Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask you to explain non binary to me (genuine question)

584 replies

crochetmonkey74 · 15/02/2022 10:05

I have a new non binary person on my team at work (I am a manager)
They present as female-very much so in dress and grooming, they have a very feminine name too ,they have told me that they are heterosexual and live with their partner. However they want to be known as 'they' and the pronoun 'MX'
I am happily doing all this, I believe everyone should be comfortable and I will address people how they wish to be addressed.
I'm a teacher so my new member of the team is continually being misgendered by the students (due to the incongruity of appearance and pronoun) we have other non binary more androgynous looking staff who are not misgendered.
My new staff member is a nice person but they are very aware of correcting people, and have already complained (not about me)
I'm keen to do this right and not offend but also despite trying to read around the issue, I cant find much about non binary females who present in a feminine aspect.
This is not a bait thread or a stealth moan. It is a genuine question. Anyone got any experience with this?

OP posts:
Ereshkigalangcleg · 15/02/2022 14:03

But we now have a problem, namely that not everyone is using the word in the same way, which hinders communication.

Yes, exactly. The waters are very muddy indeed, and it benefits trans activists and it doesn't benefit women and girls.

Zerogravity · 15/02/2022 14:03

If kids get it wrong, remind them
Why? Maybe they don't believe in your religion. Stop forcing them to.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 15/02/2022 14:01

This person isn't trans.

This person is trans. Trans covers a wide range of identities, from transsexuals who can pass as the opposite sex and have a gender recognition certificate to people who "change gender" multiple times a day. Through people who say they don't have any gender identity at all, which you would think would cover gender critical feminists, but no, we are told we have to be "cis".

MostIneptThatEverStepped · 15/02/2022 14:00

@Lostinafjord

I think it just means they feel neutral, neither male or female. How they dress may be because they feel a split between their body and their mind/soul? So presenting the body in a feminine way is fine to them, it's their mind/soul/sense of self that feels non-binary.
As do most of us, no?

There have been lots of threads on here of people trying to "feel" female and not succeeding.

PoshWatchShitShoes · 15/02/2022 14:00

I hope my sons stay boys/men. I'm not buying into this bollocks of Mx and the like 🤦🏼‍♀️ How does one even pronounce that??!

CanadianJohn · 15/02/2022 13:59

Sorry if this has been asked, I didn't read the whole thread (360 replies!), but does your colleague want people to use MX as a pronoun, as stated in the original post, or as an honorific, like Mr, Mrs, Ms?

babyjellyfish · 15/02/2022 13:59

@Ereshkigalangcleg

The trouble is, the word "woman" used to mean "biologically female people", and now it means something else we no longer have a word for "biologically female people".

Except most people stubbornly go on using the word the way it was always used.

Well, yes.

But we now have a problem, namely that not everyone is using the word in the same way, which hinders communication.

If I want to provide a single sex service for women, I now either run the risk of male people believing this includes them, or I have to explicitly state "this service is only for biological women and not trans women", which exposes me to the risk of being accused of transphobia or even getting into legal difficulties.

MostIneptThatEverStepped · 15/02/2022 13:58

@Ereshkigalangcleg

I did start to ask , but they said they felt it was triggering to explain it

What a very unexpected response. sarcasm

The ultimate shut down and get out clause.

It just won't do as an answer if they want people to address them the way they want.

TheKeatingFive · 15/02/2022 13:56

He'd have his own reasons for his appearance and calling himself male. It's just the same in this case.

It's not the same at all. In your example the children would be factually wrong in calling him female. In the OP's example, they're factually right to do so.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 15/02/2022 13:56

Tempting, but sadly not an option if you are their line manager.

Indeed.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 15/02/2022 13:53

The trouble is, the word "woman" used to mean "biologically female people", and now it means something else we no longer have a word for "biologically female people".

Except most people stubbornly go on using the word the way it was always used.

babyjellyfish · 15/02/2022 13:53

Anyway , the only solution was to never talk to this person again.

Tempting, but sadly not an option if you are their line manager.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 15/02/2022 13:52

I don't understand this bit of it

That the only people who aren't allowed to have the label they want are women who merely want their female sex acknowledged as a thing.

pancakesandsyrupplease · 15/02/2022 13:52

@WeeBisom your friend sounds batshit. How the hell did they justify expecting you you be a mind reader / fortune teller? Confused

babyjellyfish · 15/02/2022 13:51

I don't understand this bit of it

Basically they have redefined the word "woman" as a gender identity, which includes both trans women and "cis" women, but not trans men or non binary people.

The trouble is, the word "woman" used to mean "biologically female people", and now it means something else we no longer have a word for "biologically female people".

Saracen · 15/02/2022 13:51

Haven't RTFT.

You don't need a deep understanding of nonbinary gender to address this situation. Just address your staff member in whatever way they have asked (pronouns, title). If kids get it wrong, remind them. It can be tricky to figure out whether kids are making a genuine mistake or whether kids are being sly and malicious - but that's often true of schoolkids and you'll have dealt with that challenge before. For example, I have a difficult-to-pronounce surname; some kids would snigger and mangle it deliberately while others genuinely couldn't manage it.

Suppose you had a male teacher who painted his nails and grew his hair long, and the kids kept calling him "Miss" and "her". You might privately think the kids were making an understandable mistake and that if he really expected them to remember he was male, he should cut his hair and stop painting his nails. But it wouldn't be your place to say so. I'm sure that will have occurred to him. He'd have his own reasons for his appearance and calling himself male. It's just the same in this case.

PearPickingPorky · 15/02/2022 13:50

The pretentious identities of middle class young adults is something I find really tedious.

WeeBisom · 15/02/2022 13:49

Just popping in to point out that in 2020 the employment tribunal held (in Taylor v Land Rover) that non binary and gender fluid people are protected under the “gender reassignment” characteristic. So if this non binary member of staff feels discriminated against they definitely have a route under the equality act. Now , it is only a first instance decision so doesn’t create precedent but still…

Something that confused me… the tribunal said that non binary identity is “clearly” a case of gender reassignment and that it is “clear that gender is a spectrum.” But hold on… if gender is a spectrum there is no gender binary. Everyone , by definition, occupies a point on the spectrum. So everyone is non binary!

As for advice… I sympathise with you OP. A long standing friend of mine “came out” as non binary last year. The problem? They insisted the entire time I knew them (four years ago) that they had ALWAYS been non binary. So they kept complaining that I had constantly misgendered them, always used offensive language like “ladies”, never respected their identity etc. And that I was transphobic. It didn’t matter that I and other friends pointed out that they had actually identified as female for the entire time we knew them and the non binary identity was a recent revelation. Apparently they have always been non binary, gender identity doesn’t change, and they are deeply hurt by thinking about years of memories of me misgendering them. It’s apparently “besides the point” that they only came out last year. So I was being called a bigot, a TERF, etc because I should have had mind reading powers and directly contradicted her at a time when she introduced herself with “she” pronouns. Anyway , the only solution was to never talk to this person again. They were absolutely determined to make drama and fuss out of every interaction and make me walk on eggshells. It’s trickier for you because it’s a workplace situation, so I suggest you make everything completely formal and by the book.

crochetmonkey74 · 15/02/2022 13:47

I actually can't tell now which posts are sarcastic and which are earnest.

I feel entirely baffled and I am an intelligent, liberal woman who should understand it

OP posts:
crochetmonkey74 · 15/02/2022 13:46

@Ereshkigalangcleg

If I only want to be labelled an adult human of the female biological sex then I am shit out of luck because we do not have a word for that in the English language.

This is the kicker.

I don't understand this bit of it
OP posts:
pancakesandsyrupplease · 15/02/2022 13:45

(Or @babyjellyfish were you being sarcastic?)

pancakesandsyrupplease · 15/02/2022 13:44

@babyjellyfish
"binary.
Then they are transphobic and need to be educated.

Teaching them the curriculum pales into insignificance next to this."

This person isn't trans.
And being GC is a characteristic protected under the equalities act.
So how do you square that circle?

GladysAndFred · 15/02/2022 13:40

@RoaringtoLangClegintheDark

This is a great idea as I'm aware lots of students are being reminded/spoken to a lot about misgendering and it is a genuine mistake for them, they forget as my colleagues presents traditionally female.

To come at this from another angle, I think you are - quite unintentionally - participating in the wholesale gaslighting (which is a form of emotional abuse) of these students.

This is harmful to them. To be constantly pulled up for something they are pretty much inevitably going to do. To be told that they cannot trust the evidence of their senses, their own interpretation of the world; they are wrong for not censoring and pre-editing every single one of their interactions with this person, and for reading this person who presents as obviously female, as obviously female.

It seems to me this colleague is far more concerned with “their” own well being than that of the students. I would seriously question this person’s suitability as a teacher at all.

I realise that’s no help to you in dealing with the current situation but I just thought you might find it interesting to have another perspective. The adult is effectively claiming to be vulnerable relative to the students here, but that’s turning everything on its head. In the adult teacher/student dynamic, it is the young people who are more vulnerable - which safeguarding acknowledges.

What I see here is a teacher making the students prioritise “their” (singular) well being ahead of their (plural) own, and that’s not good. It’s a form of control.

How can we teach young people to spot the red flags of abusive behaviours in their personal relationships if we are allowing teachers and other staff in schools to behave in the very same controlling and gaslighting ways towards them with impunity? Not just allowing but enabling and encouraging?

I suspect you are used to living and working within a culture where it’s heresy to even ask any of these questions though, so I guess it won’t be easy to take this on board. And as I said originally, I am quite sure that you are acting from the very best of intentions.

It is worth asking yourself though if you feel your first duty is to the students in your care, or your colleagues?

This.
babyjellyfish · 15/02/2022 13:34

@PearPickingPorky

So a straight person who isn't one of the Boring Straight People, then.
I didn't know Laurie Penny had joined the teaching profession.
diddl · 15/02/2022 13:34

They have said how they would like to be addressed which is fine.

The problem is all the "triggering" that surrounds all this bollocks (imo).

People get things wrong, it's not malicious.

My kids wouldn't have got to adulthood without a shit load of therapy if they were triggered every time I accidentally called them by each other's names, the dogs name, the cats name...

Swipe left for the next trending thread