Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"He's always been on the 99th centile"

370 replies

StickerPlace · 16/02/2022 09:46

I'm in a bad mood this morning. So I may we'll BU.

But I've seen this twice today. (Granted was on the same thread about child size)

But I feel like I've read/heard that comment so many times. But it can't be true?

Or are the 1% of parents with 99% children very keen to talk about that?

(FWIW just weighed/measured mine for new dance uniform as had a growth spurt and nothing fits and 11th centile.)

OP posts:
Waspie · 16/02/2022 11:02

Mine was only 92nd centile. Was at birth and still is. He's 14 and 184cm. For weight he was 50th centile at birth and still is now.

As others have said if you post about big/tall children you get people with big children answering.

Incidentally DS is one of the smaller (certainly thinner) kids at his rugby club and one of the tall kids at his tennis club. Rugby clearly attracts the 99th centile children Smile

planningtomakeaplan · 16/02/2022 11:01

The reality is that a sizeable % of the excess of children on the 99th Centile are known to have problematic diets or issues with a lack of exercise.

Its just that too many people don't want to admit this.

Not sure how my baby managed to have poor diet in the womb?!!

By definition, 1 in 100 babyes are born abover the 99th. And - if it's genetic, then that'll be pretty much the same regardless of diet - surely.

Although I guess there could be factors like mothers smoking less while pregnant these days, meaning fewer babies have their growth stunted. That's not poor diet though, that's health improvements.

Yes, when they're older I have no doubt that modern diet and lack of exercise play a part, but that doesn't affect the underlying 1% who are are there because of genetics.

dizzydizzydizzy · 16/02/2022 11:00

Those charts only give you a rough idea and are not that accurate. They are.probably based on some small group of kids from a long time ago.

DD1 is 6' and I believe off the chart. It is unusual for a girl to be that tall but on the other hand it is not that rare these days. We know others her height.

LimeSegment · 16/02/2022 11:00

If you have a child on this centile, it should be a concern if there isn't obviously a family trait.

OP is taking about babies that were born on the high centiles. Not sure how you can put a foetus on a diet. Yes of course you can diet yourself, but I am normal size, ate healthily (could hardly eat due to sickness), didn't put on much weight, no gd. People commented that my bump was small. And baby was 95th centile. I am just not sure what I could have done.

BuddhaForMary · 16/02/2022 10:59

@Treaclepie19

Both of mine are 🤷‍♀️ I often say it when people say how tall they are for their ages. Also when people ask how heavy they are and then they delight in telling me that's far too big and their 20 year old is that heavy.
Yeah I get this too.
Lesperance · 16/02/2022 10:59

@elfycat

I clicked on this post BECAUSE it said 99th centile. Which DD1 has never been on since birth as she's off the top in length/height. She's tall and thin (I take no pride in this - genetics and all that) and a pain to get school uniform for - the elastic waists can be uncomfortable for her as so much material is gathered.

If you'd specified bottom 1% or 25th I might not have bothered even clicking on this thread. You've created a self-fulfilling prophecy here.

Me too. Mine is probably on 90th or thereabouts. His height is commented on, his dad's height is also commented on, usually in relation to one another (both are are tall, see where he gets it from etc). It's harmless, but yes, it could mean that I say he's always been around 90th.
Herewegoagain84 · 16/02/2022 10:58

Why wouldn’t it be true? Also of course they would have “always” been on that percentile if they started there - babies/children are supposed to track, and a drop in a couple of centiles is a warning sign. Are you one of those people who assume every kid should be aiming for the 50th?

SMBC2020 · 16/02/2022 10:57

The centiles are based on the worldwide population so you would expect more children in the UK and other western countries to be above the 50th centile.

LibrariesGiveUsPower · 16/02/2022 10:55

I don’t know when the centiles were drawn up, but kids have got taller in the last couple of decades. So if it was made I’m the 80’s yes 1 in 100 then, probably 5 in 100 now.

Treaclepie19 · 16/02/2022 10:55

I should add, my dh is 6 foot 2 so it's not surprising.

Treaclepie19 · 16/02/2022 10:53

Both of mine are 🤷‍♀️ I often say it when people say how tall they are for their ages.
Also when people ask how heavy they are and then they delight in telling me that's far too big and their 20 year old is that heavy.

GrendelsGrandma · 16/02/2022 10:52

People with kids around the middle of the centiles don't give a stuff because it's not remarkable and their kids are average sized. It's only parents with smaller or larger kids who talk about centiles because it might be a cause for remark or concern.

I don't give a stuff what centile my kids are, they seem fairly average and that's ok for me.

fishonabicycle · 16/02/2022 10:52

It seems a bit odd as the whole concept of centiles means that anywhere very high or very low is an outlier and there shouldn't be many of them at all.

WaitingForSunshineAndDaisies · 16/02/2022 10:52

DS2 always used to be on the 50th centile or thereabouts until he was around 13 so I didn't post about him because it seemed so boring.

He's now 15 and 6'3 - those centile calculations don't always follow through!

People will post about the extremes though, it just makes it more newsworthy (notice I haven't said anything about DS1)

RedToothBrush · 16/02/2022 10:52

@StickerPlace

I'm in a bad mood this morning. So I may we'll BU.

But I've seen this twice today. (Granted was on the same thread about child size)

But I feel like I've read/heard that comment so many times. But it can't be true?

Or are the 1% of parents with 99% children very keen to talk about that?

(FWIW just weighed/measured mine for new dance uniform as had a growth spurt and nothing fits and 11th centile.)

First up, lets debunk the '1% of kids' here.

Its NOT. Thats the issue.

When the scale was drawn up a while ago. So at the point the scale was drawn up it was accurate. Only 1% of kids were on the 99th Centile.

The problem now is that more and more kids are obese and bigger than they should be for their age. We now have more kids, who would have been on the 99% centile at it was because the size of kids are increasing. This is not a reflection of an increase in nutrition or genetics in such a short period of time. It will account for a portion of the increase being natural and healthy, but not the majority of it. And even with a natural increase, we know that extra height carries an increase in the lifetime risk of cancers so this matters.

This is where it isn't necessarily a 'normal' or a 'good' thing that many try to make out. Where there is a problem because we now have an excess of children who are at a weight/height that is potentially problematic.

Only a small number of children who are clocking the 99% SHOULD be that size based on their genetics. The majority SHOULD NOT be on the 99% centile because its problematic and shows there is a problem.

The dismissal of this as a concern is worrying.

If you have a child on this centile, it should be a concern if there isn't obviously a family trait.

For example, if you have a 5'1" woman and a 5'10" man who are averagely built and they had normal development and never had a medical history which asked questions about their size and they have a child who is huge, you might want to be asking a few questions. If you have a 5'11" woman and a 6'4" man who are broad and well build, maybe not so much.

Thats why if you have a child who is registering very high on the scale it really should be being flagged and monitored. It shouldn't result in a diet to lose weight. Parents should be being encouraged to have a think about what they are feeding their children and portion sizes but not a full on diet.

I think the lack of understanding of WHY its a problem and what steps should be taken if it raises a flag is the issue.

The denialism is often reflective of parents not wanting to address their OWN eating and exercise habits. Its easy to hide behind the 'its normal because someone has to be in the 1%' phrase, without actually acknowledging whats going on here.

The reality is that a sizeable % of the excess of children on the 99th Centile are known to have problematic diets or issues with a lack of exercise.

Its just that too many people don't want to admit this.

Shutupandcry · 16/02/2022 10:52

My child has been on the 99th centile since my 37 week scan until now (they are 5). I find it useful to explain that they have always been larger rather than be accused of feeding them crap etc. They were large in utero (I was a healthy weight, no GD, no excessive weight gain) when EBF and when weaned on single vegetables. Some people are so aggressive towards parents of larger children blaming them for their health that I feel the need to justify this.

Triffid1 · 16/02/2022 10:52

Agree with @C8H10N4O2 as well. DD is tall but probably something like 85th percentile, but she's big - large feet, definitely a bit overweight etc. It is stressful and worrying. And then there are issues like the fact that she's wearing size 2 shoes in Year 2 which means the last time we went into a shoe shop, none of the cute boots with pink fur or unicorn glitter were in her size - they all only went up to size 1. She doesn't want the more grown up shoes - she's only 6. Similar issues with coats.
Or the fact that her school clothes are all too long and have to be altered.

And as another PP said, it's self selecting. I worry about her size so tend to click on posts about these issues. Similarly, DS used to be overweight but has lost it all so I tend to click on posts about that sort of thing because maybe our experience can help other families.

DontWantTheRivalry · 16/02/2022 10:51

My 4 year old is on the 12th percentile so he’s a little dot.

Someone the other day thought he was 2 years old and it made me feel like shit.

ancientgran · 16/02/2022 10:50

I've also been told that because my children are taller than their age they should act older than their age. It mightily pisses me off. Family are just as bad. Many times had to remind people that DC are only X age and therefore acting perfectly normal for their age!!!

I sympathise, I had that experience with one of mine, I also had one who was tiny and is still below average height as an adult, as they were bright and academic it caused even more comments about how amazing they were, no just a bright 5, 6 or 7 year old.

Quartz2208 · 16/02/2022 10:50

I have a 50th and a 95th and having a tall boy means you often do have to say. I remember when he was 4 being asked in the supermarket by the attendant why he couldn’t read (because he has just started reception), being looked at when he was 3 and having a massive tantrum and worrying that school clothes won’t fit him through school.

And yes it is actually more common give it is 1/100 (probably 5 actually if you take it from 95) DS is one of 3 tall boys in his year of 90 who have different builds
DD (12) good friend (girl) is 6ft and size nine feet (and has 2 equally big younger sisters) and her mum finds clothes and shoe buying tricky and her DD finds it hard being so tall around her shorter froends

Sausagesausagesausage · 16/02/2022 10:49

On MN children are either 99th centile or 0.4centile, nothing in between. It's like you can only have children destined for Oxbridge or a life of crime.

I do have large boys (both over the 90th+ for weight and height - both had recent hospital appointments so I know for definite). That said, they're not massively larger than their peers - maybe a head taller than some, a few inches over others, shorter than a few. 4yo DS is noticeably smaller than his 6yo cousin. MN seems to have a large number of giant toddlers who dwarf primary school children.

planningtomakeaplan · 16/02/2022 10:49

I don't understand what you're asking?

DS has been above the 99th percentile since he was a baby, and I do mention it occasionally, if it's relevant.

DD is tall, but not as unusually tall as DS. I can't remember what her percentile was as an older baby or toddler (low 90s I think?) as it's less unusual. I'll say she's tall if it's relevant but I won't quote a percentile.

So maybe that's a factor. Can others with DC who aren't at either extreme remember what percentile their DC were at, beyond when they were newborns?

But also, 1 in 100 is A LOT of people. If you're engaging with chat forums where there are thousands of parents, loads of them will have DC who are at the 99th percentile.

Also, why does it annoy you? I don't understand?

Allthesefolks · 16/02/2022 10:49

My DC1 is on the 98th for height, we do get a lot of comments as she’s tallest in her reception class. I don’t know what she was at birth as here HVs don’t measure length so I can’t say what you have said we all say Wink. She was born on the 25th for weight.

My other DC is on the 0.4th for height and weight though, I stress more about this tbh Sad

Simonjt · 16/02/2022 10:48

@C8H10N4O2

More a wonder if how only 1/100 people can be on 99th that it's so frequent to see people say their child is 99th

Because when you are on the extreme ends you have actual problems which are less likely to trouble people who conform to society's expected size.

Like:

  • paying VAT on shoes for children still in infant/junior classes
  • not being able to buy clothes that fit (because obviously children of a fixed height are all the same width)
  • VAT on clothing whilst still child age
  • people complaining that your 18month old behaves like an 18 month old (I was actually told that if a child looks older they should behave older)
  • constant challenges over ticket pricing well before being at threshold age

The list is endless and parents of very small children will have a comparable set of problems.

If my DC had all been average size and small feed I'd not have faced any of these size related problems to make size relevant to a question.

My son at six still has no bum, all of his trousers have to be taken in at the waist, its a right pain. Thankfully he likes shorts! He’s a bit behind socially and emotionally due to early trauma, so people can be extremelt unforgiving of his behaviour, even medical professionals and sometimes staff at school. He may be the height of your average eight year old, but chronologically he is 6.5 and developmentally he is around 5.
Fabuleuse · 16/02/2022 10:47

My first was born above the 99th centile at 11 lbs 9oz. He was an enormous baby and toddler up til about 3 but he's now a reasonably tall (91st centile I think) but skinny 7 year old so that rules me out of boasting about my 99th centile child any more.Wink