Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DNA surprises!

311 replies

lynfordthecrab · 15/02/2022 15:46

So my DS is big on drawing up the family tree, which she has done very successfully back to the 1500s. She then decided to do a DNA match, and yep you guessed it, its opened a whole can of worms that wont go back in the can!
Her DNA did not match our DF (who is no longer with us) but did match DM. Before saying anything to DM she asked me if I would take a DNA test which I have and I don't match DF either. Now my parents were married 5 years before my DS was born and there is 3 years between us. The DNA shows we have the same parents but its not the DF my DM was married too!
My DS is all for confronting DM for an explanation, I'm not fussed one way or the other, it doesn't change who I am. For me DF will always be the one that brought me up.
However because DS doesn't live in the same country, if she does the confrontation I'm the one that has to sort out the aftermath as she wont be here. I understand she has a need to know.
Neither of us are close to DM emotionally but due to her age now she is quite dependent on me.
Thoughts oh wise ones?

OP posts:
OhFuckBloodyHell · 15/02/2022 18:35

Even if he isn't your father, it doesn't mean ivf or affair. There's gags about turkey basters for a reason....

But, I think what I would do, is cross of people who you know you definitely aren't related to, via their dna.

So great uncle bobs grandson? - no match to his dna. Cross him off.

But great uncle bob? He's still in play. Maybe his DIL was cheating / they used ivf /adopted / whatever.

Hopefully that way you can work out where the definite lines of 'not related' fall, and can reduce the possibilities.

Remember there are possibilities that no one alive today would know about - DF may have been adopted and never told. (ffs, my dgm born in the 20s has a 'brother' that was actually the neighbour's - they just fucked off one day and left him behind!!) I'd really really not want my sister going off half cocked and accusing DM of something.

BestKnitterInScotland · 15/02/2022 18:35

It’s not a question of doing the tests properly. That’s very accurate. It’s interpreting the results which can be very tricky.

Gwenhwyfar · 15/02/2022 18:34

"There are ethical considerations first though. These sites are used by crime enforcement to solve crimes, and some jurisdictions have the death penalty."

Interesting. Important to avoid US sites then as I suppose a lot of American companies own these things like they do other sites. Or is data from Europe protected?

RedHelenB · 15/02/2022 18:33

[quote lynfordthecrab]@BestKnitterInScotland
you really are rather rude!
How am I leaping to my own conclusions?
My sister has a degree in genealogy - she knows what she is doing and she knows what the matches are and what they mean[/quote]
But how do you know if the company have done the DNA tests properly. Without your Dad's dna you can't be 100% sure. I'd let it go, you'll juat make yourselves miserable as there is no way of categorically knowing the truth

BestKnitterInScotland · 15/02/2022 18:32

No intention to be rude. But Ancestry only suggests how other people who have taken tests may fit into your tree. As I said, cousin dna matches is a range from approx 400 to 1400. There are other possibilities which can’t be discounted.

AcrossthePond55 · 15/02/2022 18:30

[quote lynfordthecrab]@AcrossthePond55 you are correct and have worded it much better than I can.
definitely not IVF that was relitively new and very very expensive way back then, would not have been an option[/quote]
Then I think my next step would be to try and trace the connection through this cousin so as to leave your mum out of it for as long as possible. Again, not an expert, but I'd think if they were cooperative you should be able to find out some 'possibles' and whether or not they lived in the same area as your parents during the time of your and DS's conceptions.

If cousin's family/uncle has no connections to your parent's area of residence at that time then chances are your dad was adopted. If there is, then I think you'd have to ask your mum.

Of course, it's entirely possible that this cousin is adopted. That would be another dead end. If someone contacted me as a DNA match wanting to find her bio-father I'd have no info to give them as I know nothing about him.

lynfordthecrab · 15/02/2022 18:27

@BestKnitterInScotland
you really are rather rude!
How am I leaping to my own conclusions?
My sister has a degree in genealogy - she knows what she is doing and she knows what the matches are and what they mean

OP posts:
NatashaBedwouldbenice · 15/02/2022 18:26

Can you get DNA from someone close on your dad's side? Would that help?

Yes it would absolutely.

Georgyporky · 15/02/2022 18:26

How long ago did DF die ?
Is it possible that DM might have something with his DNA on it? Lock of hair, hairbrush etc ?

HeadPain · 15/02/2022 18:25

I've read this thread and it's confusing but I don't think the conclusion your sister has come to is necessarily the right conclusion, and I wouldn't be so sure/wouldn't confront your mother unless you're more sure. Can you get DNA from someone close on your dad's side? Would that help?

anyhue · 15/02/2022 18:23

I've had direct experience of this with a DSis (one child not her DHs). This was just a total shock to me, and I still don't know the details. What was meant to be a nice family research project turned into something else altogether.

WonderfulYou · 15/02/2022 18:23

How old are you? It was unusual back in the 60s/70s/80s for people to wait to start a family once married. That makes me think that it taking 5 years means that there may have been a fertility problem.

This is very true!

Are you 100% sure that’s when they got married?

I recently found out my mum got married years after she told us. I’m not really sure of the reason she lied as it had no effect on us.

NatashaBedwouldbenice · 15/02/2022 18:21

DNA Is complex and you really don't understand what you're doing OP. There are lots of possibilities and "mum had an affair" is just one of dozens.

Yes, this reads a bit like research for a novel.

BestKnitterInScotland · 15/02/2022 18:20

Yes the sister does. OP doesn't though and is leaping to her own conclusions.

CharlotteRose90 · 15/02/2022 18:19

I’m going with the your dad being adopted route. One child from an affair you can get away with but 2 no I don’t think so . I think your mum would have tried you not going down that if she was hiding something. I get your sister wants answers but rather then asking on a forum she should be asking your mum and the rest of your family.

Zolla · 15/02/2022 18:19

@BestKnitterInScotland - OP has literally said her sister has a degree in geneology.. she clearly does know what’s she doing.

Flaxmeadow · 15/02/2022 18:18

But 99% of people who say they have researched their trees back that far don't know what they are doing...

True and also if a tree is wrong, and many are, then a DNA match can be very misleading.

Also trees are repeatedly copied without being checked, this makes others assume that everyone agrees the tree is correct.

There are multiple trees on ancestry that have an ancestor of mine with completely the wrong town of birth, parents and burial. Anyone looking up this same ancestor sees copy after copy of this original wrong tree. He was infact born 50 miles away, to different parents and is buried in England (not wrongly the USA)

BestKnitterInScotland · 15/02/2022 18:15

WHAT IS THE cM MATCH?????

Sorry for shouting but it's REALLY IMPORTANT. A first cousin can share anything between 396 cM and 1397 cM of DNA with you.

1200 - so within that cousin possibility range, could also be a half sibling. Or a half aunt/uncle.

500 - again within that range, could be a half cousin, a first cousin once removed, a great niece/nephew.

DNA Is complex and you really don't understand what you're doing OP. There are lots of possibilities and "mum had an affair" is just one of dozens.

Dreamscomingtrue · 15/02/2022 18:15

I’ve researched my Mum’s family back through her Dad’s family tree back to 1600 in Devon, there’s a cottage that he was born in there and still standing amazingly. Also a female living in London around 1660 from the same family tree, so it is possible to go back that far which just your parents DNA. It’s amazing to me that both of these ancestors were around to witness the plague & the Great fire of London.
And the Devon ancestor & his wife both lived until their 80’s which I found amazing as well when the death rate was so young at that time.
I’d love to know what diet they ate and I’m guessing they were probably farmers or Inn keepers as their cottage was near to the village public house!

Lunde · 15/02/2022 18:12

[quote lynfordthecrab]@Crucible we did consider this but very unlikely given the years we were born, how accessible it was then and the same father 3 years apart[/quote]
I don't know how old you are but a friend of mine who went the donor insemination route has 3 adult children, born several years apart, from the same donor. The clinic asked if they wanted to retain samples from that donor for subsequent attempts, The children are full biological siblings but not their dad's who was infertile.

My friend has always told her children about their origins - but many did not

NatashaBedwouldbenice · 15/02/2022 18:10

Hey @lynfordthecrab I've just rembered that when you do an ancestry website, you can download your DNA file for free and upload it to some of the other DNA websites for free, to find matches who may have used those companies instead.

There are ethical considerations first though. These sites are used by crime enforcement to solve crimes, and some jurisdictions have the death penalty.

Bettyboopawoop · 15/02/2022 18:10

Clausits

Bettyboopawoop · 15/02/2022 18:10

I was talking to my partner about this a few nights ago with all this ancestry business there will be a lot of skeletons coming out of clsusirs.

lynfordthecrab · 15/02/2022 18:09

@AcrossthePond55 you are correct and have worded it much better than I can.
definitely not IVF that was relitively new and very very expensive way back then, would not have been an option

OP posts:
Justkeeppedaling · 15/02/2022 18:08

Does either of you look like the man you thought was your father?

Swipe left for the next trending thread