Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"He's always been on the 99th centile"

370 replies

StickerPlace · 16/02/2022 09:46

I'm in a bad mood this morning. So I may we'll BU.

But I've seen this twice today. (Granted was on the same thread about child size)

But I feel like I've read/heard that comment so many times. But it can't be true?

Or are the 1% of parents with 99% children very keen to talk about that?

(FWIW just weighed/measured mine for new dance uniform as had a growth spurt and nothing fits and 11th centile.)

OP posts:
Geezabreak82 · 16/02/2022 11:17

My first born was on the 99th percentile at birth my second was off the chart at 11lbs. Youngest followed the 99th percentile line through toddlerhood, and eldest settled on the 91st percentile line after he reached one year. I'm proud to have given birth naturally to two big bouncing babies and to have breast-fed them both (not exclusively). They're now aged 4 and 7 and we occasionally check where their height/weight sit on the chart. I probably did go on about it a lot, especially when they were little.

It is a different experience in some ways because we you race through sizes in clothes, car seats, buggies and have to replace things more quickly than parents of smaller babies (DS1 couldn't use baby swing as newborn because was too heavy and was tipping out headfirst, DS2 couldn't fit in first high chair we ordered at six months, first car seat outgrown by 8 months, buggy too small by 18 months, up to 18kg car seat outgrown by 2.5 years - brilliant!). Also the breast-feeding positions that they teach to new mums do not work for bigger babies - cross cradle hold depends on your baby being shorter than your forearm and neither of mine were.

Simonjt · 16/02/2022 11:17

@Cuck00soup

Poorly fed children won't be on the 99th centile. Parents associate with people like them. It's not that surprising that you get clusters of children who are.

Although -dons helmet - some of the parents who claim their DC are on the 99th centile, simply have fat children.

Percentile for height and weight are different, my son was denied adequate nutrition as a baby, he was very underweight, as a result his weight and diet were carefully monitored until he was four. He is 95th percentile for height.
Starcrossed2 · 16/02/2022 11:13

I was just going to say that @smbc2020. I'm sure the little red books make reference to unicef.
Incidentally my ds is literally off the charts and I'm being made to feel crap about it off the hv.
He's the same height as his sister who's 16 months older and she's on the 90th for height. He's slightly heavier too. He will constantly ask for food, clears his plate (of healthy food) and looks to take more from elsewhere. He's been absolutely massive since the day he was born, was drinking so much milk as a baby I took him to the Dr who said as long as he's gaining he won't over eat. Yet here we are.
His dad is 6'3 and mil said he was exactly the same as a child. A photo I thought he was about 6 in, he was only 3 and built the same as ds. Dh is a normal weight now, but its certainly not something I brag about. Quite the opposite I'm very conscious of it

CornishGem1975 · 16/02/2022 11:13

@danorak

My toddler DC is 99th and has been since birth (just shy of 10lbs).

Can't say it's something I ever bring up unless someone comments on size first or misjudges age. Only ever mentioned because people think he's older than he actually is.

I get that too. People regularly think my DS is a year old than he is. I feel the need to defend the gasps when I say how old he is, with 'he was born big'.

And no, he's not just fat. He really was 99th centile, requiring an extra stay in hospital as they had to check blood sugar levels etc for the first 24 hours.

SleepingStandingUp · 16/02/2022 11:11

The percentiles at birth are from 1990, and based on UK data. So, not that old!. It's 32 years. Now I feel old 😂 but I concede that point.

But I do think there's a glut of apocalypse ready babies /, toddlers. I was surprised what decent sized twins we all had at twin group and all the recent singles are all big boys too

Cherryblossoms85 · 16/02/2022 11:11

My ds1 is 2nd centile, up from 0.4 though. That's a whole different angle when his younger brother is taller than him Grin

iheartme · 16/02/2022 11:11

@RedToothBrush you do realise that tall children don't always equate to heavy. DC1 was off the chart for height at birth but only 88th percentile for weight. As an older child I think her weight is probably around 50th percentile whilst height still 99th percentile.

ThirdElephant · 16/02/2022 11:11

@Cuck00soup

Poorly fed children won't be on the 99th centile. Parents associate with people like them. It's not that surprising that you get clusters of children who are.

Although -dons helmet - some of the parents who claim their DC are on the 99th centile, simply have fat children.

Depends- are we talking about 99th for height and weight, or just weight? If they're 99th on both, I would say it's unlikely they're just obese.
BinBandit · 16/02/2022 11:11

We are a tall family but I don't think about it too much except when trying to book holiday accommodation and having to ensure that the beds don't have ends on them or when DS can't get comfy in a restaurant as his knees don't fit under the table, especially when they have those sort of wooden skirt things under and he's not exceptionally tall, just really long limbed. DS2 and Dh are only an inch shorter and don't have any issues with the tables.

However, I was reading another thread where someone was moaning that she was having to buy clothes in the petite range even though she was 5'2 and didn't consider herself particularly short. That prompted me to look at the average height for the UK and for women it's about 5'3.5 which I found really surprising. We aren't a particularly tall nation it seems. (I think it was 5'9 for men)

danorak · 16/02/2022 11:10

My toddler DC is 99th and has been since birth (just shy of 10lbs).

Can't say it's something I ever bring up unless someone comments on size first or misjudges age. Only ever mentioned because people think he's older than he actually is.

Jvg33 · 16/02/2022 11:10

I don't think it matters op. Nothing wrong with being average weight/height. Life is what you make of it.

ThirdElephant · 16/02/2022 11:09

I've not seen that many people make this claim tbh. Mine have consistently been on the 91st though.

Cuck00soup · 16/02/2022 11:08

Poorly fed children won't be on the 99th centile. Parents associate with people like them. It's not that surprising that you get clusters of children who are.

Although -dons helmet - some of the parents who claim their DC are on the 99th centile, simply have fat children.

Bunnycat101 · 16/02/2022 11:08

I have one child who is very tall (taking after one parent) and one who is between the 9th and 25th centile (taking after the other). Both have followed their lines from early on.

The first one’s height has come up more often as an issue. Firstly as she outgrew car seats too soon so height became a consideration and talking point for me. Secondly, she has gone through clothes and shoes much quicker than her friends. Thirdly there have been some issues with people thinking she’s older especially as a toddler.

The height of the other one has rarely come up in conversation

planningtomakeaplan · 16/02/2022 11:08

@SleepingStandingUp

I get what you mean op, it's a statistics qn not a child size qn.

99th percentile indicates that at that size, only a tiny % of similarly aged children are that size. Same for being in 1st percentile. But if every child is 99th then that measurement is not longer accurate.

I think the percentiles are probably very outdated and I think babies in general seem to be large this year. Like extra fat chickens that are prepared for a cold winter.
DTwins were 6lb 12 and 6lb 13 at four weeks early. They're two and I'm contemplating a move to 3-4 (always been a size ahead). But they're similar size at respective ages to the two other babies bornin our school mom group. It's like they're pandemic prepped

The percentiles at birth are from 1990, and based on UK data. So, not that old!

99th percentile means 1 in 100 children, which is quite a lot really!

www.rcpch.ac.uk/resources/uk-who-growth-charts-0-4-years

MythicalBiologicalFennel · 16/02/2022 11:08

Here we go again with the denialism Hmm

Dd has always been off the chart for height and borderline underweight regardless of what she eats. But according to the tall-is-fat brigade she is going to become obese any time now (12 years and waiting) Confused

DS was born around 2nd decile, went to 50th and has always been there for height and weight.

To answer your question OP I have never felt the need to discuss any of this with anyone. People have so many hang ups about being or not being "tall" it's unbelievable.

planningtomakeaplan · 16/02/2022 11:07

I found that growth chart here: www.rcpch.ac.uk/resources/uk-who-growth-charts-0-4-years

caringcarer · 16/02/2022 11:07

When our foster son was 5 he was on 1st centile for weight and 3rd for height. Now he is 15 and in 60th cc entile for weight be and 68th for height. Things can change over time.

GrolliffetheDragon · 16/02/2022 11:06

DS was nowhere near 99th, but was in the 70s or 80s for height, so we had a lot of people thinking he was badly behaved because they assumed he was older than he was.

BobHadBitchTits · 16/02/2022 11:06

What's the thread?

I'm interested to know how accurate the charts are.

SleepingStandingUp · 16/02/2022 11:06

I get what you mean op, it's a statistics qn not a child size qn.

99th percentile indicates that at that size, only a tiny % of similarly aged children are that size. Same for being in 1st percentile. But if every child is 99th then that measurement is not longer accurate.

I think the percentiles are probably very outdated and I think babies in general seem to be large this year. Like extra fat chickens that are prepared for a cold winter.
DTwins were 6lb 12 and 6lb 13 at four weeks early. They're two and I'm contemplating a move to 3-4 (always been a size ahead). But they're similar size at respective ages to the two other babies bornin our school mom group. It's like they're pandemic prepped

planningtomakeaplan · 16/02/2022 11:06

It's not true that the WHO charts are solely based on wolrd data.

The WHO charts we use are labeled UK and say that whereas the data is worldwide from 2-4 weeks, the birth measurements are based on British data. It says:

The UK–WHO growth chart combines World Health
Organization (WHO) standards with UK preterm and birth
data. The chart from 2 weeks to 4 years of age is based on
the WHO growth standard, derived from measurements of
healthy, non-deprived, breastfed children of mothers who did
not smoke.

1 The chart for birth measurements (32–42 weeks
gestation) is based on British children measured around
1990.

2 The charts depict a healthy pattern of growth that is
desirable for all children, whether breast fed or formula fed,
and of whatever ethnic origin."

JuneySunshine · 16/02/2022 11:05

Oh I can relate to this in terms of fetal growth curves. My little one has been on the smaller side so I always have my fingers crossed they're staying on their little curve about 15-20th percentile.

I only know 5 other pregnant women and of those 3 have said at some point that their bump/ baby is measuring on or over the 99th percentile.

Well I know I'm being sensetive because of my own anxieties, but that just doesn't make any mathematical sense does it?!

Earlymorningcuppa · 16/02/2022 11:03

No idea what centile my kids were on but nothing fitted when they were kids - skinny feet made buying school shoes a nightmare and skinny bodies made buying uniforms a nightmare too.
Late teens now and they have gained some breadth - still have skinny feet though no need to buy school shoes, so all much easier.
The thought of school uniform still gives me the rage!😂

CornishGem1975 · 16/02/2022 11:02

My son was on the 99.6th centile at birth, he was just under 10lb though. The centiles you are given when preggo (now anyway) are customised charts based on a range of factors, including maternal weight and height. So it didn't mean he was massively tall or heavy (I mean he was...) but he was big for me. I've no idea what he weighs or how tall he is now (he's 2).