Nowhereelsetogo90 · 16/02/2022 19:54

[quote TracyMosby]@Nowhereelsetogo90
Id be surprised if 50/50 benefits the children, unless the children are teens. Id be even more surprised if 50/50 ends up actually being 50/50 with responsibilities and commitments, and not just time.

Is he likely to do clubs / parties / make and keep dentist and doctors appointments / hairdressers and barbers / clothes shops
Why would this be a surprise? My DH has 50-50 and does his part of all these things. Not every Dad is a useless deadbeat.

But this dad, the one we are discussing, was happy not having much contact for the past 8 YEARS! Now theyre significantly older, why now?[/quote]
Well that’s an odd interpretation of the facts. I think previous posters have posted the maths but his increase isn’t much at all in reality over a fortnight.

Luredbyapomegranate · 16/02/2022 19:39

You would be unreasonable to say no without a good reason.

Frankola · 16/02/2022 19:31

@wingingit15 If there was a genuine reason I'd be 100% behind OP saying no. It just doesn't seem fair to NRP to refuse more access. I understand this sounds very naive of me, but all parents should be able to have the best relationship possible with their kids.

Hopefully OP does come back when she can.

wombleflump · 16/02/2022 19:08

My friends ex dp got 50:50 much to her heart break. However he is always at work but give the kids to his sister and mother often on his time. He just wanted to not pay any money and punish her for leaving.

Wingingit15 · 16/02/2022 19:07

Hopefully OP will return. 2.50pm until 7 pm is not a long time in the real world when you are juggling kids, house and maybe a job alone

Wingingit15 · 16/02/2022 19:06

I must have missed where OP says there is no reason to refuse an increase sorry @Frankola

worriedatthemoment · 16/02/2022 19:05

@TracyMosby he has had consistent contact though and just asking for an increase which could be for many reasons, maybe his jobs has changed , maybe his kids have asked for it, maybe he has moved closer
The OP has given hardly any details and not come back
Every situation will be different and warrant a different answer

worriedatthemoment · 16/02/2022 19:02

@wombleflump no experience but it also shouldn't be assumed that mums should get the most time as it is on here , once old enough the child should get the say, but its wrong that many on here automatically think its the dads that see them less
And the few I know who do 50/50 or close too , kids are happy as they have two loving parents who they want to spend time with but who are also flexible with changes if dc need them , plus when done from a young age they don't know very much different

Frankola · 16/02/2022 18:58

@wingingit15 I make it clear in my post that I do not believe all single parents are like this.

However, according to OP herself there's no reason not to increase contact. She just doesn't want to. It's a viable question to ask if it's because of maintenance.

If this was a NRP who was a woman asking for more contact and the RP man was saying no because he didn't want to there would be uproar.

TracyMosby · 16/02/2022 18:57

@Nowhereelsetogo90
Id be surprised if 50/50 benefits the children, unless the children are teens. Id be even more surprised if 50/50 ends up actually being 50/50 with responsibilities and commitments, and not just time.

Is he likely to do clubs / parties / make and keep dentist and doctors appointments / hairdressers and barbers / clothes shops
Why would this be a surprise? My DH has 50-50 and does his part of all these things. Not every Dad is a useless deadbeat.

But this dad, the one we are discussing, was happy not having much contact for the past 8 YEARS! Now theyre significantly older, why now?

Swipe left for the next trending thread