Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel depressed and angry about Bankers Bonuses

255 replies

SapatSea · 16/02/2022 13:42

Most people in the country are facing a cost of living crisis. We have had austerity for over a decade due to bailing out the banks and the "we're all in it together" mantra (lies). Although our GDP doesn't look too bad as a bald figure the GDP per person is falling year on year and the multiples of difference in salary/wealth between those at the bottom and top is ever widening. We are becoming a more and more divided society in terms of the have's and have's not.Most people are deeply worried about fuel bills and the future and then we have this
www.theguardian.com/business/2022/feb/16/weve-had-a-run-on-champagne-biggest-uk-banker-bonuses-since-financial-crash
barely reported by the MSM. It's obscene.

(I do realise that just a few months after the crash and bail out that bankers got bonuses again but this just really hurt reading it this morning)

OP posts:
Dexy007 · 16/02/2022 20:22

Bankers have very little job security though. I gather at Goldman Sachs the bottom 10% of traders get axed every single year.

I think it's a great job, I'd encourage my kids to do it if they had a thick enough skin.

TheReluctantPhoenix · 16/02/2022 20:15

@CrimbleCrumble1,

Connections and luck.

Certain backgrounds are favoured, and the right work experience.

But, ultimately, some banks will get hundreds of very similar graduate applications for a few positions. They will also mostly interview pretty similarly.

You have to select 5 out of the, say, 400 applicants, so you do rounds of interviews, but it is really hard to judge (very similar) people.

So, 5 win the lottery and get to be graduate trainees. They work hard and show a good attitude and, a few years down the line, they are rich.

They are not idiots (obviously) but neither are they super talented. On the whole, they are very ambitious and competent people who got lucky.

It is part of human psyche to think that because they made a lot of money, they are immensely talented.

CrimbleCrumble1 · 16/02/2022 19:54

My DH and loads of these comments from his siblings. Obviously they all had the same background and education but he went to university as a mature student, took a risk and moved to London with no money, just student debt. Now they constantly talk about bankers bonuses. It does seem like sour grapes as he earns 10 to 20 times more than them. If it was that easy then why didn’t they do it?

TheReluctantPhoenix · 16/02/2022 19:45

@Stressedout1009 and @TheKeatingFive,

It really isn’t quite like that.

Investment bankers do work very hard and do get very stressed but, ultimately, a lot of it is self-inflicted and many are stress addicts.

There is A LOT of luck in investment banking. If you make a few good bets as a trader, you can walk away with several hundred thousand pounds at the end of the year. In M&A, one big FD likes your proposal and you get to advise on the deal, you are a ‘rainmaker’ and, again, get immensely rewarded.

There is good research suggesting that the most successful bankers are far from the best, as the best can see the downsides and tend to be less aggressive.

JoanWilderbeast · 16/02/2022 19:35

They never have to pay back any of their bonuses due to the fallout of that profit making though. Privatise the profits, socialise the costs.

Cameleongirl · 16/02/2022 19:35

@ButtockUp. That’s the issue, isn’t it, a medical professional in America, for example, CAN make a lot of money, because they’re not employed by the state, although they carry massive insurance as well. Public vs. private sector, two completely different ball games.

Stressedout1009 · 16/02/2022 19:23

@TheKeatingFive

Instead of employing 10 workers on £150k and expecting them to work 18 hour days they could employ 15, either on a lower salary or by reducing their profits a smidge. They could adhere to the Working Time Directive. They could give their staff some job security. They could start family friendly policies.

I'm not sure this demonstrates any understanding of the business and how it works. Clients want the best people and the best people rise to the top via their skill and putting in those long hours.

It's just not the type of business where you can work eight hours and skip merrily home, to be truly on top of things you need to know what's going on across the globe and that changes hour by hour.

^Exactly. These people are so skill specific that companies are at bidding wars trying to get them hired. My dh works constantly, he is always watching the markets, up at the crack of dawn, 12-14 hour days, returned from/cancelled holidays earlier. I would definitely not consider this job a walk in the park.
Itsnotdeep · 16/02/2022 19:22

lol at all the bankers and their wives coming on here and saying how many hours they work, as though that somehow justifies these obscene sums.

There's something so morally wrong with the system that people are getting this kind of money while millions of people can't afford to feed themselves in this country.

Shortofspace · 16/02/2022 19:14

@Blossomtoes

Also don’t think there is anything wrong with hard work getting rewards ?!?

Nothing wrong with it at all which is why it’s so scandalous that some of the hardest workers in our society are on minimum wage.

Great post
Blossomtoes · 16/02/2022 19:10

Thanks for the lecture @sst1234.

sst1234 · 16/02/2022 19:08

@Blossomtoes

Also don’t think there is anything wrong with hard work getting rewards ?!?

Nothing wrong with it at all which is why it’s so scandalous that some of the hardest workers in our society are on minimum wage.

Physical labour is not exactly the backbone of the economy. We are not an agrarian society. If you want the lifestyle of 21st century with all its comforts then you have to accept that the people who are generating these comforts are the ones in tech, engineering and finance. It’s all very virtuous, equating hard work and remuneration to physical labour, but it’s not how modern societies work. You are about 1000 years too late to run the economy in that way.
ButtockUp · 16/02/2022 19:02

As medical professionals are generally employed by the state , their pay will always be dictated by the constraints of the taxpayer.

Bankers are generally performance related in their remuneration, and so, the sky is the limit, in theory.

Remember though, that the vast majority of bank workers earn not too much. It's Investment Bankers , a whole different breed, who earn these stellar salaries and bonuses.

Their stresses aren't life and death, but they are under enormous pressure to 'perform' which often means, working 12-15 hour days, working through the night and knowing that they could be sacked, at the drop of a hat.

The pressure to 'earn ' eleventy million quid is absolutely enormous. Being able to , in almost a nanosecond, calculate a profit or loss , mentally doing fractions of percentages and converting to another currency and also knowing that you could not work the next day is quite stressful.

gemloving · 16/02/2022 18:48

@Florenz

Just have a government account where your money is held. No interest. They could also bring back the right to be paid wages in cash which Thatcher abolished.
In the world of digitalisation, this would be a huge step backwards.
Mindtheears · 16/02/2022 18:29

I watch all these “cut and thrust” programmes and roll my eyes. Some places maybe but not like where I worked.

Blossomtoes · 16/02/2022 18:23

@TizerorFizz

These bonuses are taxed. The rate will be higher the corporation tax paid by the banks. So potentially more for uk coffers.
Only until next year when the rate rises to 25%.
Florenz · 16/02/2022 18:18

Just have a government account where your money is held. No interest. They could also bring back the right to be paid wages in cash which Thatcher abolished.

BasiliskStare · 16/02/2022 17:58

Florenz
The world would be much better off if there were no bankers and no banks.

Are you absolutely sure about that - have you researched ?

@FourBookPiles - I have some paperback books - would you like to get my downstairs loo painted in return ? Just a thought.

Oh I don't think anyone is saying that people work long and hard hours for less money - of course they do . But I think the headline millions in bonuses is a relatively few people. Of course others will get a very very nice sum in bonuses - but it is a business the UK is in. What else do we do ? knitted cushions ? - Don't get me started on Dyson who has taken all his manufacturing abroad. Well I suppose he can make them more cheaply and increase revenue - good for him but not so good for UK factories . Enough - I don't really know enough

TheReluctantPhoenix · 16/02/2022 17:51

@TheKeatingFive,

A successful deal maker/allocation can make a good return on his risk allocation (it is called the sharpe ratio).

So, if you move from a small bank to a large one, with the same percentage payout, you will make 10x the bonus. No one would be making 7 figures without the bank behind them.

And, as for the tax argument, it depends whether you think that banks create wealth or ‘nick’ other peoples (GS was termed the ‘Giant Vampire Squid’ in one article).

Clearly we do need banks and they do create some wealth but they also effectively tax everyone’s pensions and this adds nothing net to the exchequer. The banking sector has multiplied by a factor of 10 since the Big Bang. It is debatable whether this has created any value.

High frequency trading is just front running, large scale mergers have been shown to be wealth destructive for shareholders and block trading is being investigated right now. And this is excluding the massive scandal of credit derivatives.

FourBookPiles · 16/02/2022 17:46

@Florenz

The world would be much better off if there were no bankers and no banks.
And we all bartered for everything, with pebbles and bags of wheat.
TizerorFizz · 16/02/2022 17:28

These bonuses are taxed. The rate will be higher the corporation tax paid by the banks. So potentially more for uk coffers.

TheKeatingFive · 16/02/2022 17:15

There is no evidence that these extraordinary rewards are justified.

I'm certainly not saying any of this is 'justified' on some moral or work ethic level. Simply that in a capitalistic society, you're going to get bigger salaries and bonuses in sectors where there's a lot of money sloshing around. And nowhere is more money replete than banking.

If you bring in 10 million that is you. Not everyone can do that, not by a long shot. It is, however, you in the context of a sector with lots of cash flying around. Which is of course a big reason why those people chose it.

TheReluctantPhoenix · 16/02/2022 16:59

Public and shareholders..

TheReluctantPhoenix · 16/02/2022 16:59

I see the same old tired arguments being recycled justifying the massive ripping off of the top unlock and shareholders who are again the public, via pension funds (staffed by ex bankers via the revolving door).

If you are bringing in 7 figures for your bank, the main driver is ‘the seat’, not you. Anyone, with massive risk limits can generate a massive return (in a good year) and, in a bad year, get sacked and pop up at a similar institution within a short period.

There is no evidence that these extraordinary rewards are justified. They are a bubble, no different from tulip bulbs and NFTs.

TheKeatingFive · 16/02/2022 16:54

The world would be much better off if there were no bankers and no banks.

How would you get paid? Get a mortgage? Buy things?

MarshaBradyo · 16/02/2022 16:53

Post-kids and I am now a civil servant. I earn about a quarter of what I used to (but still decent enough). The contrast between working hours and culture could not be more stark. The civil service is far from perfect, but wow, it’s like working in a rainbow and unicorn shop in comparison, everything is fluffy, relaxed and flexible.

Interesting post but this stood out, I think people underestimate this factor. And if it is actually easy then apply and do it.

I made decisions based on stuff like this as I know what suits me and what wouldn’t

Swipe left for the next trending thread