Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DNA surprises!

311 replies

lynfordthecrab · 15/02/2022 15:46

So my DS is big on drawing up the family tree, which she has done very successfully back to the 1500s. She then decided to do a DNA match, and yep you guessed it, its opened a whole can of worms that wont go back in the can!
Her DNA did not match our DF (who is no longer with us) but did match DM. Before saying anything to DM she asked me if I would take a DNA test which I have and I don't match DF either. Now my parents were married 5 years before my DS was born and there is 3 years between us. The DNA shows we have the same parents but its not the DF my DM was married too!
My DS is all for confronting DM for an explanation, I'm not fussed one way or the other, it doesn't change who I am. For me DF will always be the one that brought me up.
However because DS doesn't live in the same country, if she does the confrontation I'm the one that has to sort out the aftermath as she wont be here. I understand she has a need to know.
Neither of us are close to DM emotionally but due to her age now she is quite dependent on me.
Thoughts oh wise ones?

OP posts:
Briony123 · 15/02/2022 21:32

Would it make sense if your father had been adopted? This happened a lot back then and would explain why you have no match with his close relatives.

Neotraditional · 15/02/2022 21:32

.

Gwenhwyfar · 15/02/2022 21:31

[quote Zilla1]@Gwenhwyfar certainly a clash of rights but I'm not sure everyone would agree a victim of rape or abuse matters are not private to her. Agreed in this case it's not likely but have known cases where it took place for years by family members. I see lots of PPS agree with the right to know though suspect if the DM told the DSis to FO then the best might be for the OP to ask the DM to leave a letter if she knows anything. Equally, unless I've mis-read the thread, it still seems possible the DSis is wrong in her presumption that her DF isn't her genetic father. It seems possible her DF could be her genetic father and it's his paternity in question or his status as an adoptee perhaps.[/quote]
Possible, but unlikely given the DM's reaction.

Mellowyellow222 · 15/02/2022 21:29

Surely without your dads dna you have no dues whether the new cousin is related to him

Mellowyellow222 · 15/02/2022 21:24

@Aquamarine1029

Your father could have been adopted.
This.

Why would questioning your mum be a confrontation? It’s a discussion

ShowMeTheSugar · 15/02/2022 21:20

Saying your sister already asked your mum who instead of denying there was something up muttered about it being no good getting brought it is a pretty big drip feed more than 10 posts in. Is there anything else missing from the OP? Or is this a conversation your sister told you she had but you weren't party to?

For someone with a degree in genealogy its also quite strange she's taken those findings and concluded it must mean your DFs DNA doesn't match either of yours. It's the one part of the puzzle untested, leaving two distinct possibilities and pretty poor for someone with a background in that kind of analysis.

I'd speak to your sister to understand what she wants as an outcome here because something seems very off.

Zilla1 · 15/02/2022 21:19

@Gwenhwyfar certainly a clash of rights but I'm not sure everyone would agree a victim of rape or abuse matters are not private to her. Agreed in this case it's not likely but have known cases where it took place for years by family members. I see lots of PPS agree with the right to know though suspect if the DM told the DSis to FO then the best might be for the OP to ask the DM to leave a letter if she knows anything. Equally, unless I've mis-read the thread, it still seems possible the DSis is wrong in her presumption that her DF isn't her genetic father. It seems possible her DF could be her genetic father and it's his paternity in question or his status as an adoptee perhaps.

NoCauseRebel · 15/02/2022 21:17

Not even if they were mega rich and you would be the only beneficiary? no. Not least because it wouldn’t be possible.

When my dad found his half sibling his sister started to say they should demand DNA testing so they could contest their father’s will if need be. Given he was actually married to someone else the money, assuming he’d had any, would have gone to his wife anyway so they wouldn’t have been entitled to anything, but either way, their sibling had no idea she had 5 other siblings,imagine having her inheritance questioned into the bargain. Hideous.

Branleuse · 15/02/2022 21:15

@Nancydrawn

I can't imagine a situation in which I would do one of these tests, if only because I don't want these companies to have my DNA.

Not a useful answer. But the ways in which people steam ahead without considering privacy is really stunning.

Ive done one, so have loads of my family. I have 3 new cousins that have been discovered via these tests. I think its fascinating and really dont feel concerned about the privacy aspect.
Lalliella · 15/02/2022 21:15

I think your DF was adopted and new cousin is the product of an affair.

shakeitoffshakeacocktail · 15/02/2022 21:07

[quote lynfordthecrab]@AcrossthePond55 my sister has been in contact with this cousin for over a year now. She only lives about 12 miles from me (the cousin), she even got her mum to do a DNA so we could discount cousins maternal side from the equation.
there are also a lot of links as to how her paternal uncles and my mother could know each other.
My sister did ask my mother last year when it first came to light and she muttered something about "what good is it bringing it up now?" and changed the subject so she knows something[/quote]
*'She knows something'
*
The line of the thread!! 😂

I'm sure she does! Even if memory can be a bit patchy

Gwenhwyfar · 15/02/2022 21:02

"I would leave it, and it’s your choice not your sons even if he did the research"

It's her sister who wants to know and it's as much her choice as the OP's.

dontblamemee · 15/02/2022 21:01

@lynfordthecrab when I did ancestry 4 years ago, I matched to a new first cousin that I did not know. It turns out she's my half sister not a cousin so I wouldn't rule out this new cousin actually being a sibling!

Gwenhwyfar · 15/02/2022 21:01

@Zilla1

Interesting PPs seem to this the OP's DSis' 'right to know' trumps the DM's right to privacy, possibly in case of rape, abuse or marital infertility and the repercussions in terms of the OP having to pick up the pieces once the DSis in another country throws that grenade over the wall, especially when the DSis doesn't have immediate medical concerns that require access to their genetic father.
I think rape by the same man years apart is possible, but not the most likely explanation. I think that while infertility and adultery are private matters they're not absolutely private to the DM when they affect her daughters as well.
Asdawindowandglass · 15/02/2022 21:01

The same thing happened to my dad (a relative did a family tree and found out his dad wasn’t his biological dad). He didn’t raise it with my grandma as his dad brought him up and was to all intents and purposes his dad, and she was very old. Why distress her? I would leave it, and it’s your choice not your sons even if he did the research

Gwenhwyfar · 15/02/2022 20:59

@Nancydrawn

I can't imagine a situation in which I would do one of these tests, if only because I don't want these companies to have my DNA.

Not a useful answer. But the ways in which people steam ahead without considering privacy is really stunning.

I think the cat's out of the bag with all of this now. You won't be able to stop people looking for the information they want.
Gwenhwyfar · 15/02/2022 20:58

"It's all very interesting. I think it's fine to say to your mum that you've uncovered something strange, suggesting your dad wasn't linked to X family, suggest maybe there's a mistake but ask if she knows any reason why that could be. Keep it casual, if she doesn't want to respond and tries to fluff through then leave it there. If she's willing to talk then she can."

She's already avoided giving the answer once hasn't she. If OP/her DS want an answer they'll have to be more persistent than that.

SwedishEdith · 15/02/2022 20:56

@Gastonia

Yeah.. I found that one too. It's a bit obscure though, innit Not for people interested in family history - it advertises widely.
Plus, OP said her sister lives in another country so may not even be a UK university. Strathclyde is not obscure though - it's where the great John Curtice is a Prof.
Nancydrawn · 15/02/2022 20:55

I can't imagine a situation in which I would do one of these tests, if only because I don't want these companies to have my DNA.

Not a useful answer. But the ways in which people steam ahead without considering privacy is really stunning.

CobraChicken · 15/02/2022 20:51

As various other people have already pointed out @lynfordthecrab you cannot know for sure that your dad was not your biological father. All you can conclusively deduce from those matches you have is that you are not related to who you believe you should be down the paternal line - but equally, neither might your dad have been.

He could have been adopted and therefore totally unrelated (by blood) to who you think of as your paternal grandparents.

Newschapter · 15/02/2022 20:51

@Bettyboopawoop

Clausits
Or even closets Wink

@lynfordthecrab my sisters want to do this too but as there are 9 of us siblings and my father never kept his dick in his pants I wouldn't be surprised to find half siblings elsewhere...

I do hope you get the answers you're looking for and that it's not too painful for you or your mum Flowers

Gwenhwyfar · 15/02/2022 20:47

"And neither would I agree to do any kind of DNA test to prove I was or wasn’t someone else’s far-flung relative."

Not even if they were mega rich and you would be the only beneficiary?

Zilla1 · 15/02/2022 20:47

HNRTT but without the father's personal DNA sample, is there a plausible way the DSis and OP can be certain their father isn't their genetic father instead of, for example as a PP has suggested above, her father was the OP and Dis' father but his father might not be his genetic father/he could have been adopted?

OnlyAFleshWound · 15/02/2022 20:46

@BestKnitterInScotland

Yeah.. I found that one too. It's a bit obscure though, innit

It's a "degree in genealogy" though.

Yes, agreed
JustUseTheDoorSanta · 15/02/2022 20:45

It's all very interesting. I think it's fine to say to your mum that you've uncovered something strange, suggesting your dad wasn't linked to X family, suggest maybe there's a mistake but ask if she knows any reason why that could be. Keep it casual, if she doesn't want to respond and tries to fluff through then leave it there. If she's willing to talk then she can.

None of my relatives can test because there is a known parental uncertainty in an older generation of our family, and it is for them to decide if they want to test or not. The trouble is that you can't test and just confirm or disprove something, by testing someone else could find you and then uncover the uncertainty. Perhaps once they are gone we could each consider if it's something we want to know or not for ourselves, until then it is their uncertainty to do with as they wish. When he's old enough I'll tell my DS what the uncertainty was, in case it ever makes him wonder, so he knows it was all known about and how everyone felt. The emotions could never be known from a DNA test. I'd advise anyone to think extremely carefully before taking one.