Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have hoped the teacher would respect our wishes

266 replies

Sixmonthcruise · 15/02/2022 13:16

Dd is 13/year 9.
Firstly, I know it must be difficult for schools when dealing with and addressing 1500+ pupils but one of her teachers is really getting my back up.
She has sent me several emails over recent weeks regarding dd’s school work but when she mentions my dd it is always in a non-binary way (ie they/them).
I have replied back a few times to state that dd is NOT non-binary and she wishes to be addressed as she/her.
However, she never replies back after my requests and with each subsequent email still refers to dd as they/them.
I know it may not be a big thing for many but it is really annoying me.
Dd does not wish to be non-binary (she has no issue with anyone who wants to be), she is more than happy with the sex she was born into and loves being female. She recognises and happily accepts she is she/her.

Would you be happy for your child to be continually addressed as them/they when you have specifically asked for the teacher not to?

OP posts:
Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 15/02/2022 19:38

Well it's misgendering isn't it? If the trans lobbyist want respect for their chosen ways to be addressed, they should also respect others. If the teacher can't remember who wants what....well that's where the whole house of cards starts to fall down.

SeasonFinale · 15/02/2022 19:31

Why have you showed your DD emails addressed to you in any event? if there is a behavioural or work issue you can discuss these with her without even showing them to her.

I would concentrate in sorting out DD's misbehaviour or unacceptable work rather than bring up non issued just because you can.

MrsTophamHat · 15/02/2022 18:44

Depends on the email. If it was specifically composed about your daughter then you'd have more grounds to be annoyed, however if this is an email she has adapted to be sent to multiple parents then I think use of neutral pronouns is efficient.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 15/02/2022 18:27

If DD was a girl and the teacher kept saying he or she wanted to identify as male but the teacher kept saying she - than fair enough - but no one would have a problem with being called they.

I would have a problem with being called 'they' by a person who knows me, knows my sex and is writing/talking specifically about me.

Your name is a proper noun and he/she/they are pronouns. Therefore, if you don't care about somebody using the correct pronoun when referring to you, why would you care if they use your correct proper noun (name) or not?

If they're going to decide that a particular random pronoun is neutral, and suitable for everybody, regardless of their actual pronouns, why would they not be just as valid in picking a random name and referring to every single child as 'Bob' or 'Ann' or whatever? It makes no more or no less sense than with pronouns.

VioletWitchery1 · 15/02/2022 18:14

I can understand why this is annoying. Girls fight hard for recognition and to reduce her to incorrect pronouns is insulting. To ask this saying you'd be more concerned about how many emails are being sent, this teachers attitude could be part of the problem. If she is overly pushing gender ideology then she could be negatively focusing on the students who are not going along with it. I'd request clarification from the head of school and governor's and then tailor my next email accordingly to the teacher.

LaughingCat · 15/02/2022 18:14

Not read the thread all the way through so prolly already been said/addressed a hundred times.

So, I refer to everyone as they/them. It’s not a non-binary thing - I’ve always done it, since I was a kid. Before the words ‘non-binary’ or ‘cis-gendered’ ever entered my lexicon. I think Mickey Flanagan even did a sketch about how women don’t worry about how to address people - we just address everyone as ‘they/them’.

Is it a big deal? I would refer to your child in the same way if in the teacher’s shoes and on getting your requests, I’d probably roll my eyes and ignore it just the same, too. I mean, had you even considered that this might not even be a gendered thing?

They/them predates the whole gender debate. Everyone seriously gets their panties in a twist about it and I just don’t get why. (For context, I’m genderfluid but go by she/her if anything as biologically, I’m female and mentally, I’m don’tgiveafuck).

Alittlepotofrosie · 15/02/2022 18:13

*FairyCakeWings

I don’t think this is something that should just be brushed aside as if it doesn’t matter. It does matter, and personally I’d be prepared to put in a formal complaint about it. It’s rude and disrespectful to your daughter, and it sends the message that she is irrelevant to her teacher. People would be quick enough to complain about a teacher ‘misgendering’ them if they were trans*

Teachers are being driven out of the profession in droves, yet this is what you think they should be spending their time doing? Dealing with a formal complaint because your kid got called a gender neutral pronoun?

Can you just imagine being that teacher, after a 12 hour day dealing with self important teenagers, bratty teenagers, bad behaviour, mountains of paperwork, then getting a complaint about something as pathetic as pronouns because they referred to a girl as "they".

FairyCakeWings · 15/02/2022 18:00

They have been informed by SLT that all student communication must be neutral now as in they/them.

And this is why the parents who want their children to continue to be referred to by what and who they are need to complain equally as loudly as the ones who instigated the nonsense.

OfstedOffred · 15/02/2022 17:59

Yanbu. If we are required to respect the choices of non binary we must respect the pronoun choices of everyone.

We don't all have to become something we are not.

peboh · 15/02/2022 17:56

I don't believe this is a new thing though. I remember letters from when I was in secondary school that used they/them in communication. Usually it's a standard template that teachers use so they don't have to change up every email, or risk sending the wrong template out to the wrong child. I think it's still to get worked up over something this minor.

MadMadMadamMim · 15/02/2022 17:52

My DD teaches. They have been informed by SLT that all student communication must be neutral now as in they/them.

This is because of numerous complaints from parents who wish their female daughter to be referred to as he/him or they/them. And also the odd parent whose son now wishes to be she/her. I imagine it has come as guidance from the Education Department and certainly no school would ever now be able to say Don't be utterly ridiculous, Sandra. You aren't a boy, and we're not referring to you as 'he' just because you wish you had a penis which is basically what they would have done when I was in school.

They/them is probably coming from the powers above. So by all means fuck about wasting the teacher's time by repeated emails saying you want your dd referred to as she - rather than dealing with the actual issue and the reason the teacher has to keep emailing.

And the teacher will keep ignoring you if they have been instructed by their senior management that they have to send neutral emails.

FanFckingTastic · 15/02/2022 17:51

All the posters here claiming that pronouns are irrelevant, and inoffensive... I wonder if the same pronouns would be considered in this way if they were being used in a way that a mis-gendered a child that had specified that they wanted to be referred to as he rather than she, or she rather than he? If Teachers have agreed to refer to students in a specific way based on the students preferences then this should either be observed in all cases, or not at all.

Krapom · 15/02/2022 17:46

@amnm

I think it's very possible she has a standard template she uses for pupils which will refer to they/them, rather than he/him & she/her to avoid having to change the email for each student.

I don't really think this is meant to suggest your dd is non-binary.

This will be it. How does she refer to your daughter in person?
Abhannmor · 15/02/2022 17:41

They as a singular always annoys the hell out of me. I don't care if Chaucer uses it. It sounds vague, ill defined and sloppy. But it may not be the result of some directive? I'd just ignore it and keep using her correct pronouns in your replies.

Dogmatix34 · 15/02/2022 17:39

I use mail merge to email parents and try to avoid they/ them by continually “insert pupil’s name here” but somehow one always gets in! No way have I got time to separate the list into boy/girl. I also send emails on behalf of whole department and often wouldn’t know if it was a boy or girl based on name alone. Large number of EAL pupils in our school.

Fairislefandango · 15/02/2022 17:39

It’s really not. It’s a case of emailing maybe 20 parents and it taking 15minutes out of a day rather than an hour. Meaning I can then focus on other aspects of my job that need doing and leaving work at a reasonable time.

The OP said the emails are specific to her daughter and also include her name. So presumably the teacher is already personalising each one if it's a letter that's being sent to multiple students.

I agree that if you're sending a generic email saying "If your son/daughter is blah blah blah, they should etc etc", but if you're emailing about a specific individual, it should be he/she etc. What's next, school reports all referring to 'they'? Ridiculous. I'm a teacher too btw.

WonderfulYou · 15/02/2022 17:38

It would piss me off too, as long as DD wanted to be addressed by her chosen "pronouns" identifying as female she has that right. Doesn't anyone else see the irony here?

Wow people are really reaching here.

If DD was a girl and the teacher kept saying he or she wanted to identify as male but the teacher kept saying she - than fair enough - but no one would have a problem with being called they.

I can’t believe anyone is actually trying to make this into a thing.
It’s actually quite embarrassing to read.

WonderfulYou · 15/02/2022 17:36

YABU
Stop projecting your issues onto your daughter.

No wonder the teacher hasn’t replied.

tigger1001 · 15/02/2022 17:35

@Fatmax22

It would piss me off too, as long as DD wanted to be addressed by her chosen "pronouns" identifying as female she has that right. Doesn't anyone else see the irony here?
I agree.
VickyEadieofThigh · 15/02/2022 17:34

@JustWonderingIfYou

I agree with you actually.

If people can make such a fuss about being they/them you can make just as much fuss for she/her. More so as its actually factually correct.

I'd make a complaint just stating teacher is ignoring preferred pronouns- it's rude.

THIS.

If we're supposed to respect everyone's pronouns, it includes those who want their sex-specific ones, too.

FunnyTalks · 15/02/2022 17:27

If I was a teacher I would probably use "they /them" as standard for all pupils in comms such as this. It is not fair to expect teachers to remember individual pronouns for all pupils in an environment where pronouns are no longer based on sex. Teachers have a staggering work load on top of the week of actual teaching and often struggle to get an acceptable work life balance.

Personally I don't have a gender ID or believe they are innate. I respect the fact that other people believe differently, however I don't wish to participate in the performative aspects of their belief, in much the same way I don't attend church /mosque /synagogue etc.. Using "they /them" as standard is a safe way of not getting it too wrong, without being forced to say words I don't believe.

I can't think of a fairer way to deal with this current situation where trans rights activists have told schools that sex based pronouns are no longer acceptable, despite the fact not everyone has a gender ID. I think there's something fair about the way "they /them" will probably piss everyone off a little bit without overly insulting sensitive types!

Seemssounfair · 15/02/2022 17:22

I assume the teacher is emailing about your child education, maybe focus on that instead of inoffensive pronouns.

SamphiretheStickerist · 15/02/2022 17:18

Yes, any gender. But OPs DD doesn't claim a gender, she is of the female sex, she!

Remember, it isn't women, GC or otherwise who are doing this to the language. If you don't think it matters then step aside for those, GC or Genderist, who do. You can join in when it affects you and you realise what the issue really is.

Museumland · 15/02/2022 17:18

I completely agree with you. I would find it incredibly annoying. I think the school should know that not everyone would like their child addressed in this way. Can't they use he/she/they thus catering to all.

newnameforthis76 · 15/02/2022 17:15

Get a bloody grip. ‘They/them’ can refer to anyone of any gender. It doesn’t mean anyone is suggesting your precious daughter is non-binary. Grow up.