Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to assume that my DS's money will be safe if marriage fails?

112 replies

SweatyBetty1234 · 15/02/2022 19:02

My 65 year old DS met a man from Morocco who was aged 30 in a pub, and then spent the following 2 years wrangling with the authorities to get his application to live in the UK approved. They then married in Morocco and he came to live with her in the UK. This was 4 and a half years ago. She has supported him since he came to the UK as he has only done small bits of work here and there.

As he has nearly been in the UK 5 years, it will soon be time for her husband to apply for indefinite leave to remain.

We are just worried that if DS's husband's intentions are not honourable, he may just leave her when he has a full UK passport. Whilst there is nothing anyone can do to stop this happening, will he also be entitled to half her money if he files for divorce?

My DS worked hard for her money, and we feel sad that her DH could potentially try and take it from her.

What would he be entitled to? DS's husband has not contributed financially since the marriage, other than the odd piece of work here and there.

OP posts:
SweatyBetty1234 · 15/02/2022 22:04

@TheYearOfSmallThings

He probably wouldn't get much in those circumstances. The truth is he will only hang around (at her expense) until he gets a better offer, and then just take off. And maybe rock up periodically seeking money.

In a sense though, she has already had her money's worth (and I would say the same of a 65 year old man who married a woman half his age from a poor background).

Wel she has had a lovely few years with him.
OP posts:
TheYearOfSmallThings · 15/02/2022 21:58

He probably wouldn't get much in those circumstances. The truth is he will only hang around (at her expense) until he gets a better offer, and then just take off. And maybe rock up periodically seeking money.

In a sense though, she has already had her money's worth (and I would say the same of a 65 year old man who married a woman half his age from a poor background).

SweatyBetty1234 · 15/02/2022 21:52

@Rumplestrumpet

Lots of harsh comments here!

Firstly on the legality of their marriage - it's pretty clear from the OP that she managed to get him out to the UK after they were married so there's no question about its legality - he's had legal residency for a few years and and will soon be eligible to apply for ILR, after which point he would be free to leave her, divorce if he wishes and marry someone else. He may want to wait another year and get British nationality before leaving her but either way yes there is a real risk that he will leave once he has ILR or a passport.

On how to protect her assets - it is not certain he would get anywhere near 50% but she might have to pay heavy legal fees to fight it and at a time when she's emotionally vulnerable.

If at all possible then, I would suggest you convince her to speak to a solicitor, perhaps presenting it as getting ducks in a row, general life admin, will writing etc. Then go along with her and see if you can get the solicitor to suggest a way of protecting her finances incase the worst should happen (not just divorce).

I have seen relationships like this first hand - I have seen a genuine relationship that was always judged but he was genuinely in love with her (10yr difference though, not 35!). And I've seen women allow themselves to be swept off their feet. I can tell those of you who are accusing her of somehow taking advantage of the man that you're almost certainly far off the mark. It is not the same as when the roles are reversed because the power dynamics are totally different.

Good luck OP

Thank you for this informative post. I can't actually speak to D Sis about any concerns I have as she would bat them off. D sis thinks all the people who doubt her relationship's validity are just prejudiced against age gap relationships or possibly racist.
OP posts:
Rumplestrumpet · 15/02/2022 21:28

Lots of harsh comments here!

Firstly on the legality of their marriage - it's pretty clear from the OP that she managed to get him out to the UK after they were married so there's no question about its legality - he's had legal residency for a few years and and will soon be eligible to apply for ILR, after which point he would be free to leave her, divorce if he wishes and marry someone else. He may want to wait another year and get British nationality before leaving her but either way yes there is a real risk that he will leave once he has ILR or a passport.

On how to protect her assets - it is not certain he would get anywhere near 50% but she might have to pay heavy legal fees to fight it and at a time when she's emotionally vulnerable.

If at all possible then, I would suggest you convince her to speak to a solicitor, perhaps presenting it as getting ducks in a row, general life admin, will writing etc. Then go along with her and see if you can get the solicitor to suggest a way of protecting her finances incase the worst should happen (not just divorce).

I have seen relationships like this first hand - I have seen a genuine relationship that was always judged but he was genuinely in love with her (10yr difference though, not 35!). And I've seen women allow themselves to be swept off their feet. I can tell those of you who are accusing her of somehow taking advantage of the man that you're almost certainly far off the mark. It is not the same as when the roles are reversed because the power dynamics are totally different.

Good luck OP

AffIt · 15/02/2022 21:27

What's that line about 'if you marry for money, you'll pay for it with every day of your life'?

Both of these people are predators, in their own way.

Stay out of it, OP.

SweatyBetty1234 · 15/02/2022 21:22

@BotterMon

Depends on the Moroccan wedding. If married by an Imam then it's not recognised in the UK so he won't get anything. If under Moroccan civil law then she's at risk of losing at least some of her assets if they were to divorce.

Considering he was able to move with her to the UK as her husband I would assume it was under civil law.

Maybe they are madly in love? Have you any evidence apart from your cynical view that they're not?

I would love it if they really were both madly in love. I can't tell how he feels in all honesty. He doesn't give much away.
OP posts:
SantaHat · 15/02/2022 21:08

Ok… so then a huge amount of this hangs on the legalities of their Moroccan wedding I suppose.

BotterMon · 15/02/2022 21:04

Depends on the Moroccan wedding. If married by an Imam then it's not recognised in the UK so he won't get anything. If under Moroccan civil law then she's at risk of losing at least some of her assets if they were to divorce.

Considering he was able to move with her to the UK as her husband I would assume it was under civil law.

Maybe they are madly in love? Have you any evidence apart from your cynical view that they're not?

ForeverSingle881 · 15/02/2022 21:03

If she genuinely is happy and believes he’s in love, what’s the harm? If he makes her happy, surely that’s great? And then any relationship can end anyway, 5 years is a long time already

historygeek · 15/02/2022 20:56

If they married in Morocco, is the marriage legal in the UK?

VodselForDinner · 15/02/2022 20:56

We are just worried that if DS's husband's intentions are not honourable, he may just leave her when he has a full UK passport

Who’s “we”? Because if it includes your sister, there’s something very, very sinister about an older woman who exploits a younger man from a poor country, then tries to cut him off when there’s a chance he’ll get some independence.

Sounds like two people are conning each other here.

Branleuse · 15/02/2022 20:53

Youve told her how you feel. She doesnt agree. Theyre already married. Its been years. I dont think theres anymore to be done. If its a mistake she will learn the hard way

Looubylou · 15/02/2022 20:53

Some posters are being a little harsh. These men (if he turns out to be a wrong'un, he might not 🤞) target vulnerable women, who usually believe they have found love. Only sounds ridiculous to those who are not vulnerable, and haven't been targeted. The scammers do a good job on them - I doubt she will listen to you OP. I don't envy you feeling the need to protect her - it might back fire and ruin your relationship. Happens to men too obviously.

SweatyBetty1234 · 15/02/2022 20:49

@SantaHat

DS is genuinely believes her husband loves her as much as she loves him. She has no doubts at all about this.

But you obviously don’t think this is the case?

Whilst no one can see into someone else's heart, I find it difficult to imagine that a 30 year old would be attracted to a 65 year old.
OP posts:
SantaHat · 15/02/2022 20:46

DS is genuinely believes her husband loves her as much as she loves him. She has no doubts at all about this.

But you obviously don’t think this is the case?

SweatyBetty1234 · 15/02/2022 20:45

@ForeverSingle881

Your sister made her choices, including buying herself a toyboy from a poor country. No 30 year old man enjoys being with a 65 year old woman. You could argue he earned his payday.
That is certainly how it appears. However, DS is deluded enough to think that it is just an age gap relationship.
OP posts:
MyBottleOfRibena · 15/02/2022 20:43

@AnneElliott

He's likely to be after the ILR. So I wouldn't be surprised if he leaves once he has that.

Not sure about the money - in my experience (previously in immigration) they want a quick divorce so they can marry someone else and start the whole ILR scam all over again.

I don’t understand why he would need to marry someone else if he has ILR?
Derbee · 15/02/2022 20:39

@SweatyBetty1234

Thank you all for posting. It is a case of "There's no fool like an old fool". DS is genuinely believes her husband loves her as much as she loves him. She has no doubts at all about this. I take the point many have made that DSis is exploiting her husband in some respects. She definitely thinks he is head over heels in love with her though and wouldn't see she has taken advantage of his situation in any way.
Then it’s not your circus, not your monkeys. She has what’s inevitably coming to her unfortunately, but she’s walking straight into it. Nothing you can do
ForeverSingle881 · 15/02/2022 20:37

Your sister made her choices, including buying herself a toyboy from a poor country. No 30 year old man enjoys being with a 65 year old woman. You could argue he earned his payday.

RB68 · 15/02/2022 20:37

its a bit more complex than 50 50. It will depend on whose name things are in and whether they were used as "family " assets or not. So if she owned 3 houses in hr name and rented them out and the monies were all kept seperate or paid into an account in her name for her use then they might not be considered joint assets. If they lived in ne house then it would depend how long in ownership - if she owned for 30 yrs and they lived together for 5 in it as married couple then he could have a claim on that (although if it was mortgaged to the hilt and capital was low it would be a proportion of that capital... so that might be a route to take short term)

SweatyBetty1234 · 15/02/2022 20:35

Thank you all for posting. It is a case of "There's no fool like an old fool". DS is genuinely believes her husband loves her as much as she loves him. She has no doubts at all about this.
I take the point many have made that DSis is exploiting her husband in some respects. She definitely thinks he is head over heels in love with her though and wouldn't see she has taken advantage of his situation in any way.

OP posts:
thepeopleversuswork · 15/02/2022 20:24

@Stompythedinosaur

Of course her husband will be entitled to a share of the marital assets, I dobt know why you think he wouldn't be?
He will but probably not 50% as someone else said upthread. If its a (relatively) short marriage without children and with most of the assets accrued before the marriage he would be unlikely to get 50%.

50% is the default starting point but any half decent lawyer would be able to make sure she doesn't get cleaned out.

If they are about to divorce though the sooner she does it the better. And she should definitely get a decent lawyer.

Jvg33 · 15/02/2022 20:20

Your concerns are valid.

Not much you can do - dear sister made a choice and no one forced her. I suppose it's a case of length of marriage, contribution etc. I don't think necessarily he will be entitled to 50%.

beautifullymad · 15/02/2022 20:20

@Northernparent68 it's not illegal to make a gift of your assets. But only if they are In your sole name and not joint names.

We are reading into this situation (I think correctly) that her husband may apply for citizenship then divorce her. But at this point in time this is speculation. No one has filed for divorce so assets can freely be given.

She is entitled to gift whoever she wants with her assets. But, if a divorce gets to the financial statements within 12 months of transfer then all must legally be declared. If it's 12 months and one day, she doesn't have to mention it.

My advice is to get everything done quietly and above board and through a reputable solicitor and a financial planner who deals in divorce.

VladmirsPoutine · 15/02/2022 20:18

Is it you that's worried that he might do a runner with half of her assets or is she equally concerned? Because depending on her position you might either alienate her further if she thinks this is 'true love' or indeed she might need to get planning if she fears the worst.

So he's been living off of her for 5 years just doing odd jobs here and there. So ostensibly a kept man?