Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to wonder why some winter sports are funded?

37 replies

DDfollowed · 16/02/2022 12:25

I love watching sport but I cannot work out why British athletes in minority sports are funded to compete. We spend millions sending a handful of people to the winter Olympics to finish in the teen positions and I genuinely can't work out why, the majority of children are not in a position to be inspired to become a winter sport athlete. Is it just funding a small number of people to live their dreams when it doesn't pay them enough (via prize or sponsorship) to support themselves? Would the money be better spent on getting more people active?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Downtownmarjoriebrown · 17/02/2022 00:07

@MorningStarling

There's more point in funding ski-jumping or bobsleigh than dozens of other sports (and "sports") like gymnastics or pole vaulting or the triple jump. At least winter sports are interesting, I mean any idiot can ride a bike round and round in circles or thrown an unnecessarily heavy object a short distance.

Generally, a sport isn't a sport unless people die doing it. Without risk and danger it's just a game.

I don't know if I'm misinterpreting your inverted commas around sport, but are you seriously suggesting gymnastics isn't a proper sport? You watched Simone Biles right?! Why does it make more sense to fund bobsleigh?
itwasntaparty · 16/02/2022 19:53

I'm in the Se and there's a full size curling rink just down the road

ErrolTheDragon · 16/02/2022 19:49

Well, yes, there's some truth in that. But that's why funding is necessary- facilities/kit sufficient for entry level, so many kids can try various sports (generally with volunteer instructors and helpers) and then subsequent targeted funding (larger sums per head but for far fewer people) to support the ones with the dedication and talent to go further.

TheMullerLightOwl · 16/02/2022 19:41

@DDfollowed

Not for that reason *@ErrolTheDragon* - it is an elitist activity regardless of where you do it. Not many people can sail as a hobby therefore it's reasonable to suggest that there are limited opportunities for Joe Bloggs to get to an elite level. Funding doesn't change that.
I would argue that pretty much all Olympic sports are elitist activities. In order to get to that level of most sports, you have to have some serious funding behind you for things like coaching, clothing/costumes, equipment. Often families will sacrifice income so one parent is always around to take children to and from training/competitions etc.
balalake · 16/02/2022 19:36

If it's mostly lottery funding then we have a choice not to contribute if the distribution of the money you feel is not the best.

ErrolTheDragon · 16/02/2022 19:33

@DDfollowed

Not for that reason *@ErrolTheDragon* - it is an elitist activity regardless of where you do it. Not many people can sail as a hobby therefore it's reasonable to suggest that there are limited opportunities for Joe Bloggs to get to an elite level. Funding doesn't change that.
The club I used to belong to up on the pennine moors couldn't by any stretch of the imagination be called 'elitist'.
DDfollowed · 16/02/2022 19:19

Not for that reason @ErrolTheDragon - it is an elitist activity regardless of where you do it. Not many people can sail as a hobby therefore it's reasonable to suggest that there are limited opportunities for Joe Bloggs to get to an elite level. Funding doesn't change that.

OP posts:
ErrolTheDragon · 16/02/2022 19:05

@DDfollowed

I think sailing is another one that shouldn't necessarily be funded either for the reasons you state *@CaptainMerica*. I also don't know how you've inferred that I said we shouldn't fund curling because it's mostly played in Scotland! I've agreed with a PP that it would be popular if more available as it's very inclusive.
Sailing is available all over the country, on lakes, reservoirs and rivers. It's not just a coastal activity.ConfusedHmm
DDfollowed · 16/02/2022 18:52

I think sailing is another one that shouldn't necessarily be funded either for the reasons you state @CaptainMerica. I also don't know how you've inferred that I said we shouldn't fund curling because it's mostly played in Scotland! I've agreed with a PP that it would be popular if more available as it's very inclusive.

OP posts:
Acheyknees · 16/02/2022 16:06

I don't think the skeleton 6 million is very good value for money. We have no proper track/runs and there will never be mass participation. The UK would never be able to host any skeleton competition. I would imagine the vast majority of that money is spent on supporting athletes to train in foreign countries. And I don't see a benefit in that.

bluechinavase · 16/02/2022 15:40

There is no reason that curling should not be available in ice rinks all over the country. The reason it remains popular in Scotland is that once upon a time, back when you were guaranteed cold winters, there were over 2000 curling rinks around the place so it remains in living memory that it was something that people did. Even where I live, there were three outdoor rinks within one mile of my house. But no curling takes place outside now (even when it is cold enough to freeze lochs, health and safety issues take precedent). It's all held indoors in rinks that are usually shared with other ice sports. Lobby your local rink to set aside an hour or two a week to allow curling.

ErrolTheDragon · 16/02/2022 15:29

Maybe there's an opportunity waiting for an entrepreneur in Exeter or Bristol or some random place near a motorway/major road in the south west?

MummKnowsBest · 16/02/2022 14:46

Funding for GB Olympic sports seems to follow past Olympic successes. Some sports delivered in Tokyo (Equestrian £12m -5 medals incl. 2 golds); others didn’t (Hockey £12m - 1 bronze).

CaptainMerica · 16/02/2022 14:16

[quote DDfollowed]@CaptainMerica I'm not sure what I've said to give you the impression I wasn't aware Scotland is in the UK Hmm

A couple of curling rinks in the UK outside Scotland does not make it an accessible sport for 60m people to give it a go.

It just seems that in this day and age the lottery system enables a few select people to pursue their sporting ambitions, I don't think there is a huge amount of value in spending £30m for mediocre results in most winter sports.[/quote]
Saying that we shouldn't fund curling because it's only.popular in Scotland is like saying we shouldn't fund sailing because lots of people don't live anywhere near the coast.

Don't get me wrong, most sport is completely elitist and winter sports on particular has lots of examples where the medal goes to the person with the most money to spend.

However, the examples you used - snowboarding and ice-ring based sports - happen to be the sports that I am most exposed to in winter. E.g. I, and lots of people I know, take DC ice skating, go snowboarding, watch/play curling, etc. So I don't see why they are less deserving than any other sport.

Hillarious · 16/02/2022 14:05

Curling deserves every penny. It's so good to watch. Been late for work too many times recently!!

ErrolTheDragon · 16/02/2022 13:53

I just looked at the curling centre quite near me. To the best of my knowledge, it's an entirely commercial venture. It says it's completely wheelchair-friendly so perhaps it's a sport which should be encouraged and supported for accessibility reasons. It seems like a much more practical proposition to support than outdoors winter sports such as skiing.

DDfollowed · 16/02/2022 13:49

@CaptainMerica I'm not sure what I've said to give you the impression I wasn't aware Scotland is in the UK Hmm

A couple of curling rinks in the UK outside Scotland does not make it an accessible sport for 60m people to give it a go.

It just seems that in this day and age the lottery system enables a few select people to pursue their sporting ambitions, I don't think there is a huge amount of value in spending £30m for mediocre results in most winter sports.

OP posts:
randomsabreuse · 16/02/2022 13:47

The more sports people are aware of the more likely it is that people will find their niche and the motivation to exercise and get fitter for the sake of that sport.

I don't enjoy any of the mainstream sports or the classic school team sports, found my niche in fencing and have become generally more active as a result...

Most sports (other than bobsleigh and skeleton) have a grassroots/amateur scene which help support the performance programmes, even if relatively small.

I think this Olympics is tougher than most because of the impacts of the lockdowns and travel restrictions - so our athletes have had a tougher time training than in a normal Olympic cycle. Some of it comes down to "luck" or tiny mistakes - Dave Ryding was in contention on the first run until he made a mistake - bigger names than him had their issues - Shiffrin of the USA as well as members of the "big" teams.

There's no climate based reason we don't do well at short track, ice hockey or figure skating - investment in facilities would work long term, but most sports funding is pretty short term...

RoseslnTheHospital · 16/02/2022 13:46

Yeah. I'm not suggesting that there's widespread availability of curling in England, Wales. NI. Just that it isn't only Scotland where you can try curling.

Apparently floor curling is a thing, doesn't require ice!

MorningStarling · 16/02/2022 13:45

There's more point in funding ski-jumping or bobsleigh than dozens of other sports (and "sports") like gymnastics or pole vaulting or the triple jump. At least winter sports are interesting, I mean any idiot can ride a bike round and round in circles or thrown an unnecessarily heavy object a short distance.

Generally, a sport isn't a sport unless people die doing it. Without risk and danger it's just a game.

ClaudiaWankleman · 16/02/2022 13:44

They have a cultural value. Not everything has to be profitable or tangible.

AChocolateOrangeaday · 16/02/2022 13:39

Apparently Eddie the Eagle lived in a mental hospital to save money to achieve his dream

Penvelopey · 16/02/2022 13:36

Why do we fund anything like arts sports etc. Because we value it.

popcorndiva · 16/02/2022 13:34

We are talking about England only having 3 rinks. Then if you want to play against other teams it usually involves travelling to Scotland.

I would give it a go but the nearest rink is 2 hours away

ItsSnowJokes · 16/02/2022 13:34

I have looked for curling and here are the nearest centres to me. That cuts out a fast majority of the south central and south west of England. 102 miles to the nearest one! My 5 year old loves watching curling and would love to give it a go (to be honest I think it's the shoes that slide on the ice) but not when it's so far away.

We don't have any ice rinks near us either. Nearest one is about 50 miles away.

to wonder why some winter sports are funded?