Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel depressed and angry about Bankers Bonuses

255 replies

SapatSea · 16/02/2022 13:42

Most people in the country are facing a cost of living crisis. We have had austerity for over a decade due to bailing out the banks and the "we're all in it together" mantra (lies). Although our GDP doesn't look too bad as a bald figure the GDP per person is falling year on year and the multiples of difference in salary/wealth between those at the bottom and top is ever widening. We are becoming a more and more divided society in terms of the have's and have's not.Most people are deeply worried about fuel bills and the future and then we have this
www.theguardian.com/business/2022/feb/16/weve-had-a-run-on-champagne-biggest-uk-banker-bonuses-since-financial-crash
barely reported by the MSM. It's obscene.

(I do realise that just a few months after the crash and bail out that bankers got bonuses again but this just really hurt reading it this morning)

OP posts:
gemloving · 16/02/2022 14:50

I sit on the sales desk but do the compliance part, even the juniors earn more than me because their bonuses are mad BUT I work 9-5, if they need me urgently, they can ring and I get stuff done if really needed but it's not often. They work 12-16h a day. I have children that I see, those men have children but they don't see them. A lot of them work incredibly hard are available 24/7. I wouldn't want that life/ wouldn't be able to sustain it without burning out. It's pressure, pressure & more pressure. They bring in the money for the bank, and get their cut. I personally don't think it's unfair.

TheKeatingFive · 16/02/2022 14:48

Yes the government bailed out the banks and let them away with murder, but ultimately the banks had a lot of power and knew it. The government needed to avert societal collapse. Their hand wasn't strong.

Whiskeywithwater · 16/02/2022 14:47

As someone has said, if it’s so piss easy then feel free to go and get a job trading then. As a 30+ year veteran of investment banking, I can assure you it’s not that easy. And you are most definitely not rewarded for failure. What is sometimes not understood is that it wasn’t bankers being baled out in isolation - the collapse of the banking industry would have been catastrophic for the country and everyone in it! The banks were bailed out to protect the population and the country itself. Heads rolled .. they continue to roll. The conduct of everyone in the industry is under intense scrutiny always - the conduct risk awareness now far surpasses most other industries. Yes, some bankers get eye watering bonuses - but they generate eye watering profits. The financial services industry is a colossal contributor to the overall wealth of the nation. Banking profits lead to higher dividend payouts of course to shareholders. Which by the way - pension funds make up a hefty proportion.

Mybestyear · 16/02/2022 14:46

It is obscene but YABU. We live in a capitalist society which rewards those who shaft others and the accumulation of extreme wealth and “stuff” so I don’t know why people are surprised by this.

Getoff · 16/02/2022 14:44

Because UK taxpayers subsidise the banking failures - we are paying for their failure. If you aren’t a shareholder but are a taxpayer then you very much are a stakeholder.

It's true that this happened, once in living memory, as far as I know, but that doesn't mean individual bankers who had nothing to do with it should be paid less. Or even that the ones who are guilty should be paid less. If the government wants to recover money, it needs to get it from the banks, not their employees.

TheKeatingFive · 16/02/2022 14:44

There's a culture of high pay in banking because money begets money begets money. If your job involves growing large pots of money into even larger ones them it's quite easy to make the argument that you should be generously reimbursed out of the proceeds.

That kind of thing would never translate into public sector jobs, because there are hundreds of thousands of teachers and nurses out there and a limited pot to pay them from.

It's got absolutely nothing to do with how challenging the job is and everything to do with the micro economics of it all.

In any corporate environment, those who bring the cash in (i.e. make the sales) have the most leverage with regards to pay. Bankers are just an exaggerated version of this, they bring in the money to the tune of billions.

The only way to tackle this would be a radical rehaul of taxation and even at that rich people tend to find ways round the rules.

CrimbleCrumble1 · 16/02/2022 14:40

My DH is a retired banker, the tax he paid on his annual bonus went towards towards schooling, welfare, and the free 15 hours free childcare families receive.
If anyone else wants as much tax and contribute towards society in this way then please apply.

MarshaBradyo · 16/02/2022 14:39

As a consultant you can go into private practice too, at the same time as NHS, so there is scope to increase earning if you want. As there should be

Most people aren’t attracted to finance even despite the money as it is a hard slog and tough environment, plus other careers have social rewards, eg top surgeon is something people go for as it suits their mindset more

If it all still sounds attractive to work in finance sector then go for it

TheReluctantPhoenix · 16/02/2022 14:35

@JimmyDurham,

Doesn’t quite work that way with banks since 2008!

Many middle income people paid extra tax to keep people on large 6 figure salaries employed.

And there is still an issue of capitalism for profits, socialised losses.

And that is leaving aside the issue of where these bonuses come from (clue: look at how your pension has performed long term).

pateu · 16/02/2022 14:35

Unless you are a shareholder, what business is it of yours (or the Guardian's come to that)? A company can pay what it likes if its shareholders don't object.

😆

MissConductUS · 16/02/2022 14:34

Also - morally how would the bonuses be decided? Doctor A saved 85% of his patients during surgery so gets a fat check, but Doctor B only saved 82% so doesn't? Nurse A accidentally gave too much morphine out twice so loses half her bonus, but Nurse B inserted 1,000 catheters in 6 months so gets a bonus? I'd love the see the compensation scheme

Incentive compensation for health care workers isn't really done routinely for front-line health care workers in the US, but salaries are generally quite high. And salaries are set comparatively. Hospitals recruit nurses from each other all of the time with higher wages, signing bonuses, better hours, etc. There's no need to come up with artificial bonus triggers.

pateu · 16/02/2022 14:33

There’s room for some changes without scaring the horses.

agree

Spottiswoode · 16/02/2022 14:32

@JimmyDurham

Unless you are a shareholder, what business is it of yours (or the Guardian's come to that)? A company can pay what it likes if its shareholders don't object.
Because UK taxpayers subsidise the banking failures - we are paying for their failure. If you aren’t a shareholder but are a taxpayer then you very much are a stakeholder.
GingerFigs · 16/02/2022 14:30

Agree with @Kilimanjaro97

The roles are there if you want to apply but say goodbye to your social life and job stability.

I absolutely agree that some professions are woefully underpaid but some areas including government roles have job security unlike any other no matter how you perform.

JimmyDurham · 16/02/2022 14:30

Unless you are a shareholder, what business is it of yours (or the Guardian's come to that)? A company can pay what it likes if its shareholders don't object.

TooExtraImmatureCheddar · 16/02/2022 14:30

The highest corporation tax in the world is paid in UAE. Europe has lower tax than anywhere else in the world. There’s room for some changes without scaring the horses.

Spottiswoode · 16/02/2022 14:29

They get bonuses for making money, through touch decisions and hard work. If they don't perform, they don't get the bonuses. Its the way bonuses work?

Erm, with the bailout due to bad performance, they are subsidised by the taxpayers to the tune of £500 Billion. (£500 Billion in 2008 monetary value.)

They don’t perform, they have a fail safe economy, socialism for them. Not so much for others.

DaveGrohl · 16/02/2022 14:27

@Kilimanjaro97 agreed. I am married to/am/related to/best friends with people in all those professions.

The banker didn’t get any special handout or secret handshake to get into the job. They worked incredibly hard, went to Cambridge after coming from a working class northern background, and then has continued to work incredibly hard in an incredibly uncertain environment for the last 20 years - 10 or so different employers. They work much much harder than the dr/nurse and teacher. The person who has it easiest is the dr with the £1m+ pension pot who works 3 days a week -
and admits themselves they have it sweet!

pateu · 16/02/2022 14:27

There is the question about why the deals are so £££££ that the 0.5% fee for the banks advice runs into millions.

feb21 · 16/02/2022 14:25

It's not so much the individuals leaving as the risk of the financial institutions leaving if you make corporate tax uncompetitive. That doesn't benefit anyone, including revenue to fund the public sector.

TooExtraImmatureCheddar · 16/02/2022 14:22

Again, it’s not the fault of the individuals. It’s down to what we value as a society. Making lots of money is valued more highly than saving lives or educating the young. That’s not a moral judgement on individual bankers.

The macho culture of investment banks is created solely by investment banks, though - that’s on them.

Maybe as a county we should be taxing company profits more. I often hear people arguing that increasing taxes will make the rich leave the country. For most people, that’s not remotely likely. They’ve got their whole lives here, kids in school, family, friends…they aren’t going to disappear to some low-tax haven just because tax bands change. I’m at the edge of the 40% tax band and I’m hardly going to up sticks and move country if the Scottish government moves the band a bit. Similar with companies - Amazon’s not going to pull out of the lucrative market that is the UK if the tax it has to pay here increases by a few percent.

ohhooh · 16/02/2022 14:22

[quote Cameleongirl]@ohhooh. I agree that we’d have to pay ALOT of extra tax to give nurses and teachers bonuses and everyone would moan about it, even though it might be the morally right thing to do…can’t win really.😂[/quote]
Exactly then everyone would have to turn to banking careers to make enough money to pay their taxes for the NHS bonus scheme 😂

Also - morally how would the bonuses be decided? Doctor A saved 85% of his patients during surgery so gets a fat check, but Doctor B only saved 82% so doesn't? Nurse A accidentally gave too much morphine out twice so loses half her bonus, but Nurse B inserted 1,000 catheters in 6 months so gets a bonus? I'd love the see the compensation scheme 😂 😂

pateu · 16/02/2022 14:21

My dad was an investment banker, he worked long hours & very hard. He's also said most of his job was BS though

Brainwave89 · 16/02/2022 14:19

I work in finance. Bonus is not as high as banking but is still decent. Half goes in tax, but still nice to have. I do not doubt that caring roles are valuable, but I have worked hard and this is the nature of the industry I am in. Open to anyone to join.

MarshaBradyo · 16/02/2022 14:18

@Kilimanjaro97

Being a banker isn’t any harder (in fact, much easier) than being a doctor/nurse/carer/teacher etc

We have some of these careers in my family. The banker works far longer hours (18 hours a day 6 and a half days a week) than the doctor. The banker has no job security (instant redundancy is the norm), no automatic career progression and is the object of uninformed hate from many in society (cf this thread). Additionally they work in a pretty toxic environment and they either get measurable results or they are fired. If they succeed they are well rewarded. Most leave after a few years as the pressure is unsustainable.

For those moaning about the demographic, the jobs are open to anyone with the right skill sets who applies. As things currently stand “diverse” applicants are preferred over white men. But most people would not dream of applying for the reasons given above.

Medicine, nursing, caring, teaching etc are different jobs which require different skill sets and are rewarded differently. If people in those jobs want the rewards of banking then they should apply for banking jobs - and if they are successful, they can put in the hours, deliver the results, and reap the benefits. But there are no weekends, evenings off, long holidays and people clapping in appreciation on their doorsteps - and no nice coffee chats at break time.

This and also the tax paid here instead of elsewhere

Op I think it’s easy to feel as you do but would you want to work in finance?