Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Booking a taxi for 14yo daughter to get home from a club

158 replies

JakeDad · 16/02/2022 10:17

I thought this was really simple and obvious but was surprised at the reactions, including from my daughter.

She's comfortable getting trains and buses on her own when needed, which happens regularly being in a rural setting, but the car is in for repair and I cannot get her home from a club later when the buses have stopped running at 6pm.

So I was going to book a taxi like I sometimes do for her older brother and with a trusted firm I've used for years.

But she said she was scared and decided to miss the club entirely.

Am I being unreasonable and am way off base with the expectations of an otherwise independent, smart, capable teen?

OP posts:
catscatscatseverywhere · 16/02/2022 13:15

@JakeDad

UPDATED INFO

In light of some of the suggestions on the thread thanks folks! I've checked with the taxi firm I use, and have found out that as well as being a trusted local well-established family-run business (which feels nice but doesn't necessarily prove much more than my own experience of them), they also:

  • are DBS checked
  • offer female drivers on request
  • many drivers old extended licences to do county council work too

So, these are some useful elements I can look at if the situation arises and again, and no doubt will chat with my daughter about all of this to see what she thinks along the way.

Thanks also to those who've offered insights, supportive comments, helpful advice, and clarified areas I hadn't thought of. Makes it worth asking on a forum in the first place, which sort of seems the point :)

Female driver is very good option. I would use one if I could. Only once I had lady driver. Rest of the time men talking to me :/
BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 16/02/2022 13:14

And which have multiple people on, space to move away from creeps, options to disembark earlier because you feel less safe, usually CCTV and wifi for added security.

Bbq1 · 16/02/2022 13:13

@BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz

She's 14, not 4. Of course, because a pre booked taxi arriving to collect you is just the same as a random man stopping his car and offering you a lift home...

No one is saying it is.

But they are both cars being driven by strangers

As are buses and trains? Which people apparently feel really safe on.
BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 16/02/2022 13:10

She's 14, not 4. Of course, because a pre booked taxi arriving to collect you is just the same as a random man stopping his car and offering you a lift home...

No one is saying it is.

But they are both cars being driven by strangers

Comefromaway · 16/02/2022 13:08

Walking to and standing at a deserted bus stop or train station is far less safe that being picked up from a safe place by a pre-ordered taxi where you are given the name, car reg and are a regular customer of that firm.

DontWantTheRivalry · 16/02/2022 13:07

No one told me as a kid, it wasn't obvious to me otherwise, and only when someone told me that my remarks were problematic, did I see a perspective I didn't have previously.

Most taxi drivers aren’t ‘kids’ though are they?

They are adult men who generally know the boundaries of what is and what is not acceptable to say to women - especially to vulnerable women who are sitting in their car with a male stranger.

No man who is grown up enough to be a taxi driver needs to told what comments may be problematic. Men are generally not stupid, they are not children and therefore they shouldn’t need to be ‘told’ what is and what isn’t appropriate to say to women.

PigeonLittle · 16/02/2022 13:06

I've been the subject vile sexist comments. I've been leered at, groped in clubs, heard smutty jokes.

That's entirely different to feeling unsafe. The most scared with men is when they have not said any untoward comments.

A lot of women have great instincts for feeling at risk, and it's generally not from stupid drunk or borish men. That's not to say sexist comments etc should be allowed to continue but misogyny often isnt threatening.

Bbq1 · 16/02/2022 13:04

@MorningStarling

I thought you meant nightclub and was a bit WTF?

I'm not surprised she's reluctant to take a taxi though, we live in a world where strangers are dangerous and she's probably been brought up being told that there's no way in hell she should get in a car with a stranger, which is what the taxi driver would be.

She's 14, not 4. Of course, because a pre booked taxi arriving to collect you is just the same as a random man stopping his car and offering you a lift home...
sillyrubberduck · 16/02/2022 13:03

I would have been uncomfortable even with my 14 year old DS getting in a taxi with an unknown man. I feel uncomfortable myself and i am a grown up woman. It may be irrational but I cannot help the way I feel.

JakeDad · 16/02/2022 13:02

UPDATED INFO

In light of some of the suggestions on the thread thanks folks! I've checked with the taxi firm I use, and have found out that as well as being a trusted local well-established family-run business (which feels nice but doesn't necessarily prove much more than my own experience of them), they also:

  • are DBS checked
  • offer female drivers on request
  • many drivers old extended licences to do county council work too

So, these are some useful elements I can look at if the situation arises and again, and no doubt will chat with my daughter about all of this to see what she thinks along the way.

Thanks also to those who've offered insights, supportive comments, helpful advice, and clarified areas I hadn't thought of. Makes it worth asking on a forum in the first place, which sort of seems the point :)

OP posts:
MuffinStrops · 16/02/2022 13:00

I don’t feel comfortable on my own on taxis either. I certainly wouldn’t put a 14 year old girl in one.

Comefromaway · 16/02/2022 12:58

The OP wasn't talking about Uber though. I would never use Uber.

Bbq1 · 16/02/2022 12:58

I have to take a taxi 5 times a week minimum. When my ds was 13 he would take a short taxi ride from our house to his guitar lesson and I tracked it on the taxi app. Thing to remember is that 99.99% of taxi drivers are not rapists, murderers or in the habit of abducting passengers.

catscatscatseverywhere · 16/02/2022 12:57

After recent stories of sexual abuse by uber etc. drivers, no. No way I would book a taxi for my young daughter. In fact, my husband got so scared of these stories, that he said he will never ever ask me to book uber from work, when he takes a car. He will plan things around to pick me up always.

Comefromaway · 16/02/2022 12:57

@Starcrossed2

This is the opposite for me. My df is a taxi driver and I know he wouldn't harm a hair on anyones head. That, and the fact that all licenced drivers have to have an enhanced dbs would make me think it's one of the safer forms of transport. I know there are always outliers but generally I think I'd prefer to be in a taxi than on a train solely based on how safe I feel.
well quite, dd has been assaulted on a train and despite cctv the police were unable to trace anyone.

Taxis are very traceable and she has always felt perfectly safe in them.

JakeDad · 16/02/2022 12:56

@Starcrossed2

This is the opposite for me. My df is a taxi driver and I know he wouldn't harm a hair on anyones head. That, and the fact that all licenced drivers have to have an enhanced dbs would make me think it's one of the safer forms of transport. I know there are always outliers but generally I think I'd prefer to be in a taxi than on a train solely based on how safe I feel.
Yes, this was my thinking.
OP posts:
Starcrossed2 · 16/02/2022 12:56

This is the opposite for me. My df is a taxi driver and I know he wouldn't harm a hair on anyones head. That, and the fact that all licenced drivers have to have an enhanced dbs would make me think it's one of the safer forms of transport. I know there are always outliers but generally I think I'd prefer to be in a taxi than on a train solely based on how safe I feel.

Comefromaway · 16/02/2022 12:52

@onedayoranother

I flew internationally, caught a train then a taxi at 14 - I looked older than my years and the taxi driver was a bit friendly, asking if I was heading back to uni (I had taken the train to Cambridge) etc. I was wise enough not to engage too much - it's one thing a driver making conversation with someone he thinks is 18+ but I didn't want him to know I was only 14. My main issue when I order a cab is that you can't recognise it - they aren't standing there with a big sign with your name on it. I'm always a bit wary going up to an unmarked parked car and peering in to ask, snd I can readily see a 14 year old asking 'are you a taxi for X' and getting in to any old car. If the taxi was well marked as one that's different, but it can still be nerve wracking. Your daughter made a decision and it was a good one for her.
You get a text with the car registration number on these days and can follow the car on a tracking app.
JakeDad · 16/02/2022 12:43

@DontWantTheRivalry

The specific point a few people have raised is that men whether they know it or not can often engage in conversation which is inappropriate or unpleasant, feels threatening, and so on... So, that may be something to be avoided, in any case.

They do know it.

No, not always. I can give you an absolutely concrete example. Back when I was a young adult, I'd talk about something with literally no clue it was going to be upsetting and it was only by the person telling me I was wrong and why, that I learned what my mistake was.

That's not to say the majority are innocent or naïve -- but it highlights the usefulness in flagging it up. No one told me as a kid, it wasn't obvious to me otherwise, and only when someone told me that my remarks were problematic, did I see a perspective I didn't have previously.

I think spreading the understanding and demanding of men that they gain such perspectives and expect them to call out their male peers too is ultimately constructive for a better society as a whole.

OP posts:
onedayoranother · 16/02/2022 12:41

I flew internationally, caught a train then a taxi at 14 - I looked older than my years and the taxi driver was a bit friendly, asking if I was heading back to uni (I had taken the train to Cambridge) etc. I was wise enough not to engage too much - it's one thing a driver making conversation with someone he thinks is 18+ but I didn't want him to know I was only 14.
My main issue when I order a cab is that you can't recognise it - they aren't standing there with a big sign with your name on it. I'm always a bit wary going up to an unmarked parked car and peering in to ask, snd I can readily see a 14 year old asking 'are you a taxi for X' and getting in to any old car. If the taxi was well marked as one that's different, but it can still be nerve wracking.
Your daughter made a decision and it was a good one for her.

RoomOfRequirement · 16/02/2022 12:40

I'm confused about what being smart, Independent or capable has to do with stopping yourself from being raped when in an enclosed space with a male stranger, but maybe that's just me.

In fact, I'd say her reluctance is proof of her intelligence more than anything.

JakeDad · 16/02/2022 12:39

@Killermontstreet

I can understand your daughter's fears - as a grown woman I still only use taxis alone when I absolutely have to.

Slight derail possibly, but evidence here of how many adults wilfully misunderstand the fears that women have getting into cars driven by unknown men: www.heraldscotland.com/news/17631254.glasgow-city-council-blocks-plans-launch-female-only-taxi-service/

Great move there Glasgow City Council - surely a misunderstanding of the equality act.

Derail about taxis, not trains... haha...

Interesting story -- seems like they really are wrong on the legislation, though, as you say. I can't easily find any details of what happened afterwards. I'm sure I know of other apps that are female-only, be it taxi or other service, so I'd have thought it would be possible for it to be overturned eventually.

Her lawyer Stephen McCaffrey said he disputed conditions would be breached by the app, adding councillors disliked the concept itself. “I have appeared before many committees over the last ten years throughout the UK. The hearing this morning was the most hostile and dismissive I have ever been before.”

There was a petition started, but it seems to have gone quiet since, and discussion on mumsnet at the time, too.

OP posts:
BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 16/02/2022 12:35

@DontWantTheRivalry

The specific point a few people have raised is that men whether they know it or not can often engage in conversation which is inappropriate or unpleasant, feels threatening, and so on... So, that may be something to be avoided, in any case.

They do know it.

And if they dont know it then they don't have the mental capacity to be behind the wheel of a car.
dworky · 16/02/2022 12:34

I'd far rather use a bus, train or even walk than get a cab because my social anxiety baulks at the one on one space.

Is it possible she has similar issues?

DontWantTheRivalry · 16/02/2022 12:33

The specific point a few people have raised is that men whether they know it or not can often engage in conversation which is inappropriate or unpleasant, feels threatening, and so on... So, that may be something to be avoided, in any case.

They do know it.