Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask you to explain non binary to me (genuine question)

584 replies

crochetmonkey74 · 15/02/2022 10:05

I have a new non binary person on my team at work (I am a manager)
They present as female-very much so in dress and grooming, they have a very feminine name too ,they have told me that they are heterosexual and live with their partner. However they want to be known as 'they' and the pronoun 'MX'
I am happily doing all this, I believe everyone should be comfortable and I will address people how they wish to be addressed.
I'm a teacher so my new member of the team is continually being misgendered by the students (due to the incongruity of appearance and pronoun) we have other non binary more androgynous looking staff who are not misgendered.
My new staff member is a nice person but they are very aware of correcting people, and have already complained (not about me)
I'm keen to do this right and not offend but also despite trying to read around the issue, I cant find much about non binary females who present in a feminine aspect.
This is not a bait thread or a stealth moan. It is a genuine question. Anyone got any experience with this?

OP posts:
Hankunamatata · 15/02/2022 15:05

This reminds me years ago before non binary when I was in high school many many years ago. We had a teacher who went on and on at us that we called her Ms (pronounced mz) not miss or mrs. She became a bit of a joke as honestly we didnt care and couldn't work out why she kept going on and on at us.

DdraigGoch · 15/02/2022 15:01

@WhatEvenHappened44

Here's a question. How do you all feel about a woman correcting someone when they are referred to as Mrs instead of Miss? Only pure attention seeking narcissists that do that yeah? Hmm
If I was somewhere as a customer (in the sort of place where you have an account and hence names get used), I may correct a mistake by a member of staff. As a customer I can do that.

Correcting a colleague in front of a customer? Or in this case a class? No, unprofessional. You do so quietly where the customer/class can't hear you.

babyjellyfish · 15/02/2022 15:00

@lifeturnsonadime

Oh baby i'd completely forgotten about India's (imaginary) cervix.

Grin

Sadly I haven't been able to expunge the mental image of someone showing their cervix on live TV.

Is it misogynistic to speculate about someone having a bucket fanny if that person is male?

Ereshkigalangcleg · 15/02/2022 15:00

But some people are neither XX nor XY

And they have a sex development disorder (which I specifically wasn't referencing in that quote as I made clear), and all of these can be categorised as male or female, and a DNA karyotyping can be carried out to discover this even where the sex of a person is truly ambiguous to the (puzzled?) observer. Which is extremely rare.

Marcipex · 15/02/2022 14:54

‘Yes, I am rather nervous as they said middle aged women in jobs above them are triggering to them wtf??? Imagine the hell that would break loose if you said that you were triggered by younger non binary women.‘

Exactly.

I think this teacher is going to be a menace to everyone else in the department. Looking for slights to correct.
I work with children and I am routinely called Miss, my name, mum, mummy, Dawn (colleagues name) etc.
In return I mix up Lila and Layla, Isla and Ayla, Luca and Lucas.
We forgive each other and carry on. Nothing happens.

lifeturnsonadime · 15/02/2022 14:54

Oh baby i'd completely forgotten about India's (imaginary) cervix.

Grin
Ereshkigalangcleg · 15/02/2022 14:53

Sorry I meant to comment on this:

I am in a book discussion group and commented on someone's "review" of an anthology of stories. They said they refused to read it because one of the stories was written by an author who is a "TERF". I questioned why they felt they could review this, when they hadn't read the book, and reminded them it was a book review forum.

They posted the same "review" again and I commented on this, and again reminded them it was not a political forum.

I was told that "This is the third or fourth time you've commented on this review. It's creepy and obsessive. You may want to work on your social skills." - I hadn't commented on the review three or four times.

I was told I was "not welcome here" and "my behaviour is unacceptable".

Massive, massive attention seekers attempting to use this sort of thing with impunity.

I imagine if you hadn't risen to it and given them attention they would have jumped on any post praising the "TERF's" story in a similar way, to make it all about them.

RoaringtoLangClegintheDark · 15/02/2022 14:53

ImJustMadAboutSaffron can I ask, what is the essential quality you share with India Willoughby, and me, and Helen Mirren, and every woman on the planet, and every male person who “identifies as a woman”, that you don’t share with any men (who “identify as men”) on the planet?

What is the defining characteristic of a woman, in your view?

babyjellyfish · 15/02/2022 14:53

Now I am confused. I was born female and now I'm an adult I'm a woman. Take for example, India Willoughby. She was born a boy but is now a woman. We're both women. Seems simple to me, even if only one of us menstruates. But then I guess Helen Mirren doesn't, and she's a woman too ......

What do you think a woman is?

babyjellyfish · 15/02/2022 14:52

There is not one thing, other than stereotypes, that we have in common.

What about a cervix?

Grin
DomesticatedZombie · 15/02/2022 14:52

"Is" sounds grammatically wrong, but "are" indicates more than one person.

Yes, it doesn't quite work either way.

pancakesandsyrupplease · 15/02/2022 14:51

@ImJustMadAboutSaffron India Willoughby is a transwoman.

DomesticatedZombie · 15/02/2022 14:51

Take for example, India Willoughby. She was born a boy but is now a woman. We're both women

In what way is India Willoughby a woman?!

babyjellyfish · 15/02/2022 14:50

But some people are neither XX nor XY…

None of them are W or Z though.

lifeturnsonadime · 15/02/2022 14:49

India Willoughby is not a woman. There is not one thing, other than stereotypes, that we have in common.

Helen Mirren is a woman every cell in her DNA makes her a woman regardless of her current reproductive capabilities.

Amazing how easy it was when there was a word , a collective noun, for all of the human beings who share the same sex.

It's not hard to work out which class of people benefits most from the removal of the language we have to describe ourselves collectively as a sex class. it's definitely not women .

RoaringtoLangClegintheDark · 15/02/2022 14:49

PuzzledObserver, I’m afraid you too have fallen for TRA propaganda (Wikipedia is noted for being captured by TRAs).

As others have said, there are in fact only two sexes, and everyone falls into one of them, even if they have a DSD/VSD. It’s somewhat dehumanising to suggest otherwise and many campaigners on this issue have asked for that to be respected.

And as others have also said, this has precisely nothing to do with gender ideology. It is used as an obfuscatory mechanism to try and hide the clear fact that one sex class has dominated, controlled and abused the other sex class throughout history and throughout cultures.

The clear fact that only one class of people can impregnate and only one class can become pregnant (whether they actually do or not), and that the members of one sex can, generally speaking, overpower the members of the other sex if they so choose - and so there are different risks for the two sexes, different outcomes altogether in the case of unprotected heterosexual sex.

And that it is consequently important to accurately name and recognise those two sex classes, and who belongs to each one.

Particularly important for feminism: if we can’t name our oppressors, or identify the reality on which our oppression is based, how can we fight it?

pancakesandsyrupplease · 15/02/2022 14:48

@PuzzledObserver

Sex is about reproductive potential. It is not a spectrum, and the existence of developmental disorders in both male and female people don't change the fact that human beings are sexually dimorphic. Sex is determined by gametes, not chromosomes but absent any developmental disorders all XY chromosomed people will develop to produce small gametes/sperm, as determined at the moment of conception, and all XX large ones/ova. Both are needed to reproduce.

But some people are neither XX nor XY…

But how many? And how many of those are trans?
Ereshkigalangcleg · 15/02/2022 14:45

Take for example, India Willoughby. She was born a boy but is now a woman. We're both women.

Why?

ImJustMadAboutSaffron · 15/02/2022 14:43

@Ereshkigalangcleg

The trouble is, the word "woman" used to mean "biologically female people", and now it means something else we no longer have a word for "biologically female people".

Except most people stubbornly go on using the word the way it was always used.

Now I am confused. I was born female and now I'm an adult I'm a woman. Take for example, India Willoughby. She was born a boy but is now a woman. We're both women. Seems simple to me, even if only one of us menstruates. But then I guess Helen Mirren doesn't, and she's a woman too ......
Abigail12345654321 · 15/02/2022 14:43

@Saracen

Haven't RTFT.

You don't need a deep understanding of nonbinary gender to address this situation. Just address your staff member in whatever way they have asked (pronouns, title). If kids get it wrong, remind them. It can be tricky to figure out whether kids are making a genuine mistake or whether kids are being sly and malicious - but that's often true of schoolkids and you'll have dealt with that challenge before. For example, I have a difficult-to-pronounce surname; some kids would snigger and mangle it deliberately while others genuinely couldn't manage it.

Suppose you had a male teacher who painted his nails and grew his hair long, and the kids kept calling him "Miss" and "her". You might privately think the kids were making an understandable mistake and that if he really expected them to remember he was male, he should cut his hair and stop painting his nails. But it wouldn't be your place to say so. I'm sure that will have occurred to him. He'd have his own reasons for his appearance and calling himself male. It's just the same in this case.

Sly and malicious? Are you on something?
PuzzledObserver · 15/02/2022 14:42

Sex is about reproductive potential. It is not a spectrum, and the existence of developmental disorders in both male and female people don't change the fact that human beings are sexually dimorphic. Sex is determined by gametes, not chromosomes but absent any developmental disorders all XY chromosomed people will develop to produce small gametes/sperm, as determined at the moment of conception, and all XX large ones/ova. Both are needed to reproduce.

But some people are neither XX nor XY…

MrsEdnaWelthorpe · 15/02/2022 14:41

Tbh I would assume she/they will complain about you at some point, and I'd keep that in mind when interacting with her/them.

LittleSnakes · 15/02/2022 14:38

Yes, I am rather nervous as they said middle aged women in jobs above them are triggering to them wtf??? Imagine the hell that would break loose if you said that you were triggered by younger non binary women.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 15/02/2022 14:37

want to comment on something I’ve seen stated twice, but not commented on, namely that there are only two biological sexes, male and female, and everyone is either one or the other. This is not true. A tiny proportion of people are biologically intersex, having chromosomes, hormones and/or genitalia which are ambiguous.

Sex is about reproductive potential. It is not a spectrum, and the existence of developmental disorders in both male and female people don't change the fact that human beings are sexually dimorphic. Sex is determined by gametes, not chromosomes but absent any developmental disorders all XY chromosomed people will develop to produce small gametes/sperm, as determined at the moment of conception, and all XX large ones/ova. Both are needed to reproduce.

This also has nothing to do with "non binary" gender identity.

EishetChayil · 15/02/2022 14:35

I absolutely hate how heterosexual people are trying to colonise LGBT identities. As a member of the community since before Stonewall went rogue, I find it tragic what's happening to the movement. It's become a caricature.

Swipe left for the next trending thread