Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have hoped the teacher would respect our wishes

266 replies

Sixmonthcruise · 15/02/2022 13:16

Dd is 13/year 9.
Firstly, I know it must be difficult for schools when dealing with and addressing 1500+ pupils but one of her teachers is really getting my back up.
She has sent me several emails over recent weeks regarding dd’s school work but when she mentions my dd it is always in a non-binary way (ie they/them).
I have replied back a few times to state that dd is NOT non-binary and she wishes to be addressed as she/her.
However, she never replies back after my requests and with each subsequent email still refers to dd as they/them.
I know it may not be a big thing for many but it is really annoying me.
Dd does not wish to be non-binary (she has no issue with anyone who wants to be), she is more than happy with the sex she was born into and loves being female. She recognises and happily accepts she is she/her.

Would you be happy for your child to be continually addressed as them/they when you have specifically asked for the teacher not to?

OP posts:
rainrainraincamedowndowndown · 15/02/2022 17:13

She has sent me several emails over recent weeks regarding dd’s school work

I think your focus is on the wrong thing.

Happy36 · 15/02/2022 17:11

If all students are being referred to as they in these kinds of e-mails then YABU. Similarly, teachers use 'Dear parents,' and 'Your child' to save time (and not accidentally use the wrong name).

Why does your child need so many e-mails? This would be my main focus as a parent.

Does the teacher call your DC "they" in person or she/her?

scammedmum29 · 15/02/2022 17:08

The teacher will be using a standard format to ensure they don’t misgender a pupil- they/them is generic and not exclusive to non binary people.
At least the teacher is communicating with you- give them a break.

Rosscameasdoody · 15/02/2022 17:07

And this dilemma is what we have ended up with as a result of allowing a minority of people to wreak havoc with language for fear of offending them.

Tillymintpolo · 15/02/2022 17:07

@AssemblySquare

OMG the comments on here are just confirming that leaving teaching is the right decision for me. I can’t be doing with the entitled batshittery displayed by parents and their offspring.

Instead of quibbling over this stuff, consider how the relentless moaning impacts on those of us at the chalk face. There are over 10000 teaching vacancies on www.tes.co.uk - parents like you OP are partly responsible!

Completely agree
Rosscameasdoody · 15/02/2022 17:05

It’s perfectly simple. If you support the rights of people not to be misgendered and to be addressed by their chosen pronouns, then that applies to everyone. Your child has as much right not to be misgendered as trans or non binary people and if the teacher has been alerted as to which pronouns your child prefers, ignoring that information is misgendering.

AssemblySquare · 15/02/2022 17:05

OMG the comments on here are just confirming that leaving teaching is the right decision for me. I can’t be doing with the entitled batshittery displayed by parents and their offspring.

Instead of quibbling over this stuff, consider how the relentless moaning impacts on those of us at the chalk face. There are over 10000 teaching vacancies on www.tes.co.uk - parents like you OP are partly responsible!

Mummyoflittledragon · 15/02/2022 17:02

@Whatelsecouldibecalled

I've just had an email from my manager telling me I have to call a pupil they them as they are now non binary. However they don't wish parents to know so when speaking with parents we have to use the birth pronouns. I am not comfortable with this at all. As much as I wish to up hold the pupils wishes as a parent myself I'm not sure I would like this approach. It's so so hard to know what is right
The DfE guidelines changed in September 2021. I thought schools were no longer allowed to do this.

As for the op, I agree the they / them annoys me but I understand why. Teachers are under such pressure that this is not a hill to die on Imo.

Lovemydoggie · 15/02/2022 16:52

@JustWonderingIfYou

I agree with you actually.

If people can make such a fuss about being they/them you can make just as much fuss for she/her. More so as its actually factually correct.

I'd make a complaint just stating teacher is ignoring preferred pronouns- it's rude.

Agree 100%!
Iwab82 · 15/02/2022 16:51

It wouldn't bother me. I think it's hard for teachers to keep up, this is the safe option.

downtonupton · 15/02/2022 16:50

.

jcyclops · 15/02/2022 16:49

You could ask parents of other pupils in the relevant class, or suggest your DD asks other pupils in the class, about emails the teacher in question has sent to them. You will see whether the teacher uses they/them for everybody.

DSGR · 15/02/2022 16:48

Actually I’d hate this and I’m as liberal as anyone. They should address them by their chosen pronouns!

GracieLouFreeebush · 15/02/2022 16:43

It's just another case of everyone having to conform to accommodate the minorities. It's annoying and insulting
It’s really not. It’s a case of emailing maybe 20 parents and it taking 15minutes out of a day rather than an hour. Meaning I can then focus on other aspects of my job that need doing and leaving work at a reasonable time.

MaggieMooh · 15/02/2022 16:41

I would make a complaint on principle. The teacher cannot refuse to use your child’s preferred pronouns, it’s misgendering.

Fairislefandango · 15/02/2022 16:38

Honestly I think it's just the norm now and is easier when the children change their pronouns regularly. My child uses they pronouns when referring to their friends now even if they're still she/he. Makes sure you're not misgendering someone.

If by 'misgendering' you mean referring to people by pronouns which aren't the ones by which they wish to be referred to, then no it does not avoid misgendering. I am a woman and wish to be referred to by the pronouns which match my sex - i.e. she, not they.

I suspect that when people talk about avoiding misgendering people, they really just mean avoiding offending only trans and non-binary people, but fuck everyone else (i.e. the vast, vast majority of human beings). That vast majority of individuals can damn well be called 'they' and 'cis' etc whether they like it it not.

Oblomov22 · 15/02/2022 16:37

It would bother me. I don't think it's right.

christinarossetti19 · 15/02/2022 16:36

Although this would piss me off no end, the fact that it's just this one teacher (who I would like to keep on side) means that I would probably let it go for the moment especially if my dd was not aware of it.

The teacher may or may not be invested in gender ideology - it may just be a habit she's developed over the years, so that she doesn't get it wrong.

Yes fucking irritating, but escalating it would be a sort of confirming the idea that pronouns used about you when you're not there are REALLY IMPORTANT and definitely MUCH MORE IMPORTANT that the content of the emails.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 15/02/2022 16:35

I wouldnt care. Its probably easier for a lot of teachers to just use they/them for everyone rather than accidentally getting a wrong pronoun and the chaos that would then ensue when the child felt invalidated and the teacher got death threats.

But they are using a wrong pronoun - deliberately - if they refer to a single child of known/acknowledged male or female sex as 'they'. Why is 'they' seen as some kind of neutral default?

People used to just use 'he' as a 'neutral' pronoun for everybody, rather than have to bother thinking whether what they were saying also referred to females - should we have just continued doing that in modern speech and not expect any 'non-he' people to mind, care or object?

Dovecare · 15/02/2022 16:29

I think she is cheeky. How dare the school force their standards on you. Write to the head.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 15/02/2022 16:28

Have you thought the teacher is talking in the 3rd person rather than non binary?

It's not common/standard English to refer to a single person as 'they' in the third person when you know the actual person and his or her sex that you're talking about.

I'm emailing regarding Jessica, and the issues with them not completing their homework. This has happened a lot and I've spoken to them on numerous occasions.

Yes, my response to that would be to ask why Jessica is being singled out or has been made the spokeswoman/scapegoat when the whole class (or multiple members of the class) have reportedly not been completing their homework.

Heard your grandma's been poorly. How are they doing?

If you said that to me, I'd naturally assume you were referring to the medical team looking after her and say something like "Well, they've run some tests on her and are continuing to monitor her situation before they can decide when she'll be able to be discharged." Of course, 'they' could indeed just be referring to a single doctor or nurse, if you don't know their name and what sex they are.

If you said 'she' or 'her', it would be obvious that you meant Grandma. Language is designed/has developed as a sophisticated way of communication - why go out of your way to complicate matters and confuse people?

but the persons gender choice has already been stated by use of the word "grandma"

You're allowed more than one sex signifier! Just because you've already identified her as a female by calling her grandma, doesn't mean that you don't need to use female pronouns in continuing referring to her - the opposite, in fact.

Fatmax22 · 15/02/2022 16:26

@FairyCakeWings

I don’t think this is something that should just be brushed aside as if it doesn’t matter. It does matter, and personally I’d be prepared to put in a formal complaint about it. It’s rude and disrespectful to your daughter, and it sends the message that she is irrelevant to her teacher. People would be quick enough to complain about a teacher ‘misgendering’ them if they were trans.
Thank you, great post.
Branleuse · 15/02/2022 16:24

I wouldnt care. Its probably easier for a lot of teachers to just use they/them for everyone rather than accidentally getting a wrong pronoun and the chaos that would then ensue when the child felt invalidated and the teacher got death threats.

EdenFlower · 15/02/2022 16:22

It's just another case of everyone having to conform to accommodate the minorities. It's annoying and insulting.

ChateauMargaux · 15/02/2022 16:20

Oh the irony... it is irritating.