Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Booking a taxi for 14yo daughter to get home from a club

158 replies

JakeDad · 16/02/2022 10:17

I thought this was really simple and obvious but was surprised at the reactions, including from my daughter.

She's comfortable getting trains and buses on her own when needed, which happens regularly being in a rural setting, but the car is in for repair and I cannot get her home from a club later when the buses have stopped running at 6pm.

So I was going to book a taxi like I sometimes do for her older brother and with a trusted firm I've used for years.

But she said she was scared and decided to miss the club entirely.

Am I being unreasonable and am way off base with the expectations of an otherwise independent, smart, capable teen?

OP posts:
KatieB55 · 16/02/2022 14:04

Lots of taxis do school runs and drivers are DBS checked. At 14 I travelled across the world on my own (no mobile phone) as my parents lived abroad with forces. There were things I didn't like but I had to get on with it and it made me very independent and resilient.

saleorbouy · 16/02/2022 14:00

As a principle from travelling world wide I always take a picture of the cab plates and driver ID when possible to have a record, in case.

saleorbouy · 16/02/2022 13:58

Many taxi firms do school runs for the councils so can't see the issue regarding her safety.
Of course if she is not comfortable or confident to do it on her own then that separate issue.
Can you find out if there's a female driver in the fleet and get a driver name for her before the pickup.?

Juliauns91 · 16/02/2022 13:56

It completely depends on the "taxi".
If it was a private hire firm I knew well, I would not worry at all. You get to know all the drivers.

Uber - never.

However, if your daughter isn't happy with it, then it's no good.

TheOccupier · 16/02/2022 13:55

Teenagers are very grown up in some ways and not at all in others, especially now when they have spent so long stuck at home. I think it was fine for you to make the suggestion but at 14, I wouldn't push it if she said no thanks. Sounds like you handled it fine.

I am astounded by the number of adult women who won't use taxis though - really?

northernsquirrel · 16/02/2022 13:54

Good for her for making the choice and at least you supported her and didn't bully her into it or made her feel like she was 'making a fuss'. I wouldn't have been able to confidently make that choice at her age.

Oh God, the thought of having to sit in the back of a car with a stranger at that age feeling vulnerable and potentially trapped. Awful!

Comefromaway · 16/02/2022 13:49

For those saying that CCTV makes you safer, this is not true, there are tonnes of CCTV footage of women being harassed or assaulted. Much CCTV is unmanned and only looked at once a crime has been committed, or wiped quickly anyway. It doesn't appear to deter criminality otherwise the most CCTV'd nation in the world, the UK, wouldn't have so much violent crime!

Well quite.

Dd was groped on a train. She had no signal at the time so couldn't text the BTP number and the man got off at the next stop. The police told her there was no point even reviewing the CCTV because they would not be able to identify him.

OnwardsAndSideways1 · 16/02/2022 13:47

I mean, my teen girls take buses and trains, I've given them guidance to do when it all goes wrong, but none of it is 'buses and trains have conductors and CCTV and so that's far safer than a taxi'. You need to be alert and prepared to act in ANY method of transport.

JakeDad · 16/02/2022 13:45

@Comefromaway

Walking to and standing at a deserted bus stop or train station is far less safe that being picked up from a safe place by a pre-ordered taxi where you are given the name, car reg and are a regular customer of that firm.
Exactly. Plus numerous other factors.

There are lots of horrible risks out there, and I do everything I can to help my kids navigate them as safely as possible and to have as full and as actualised a life as possible.

OP posts:
OnwardsAndSideways1 · 16/02/2022 13:45

For those saying that CCTV makes you safer, this is not true, there are tonnes of CCTV footage of women being harassed or assaulted. Much CCTV is unmanned and only looked at once a crime has been committed, or wiped quickly anyway. It doesn't appear to deter criminality otherwise the most CCTV'd nation in the world, the UK, wouldn't have so much violent crime!

In a taxi, you have the knowledge of who the person is driving (the company will disclose this, the car number), the registering of the call, the taxi number which they have to display and details of who to call if you want to report them. I don't see how that's more dangerous than CCTV where no-one is watching and even if they were, they can't see verbal harassment or intervene.

As for those saying there's a conductor, one on a whole train and many have none! Buses don't have conductors, they have one driver and I don't know what you think he or she going to do to save you if you get into difficulties on the top of a bus, but you could move to sit near them which I usually do these days.

I just wonder if some people on here have actually been on a bus lately, there are a lot of troubled people around in public spaces, buses, trains, public parks, probably worsened by the pandemic. Really weird you find these to be safe spaces IMO.

OnwardsAndSideways1 · 16/02/2022 13:40

I'm surprised at people saying public transport is much safer. I've had several incidents on public transport, called names, had to move as someone was so agitated, people inappropriately chatting. I'd much rather get in a taxi and then be busy, especially as in our city, the registered taxis usually have a barrier/the person isn't that chatty. My eldest came home age 12 from a bus ride and a person had called the whole bus to pray with him!

If you want to see all life, then get on a bus or a train. You can't easily move carriage or get off a bus if someone is already interested/targetting you. I don't think taxis are more risky than that, and waiting at bus stops and at stations can be quite awful as well.

I think it's the one on one aspect of it that a lot of teens don't like which is fair enough, but making out that taxis are unsafe and buses/trains are safe as houses, well, it just doesn't remotely chime with my experience of 100's of journeys in multiple cities all over the UK.

MrsJBaptiste · 16/02/2022 13:37

The vast majority of taxi drivers may be fine, but what happens if you get one that isn't? Not only are you trapped in a car with them alone, they also know where you live.

But you can't live lift thinking "what would happen if..." that's no way to live. You have to think "it won't happen to me" because chances are, it won't.

I'm surprised there are so few people on this thread that don't mind getting a taxi on their own. Maybe I'm naive in going walking on my own, running in the dark, waiting for buses at night or getting a taxi - I don't know but I know you have to presume you'll be fine in most situations as otherwise it makes carrying on with day to day tasks quite difficult.

EveningOverRooftops · 16/02/2022 13:34

Back when I was a teen me and my friend got a taxi home and the driver had that I’ve that we gave told him we needed the other side of the road where a path lead to the roads behind, we went though the path, down the road and hid in someone’s front garden to see the driver driving down the road I presume looking for us.

We didn’t get taxis after that unless with a bloke.

Even now I’m apprehensive with some taxis but I do use the same firm now with the same regular drivers and my ap tracks our vehicle and the number plate and vehicle description is text to me etc.

It’s not perfect but it’s as close as I can get to safe.

Comefromaway · 16/02/2022 13:30

You could say the same about the piano teacher, or the person leading the club etc etc. A random passenger on a train or at the bus stop is untraceable on the whole. A taxi driver there are records, registration numbers etc etc. Makes it much less likely they will do anything untoward.

Seeline · 16/02/2022 13:28

DBS checks just mean the person hasn't been caught doing anything wrong....

Comefromaway · 16/02/2022 13:27

Why would I do that? I cannot comprehend what people have got against taxis. I'm wondering if those thinking they are so bad have actually booked on in recent years with all the things in place like DBS certs and tracking apps.

I'm pretty certain that dd's school would not have put kids in taxis on a regular basis if they were that unsafe.

My local train station on the other hand is unmanned, lonely, in a rough part of town and I would not want dd walking back from there alone.

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 16/02/2022 13:26

@Comefromaway

Turn it around, Am I lying, is my dd lying when she was groped on a train and couldn't get away.
Of course you're not lying.

But that doesn't change the fact that many people feel more unsafe in taxis.

Embracelife · 16/02/2022 13:25

Calln taxi firms for female drivers

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 16/02/2022 13:24

@Comefromaway

Turn it around, Am I lying, is my dd lying when she was groped on a train and couldn't get away.
No one is saying trains and buses are risk free and 100% safe just that for some taxis present a greater risk and make them feel even less safe

It's almost like you are being deliberately obtuse.

Pazuzu · 16/02/2022 13:23

@PigeonLittle

As a man you cant for a second have any comprehension about the vulnerability of a 14 year old girl.
Not from first hand experience no, but it's not a wild leap of imagination to know that some of my fellow men are absolute scumbags.

I won't be letting DS1 get a taxi on his own when he turns 14 in a few years time. If I can possibly help it neither will DW anytime soon.

I'm not criticizing anyone else's choice. You may know the driver(s) well due to them doing school runs etc, but a random driver? Hell no.

They're my responsibility and that's it.

Comefromaway · 16/02/2022 13:20

Turn it around, Am I lying, is my dd lying when she was groped on a train and couldn't get away.

Comefromaway · 16/02/2022 13:20

Its perception isn't it

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 16/02/2022 13:19

Nope. All of those things will not make you safer. Buses and trains I would say are far less safe

That might be true of you but multiple people on this thread have said they feel safer on these modes of transport than solo in a taxi. Are they all lying?

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 16/02/2022 13:18

As are buses and trains? Which people apparently feel really safe on.

They're not remotely the same.

Buses and trains are public spaces with CCTV, multiple occupants and the chance/space to move. You can also speak to other people or the guard/driver for help if you're scared or worried, or you can get off at an earlier stop and ring for help, or go to a public place like a shop and ring someone.

You can't do that when you're trapped in a taxi on your own with nobody around to help you.

A taxi driver also knows where you live which adds to the danger (or perceived danger) - a bus driver or train driver doesn't know that.

Comefromaway · 16/02/2022 13:17

@BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz

And which have multiple people on, space to move away from creeps, options to disembark earlier because you feel less safe, usually CCTV and wifi for added security.
Nope. All of those things will not make you safer. Buses and trains I would say are far less safe.