Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"He's always been on the 99th centile"

370 replies

StickerPlace · 16/02/2022 09:46

I'm in a bad mood this morning. So I may we'll BU.

But I've seen this twice today. (Granted was on the same thread about child size)

But I feel like I've read/heard that comment so many times. But it can't be true?

Or are the 1% of parents with 99% children very keen to talk about that?

(FWIW just weighed/measured mine for new dance uniform as had a growth spurt and nothing fits and 11th centile.)

OP posts:
lottiegarbanzo · 16/02/2022 11:48

Extremes get talked about. That's all.

No-one feels the need to say 'oh your dd looks like a very average 4yo, is she in fact precisely on the 50th centile line?'. No-one says 'I cannot find any age-appropriate clothes at, that fit my perfectly average DS'.

Stretchandsnap · 16/02/2022 11:47

Both DDs over 99th last time I looked which was about age 1 for both of them. It was so obvious when they were born that it wasn’t going to be a useful tool for them, as DD1 went straight into 1 month old baby grows and I had to cut the toes out after a week as they were too short.

DD1 is now 12 and 5’11 and DD2 is 10 and is 5’7 - having tall kids is a giant PITA - DD1’s school uniform is already too short and she is in the tall version, both wear size 9 shoes and if they grow anymore I don’t know what I am going to do about school shoes, as it’s a nightmare when you are 44/10 above in shoes (speaks from bitter experience)

Recently DD2 had to have an operation, when I went to pick her up from recovery, the was a chorus from all the theatre staff ‘ahhhh mum’s tall!’ (6’1) as they were very bemused by how long DD’s legs are

Both DDs are slim, (I’m not, I have an arse you could balance a pint on, but they are much more athletically built than me and take more after DH (6’5) I have no idea why this is controversial, it just is what it is for our family and nothing to do with breeding a super race of rowers

Runningupthecurtains · 16/02/2022 11:45

@Talipesmum

Why couldn’t it be true? Some people are a lot taller than other people. Their kids are very likely to be consistently taller than their peers throughout their lives. Class photos often have the same few kids towering above others on the back row year after year.

It can all go a bit awry when they start hitting puberty as the growth spurts associated with that all depend rather on when puberty kicks in.

I'm stood at one side the teacher on the other side in all class photos. People would probably wonder why the TA was in school uniform if they looked at them now.
BinBandit · 16/02/2022 11:43

Better nutrition doesn't outdo genetics though, it may just allow people to meet their full genetic potential. Sometimes children who are overfed might be tall children but their bodies might be pushed into puberty early and therefore not meet their potential either. It's complex.

As i said, I come from a tall family. My parents were both born in the early 1930s. DM was brought up in a poor but not exceptionally poor house, they mostly had enough to eat albeit nothing fancy. She was 5'6. My DF was brought up in abject poverty, orphaned, at times went into a children's homes etc. Ended up 5'11. Myself and brothers and sisters are all above average height, brought up pretty poor in the 60s. All the male grandchildren are over 6'2 despite some of their mothers being around 5 foot. The female grandchildren are more of a mixed bag with the taller girls coming from my sisters rather than SiLs. I'm sure my dad would have made it over 6 foot is he'd had access to regular and decent food.

FawnFrenchieMum · 16/02/2022 11:40

@MrsTimRiggins

I don’t even know what centile my boy is, I don’t think I’ve ever been told 🤣 I expect it would be a 90-something. I guess it’s one of those things that you don’t mention unless it’s very high or very low, so you just notice it mentioned more iyswim?
Yes this I think, my DS average birth weigh and fairly average height until he hit puberty and is now 6ft at 15, I have no idea what percentile he was / is (if I want to really embarrass myself as a parent, I don't even know where his red book is). However, my DD was 4lb 1oz at birth and 3lb 10oz on discharge from hospital, we had weekly, then fortnightly weigh in's for months. I could tell you exactly which percentile she was until she went to school. She mostly followed the 0.4 percentile which the odd dip now and again. When your children are usually tall, short, slim, bigger built people constantly comment on it so you get used to saying, oh yes they have always been ....
CornishGem1975 · 16/02/2022 11:40

@Rowgtfc72

Dd also on the 99. something centile. 15 next month and 5ft 11, size 9 feet. It is no fun having a tall child. You spend a lot of time explaining why your massive 3yr old is having a tantrum. Got bored of being tutted at personally.
Also, superhuman strength that is required. I am really petite, trying to wrangle a giant 2 year old for a nappy change is impossible some days!

And yes, being judged because they look older than they are. Not helped by him having great speech [/stealthbrag before anyone else calls it].

Blueeyedgirl21 · 16/02/2022 11:37

@Sweetpeasaremadeforbees should say the child in question is a girl. I think there is a stigma about not having a ‘big strapping lad’ that is unfair

konasana · 16/02/2022 11:36

@Filthyslattern

my eldest son was consistently on the 99.6th centile and then went above it but still followed the line if you see what i mean. He's an adult now and 6 foot 8.
I love that the first reply confirms your suspicion that 'the 1% of parents with 99% children very keen to talk about that'
Blueeyedgirl21 · 16/02/2022 11:36

@Sweetpeasaremadeforbees controversial but i wouldn’t mind if my child was, like me, smaller than average. I don’t gain weight easily and can to an extent not worry about what I eat, I don’t have to go to special shops to get shoes that fit and can buy VAT free kids jeans and leggings and trainers for cheap !! If I had a daughter who was 6ft2 I think I’d worry about her. My friend is 6ft and extremely self conscious.

BiddyPop · 16/02/2022 11:35

We have been at the opposite end of the scale, with DD being on the 10th centile, but often 4th or 1st over the years (and meds she was on for a few years didn't help that). She's still very skinny, but has grown in height at least, and has some bit to go yet (her feet are size 8 so we're expecting another 3-4" in height). But she's still only a skinny size 8. (But full of muscle at the same time).

bruffin · 16/02/2022 11:31

@UnbeatenMum

I'm slightly anxious about how tall my 2yo is because people already approach him and talk to him like he's 4, it's happened twice in the last two weeks. So I probably talk about it more. Didn't really ever talk about my closer to the average height children.
When he is 3 or 4 they will ask why he isnt in school!

DS shot up the centiles in his first year, was 6ft at 13, but never got taller and is 6ft at 26.
And @RedToothBrush, he is not and never been obese or even overweight

Rowgtfc72 · 16/02/2022 11:30

Dd also on the 99. something centile. 15 next month and 5ft 11, size 9 feet.
It is no fun having a tall child. You spend a lot of time explaining why your massive 3yr old is having a tantrum. Got bored of being tutted at personally.

ODFOx · 16/02/2022 11:30

I had two who tracked the line just below the 0.4 centile. The others were more
Middling. It doesn't get brought up on chats about clothes because it's easy to buy a smaller size. It's the bigger/taller sizes that are more problematic when buying for a child.

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 16/02/2022 11:29

Someone the other day thought he was 2 years old and it made me feel like shit.

Yes like me my DD is pretty small and reading stuff like 'people are taller these days because of better nutrition' makes me think shit, do people assume I don't feed her enough healthy food? I think people speak without thinking. It's like with teenage acne, I think a lot of people think that if kids get it it must be due to unhealthy lifestyle habits.

BinBandit · 16/02/2022 11:28

@Geezabreak82

Oh yeah, and there's the whole having to explain to judgey parents why your two year old, who is the size of a five year old, is acting like a two year old in a park. The first lockdown was a blessing in the sense that we weren't allowed to take our youngest to public playparks during the worst of the terrible twos. I really feel for parents of SEN kids because other parents can be d**ks when they don't think your child is acting their age!
Yep, we've had that. Once at a play centre a boy (in school uniform so at least 4.5 (in scotland) was harrasing and poking my DS1 who was just a bit over two. Nothing overly bad, just kids being kids but i was watching carefully ready to step in if required but I wanted DS to handle it himself. Eventually my son turned round and hit him and boy went over crying to his dad. Who came over furious and shouty but was a bit more sheepish when I pointed out that his son had started it and my DS was only 2.
Flickflak · 16/02/2022 11:27

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Couchbettato · 16/02/2022 11:26

My little boy has always been around the 50th centile if that makes you feel better OP.

georgarina · 16/02/2022 11:25

My DS has always been 50th percentile
DD is 40th percentile

They are bigger than me but I am 5 foot so didn't expect giants!

Not a good or bad thing, and one you can't change. My entire family is on the small side and obsessed about me being small and started constantly talking about the DCs until I stopped them, because I don't ever want to make it an issue.

StripyOnesie · 16/02/2022 11:25

My daughter was on the 98th centile. 10lb 5oz at birth. She's only just 13 and is 5ft 8.5 inches and a size 7.5 shoe.

Blueeyedgirl21 · 16/02/2022 11:24

Everyone’s kids on mumsnet are like 5ft tall by reception
They’re ALWAYS slim though
I imagine a super race of 6ft5 teens built like Olympic rowers, striding through the streets of Home Counties towns from school where they get no less than a grade 8 in anything, to their Naice tasteful houses where they eat enormous amounts of organic veg and fruit, heaping plates of ‘from scratch’ evening meals and then retire to bed for another day of over achieving and being really, really tall. Oh and they are all good at skiing.

I think in reality mumsnetters either exaggerate and/or the over average income of many of them means their kids have access to really good nutrition and often don’t go to crappy primary schools with crappy food but prep schools where they get full on sit down meals 2x a day. So it contributes to them generally growing and thriving potentially more than someone’s kids who are being raised below the poverty line

C8H10N4O2 · 16/02/2022 11:24

@planningtomakeaplan

The reality is that a sizeable % of the excess of children on the 99th Centile are known to have problematic diets or issues with a lack of exercise.

Its just that too many people don't want to admit this.

Not sure how my baby managed to have poor diet in the womb?!!

By definition, 1 in 100 babyes are born abover the 99th. And - if it's genetic, then that'll be pretty much the same regardless of diet - surely.

Although I guess there could be factors like mothers smoking less while pregnant these days, meaning fewer babies have their growth stunted. That's not poor diet though, that's health improvements.

Yes, when they're older I have no doubt that modern diet and lack of exercise play a part, but that doesn't affect the underlying 1% who are are there because of genetics.

Well quite. I'm bemused by people who conflate size and weight and think that a 99% percentile child has a problem if they are 99% on both dimensions - there were be a significant problem if they were "normal" weight and 99% height.

All my babies were big (10lbs +) because they were long. I put on less than the recommended weight each time due to recurring HG. Didn't stop fuckwits telling me I ate too much during pregnancy.

I put them in the same category as the idiots who complain when a 5 year old behaves like a five year old, including idiots working in health and education who do this.

Nc4post99 · 16/02/2022 11:21

^ oh meant to say it’s those parents that post as they’re reaching out for support or reassurance:)

Nc4post99 · 16/02/2022 11:20

You’re probably seeing a disproportionate amount of posts on either MN or Fb parenting groups both from parents of big and small children because they’re the ones that tend to get the flack from HCPs. Big child or a child that climbed the charts ‘too quickly’ or crossed 2 centiles up and parents are often told ‘your overfeeding’ etc. Likewise parents of smaller kids are under lots of pressure to make them taller by HCPs and society that has an obsession with big children. I say this as the mother of a 10th centile girlie

Geezabreak82 · 16/02/2022 11:20

Oh yeah, and there's the whole having to explain to judgey parents why your two year old, who is the size of a five year old, is acting like a two year old in a park. The first lockdown was a blessing in the sense that we weren't allowed to take our youngest to public playparks during the worst of the terrible twos. I really feel for parents of SEN kids because other parents can be d**ks when they don't think your child is acting their age!

Quackpot · 16/02/2022 11:17

Our health visitor used to say dd was 99th centile, put her on a diet (4 months), she's overweight blah blah.

She had cmpa, complex medical needs, prem, low birth weight, so had been on high calorie supplements and was consultant led. I ignored the silly cow.

I found her red book recently and the graph reads somewhere around 80th, after jumping from somewhere around 30th. Definitely not 99th. So maybe people are just listening to health visitors who can't read charts properly.