Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU - All Estate agents are *uc*ing snakes ๐Ÿ

118 replies

tinx · 15/02/2022 22:04

Title says it allโ€ฆ estate agents are the scum of the earth sick to death of them and their bullshite lies
They bang on about sellers being time wasters, in my experience EA have wasted so much of my time
No integrity unprofessional lying low life twats all of them !!

Any EAโ€™s on here please give us some advice on how to deal with other alien/reptilian/zombie EAโ€™s

Thanks ๐Ÿ‘‹

OP posts:
Yants · 16/02/2022 10:59

A few years ago I'd been keeping my eye on an unoccupied property that was clearly overpriced and had been sat on the market for over 6 months.

When I eventually arranged a viewing, on entering the house the agent had to shove a large amount mail out of the way to open the front door so we could get in... so it clearly hadn't had much interest or viewings for quite some time.

I made an offer 12% below asking, which was much closer to the realistic market value, I then heard nothing back from the agent for over a week despite me making several attempts to find out if my offer was acceptable.

I eventually received an email from the agent informing me that my offer hadn't been accepted and the vendor had accepted another offer... no attempt at all to see if I was willing to increase my initial offer.

I'm convinced the agent had a friend or relative or perhaps just an investor who they had a "special arrangement" with who was interested in the property all along but the agent had told them to hold off from offering knowing how overpriced it was, wait for someone (me in this case) to come along and make a low offer, then the agent can tip off their "preferred buyer" who can put in a slightly better offer and then the agent can push their offer as being the best one on the table to the seller.

The house had clearly had little to no interest in it in the 6 months it had been sat on the market yet as soon as I submit an offer another offer suddenly materialises out of thin air, the weeks delay in me hearing back from the agent was them presumably giving their chum time to get their finances in place to submit their offer.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 16/02/2022 10:58

YANBU - anyone who is selling something is inherently dishonest. Agents leech off the process so are even more dishonest.

Eh? Does that include everybody who is employed, and thus selling their skills, labour and services? Poppy sellers too? Buying and selling is a fundamental part of life in all societies - why ever would the act of earning money through selling something make you inherently dishonest?

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 16/02/2022 10:44

[quote tinx]@novacancy3

I highly suspect this is what happened with my offer
They told me investors were offering on this house and since Iโ€™ve spoken to an investor who backhanded the same estate agent over 20k to accept his offer over other higher offers !!

They need to be in prison tbh[/quote]
I once met someone who openly boasted of his โ€˜arrangementsโ€™ with local EAs. He was a developer whoโ€™d buy run down properties in a relatively cheap area, do them up cheaply and sell on at a healthy profit, usually to landlords.

The EAs in question would presumably fob off any other interested parties, after receipt of nice fat brown envelopes.

The case I have personal experience of, concerned a flat that was tenanted at the time, and (as had to be stated in the blurb) belonged to one of the EA staff.
In between their purchase of it and the sale, prices had increased massively, so there would have been a hefty CGT bill.

Once Iโ€™d viewed it, with what seemed a perfectly nice and straightforward EA, my offer of about ยฃ220k was turned down for what seemed a very odd reason, but I could only accept it.

Only to find out 2 or 3 months later that it had sold for around ยฃ180k. Presumably to a mate, or a dc of the owner. They were only going through the motions of having it on the open market.

MorningStarling · 16/02/2022 10:28

YANBU - anyone who is selling something is inherently dishonest. Agents leech off the process so are even more dishonest.

Mushypeasandchipstogo · 16/02/2022 10:28

I have bought and sold 5 houses in my lifetime and sadly I have to totally agree with you! Examples of their behaviorโ€ฆโ€ฆ..
failing to pass on to us offers on our house as they deemed them to low,
bringing a potential buyer to our house, letting themselves in with a key without checking that it was ok with us. When buying we were not allowed to view a house as we did not want to arrange our mortgage through them and, worst of all, we were not allowed to put an offer on a house which had just gone on the market as the friend of the EA had just put in an offer for the full asking price.
There is a special place in hell reserved for estate agents!

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 16/02/2022 10:26

It's obviously a profession that many unsavoury sorts find attractive to get into, but then you could say the same about the police, car dealerships and garages, tradesmen (the ones who like to rip people off), consultants and surgeons (the arrogant ones with the god complex), teachers (the ones who get off on bullying kids), vicars (the ones who abuse their power and position of trust) etc. etc. Would you call ALL police the scum of the earth? Including the many thousands of decent, honest officers who want to be a positive, helpful pillar of society?

Unless we're talking about inherently objectionable 'occupations', such as pimps, drug dealers or burglars, you'll find good and bad people in every job out there. Buying and selling houses is a normal and essential part of life for many - and you don't have to use an EA as a seller, if you don't want to. As a buyer, they come as part of the deal, representing the seller - but many sellers manage quite well to be arseholes on their own, without needing the EA to help.

Sorry you've experienced some of the bad ones, but we've known a lot of good ones too. The last property we sold, I would not have been without them - they saved us from so much uncertainty and potential pitfalls from known dodgy buyers (yes, it works on both sides) and were respectful and honourable throughout when dealing with the buyer on our behalf.

tinx · 16/02/2022 10:10

@novacancy3

I highly suspect this is what happened with my offer
They told me investors were offering on this house and since Iโ€™ve spoken to an investor who backhanded the same estate agent over 20k to accept his offer over other higher offers !!

They need to be in prison tbh

OP posts:
89redballoons · 16/02/2022 10:09

I've dealt with a few EAs and like any other profession you get duds and shysters as well as great people.

The EA that we engaged when we had to sell my grandmother's house after she died was amazing. I was executor of DGM's will and her house was up the other end of the country, and I had to get permission for every step of the process from a group of 8 beneficiaries. All a bit of a difficult process and quite fraught.

Our EA was incredibly kind and calm and kept us updated about the sale really promptly. He had a really thorough knowledge of the local housing market and found us a buyer willing to make a really fair offer within weeks. He then kept the sale on track despite solicitors on both sides being rubbish. He was so helpful and really earned his fee.

He was the head of his own local, independent firm of estate agents, having set up on his own after working for a national outfit for a few years - maybe that makes a difference.

EAs when we were buying were also fine. Reliable, again good at liaising with solicitors, friendly, no complaints at all.

Some letting agents that I've viewed or rented flats through have been absolutely appalling, though, from outright lies to not passing on information about bills that cost us significantly.

novacancy3 · 16/02/2022 10:07

I've bought and sold 10 houses in different parts of the country over the last 25 years. IME there are some very good and professional estate agents and some truly dodgy ones.

Twice, as a buyer, I have become entangled with the truly dodgy variety. The main issue seems to be as others have said that they will select their preferred buyer based on whether the buyer will use their in house financial services. Higher offers from people in a better position to proceed, such as cash buyers, are not passed on to the vendor or are passed on but with warnings of why the vendors should not accept their offer despite it seeming (and being) the best offer from the most proceedable person.

In these circumstances the best way is to initially approach and present any offers to the vendor and circumnavigate the estate agents as far as possible. At least then you have a chance of success.

It's particularly an issue in a hot market such as we have now or with highly desirable or under market value properties.

MaudieandMe · 16/02/2022 09:52

YABU.

When we sold our house in the UK, I used a firm that was owned and staffed by women and they were great.
Very efficient and they dealt with the annoying buyer for us too.

I agree that there are a lot of smarmy men in the business but it's definitely the type of business that a Women Only firm should do very well in. Smile

TabithaTittlemouse · 16/02/2022 09:51

โ€˜Title says it allโ€™

Not really. It says โ€˜ucing snakesโ€™
If you are going to call them out at least do it properly.

vickyc90 · 16/02/2022 09:43

Our experiance is the opposite, estate agent is great solicitor on the other hand is rubbish

Fupoffyagrasshole · 16/02/2022 09:25

I was โ€œfiredโ€ by an estate agents for refusing to use their mortgage advisor

๐Ÿ˜‚

Then when buying current place the estate agent hounded us with calls almost daily for updates (the solicitors were updating each other and doing their thing - which is why we pay them)

I ended up having to block the estate agent as he was calling when I was in hospital in labour ๐Ÿ™ˆ๐Ÿ˜‚

tinx · 16/02/2022 09:23

@luckylavender

I wasnโ€™t being mean at all !! I lived in a council house for most of my life growing up

If she felt I was being rude I apologise but honestly it wasnโ€™t meant to be I actually meant she had been spared having to deal with house buying process. Not that renting is easier either

Thank you for your reply though the world needs decent more people Smile

OP posts:
sanbeiji · 16/02/2022 09:21

YANBU OP. I wish they were all like the ladies on Selling Sunset but too much to expect for us plebs!

FatherDickByrne · 16/02/2022 08:59

BlackishTulips

I had an awful one when private renting. Gave me total runaround.
Yanbu

^
This

xXwhenwillitendXx · 16/02/2022 08:54

@GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER I know that feeling, property we went to view was a high flood risk, asked estate agents when it last flooded, the response was I'm not sure but they now have a flood defence. I asked if the house has flooded since the defence and he said hebhad no idea Hmm. Surely if your trying to sell a house that floods you would have that information, or am I just expecting too much??

luckylavender · 16/02/2022 08:53

@tinx - what a horrible reply to @vodkaredbullgirl. Maybe you should count your blessings. And of course all EAs aren't awful.

Unsure33 · 16/02/2022 08:51

We dealt with three recently on a move . On one house we tried to buy the agents were evasive to the point of telling lies about things going on with the ( new privately built) property to the extent that we were supposed to be in last july , but when we dropped out and they got new buyers they are still not in.

On the house we eventually bought they were great and really pushed things through for the seller and us .

Our selling agent lied outright to our buyer without our knowledge and he found out . He was not happy and was threatening to sue them . It got very messy.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 16/02/2022 08:49

Easy to think like this if youโ€™ve been unlucky.

I have personal experience of proven seriously dodgy behaviour, but I certainly wouldnโ€™t tar them all with the same brush.

Incompetence would seem to be far from a rarity, though. My โ€˜favouriteโ€™ peeve is cluelessness about basic info, like the length of a lease. A bemused, โ€˜Oh! I donโ€™t know, Iโ€™ll have to find out,โ€™ - as if youโ€™d asked about e.g. the colour of a bedroom carpet.

Not to mention that judging by a lot of the blurbs, you might be forgiven for thinking that an inability to spell was in the job description.

Mydogisagentleman · 16/02/2022 08:41

We have bought 4 properties in the past 5 years.
All have been via the same agent, in our town there are at least 10. Of these, 2 are not even considered when we were looking. I wouldnโ€™t have thought about using them.
Our preferred agent s are helpful, honest and reliable

Phormiumjester · 16/02/2022 08:39

@Grenlei

Anyone with a job title that includes agent who isn't a secret agent, is invariably a test. See also letting agents and recruitment agents (the absolute lowest of the low).

I've found most agents are thick as shit, have no idea of valuing a property (when I sold my first house bloke from the 'local' agent tells me it's worth ยฃX. I asked was it not worth more, as the mid terrace up the road had sold for slightly more, and I was a corner plot with a garage. He said he didn't think people wanted a garage. I sold for ยฃ25k more than his price. See also an agent with my current house who suggested I look on Rightmove with him to work out what it was worth! And another (when I was a cash buyer) who firstly refused to arrange a viewing or even tell the vendor I wanted to view as 'someone else was planning to make an offer' and then when I did view refused to pass on my offer. Lots of other incompetent lazy behaviour which is galling when they get ยฃ5k+ from sales for taking a few photos and sticking on Rightmove. Even worse shenanigans with letting agents and GDPR breaches and the like.

I am sure there must be room in the market for a reputable and competent property agents, because they seem to be in short supply.

Well no because, by your logic, that.would immediately make them a twat.
MischievousBiscuits · 16/02/2022 08:38

Mine seem decent but I've got my eyes wide open- I had bad run ins with EAs when I was younger and renting

Summersdreaming · 16/02/2022 08:28

@FairyCakeWings in my case the EA screwed us both, the vendor was so angry he emailed and threatened to sack his solicitor, until it came out it was the EA who was lying to both sides. He could have lost the sale because I was very close to pulling out - unique property so not one that would sell again in a day.

hangrylady · 16/02/2022 08:18

"Scum of the earth" Really? I'm not an estate agent but I work with them and the ones I deal with are very professional and decent people. You've obviously had a bad experience but labelling them all as scum is extremely unreasonable. I've had cashiers in supermarkets be rude to me, should all cashiers be labelled as scum of the earth? Hmm