Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask you to explain non binary to me (genuine question)

584 replies

crochetmonkey74 · 15/02/2022 10:05

I have a new non binary person on my team at work (I am a manager)
They present as female-very much so in dress and grooming, they have a very feminine name too ,they have told me that they are heterosexual and live with their partner. However they want to be known as 'they' and the pronoun 'MX'
I am happily doing all this, I believe everyone should be comfortable and I will address people how they wish to be addressed.
I'm a teacher so my new member of the team is continually being misgendered by the students (due to the incongruity of appearance and pronoun) we have other non binary more androgynous looking staff who are not misgendered.
My new staff member is a nice person but they are very aware of correcting people, and have already complained (not about me)
I'm keen to do this right and not offend but also despite trying to read around the issue, I cant find much about non binary females who present in a feminine aspect.
This is not a bait thread or a stealth moan. It is a genuine question. Anyone got any experience with this?

OP posts:
FOJN · 15/02/2022 16:40

Oh don't worry, India didn't show her cervix on TV. But she offered to.

To be fair if India had a cervix and had shown it on TV it would have added something new to the discussion!

FOJN · 15/02/2022 16:38

PuzzledObserver

That wiki entry is very interesting. I'd be willing to bet 5 years ago it said something very different. The reality we knew is being memory holed. I've noticed these kinds of changes many times.

People with DSD's are not a third sex, sex is not a spectrum and it is not related to gender identity disorder.

IntermittentParps · 15/02/2022 16:36

babyjellyfish, thank Christ for that.

ViceLikeBlip · 15/02/2022 16:27

@FatFilledTrottyPuss

Non binary people recognise that there are stereotypes associated with biological sex. They feel that these stereotypes don’t fit who they are as a person so they have decided that they are neither male or female instead of realising that stereotypes are rubbish and don’t define any of us unless we let them. Remember back in the olden days of yore when girls were brought up to believe we could be or do anything despite our sex? It’s the opposite of that.
Perfectly explained.
babyjellyfish · 15/02/2022 16:15

@IntermittentParps

Sadly I haven't been able to expunge the mental image of someone showing their cervix on live TV. Do what now? I vaguely know the name India Willoughby but this cervix thing has passed me by. I hardly dare ask, but... what happened exactly?
Oh don't worry, India didn't show her cervix on TV. But she offered to.

She doesn't have a cervix or even appear to know what one is, obviously.

IntermittentParps · 15/02/2022 16:11

Sadly I haven't been able to expunge the mental image of someone showing their cervix on live TV.
Do what now?
I vaguely know the name India Willoughby but this cervix thing has passed me by.
I hardly dare ask, but... what happened exactly?

babyjellyfish · 15/02/2022 16:10

@Marcipex

So MX is pronounced MIX? So MX Smith ? It sounds like MickSmith? Would I be saying it correctly?
I think if you called them MickSmith you would be mxgendering them.
Marcipex · 15/02/2022 16:07

So MX is pronounced MIX?
So MX Smith ?
It sounds like MickSmith? Would I be saying it correctly?

AryaStarkWolf · 15/02/2022 15:50

Imagine a middle class white male having the audacity to tell a working class woman of colour that she is privileged.

Oh.

We don't have to imagine it.

Amazing scenes.

Crazy times

AryaStarkWolf · 15/02/2022 15:45

@RoaringtoLangClegintheDark

ImJustMadAboutSaffron can I ask, what is the essential quality you share with India Willoughby, and me, and Helen Mirren, and every woman on the planet, and every male person who “identifies as a woman”, that you don’t share with any men (who “identify as men”) on the planet?

What is the defining characteristic of a woman, in your view?

Lipstick?
babyjellyfish · 15/02/2022 15:34

If I was to ask India if she is a woman, would she be offended? Probably yes. No wonder there is so much confusion.

She would probably offer to show you her non-existent cervix.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 15/02/2022 15:31

If I was to ask India if she is a woman, would she be offended?

You can determine the answer to this question by watching Celebrity Big Brother on YouTube.

ImJustMadAboutSaffron · 15/02/2022 15:28

@DdraigGoch

I was told that "This is the third or fourth time you've commented on this review. It's creepy and obsessive. You may want to work on your social skills." - I hadn't commented on the review three or four times. *@ImJustMadAboutSaffron* I trust that you told them that they may want to work on their counting skills.
I did think about that, but instead I just blocked them.
ImJustMadAboutSaffron · 15/02/2022 15:27

@nothingmorethanthis

Now I am confused. I was born female and now I'm an adult I'm a woman. Take for example, India Willoughby. She was born a boy but is now a woman. We're both women. Seems simple to me, even if only one of us menstruates. But then I guess Helen Mirren doesn't, and she's a woman too

See, this is the problem with this movement. It throws words around without meaning.
If you want to state India is a woman, you first need to come up with coherent definition of woman and then show how India fits that coherent definition.
If you want to make statements you need to be able to defend them.
We all need to able to do that. That's what accountability really means. Being able to defend your position in debate.

If I was to ask India if she is a woman, would she be offended? Probably yes. No wonder there is so much confusion.
babyjellyfish · 15/02/2022 15:25

@AryaStarkWolf

If I say, "I share neither a biological sex nor a gender identity with trans women so why should this identity that only they have be a reason for us to compete in the same sporting category?" there is no good response to that.

So they have to insist that we share this identity whether we like it or not.

Yes you share the same gender identity but your "cis privilege" is you not even realising ............

Imagine a middle class white male having the audacity to tell a working class woman of colour that she is privileged.

Oh.

We don't have to imagine it.

Amazing scenes.

JustBlethering · 15/02/2022 15:24

@x2boys

Do we really need , someone like this teaching ,young impressionable teens ,they ,need to get over themself,and accept they are not that special.
This
Ereshkigalangcleg · 15/02/2022 15:22

I think pulling you up and then just directing you vaguely to "the internet" as it's triggering to explain is ridiculous.

I wonder how they would feel about the OP asking MN, as she did "look at the internet" as suggested?

DdraigGoch · 15/02/2022 15:21

I was told that "This is the third or fourth time you've commented on this review. It's creepy and obsessive. You may want to work on your social skills." - I hadn't commented on the review three or four times.
@ImJustMadAboutSaffron I trust that you told them that they may want to work on their counting skills.

ChristmasPlanning · 15/02/2022 15:20

Yes, I am rather nervous as they said middle aged women in jobs above them are triggering to them

Imagine a 20 year old man saying this to his female line manager 🙈

I think pulling you up and then just directing you vaguely to "the internet" as it's triggering to explain is ridiculous. The individual should as a minimum signpost a website that they agree with. As there is no topic I can think of that would not have opposing information on different websites!

nothingmorethanthis · 15/02/2022 15:18

Now I am confused. I was born female and now I'm an adult I'm a woman. Take for example, India Willoughby. She was born a boy but is now a woman. We're both women. Seems simple to me, even if only one of us menstruates. But then I guess Helen Mirren doesn't, and she's a woman too

See, this is the problem with this movement. It throws words around without meaning.
If you want to state India is a woman, you first need to come up with coherent definition of woman and then show how India fits that coherent definition.
If you want to make statements you need to be able to defend them.
We all need to able to do that. That's what accountability really means. Being able to defend your position in debate.

Hankunamatata · 15/02/2022 15:17

I find it worrying about how often she is correcting pupils and how publically. I would have been mortified as a teen to be pulled up about this infront of my class or friends. It would have stopped me speaking in class or asking questions as my anxiety would have gone though the roof.

I do remember calling my first manager sir as we had been so conditioned on high school to use sir, miss or mrs.

ImJustMadAboutSaffron · 15/02/2022 15:16

Does anyone remember the segment on Mark and Lard's radio show?

Is it a bird?
Is it a bloke?
How the hell should I know?
Sorry I spoke.

They'd never get away with that now.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 15/02/2022 15:15

There are no human beings who are not either male or female. Disorders of sex development are not either a third sex, or no sex at all.

AryaStarkWolf · 15/02/2022 15:14

If I say, "I share neither a biological sex nor a gender identity with trans women so why should this identity that only they have be a reason for us to compete in the same sporting category?" there is no good response to that.

So they have to insist that we share this identity whether we like it or not.

Yes you share the same gender identity but your "cis privilege" is you not even realising ............

PuzzledObserver · 15/02/2022 15:10

But how many? And how many of those are trans?

Not many (well under 1%). And I have no idea how many are trans.

I’ve just read the NHS page on DSD/intersex, and for most of the conditions it does seem to say that people with that condition are either a boy or a girl.

I’m still learning.