Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Booking a taxi for 14yo daughter to get home from a club

158 replies

JakeDad · 16/02/2022 10:17

I thought this was really simple and obvious but was surprised at the reactions, including from my daughter.

She's comfortable getting trains and buses on her own when needed, which happens regularly being in a rural setting, but the car is in for repair and I cannot get her home from a club later when the buses have stopped running at 6pm.

So I was going to book a taxi like I sometimes do for her older brother and with a trusted firm I've used for years.

But she said she was scared and decided to miss the club entirely.

Am I being unreasonable and am way off base with the expectations of an otherwise independent, smart, capable teen?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
thisplaceisweird · 10/03/2022 11:39

@PizzaPizza56

I'm in my 30s, female and in the UK and I've never got in a taxi by myself, feels like far too vulnerable a situation and too hard to get myself out of if I felt unsafe. No problem with trains, buses etc by myself as it's more public.
This is quite precious. Never got in a taxi alone?
MiniCooper15 · 10/03/2022 11:33

[quote LittleGwyneth]@Triffid1 Did it not occur to you to put headphones in? Or ask for the radio on? Or to say you were tired and didn't feel like talking? Or that you needed to get on with a work email?

Avoiding a useful form of transport because you think the person driving might be sexist feels like an enormous overreaction. This is why I'm so concerned about raising resilient children.[/quote]
Sexism and Racism make me really uncomfortable even now as a grown woman with teenage kids. When I was 16 I had a Saturday job in a shop and made friends with 17 and 18yr olds from different 6th forms went to a few parties and occasionally shared a taxi home I hated being dropped off last as inevitably the middle aged usually white man would start to hit on me.
Lots of them mentioned they liked black girls or they had never dated a black girl it was so creepy and incredibly intimidating, I looked around 12-13 it didn't seem to bother them in the slightest. I completely understand your daughter not wanting to get a taxi alone.

OnwardsAndSideways1 · 17/02/2022 14:50

Great that you found a solution- it's made me think about how my teen girls could also ask for a female taxi driver, or a DBS checked/council driver, these are great ideas!

I think the point is women can be harassed or made to feel self-conscious on trains, on buses, waiting at bus stops/trains, on the Tube, in taxis or walking down the road at night or even in the daytime. Both my girls have been shouted at in public by males just walking along or waiting for a bus.

There isn't a 'safe' method of transport for women and a recent report showed these fears stop women fully going out in London at night.

Given that, some of the ideas on here are helpful!

JakeDad · 16/02/2022 17:42

@lottiegarbanzo

Have read all your updates now OP. Good result!

One thing I notice, is that whenever you've engaged with someone talking about how some men talk to teenage girls in a way that makes them feel uncomfortable, you've turned that conversation back to yourself. 'I used to say naively insensitive things, I was told, learnt, so now I don't.' Ok, that's good but that's you, an apparently pleasant, thoughtful, considerate father of a daughter. Not all men are like that. Some, quite a few actually, are creeps and sleazes.

So yes, many people, like your younger self, might cross a line inadvertently, tactlessly. Many others do so quite deliberately, because they enjoy their power and the girl or woman's discomfort. I don't suppose you've ever engaged in cat-calling for example but some men do.

I just wanted to reflect that back to you - that when we talk about the way many men talk to teenage girls, we're not talking about you. You can't 'logic those bad men away' by telling us that you learnt from your early experiences (and all they need is to be told). TLDR: her experience with other men is not about you.

(Which is scary, because you cannot experience it for her, you will never know about all of it, because a lot of it is too subtle and insidious to identify as 'a bad incident I need to discuss today' and you cannot control it).

Oh yes indeed -- my brief snippets on here don't present a very full picture, I guess, plus I'm not always great at summarising well. The points I made about my own history were just to address an issue that I was worried meant things might not get said. I feel it's worth flagging things up, and the more men and women who speak up, the more it shifts what "normal" is. I live in hope.

In one of them, I did mention that I realised I was likely not representative. Also when discussing things with my daughter, there's no end of debate about the awfulness of men in the general sense, despite good experiences of men she may have encountered. I think she has a good handle on the widespread problems whilst also being able to enjoy the good parts of the world too. It's getting that balance of making the most of things with an enthusiasm whilst also knowing the data, the risks, trusting one's instincts, and so forth.

Amusingly enough, now with a free evening, she'd made plans with a friend at school, got herself a trip out to eat, and arranged a lift home later... so I will have to wait to catch her up on all the mumsnet debate today!

OP posts:
Bbq1 · 16/02/2022 17:28

@Comefromaway

Turn it around, Am I lying, is my dd lying when she was groped on a train and couldn't get away.
This is my point. Women have been sexually assaulted on trains and men physically attacked while the passengers (whom many of the posters on here seem to see as some sort of added protection) have either not been aware or turned away not wanting to get involved for fear of being attacked too. The argument about leaving the train early if feeling threatened isn't good advice - leaving the train then left alone on a dark platform with the potential to being followed off the train. What happens if all the passengers get off the train and you're alone when a drunk man/men get on? There are many more variables that can causes you harm travelling by public transport then in a taxi. I would take a taxi every time.
fairylightsandwaxmelts · 16/02/2022 17:27

[quote LittleGwyneth]@givemepickles I think there's a big crossover in being someone who uses an internet forum to discuss things and being an over thinker / very anxious. But I agree with you, I find the number of adult women who won't take a generally safe form of transport - and who apparently can't tell the driver that they don't feel like chatting - absolutely bonkers. I'm so glad I wasn't raised to be so afraid of the world around me.[/quote]
It's not about being "afraid of the world around you", though. It's about basic risk assessment.

Is a taxi likely to be safe? Yes, it probably is - but for me, the level of discomfort I would feel isn't worth the convenience of the taxi. I would rather walk, drive (and not drink), get a lift or stay home and feel comfortable.

And my choice to do that is just as valid as your choice to take the taxi.

lottiegarbanzo · 16/02/2022 17:14

Have read all your updates now OP. Good result!

One thing I notice, is that whenever you've engaged with someone talking about how some men talk to teenage girls in a way that makes them feel uncomfortable, you've turned that conversation back to yourself. 'I used to say naively insensitive things, I was told, learnt, so now I don't.' Ok, that's good but that's you, an apparently pleasant, thoughtful, considerate father of a daughter. Not all men are like that. Some, quite a few actually, are creeps and sleazes.

So yes, many people, like your younger self, might cross a line inadvertently, tactlessly. Many others do so quite deliberately, because they enjoy their power and the girl or woman's discomfort. I don't suppose you've ever engaged in cat-calling for example but some men do.

I just wanted to reflect that back to you - that when we talk about the way many men talk to teenage girls, we're not talking about you. You can't 'logic those bad men away' by telling us that you learnt from your early experiences (and all they need is to be told). TLDR: her experience with other men is not about you.

(Which is scary, because you cannot experience it for her, you will never know about all of it, because a lot of it is too subtle and insidious to identify as 'a bad incident I need to discuss today' and you cannot control it).

LittleGwyneth · 16/02/2022 15:57

@givemepickles I think there's a big crossover in being someone who uses an internet forum to discuss things and being an over thinker / very anxious. But I agree with you, I find the number of adult women who won't take a generally safe form of transport - and who apparently can't tell the driver that they don't feel like chatting - absolutely bonkers. I'm so glad I wasn't raised to be so afraid of the world around me.

PigeonLittle · 16/02/2022 15:33

9am prebooked taxi from your own home to school is entirely different than late in the evening from a youth centre.

Besides the point, she's not skiving school. She's choosing her comfort over an activity and that seems reasonable to me.

Givemepickles · 16/02/2022 15:12

I am always quite surprised by the level of anxiety on Mumsnet compared to the real world. I got taxis now and then by myself from about 5 years old. The driver collected me from home and dropped me off at school. I assume my mum checked I got there but not sure. Plenty friends did the same.

It never occurred to me to be scared. I really worry that adults are instilling fear in young people, usually fears which are enormously out of proportion to the risk.

Also, the bigotry towards taxi drivers (and the working class in general on Mumsnet) is really something.

Tenpintonpin · 16/02/2022 14:53

@TheOccupier

Teenagers are very grown up in some ways and not at all in others, especially now when they have spent so long stuck at home. I think it was fine for you to make the suggestion but at 14, I wouldn't push it if she said no thanks. Sounds like you handled it fine.

I am astounded by the number of adult women who won't use taxis though - really?

Well, it's not that baffling, is it? I've had numerous unpleasant experiences in taxis (and on buses, and trains). Most recently I had a taxi driver make inappropriate comments to me as soon as I was alone in the cab on the motorway (having dropped friends off). I called my husband, told him exactly where we were and stayed on the phone until I arrived home. I reported the driver to his firm and was told he was "probably just trying to be friendly" and that they would "would have a word with him". To be honest I didn't feel like I was in imminent danger, just uncomfortable and pissed off that I am still having to deal with this crap when I'm nearly 50. I can completely understand why some woman would chose not to use taxis at all, where they have the choice.
gogohm · 16/02/2022 14:47

I'm surprised, my DD's took taxis from around 12, we only had one car so sometimes it was the only option. They are young adults now so not that long ago

impossible · 16/02/2022 14:44

I had a similar situation to this some years ago and asked the cab company if they had a woman driver - they did and that was the driver who picked up my dd.

Perhaps worth investigating in case this happens again.

Bramshott · 16/02/2022 14:40

I've used a taxi to get DD2 (also 14) home from an after school or extra curricular club when there was no other way.

She's fairly familiar with taxis as she gets one to school every day (rural area). She'd rather not take one by herself - I think due to the perceived 'embarrassment' of it not being the norm - but was okay with it as the best of a number of non-ideal options (the other choices being missing the club, or asking the club organiser to put a general shout out to the whole group to see if anyone could give her a lift).

tttigress · 16/02/2022 14:39

E, it's because taxis are more dangerous than buses and trains

Comefromaway · 16/02/2022 14:36

Your choice of course. But my dd would have had to make massive changes to her life including not attending the specialist school she wanted to go to or ever seeing her friends at weekends.

JimmyDurham · 16/02/2022 14:32

@asnippersdream

No way would I book a taxi for a 14 year old on their own. Not a chance.
This.
lottiegarbanzo · 16/02/2022 14:24

At 14 I used buses and trains alone and with friends. Walked outdoors a lot. Didn't have need or money for taxis. As a student I liked black cabs. Have never liked minicabs. (Too small, enclosed, close to the driver, often smell of disgusting air freshener and make me feel sick). Have used them as an adult, can completely understand a teen not wanting to do so.

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 16/02/2022 14:21

I think too many people on mumsnet get each other all worked up about very normal aspects of life.

And too many get worked up about how other people choose to live their lives, even when it has absolutely no impact on them whatsoever.

A 14 year old being took scared to get a taxi is a worry. I took taxis a lot at that age. I take taxis as an adult.

Of course it's not a worry, she's only 14 years old!

If she doesn't feel happy taking a taxi on her own, she shouldn't be forced to do so.

This is like all the mumsnetters who wont answer the door and wont go for a woodland walk because they're too scared. It isnt any way to live.

Again, it's not your life, so why does it matter? Let people live how they want - it really doesn't affect you in any way.

lottiegarbanzo · 16/02/2022 14:17

I don't think this is about independence, so I think that framing of the issue is wrong. I think it is about risk assessment, at both gut and cerebral level.

I think it's about being in a small, enclosed, locked space, with and controlled by one man, upon whose good will we are completely dependent, for an extended period of time.

And we've all heard of John Worboys and we've all met creepy men and men who just make us feel a bit uncomfortable and men we don't really want to chat to, whose innocent, friendly questions might make us feel a bit uncomfortable. Especially when we were teens, without adult confidence and social skills. We might not choose to lock ourselves in a car with such a man, or any strange man, if we can help it.

Especially for women and girls, avoidance is the most effective part of self-defence. We're usually going to lose a fight, we might or might not be able to run away, so avoiding placing ourselves in uncomfortable situations with strange men in the first place is a really sensible, as well as instinctive, thing to do.

Bus and train travel require independence but generally feel safe because there are a lot of 'harmless, ordinary' people around, whose presence is likely to deter some behaviour and who might intervene or witness other behaviour. You can move between train carriages, look for staff, call the police. With a bus or train you can get off at the next stop, if really uncomfortable.

So I think this is a case of risk assessment being very different for men and women. In terms of the risks identified and perhaps, how we identify them (or how we acknowledge that we identify them). Men can be risibly keen on saying they're discussing something 'logically', when they actually mean 'in terms of my own perceptions, prejudices and preferences' i.e. 'what I want here is...(I just think my thoughts are better and more important than everyone else's)'.

IME in life in general, gut feelings are usually an effective and reliable distillation of a lot of conscious and unconscious information. Whereas you can reason your way in or out of anything.

So if you were seeking to present 'rational assessment of the risks' as synonymous with taking account of cerebrally generated information only, or presenting this as a superior form of decision-making to taking reasonable account of 'gut feeling' too, then I'd say you were wrong and failing to acknowledge an important element of how risk assessment works. I say that as someone who values rationality and is blithely dismissive of a lot of 'woo' and all sorts of fears that people build up as stories with little foundation or experience.

In the end, you have to take risks or you'd never get anything done. If my plane falls out of the sky I die. If someone wants to rape and murder me while I'm out running, I die. My coba says both activities are worthwhile (risk is very bad but very unlikely). My coba for one session of an activity vs a likely slightly awkward, maybe uncomfortable ride home, might be different.

If you took the taxis together sometimes, knew the drivers and she could specify which driver she wanted, might that work?

Comefromaway · 16/02/2022 14:17

I couldn't afford taxis at that age to be fair. I got one rarely on the odd occasion where I had to go somewhere on a Sunday when the buses didn't run or late at night when I didn't feel safe waiting at a bus stop.

Similarly dd would get buses or trains when she could but splash out on a taxi when she needed the extra security it afforded.

Rosehugger · 16/02/2022 14:15

My daughters aren't keen to get one on their own (16 and 13) so I haven't pushed it. I'm not sure that I did at their age. Probably a bit older - 17, with friends.

Itsalmostanaccessory · 16/02/2022 14:14

I think too many people on mumsnet get each other all worked up about very normal aspects of life.

A 14 year old being took scared to get a taxi is a worry. I took taxis a lot at that age. I take taxis as an adult.

This is like all the mumsnetters who wont answer the door and wont go for a woodland walk because they're too scared. It isnt any way to live.

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 16/02/2022 14:11

But you can't live lift thinking "what would happen if..." that's no way to live. You have to think "it won't happen to me" because chances are, it won't.

It's not for a stranger to decide how I live my life, though. If someone says they feel unsafe, they should be listened to and their viewpoint respected.

I'm surprised there are so few people on this thread that don't mind getting a taxi on their own. Maybe I'm naive in going walking on my own, running in the dark, waiting for buses at night or getting a taxi - I don't know but I know you have to presume you'll be fine in most situations as otherwise it makes carrying on with day to day tasks quite difficult.

I do plenty of things on my own.

I work on my own outdoors, normally in rural and isolated areas with little or no phone signal. I used to walk to work alone through a poorly lit nature reserve at 5am. I've travelled the world on my own too. I've never once felt unsafe doing any of those things.

But I do feel unsafe trapped in a vehicle with a stranger I don't know. It doesn't matter if it's logical or that I'm actually perfectly safe - I don't feel safe and it's not for anyone else to tell me that I'm wrong for feeling that way.

irene9 · 16/02/2022 14:09

It's very different walking to a station than actually getting into the very intimate and alone situation of a taxi. You can't get out and at 14 you do what grown ups tell you.
The guy could just be overly nice but make weird comments. Their only qualification is being able to drive and not have a criminal record (maybe) unless a small local firm dodged that bit.