Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DNA surprises!

311 replies

lynfordthecrab · 15/02/2022 15:46

So my DS is big on drawing up the family tree, which she has done very successfully back to the 1500s. She then decided to do a DNA match, and yep you guessed it, its opened a whole can of worms that wont go back in the can!
Her DNA did not match our DF (who is no longer with us) but did match DM. Before saying anything to DM she asked me if I would take a DNA test which I have and I don't match DF either. Now my parents were married 5 years before my DS was born and there is 3 years between us. The DNA shows we have the same parents but its not the DF my DM was married too!
My DS is all for confronting DM for an explanation, I'm not fussed one way or the other, it doesn't change who I am. For me DF will always be the one that brought me up.
However because DS doesn't live in the same country, if she does the confrontation I'm the one that has to sort out the aftermath as she wont be here. I understand she has a need to know.
Neither of us are close to DM emotionally but due to her age now she is quite dependent on me.
Thoughts oh wise ones?

OP posts:
EmmaH2022 · 15/02/2022 22:52

@markusdam

Ancestry dna test work by testing your own saliva sample and match you roughly to where in the world you are most likely to come from and also match you to other people who share dna.

It will not say this is your maternal matches and this is your paternal matches.

You have to look at each Mach and see if your recognised names or people in their tree.

I don’t honestly think that you can say that you and your sister are not your fathers children just because no one on ancestry has matched with you.

Interesting, this is part of my confusion but I assumed there must be actual DNA samples available for such a conclusion to be reached.
DanielRicciardosSmile · 15/02/2022 22:48

It's interesting how on these DNA test threads, the OPs always ignore any request for centimorgan results.

AFP10 · 15/02/2022 22:45

Given that you say you're too old for IVF, sperms donation etc to be possible then either they used a known sperm donor or, and most probable, your Father was adopted.

markusdam · 15/02/2022 22:45

Ancestry dna test work by testing your own saliva sample and match you roughly to where in the world you are most likely to come from and also match you to other people who share dna.

It will not say this is your maternal matches and this is your paternal matches.

You have to look at each Mach and see if your recognised names or people in their tree.

I don’t honestly think that you can say that you and your sister are not your fathers children just because no one on ancestry has matched with you.

DCadult · 15/02/2022 22:44

NC for this. I am a donor conceived adult in my late 40s who found my donor through commercial DNA testing, and I do searches for others from their DNA results (donor conceived, adoptees, what we call NPEs which is people born to a different parent than expected often due to an affair).

OP, depending on your age (which is completely unclear from your posts, but you did say you were born in the early years of the IVF era which might suggest early 80s) you and your sister could be donor conceived and your parents could have asked for the same donor. If you are indeed what I would consider young (born in the 1980s or later) this is very possible as sperm was routinely frozen by then and people often asked for the same donor using retained samples. If you are born before the IVF era (1970s or earlier) this would be much less likely. Certainly if you were born in the 1950s, 1960s etc, they weren't freezing samples back then, of course donors could hang around for years.

I appreciate that you don't want to ask your mum if she has had an affair, had fertility treatment etc. But I'm not sure you can prevent your sister asking those questions, and it seems she is determined to do so. You said that in your opinion your dad was your dad, so hopefully there won't be a huge issue between you and your mum going forward. Either way, you can't unlearn what you have found out so far and your sister is clearly going to continue with her research. Very best of luck that your journey going forward isn't too rocky!

EmmaH2022 · 15/02/2022 22:32

Also, where has the DNA from your parents come from?

EmmaH2022 · 15/02/2022 22:31

[quote lynfordthecrab]@AcrossthePond55 my sister has been in contact with this cousin for over a year now. She only lives about 12 miles from me (the cousin), she even got her mum to do a DNA so we could discount cousins maternal side from the equation.
there are also a lot of links as to how her paternal uncles and my mother could know each other.
My sister did ask my mother last year when it first came to light and she muttered something about "what good is it bringing it up now?" and changed the subject so she knows something[/quote]
I am finding this quite confusing

So your mum knew the worms were going to be emerging

Is it that she is not bothered if you find out?

My gut reaction is not to trouble her but if she was prepared for this, maybe she will be unbothered...but then she would have told you before your sister went looking?

I'm inclined to let sleeping dogs lie.

DogInATent · 15/02/2022 22:30

Her DNA did not match our DF (who is no longer with us) but did match DM
Unless DF and DM have had the same DNA test done, this statement is completely misleading and could cause confusion.

When you're matching DNA from "sides" of the family, you have to consider that the error may be in the other samples. How do you know that the DNA reference you have on DF's side isn't the one that has the mismatched relationship?

DF may be your DF for both you and your DS, and it's someone else who's the cuckoo.

So my DS is big on drawing up the family tree, which she has done very successfully back to the 1500s.
Chances of getting back much beyond 1800 with any degree of accuracy/reliability are very unlikely. It's possible for a few family lines, but these are unusual.

Isahlo · 15/02/2022 22:29

So could it be that your father, isn’t related to his family. And you are related to your dad. Or that the other uploadee’s have a similar thing when there is someone else adopted?
I don’t match to my paternal family on ancestry because my dad and my aunt (his sister) are adopted.
My parents are 100% biologically my parents.

NatashaBedwouldbenice · 15/02/2022 22:28

There is no amount of centimorgans that conclusively indicates a First Cousin.

Hydrate · 15/02/2022 22:20

Hi @lynfordthecrab

If the 1st cousin's father is living, your sister could purchase a dna kit and get the cousin to ask him to test.

ViceVersa · 15/02/2022 22:17

I don’t know if this has been mentioned yet but does your mother have any other children OP except for you and your sister?

If not then I think this would point more to there being fertility issues on your deceased fathers side and your mother using a sperm doner in some respect. Perhaps a friend or similar.

The reason I say this is because if your mother was having an affair but also married to the man you believe to be your father then you would expect at some point your mother would have fallen pregnant to him as well? Unless he had fertility issues and could not get her pregnant. Seems odd that you would both have the same father and no other children were conceived in the marriage.

AcrossthePond55 · 15/02/2022 22:15

[quote lynfordthecrab]@AcrossthePond55 my sister has been in contact with this cousin for over a year now. She only lives about 12 miles from me (the cousin), she even got her mum to do a DNA so we could discount cousins maternal side from the equation.
there are also a lot of links as to how her paternal uncles and my mother could know each other.
My sister did ask my mother last year when it first came to light and she muttered something about "what good is it bringing it up now?" and changed the subject so she knows something[/quote]
Well, we may be putting 2 + 2 together and coming up with 5, but I agree that your mother is hiding something. And why on earth should she need to hide the fact that your father was adopted? What would be the 'scandal' in that?

Even if it was a situation one of your dad's female relatives (sister, aunt) actually being his mother (not uncommon years ago) or a male relative being his father (rarer, but I know of one), if I was your mother I'd much rather 'spill the beans' on that than have you think I'd had either a long standing affair or two affairs with the same man.

Here's a curveball and WAY out in left field. Could it be at all possible that your dad was sterile and that they had 'a friend' impregnate your mother (twice)? The fact that you and your DS have the same bio-father is what throws me.

JustLyra · 15/02/2022 22:12

[quote lynfordthecrab]@WonderfulYou my mum and dad had been married for over 5 years before my sister appeared and 8 before I did[/quote]
Depending on how old you are (and given you ruled out donation I’m assuming you’re not young) then your parents may have made an arrangement with someone when children didn’t appear early in their marriage.

I came across this several times in my family tree. Including one time when the biological father changed his mind about the arrangement and tried to gain access to the children.

Gastonia · 15/02/2022 22:01

Natasha That's interesting. I didn't realise my result was unusual. Only my very closest match is on the paternal side. The rest down to 45cm are maternal (and one unknown, who is probably paternal).

Fangdango · 15/02/2022 22:00

If your father was adopted or brought up as another man's son, I wouldn't assume he or your mother knew that at all, or knew it "officially". She may really have nothing to tell you.

welshladywhois40 · 15/02/2022 21:54

How old are you? My partner is 42 and found out the his father was a donor thanks to ancestry. As soon as his profile completed his new half sister explained what she had discovered.

Have a google for super donors late 70s -

Cameleongirl · 15/02/2022 21:54

Given your Mum's comment, "what good is it bringing it up now?" I'm guessing that your Dad was either adopted or the product of an affair (possibly suspected by him during his lifetime).

I'd question some PP's assumptions that people didn't wait five years to have children back in the '70's and '80's, as the Pill was readily available. My parents, for example, waited five years to have me in the 70's, because maternity leave wasn't a right back then and women generally stayed at home after starting a family.

I think the OP and her sister are her parent's bio children and the mystery is further back.

ChickenStripper · 15/02/2022 21:51

I would suggest that you go to one of the DNA specific groups on FB and speak to them.They are well versed in things like DNA triangulation.

NatashaBedwouldbenice · 15/02/2022 21:49

@Gastonia yes, I may have been exaggerating to say "nobody" but I have never once applied the Leeds Method to someone's results and got only the maternal side. All have had paternal results, even when the father came from a country with low Ancestry uptake.

(The only situation this would happen would be in the case of incest, which I am grateful not to have come across).

Gastonia · 15/02/2022 21:44

Also, nobody in the UK gets DNA results with matches only on the maternal side.
I'm not sure that is necessarily true. I don't know how typical it is, but I just looked at my first 25 matches, and all but two are definitely from my maternal side, by which time I'm down to under 45cm, and it's difficult to determine who they are related to. However, it is strange the OP doesn't give the number of centimorgans.

Hugoslavia · 15/02/2022 21:43

I think that you both have a right to know the truth. I think that it should be bought up with your mother or other relatives in a sensitive way.

ShowMeTheSugar · 15/02/2022 21:41

nozbottheblue have you tagged the wrong name? My comments on a drip feed are not relevant to the inheritance comments about, nor is pointing out the research failure in terms of discounting possibilities with no basis.

In case you did mean me, my family have researched our family tree, it includes adopted relatives and I think you've very much misunderstood the points being made.

nozbottheblue · 15/02/2022 21:36

@ShowMeTheSugar

Saying your sister already asked your mum who instead of denying there was something up muttered about it being no good getting brought it is a pretty big drip feed more than 10 posts in. Is there anything else missing from the OP? Or is this a conversation your sister told you she had but you weren't party to?

For someone with a degree in genealogy its also quite strange she's taken those findings and concluded it must mean your DFs DNA doesn't match either of yours. It's the one part of the puzzle untested, leaving two distinct possibilities and pretty poor for someone with a background in that kind of analysis.

I'd speak to your sister to understand what she wants as an outcome here because something seems very off.

Sorry ShowMeTheSugar but this just shows how little you know about inheritance and what information can be had from family DNA testing. You’ve obviously not done any yourself- maybe try it, it’s fascinating!
NatashaBedwouldbenice · 15/02/2022 21:35

Anyone genuinely in this situation would answer the question that a few of us have asked now - what's the number of centimorgans.

Also, nobody in the UK gets DNA results with matches only on the maternal side.