Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel depressed and angry about Bankers Bonuses

255 replies

SapatSea · 16/02/2022 13:42

Most people in the country are facing a cost of living crisis. We have had austerity for over a decade due to bailing out the banks and the "we're all in it together" mantra (lies). Although our GDP doesn't look too bad as a bald figure the GDP per person is falling year on year and the multiples of difference in salary/wealth between those at the bottom and top is ever widening. We are becoming a more and more divided society in terms of the have's and have's not.Most people are deeply worried about fuel bills and the future and then we have this
www.theguardian.com/business/2022/feb/16/weve-had-a-run-on-champagne-biggest-uk-banker-bonuses-since-financial-crash
barely reported by the MSM. It's obscene.

(I do realise that just a few months after the crash and bail out that bankers got bonuses again but this just really hurt reading it this morning)

OP posts:
JumpingRope · 17/02/2022 06:50

@FourBookPiles

If you were making millions of pounds for your employer through your hard work and decision making, wouldn’t you want that to be acknowledged in your pay package?

It’s the same as footballers. If you’re signed by a club and the club makes multi-millions in additional shirt and ticket sales because people want to see you, why is it unreasonable to expect a cut of that?

I agree that some types of work are woefully underpaid for their contribution to society, caring roles particularly. It’s a joke they get paid so little. But it’s the system’s fault, not the individuals and it’s the role of the government to re-adjust things so there’s a fairer and more equitable distribution of wealth.

Exactly this. The issue isn't why bankers are paid loads - it is why other careers are not paid enough. And for what it's worth, doctors are also paid a very decent amount particularly if they do private work (I.e 6 figure salaries)
BobbyeinArkansas · 17/02/2022 04:20

It's economics 101 innit. Supply and demand.
Not everyone could be a trader, otherwise why aren't they doing it? The kind of relentless stress from trading, constant threat of redundancy etc is very real.
Not saying this isn't the case in many roles but let's not pretend that finance is a walk in the park.

Believe me they actively seek out women and people of colour. Just because it attracts white males for the most part doesn't mean they don't try to recruit outside that demographic.
For example my husband who also works in finance was made redundant a few years ago. Took him over a year to find a new job. One headhunter even used the term pale, stale male.
I on the other hand, who left trading years ago, still get calls and on a very regular basis from headhunters looking to recruit into Tier One Investment Banks.

I digress. What a nurse or teacher gets paid (public sector) has nothing to do with what a banker earns (private sector).
My brother is a nurse and earns about £30k a year. My husband earns about 7 times that salary excluding bonus. My brother knew what nurses salaries are when he started training. He also, having an undergraduate degree in economics, could have gone into finance and be earning £200k basic a year.
People conflating bankers bonuses with a nurses salary need a lesson in critical thinking.

TheKeatingFive · 17/02/2022 03:58

I think we all understand how capitalism works thanks very much.

Well the poster I responded to seems to think we can do without banks, so no, 'we' don't.

Some of us might be a bit more critical as to how beneficial it actually is though, in its current form.

Well you know what they say, the worst economic system, apart from all the others. I don't see anyone offering to do without the tax I raises for the treasury however.

Zotter · 17/02/2022 02:44

Financialisation of the economy that began in earnest in the 1970’s has driven inequality.

“Financialisation must be understood as a radical transformation within the financial sector that has altered entire economies – from the household and the firm to the functioning of monetary systems and commodity markets.

Research has shown that financialisation has increased inequality, slowed down investment in ‘real’ production, mounted pressures on indebted households and individuals, and led to a decline in democratic accountability.”

www.tni.org/en/publication/financialisation-a-primer#Q1

Cameleongirl · 17/02/2022 01:20

There is A LOT of luck in investment banking. If you make a few good bets as a trader, you can walk away with several hundred thousand pounds at the end of the year.

@TheReluctantPhoenix. Luck is definitely part of the equation, industry knowledge and strategy also play a major role, IMO. DH works in corporate finance and one of his colleagues made $100 million for the company last year. It was a consistent strategy based on his industry knowledge that got him there, not a few good bets. I can’t imagine generating that sort of profit, but some people can do it!

sst1234 · 17/02/2022 00:45

@MongoOnlyPawnInGameOfLife

And it clearly isn’t oversubscribed, based on the salaries and bonuses. So once again, if it’s so easy to earn bucks in investment banking, why are it more people choosing to go into that profession and earn tons of money for not working very hard.

FudgeSundae · 16/02/2022 23:39

@TheReluctantPhoenix

I will try to give you an analogy about why I believe banking is largely predatory (especially investment banking). It is imperfect, as all analogies are.

Now, most offices have plants, they need to be bought and looked after. There is some research that plants improve morale and productivity in businesses.

Now imagine a few clever people set themselves up as ‘business plant consultants’. They produced some (somewhat biased) research that not only having plants was important but the type of plant could be critical to the success of the business.

Now, the previously relatively minor role of plant buyer (aka finance director) became incredibly important. Plant consultants charged 10s of millions of pounds for plant advice and, on the back of that, were paid bonuses of millions of pounds, on the back of which they became huge tax payers.

It wasn’t enough to just have the right plants, as these could change, so plant consultants sold plant buyers claims on plants that might become important later. Some businesses made more from bets on plants than boring things like car sales (Porsche at one point in finance for instance) but others, making the wrong bets, lost their shareholders nearly everything (GE in the US).

Regardless of how companies actually did, more and more plant consultants were needed and this job became very desirable to our best minds. Potential genetics researchers decided to join plant consultants as the pay was so much better.

Finance is not as important as bankers would have you believe and bubbles are not harmless.

This only makes sense if you think that finance is unimportant commensurate to faffing about with plants (I realise you said it’s an imperfect analogy). It’s really not, though. Every company I work with is funded by… finance. I, and most people I know, have a mortgage. That’s finance. A PP was complaining about overdraft fees and I agree, but an overdraft is literally the bank lending you money… finance. Your pension… finance.

So, yeah, it’s not the same as plants in an office. Maybe more like electricity or wifi. An office (society) COULD work without it but only in a pretty backward way.

MongoOnlyPawnInGameOfLife · 16/02/2022 23:17

@sst1234

Still waiting for the answer to, if it’s so easy why aren’t more people in investment banking?
Presumably there's a limit to the number of people who can actually work in the sector?
MongoOnlyPawnInGameOfLife · 16/02/2022 23:13

@TheKeatingFive

They don't actually produce anything, just move money around.

And that makes a lot of money.

What do you mean by 'produce something'? They produce profits. Again I think a capitalism 101 class is in order.

I think we all understand how capitalism works thanks very much.

Some of us might be a bit more critical as to how beneficial it actually is though, in its current form.

Shortofspace · 16/02/2022 23:03

I don't think it's easy at all. It's just not the kind of thing I would ever have been interested in, ethically speaking.

sst1234 · 16/02/2022 22:59

Still waiting for the answer to, if it’s so easy why aren’t more people in investment banking?

Justanotherlurker · 16/02/2022 22:48

And yet, we're still talking about the government bailing out U.K. investment banks.

Disingenious, Goverments across the world bailed out the banks and bonuses where paid, what a lot of people who will pick up on that don't want to admit is that if they didn't then the economy would have crashed and their personal situation would have gone to shit, the ven diagram of being aginst banking bonuses and wanting their house price to increase is almost a complete circle, they just cant see ironic situation they are in

Blossomtoes · 16/02/2022 22:35

And yet, we're still talking about the government bailing out U.K. investment banks. They didn't.

I think you’ll find they did.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2008_United_Kingdom_bank_rescue_package

feb21 · 16/02/2022 22:17

And yet, we're still talking about the government bailing out U.K. investment banks. They didn't. My bonuses were not paid out of tax-payers' money. But I did pay half of them back in tax.

Making a lot of money isn't evil. Someone doesn't always have to lose out. I went into corporate finance from a state school education. As could others if they were willing to work their arses off and work in a highly pressured environment. We were told by our CEO that we'd be on the redundancy list if we weren't still at our desks at midnight.

And our economy would be rather screwed without the financial services sector.

ChampagneLassie · 16/02/2022 21:50

"Bankers" who get bonuses like this are generally people doing M&A deals. But yes finance is way better rewarded than many sectors. Nothing to stop anyone going for these careers. If as a society we want greater equality more people shoukd express this politically. Not just through biting but more people should get more actively involved in politics. Instead it's left to the few and the country is becoming increasingly right wing

teaandtoastwithmarmite · 16/02/2022 21:45

I get a bonus monthly in my job as long as we hit our targets. I don't feel guilty about it. It's just what happens where I work. DH works for a bank and gets a yearly bonus. It's never anything crazy but it's helpful to us and he gets taxed a fair amount.

RedRoseRay · 16/02/2022 21:40

I’m a complaint manager for a bank and I dislike when these articles come out around this time every year. The majority of ‘bankers’ ie bank staff on the front line you speak with in branch or by phone, are not highly paid. It’s a stressful job which anyone who works directly with the public on a daily basis in customer service will tell you. There’s also stats and targets that can be hard to meet. It’s ridiculous the crap we get off customers when these bonus pay articles come out every year. The investment bankers and people at the very top of the tree earn ridiculously high amounts via salary and bonus. The people the public spew their ill informed hate at do not. Writing to the CEO will get a response from someone much further down the chain who has no influence over staff bonus pay decisions. I remember reading an article a few years ago saying the average employee at the bank I work for was getting a £4000 bonus. The media calculations included the people at the top getting millions when the ones at the bottom got appx £400. Don’t believe everything you read.

Florenz · 16/02/2022 21:33

Footballers deserve their money more than bankers do IMO. At least some people get enjoyment from watching football.

TheReluctantPhoenix · 16/02/2022 21:30

I will try to give you an analogy about why I believe banking is largely predatory (especially investment banking). It is imperfect, as all analogies are.

Now, most offices have plants, they need to be bought and looked after. There is some research that plants improve morale and productivity in businesses.

Now imagine a few clever people set themselves up as ‘business plant consultants’. They produced some (somewhat biased) research that not only having plants was important but the type of plant could be critical to the success of the business.

Now, the previously relatively minor role of plant buyer (aka finance director) became incredibly important. Plant consultants charged 10s of millions of pounds for plant advice and, on the back of that, were paid bonuses of millions of pounds, on the back of which they became huge tax payers.

It wasn’t enough to just have the right plants, as these could change, so plant consultants sold plant buyers claims on plants that might become important later. Some businesses made more from bets on plants than boring things like car sales (Porsche at one point in finance for instance) but others, making the wrong bets, lost their shareholders nearly everything (GE in the US).

Regardless of how companies actually did, more and more plant consultants were needed and this job became very desirable to our best minds. Potential genetics researchers decided to join plant consultants as the pay was so much better.

Finance is not as important as bankers would have you believe and bubbles are not harmless.

downtonabbeyfan1234 · 16/02/2022 21:27

@TheReluctantPhoenix I thought the banks did the lending in the early 2000s.. with the crash happening in 08. I mean there have been graduates since that have gone into banking. Made money (and have not crashed the economy).

I'm sure on Mumsnet there are those who DC went to Oxbridge and then the city?

TheReluctantPhoenix · 16/02/2022 21:16

@downtonabbeyfan1234,

Are you quite young? Of course the bankers of today are the same as those in 2008, many quite literally the same people. It was 14 years ago, not 140!

In fact the CDS swap, the ‘never again’ instrument that was the catalyst of the 2008 crash, is back to volumes very close to those seen in 2007.

Bankers don’t go into banking only motivated by money and the next bonus, many are genuinely interested in the ‘science’ of finance.
But, when pay is so short term and life changing, and people are literally defined by their ‘numbers’ (‘we must employ him, he is a £20 mio a year trader’), the incentives are only one way.

downtonabbeyfan1234 · 16/02/2022 21:07

People complaining about '08... yes huge bonuses then probably an issues. Subprime lending would have gone on in the early 2000s. The bankers now are different people. They are not the people who crashed the economy. Also you know the financial services industry does FINANCE our economy. I see no issue.

Study well, get a good job in finance. Work brutal hours. They deserve their pay. Or would you complain about solicitor pay in magic circle firms? Or when software engineers in big tech firms get high pay?

Itsnotdeep · 16/02/2022 20:47

It's not sour grapes @CrimbleCrumble1 and we have lots of understanding @GreenLimes . It's just obscene and actually, wrong.

GreenLimes · 16/02/2022 20:27

TheReluctantPhoenix no connections here. Just brains, hard work and long hours.

GreenLimes · 16/02/2022 20:23

CrimbleCrumble1 it’s pretty simple your DH is more clever, has more qualifications and took more risks. Same as my DH. People commenting on this thread couldn’t understand the front page of the FT. There is no easy money, it’s skip the parties, study hard, sit exams, university, chartered accountant, business school, treasury exam, then 30 years hard work and yeah you get a bonus. What a shocker.