Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel depressed and angry about Bankers Bonuses

255 replies

SapatSea · 16/02/2022 13:42

Most people in the country are facing a cost of living crisis. We have had austerity for over a decade due to bailing out the banks and the "we're all in it together" mantra (lies). Although our GDP doesn't look too bad as a bald figure the GDP per person is falling year on year and the multiples of difference in salary/wealth between those at the bottom and top is ever widening. We are becoming a more and more divided society in terms of the have's and have's not.Most people are deeply worried about fuel bills and the future and then we have this
www.theguardian.com/business/2022/feb/16/weve-had-a-run-on-champagne-biggest-uk-banker-bonuses-since-financial-crash
barely reported by the MSM. It's obscene.

(I do realise that just a few months after the crash and bail out that bankers got bonuses again but this just really hurt reading it this morning)

OP posts:
MarshaBradyo · 17/02/2022 08:02

@feb21

M&A seeks to create efficiency savings and synergistic gains. Generally, these look far better on the Excel spreadsheet than they turn out in real life.

If I think about the acquisitions I advised on, some were more value-enhancing than others. But that's far more the fault of the company than the advisers. I'd say 95% of acquisitions were identified by the client (despite more acquisition search presentations than I care to admit to). Yes, we'd help them value the company, project manage the transaction and do the financial modelling (based on their numbers). But the post-integration piece is the clients' alone.

I can think of plenty of examples where we advised clients not to undertake corporate transactions. One company wanted to IPO and invited a number of investment banks to present to them on strategic options. We didn't believe they should and gave a very honest presentation. It went down like a lead balloon. They did float, but a decade later.

There were also more aborted than completed transactions. Our retainer was tiny in comparison to our final value fee. Several disposal processes were stopped when the client wasn't happy with the level of offers. We agreed. Yes, everyone wants their fees but having integrity and putting your client first is more important for your reputation long-term.

Good to get posts first hand on here from someone in sector

With all this it’s supply and demand and if people think it’s easy then why wouldn’t you just go for the money - if money was what you were after

TheReluctantPhoenix · 17/02/2022 07:54

@feb21,

It sounds like you do an interesting job with skill and integrity.

And I know many investment bankers who are like you.

However, this is anecdotal. The research demonstrates fairly unambiguously that large scale mergers are, on average, value destructive to investors.

This is why, among other reasons, I am trying to diversify my own investments as much as possible away from public equity markets. I far prefer to invest in small private equity.

Most, however, don’t have that choice. The fact that our capital markets generally work for high level employees (the ‘talent’-haha!) and bankers and lawyers is a real scandal.

It has turned property into the investment class of choice for the vast majority of the population, again not working favourably for society.

feb21 · 17/02/2022 07:46

Age old problem. In the hospital where i work there are very few female surgeons compared to female. The women couldn't do those hours with small children.

Can I ask how surgeons work? I watched the BBC documentary about St Mary's in Paddington. There was trauma surgery planned but the previous operation overran and the surgeon said they wouldn't let them start at 3pm.

Presumably emergency surgery happens 24 hours? And that's the bit that's hard to manage? Rather than the surgeon's elective list which I'm guessing is easier to work around? Or is it to do with the extra training needed to be a surgeon?

It's always interested me as 95% of surgeons do seem to be male.

feb21 · 17/02/2022 07:39

M&A seeks to create efficiency savings and synergistic gains. Generally, these look far better on the Excel spreadsheet than they turn out in real life.

If I think about the acquisitions I advised on, some were more value-enhancing than others. But that's far more the fault of the company than the advisers. I'd say 95% of acquisitions were identified by the client (despite more acquisition search presentations than I care to admit to). Yes, we'd help them value the company, project manage the transaction and do the financial modelling (based on their numbers). But the post-integration piece is the clients' alone.

I can think of plenty of examples where we advised clients not to undertake corporate transactions. One company wanted to IPO and invited a number of investment banks to present to them on strategic options. We didn't believe they should and gave a very honest presentation. It went down like a lead balloon. They did float, but a decade later.

There were also more aborted than completed transactions. Our retainer was tiny in comparison to our final value fee. Several disposal processes were stopped when the client wasn't happy with the level of offers. We agreed. Yes, everyone wants their fees but having integrity and putting your client first is more important for your reputation long-term.

malificent7 · 17/02/2022 07:37

I love a good clap me! i don't even work NHS...i work private so at least I don't have the 60 hour week my friend doing the same job in the nhs had the other week.

malificent7 · 17/02/2022 07:35

I do think it takes a certain personality type to become a banker. Correct me if i'm wrong, but it seems quite a testosterone fuelled culture with long hours which lends itself more to men than women with families. Age old problem. In the hospital where i work there are very few female surgeons compared to female. The women couldn't do those hours with small children.

ClariceQuiff · 17/02/2022 07:35

@RedRoseRay Agree 100% with your post. The people who take the fallout from this are usually those on little more than minimum wage.

Alexandra2001 · 17/02/2022 07:35

@malificent7

Please don't be so ungrateful, we all came out and clapped - what more do you want?

Alexandra2001 · 17/02/2022 07:33

Regulation on how the banks make money, pay bonuses and remuneration is very weak, so what they have in fact done is make a rewards environment where they set their own pay and bonuses.

so BOE interest rate is 0.5% try borrowing any money at anywhere near that amount.

But its not just bankers setting their own pay, its vice chancellors of uni's, nhs trust ceo's, council chief's, the ceo's of numerous public bodies.

Director pay of fairly ordinary companies has rocketed in recent years, remuneration committees are just back scratching each other, even when companies make a loss, the directors get a pay rise! and then there are the Golden handshakes when they fail......

the system has been designed to keep the rich richer and the workers poorer or as someone said to me recently "why am i working 40hrs a week to struggle?"

malificent7 · 17/02/2022 07:28

I think the phrase " job satisfaction makes it worthwhile " is the problem here. I work in health and whilst I do love my job and get job satisfaction, job satisfaction not going to pay for my mortgage, energy bills or much needed holiday is it?
I do not begrudge bankers a high wage as they work so hard. What i do begrudge is the government relying on " kind" people doing caring jobs and taking the piss as they are too kind to ask for more( or leave to become bankers). Many ARE leaving due to poor pay and conditions btw..the kindness of our hearts does not pay the bills.

feb21 · 17/02/2022 07:26

TheReluctantPhoenix

I agree with your comments. But many posts lump retail and investment banks together and they are quite different.

I made the distinction only in response to the "we paid for your bonuses" argument. No, tax payers didn't; my corporate finance firm was advisory only. Absolutely, clients may have used banks for debt raising. And a financial services crash would have affected all firms. But my colleagues getting big bonuses for bringing in even bigger advisory fees is not funded by taxpayers. The individual that received the highest bonus had branched out into restructuring, it wasn't even M&A.

Anyway, I digress. Some occupations may be underpaid. But we know that when we make our career choices. Nursing and teaching are very worthy professions, but not highly paid. I went into investment banking as it's very lucrative. It's not a secret. It's not "piss easy" either.

TheReluctantPhoenix · 17/02/2022 07:21

@Giraffesandbottoms,

Ok, let’s look at your example. Someone buys the 90 mio company for 120mio. They have just lost 30mio. No value has been created. And this is before bankers and lawyers have take.man, say, 5 mio in fees, another loss to both companies.

M&A seeks to create efficiency savings and synergistic gains. Generally, these look far better on the Excel spreadsheet than they turn out in real life.

For real research, I linked to an FT article (above) and can show you far more if you are interested.

megaz · 17/02/2022 07:21

@ButterMeTimbers

YANBU and that illustration photo is fucking depressing.

99% white men. What's with that?

How racist! The post has nothing to do with race and you decide to mention the colour of their skin! Shame on you, you racist.
Eucalyptusbee · 17/02/2022 07:19

YABU

"Banking " encompasses a massive spectrum of jobs most of which are gruelling and stressful. Feel free to apply if its thar "piss easy"

The gravy train lawyers and quangos and bug accountantcy firms are the ones you should be focusing your attention on

Oblomov22 · 17/02/2022 07:18

"I wasn't even allowed to return to my desk to collect my handbag." Sad

Giraffesandbottoms · 17/02/2022 07:17

@TheReluctantPhoenix

Btw I strongly
Agree many areas of finance create fuck all and move money around. This isn’t one of them.

Giraffesandbottoms · 17/02/2022 07:16

@TheReluctantPhoenix

Of course they create value. They are selling company A. They need to do the work to value it correctly, but then they need to package and sell it attractively at a profit, usually involve bidding. If you sell a 90m company for 120m, you have created 30m. Just like selling a 1m house for 1.3m creates 3m. 25m or whatever goes to the company A, 5m goes to the bank. 5m has been made for the bank. Why wouldn’t the people involved in these deals personally get some of what is essentially sales commission?

TheReluctantPhoenix · 17/02/2022 07:13

@feb21,

RBS was retail in name, investment in nature. It had also just bought ABN Amro in one of the most scandalous mergers in history, where 90% of retail investors voted against the merger (but it went ahead, nodded on by the tame institutional shareholders).

There is no meaningful distinction between retail and investment banking in the uk. In addition, investment banks are financed by retail banks.

Of course investment banks were bailed out, both directly and indirectly.

Oblomov22 · 17/02/2022 07:13

Interesting. I couldn't do it, the long hours, the stress.

dottiedodah · 17/02/2022 07:13

I think singling out one group and being annoyed about it is just being envious for the big bonuses offered.the whole job is very stressful and tiring.its certainly not piss easy! Nurses and doctors should obv get more cash.however they don't make money for the country.job satisfaction makes it worthwhile for them.lots of people make money not just bankers .sir alan sugar had a 4 million pound bonus .many people who are in media jobs and so on

FindingMeno · 17/02/2022 07:12

It all makes me sick to my core.

TheReluctantPhoenix · 17/02/2022 07:09

@Giraffesandbottoms,

It generally isn’t value created, sorry, it is value taxed by the banks from the shareholders of the merging companies (see my post above).

Don’t be bamboozled by the hype. Ask yourself a simple question. Does a share price generally go up or down when it bids for another company.

As a shareholder, a company I own being involved in an equal merger or making a bid for another company is an event I dread.

feb21 · 17/02/2022 07:03

[quote Blossomtoes]And yet, we're still talking about the government bailing out U.K. investment banks. They didn't.

I think you’ll find they did.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2008_United_Kingdom_bank_rescue_package[/quote]
Erm that article clearly states they didn't. Lloyds and RBS had bailouts. Both of which are retail, not investment, banks. There's a big difference.

Giraffesandbottoms · 17/02/2022 07:01

DH works in M&A. For a boutique bank btw, certainly not one “bailed out” by the govt.

Yes, there have been record bonuses, because of the record money generated for the company. He pays essentially 50% of it in tax. That’s a lot of money contributed to society. He works extremely long hours and extremely hard - his bonus doesn’t in any way STOP nurses, teachers etc getting a bonus. He’s not stealing from another pot - it’s value created and actually then paid towards the pot.

TheReluctantPhoenix · 17/02/2022 07:00

@BobbyeinArkansas,

I am not sure, based on the above rambling post, whether you are in a position to critique others’ thinking.

The point is that if you assume every banker is doing a role critical to the good functioning of the economy, what you say hold water.

I would strongly dispute the axiom, however. I would say the finance sector needs to be about 20% of the size it is now to actually support the economy. The other 80% is, effectively, very expensive (to everyone else) financial masturbation.

M&A of large companies, one of the biggest payers, has been generally shown to be value destructive.

amp.ft.com/content/4ed717f2-df96-11e9-b8e0-026e07cbe5b4

As for why shareholders vote to approve it, the large pension fund shareholders are run by ex and soon-to-be bankers in a very rewarding revolving door.

Let’s look at the genius traders now. Something like 70% of trading is now algo-driven, where computers are (very cleverly) programmed to extract tiny bits of value from short term moves in the market or discrepancies between the price of the same shares on different exchanges. ‘Flash Boys’ by Michael Lewis is a fascinating read on one form of alto trading and why it is a tax on other players in the market (I.e your and my pension).

To bring things bang up-to-date, another very lucrative practice is block trading, where large players are allowed to trade large blocks of shares without letting anyone else know until we’ll after the fact. Illegal sharing of this information is now being investigated.

amp.ft.com/content/da23c81e-b6cd-4026-9eef-ff9116dddd8e

I could go on, and on….,,and on.

The idea that bankers are some kind of financial alchemists creating money out of screens and genius has been well and truly debunked.

Banks know this, which is why they employ ex politicians on ludicrous salaries (Tony Blair inter alia), give massive political donations, and are major sponsors of sport. No company decides to hedge their interest rate risk with JP Morgan (for example) because they have seen them on a bill board at the Super Bowl.

Banks do all the above to make sure that it is in no one’s interest to upset the gravy train.

It is a bubble but, as anyone who has ever traded knows, you cannot bet against the bubble as they always go on longer and further than anyone imagines. Does not stop a bubble being a bubble.

Finance is necessary. We need bankers. However, we have reached the point where the finance tail is wagging the real economy dog.