Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask you to explain non binary to me (genuine question)

584 replies

crochetmonkey74 · 15/02/2022 10:05

I have a new non binary person on my team at work (I am a manager)
They present as female-very much so in dress and grooming, they have a very feminine name too ,they have told me that they are heterosexual and live with their partner. However they want to be known as 'they' and the pronoun 'MX'
I am happily doing all this, I believe everyone should be comfortable and I will address people how they wish to be addressed.
I'm a teacher so my new member of the team is continually being misgendered by the students (due to the incongruity of appearance and pronoun) we have other non binary more androgynous looking staff who are not misgendered.
My new staff member is a nice person but they are very aware of correcting people, and have already complained (not about me)
I'm keen to do this right and not offend but also despite trying to read around the issue, I cant find much about non binary females who present in a feminine aspect.
This is not a bait thread or a stealth moan. It is a genuine question. Anyone got any experience with this?

OP posts:
DdraigGoch · 15/02/2022 18:27

@UsernameIsNotAvailableRightNow

People saying things like "they is plural" do you never say in response to a question like "where's Sarah gone?" Something like "they went to the shop"

I probably half the time say he/she and half they just in reference to people in general.

I think this whole none binary thing is stupid but I don't understand peoples problem with saying they generally.

If asked where Sarah had gone, I'd always respond "she". I only ever use "they" in the singular form when the sex of the person/animal is uncertain: "Have you seen the doctor, what did they say?"; "That dog is barking again, I wish they'd shut up".
RoaringtoLangClegintheDark · 15/02/2022 18:22

Yes I have been thinking deeply about it. I think for speed of posting, I may have used reductive language but I definitely take the point and I think that this is an ideological debate that will gain in importance over the next few years

Glad to read this update, good luck with it all - and I second the advice from Thewindwhispers re contacting Transgender Trend or particularly Safe Schools Alliance for support:

safeschoolsallianceuk.net/

InTheNameOfAllThatIsHonest · 15/02/2022 18:12

I am so confused: is this person biologically male or female? Is their partner male or female? I'm trying to understand the issue - are they a biologically female, presenting as female, in a relationship with a male?

Thewindwhispers · 15/02/2022 18:10

This is an extremely tricky situation for you to navigate OP. The non-binary person (who has mental health issues) will react negatively to you if you approach them with anything other than total agreement and validation. They have several highly aggressive and wealthy lobby groups they can call on who will attack you personally and go after your career with bullying/discrimination allegations if this person decides you are anything other than unquestioningly obedient to their requests.

But. Your students have rights too, in particular not to be subjected to the very harmful consequences of the cognitive dissonance involved in being forced to say thst something/someone is not the reality they perceive.

So basically to sum up, you are going to have to choose between the whims of your batty selfish colleague or the rights of your students to describe reality.

I do not envy you! If I was in your position I would contact Safe Schools Alliance for advice, or Transgender Trend.

crochetmonkey74 · 15/02/2022 18:08

@RoaringtoLangClegintheDark

Crochetmonkey, I think you’ve had some very good advice on the thread in terms of how to manage the situation in practical terms (be on your guard with this colleague, document everything etc).

But I would really like to invite you again to look at this a bit more from the POV of the students here, especially as you have acknowledged that their well being is unequivocally your top priority.

You said in one post, I consider myself a very liberal person- I don't judge , i try to do what is asked of me to make people feel supported and comfortable, and I applaud your kindness and tolerance, which clearly spring from a real care for others and a desire to do right by them.

But problems arise when us doing what is asked of us by one person (or group of people) to make them feel supported and comfortable then makes other people - people who are potentially more vulnerable and more in need of support - feel uncomfortable, distressed and/or unsupported.

You also said in another post, and the students are just continually being corrected (not necessarily a problem) but they feel very guilty and some of our kids really worry about being seen as intlolerant or upsetting

I think the continually being corrected is actually a problem in itself - anyone who has experience of living with a critical parent or partner, for example, can attest to how it wears you down to constantly be told you’re doing something wrong. Especially when what you’re doing is actually a perfectly reasonable thing to do: when someone looks and sounds in every way like a female person, most of us would struggle to remember at all times, in all circumstances, not to refer to them as such.

And on top of that you know that there are young people here actually feeling guilty for “failing” to remember that this person doesn’t want anyone to recognise the fact she’s female, even though it’s apparently impossible not to recognise that fact when you are with her.

This is causing them genuine distress and worry. And I’m willing to bet that the vast majority of those feeling guilty and worried about this are themselves female, given that girls are socialised far more to be compliant and to “be kind” to others, often at their own expense.

Is this fair on them, especially given how challenging life can be during the teenage years anyway, how much pressure there is on young people, how much they will already be dealing with?

Like you and like many women commenting here, I always considered myself to be politically liberal, on the side of equality, tolerance and social justice. I am heartbroken actually to see the values I always believed in being co-opted in the service of an ideology that is at root, IMO, regressive and misogynistic (and also homophobic).

There is a real clash of rights here. And you have to ask whose rights take precedence.The right of this teacher to demand others verbally observe her “gender identity”, no matter how taxing for them, or how much distress it causes them when they can’t always remember? Or the right of the young people not to be burdened with this additional obligation in order to validate one of the adults who should be supporting them?

This is an issue that can’t be resolved by simply trying to be kind to everyone. There needs to be some real thought about the deeper implications and ramifications of this ideology that everyone is supposed to sign up to in the name of “liberalism”. Life sadly isn’t that straightforward.

Yes I have been thinking deeply about it. I think for speed of posting, I may have used reductive language but I definitely take the point and I think that this is an ideological debate that will gain in importance over the next few years
OP posts:
RoaringtoLangClegintheDark · 15/02/2022 18:04

Crochetmonkey, I think you’ve had some very good advice on the thread in terms of how to manage the situation in practical terms (be on your guard with this colleague, document everything etc).

But I would really like to invite you again to look at this a bit more from the POV of the students here, especially as you have acknowledged that their well being is unequivocally your top priority.

You said in one post, I consider myself a very liberal person- I don't judge , i try to do what is asked of me to make people feel supported and comfortable, and I applaud your kindness and tolerance, which clearly spring from a real care for others and a desire to do right by them.

But problems arise when us doing what is asked of us by one person (or group of people) to make them feel supported and comfortable then makes other people - people who are potentially more vulnerable and more in need of support - feel uncomfortable, distressed and/or unsupported.

You also said in another post, and the students are just continually being corrected (not necessarily a problem) but they feel very guilty and some of our kids really worry about being seen as intlolerant or upsetting

I think the continually being corrected is actually a problem in itself - anyone who has experience of living with a critical parent or partner, for example, can attest to how it wears you down to constantly be told you’re doing something wrong. Especially when what you’re doing is actually a perfectly reasonable thing to do: when someone looks and sounds in every way like a female person, most of us would struggle to remember at all times, in all circumstances, not to refer to them as such.

And on top of that you know that there are young people here actually feeling guilty for “failing” to remember that this person doesn’t want anyone to recognise the fact she’s female, even though it’s apparently impossible not to recognise that fact when you are with her.

This is causing them genuine distress and worry. And I’m willing to bet that the vast majority of those feeling guilty and worried about this are themselves female, given that girls are socialised far more to be compliant and to “be kind” to others, often at their own expense.

Is this fair on them, especially given how challenging life can be during the teenage years anyway, how much pressure there is on young people, how much they will already be dealing with?

Like you and like many women commenting here, I always considered myself to be politically liberal, on the side of equality, tolerance and social justice. I am heartbroken actually to see the values I always believed in being co-opted in the service of an ideology that is at root, IMO, regressive and misogynistic (and also homophobic).

There is a real clash of rights here. And you have to ask whose rights take precedence.The right of this teacher to demand others verbally observe her “gender identity”, no matter how taxing for them, or how much distress it causes them when they can’t always remember? Or the right of the young people not to be burdened with this additional obligation in order to validate one of the adults who should be supporting them?

This is an issue that can’t be resolved by simply trying to be kind to everyone. There needs to be some real thought about the deeper implications and ramifications of this ideology that everyone is supposed to sign up to in the name of “liberalism”. Life sadly isn’t that straightforward.

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 15/02/2022 18:02

Oddly, if a female teenager wants an elective mastectomy, these people never leap in to reassure her that she can be non-binary without surgery and that she doesn't owe the world androgyny.

LittleSnakes · 15/02/2022 17:59

Haha, I hadn’t even noticed I’d said non binary woman. It’s so confusing. It’s like that game where you have to say the colour that a word is written in rather than the word itself. It’s surprisingly hard.

babyjellyfish · 15/02/2022 17:59

@PurgatoryOfPotholes

According to TikTok, the saying is "even when I'm fem, I'm still a them".

Also: "non-binary people don't owe you androgyny".

So they don't owe us androgyny, but we owe them androgynous pronouns?
cuno · 15/02/2022 17:58

What a waste of time and resources that could be better spent on the children. Does she get any teaching done in between her correcting pronouns, complaining about Harry Potter posters, and tattletaling to you all the time?

Notahandmaid · 15/02/2022 17:57

@LittleSnakes

Yes, I am rather nervous as they said middle aged women in jobs above them are triggering to them wtf??? Imagine the hell that would break loose if you said that you were triggered by younger non binary women.
Sorry - but this comment made me laugh - “younger non binary women”. It just shows the mental gymnastics involved in this non binary rubbish. We’re all either male or female - but someone who claims to be “enby” would not therefore want to be described as a “non binary woman”.

(As an aside, I find it quite sad that so many young women want to adopt out of womanhood now. Yes, it’s crap being a woman at times but we can’t change it so should embrace it.)

mummykel16 · 15/02/2022 17:53

@UsernameIsNotAvailableRightNow

People saying things like "they is plural" do you never say in response to a question like "where's Sarah gone?" Something like "they went to the shop"

I probably half the time say he/she and half they just in reference to people in general.

I think this whole none binary thing is stupid but I don't understand peoples problem with saying they generally.

Whatever I say shouldn't be compelled by anyone, it should be my choice
TheMarzipanDildo · 15/02/2022 17:48

@UsernameIsNotAvailableRightNow

People saying things like "they is plural" do you never say in response to a question like "where's Sarah gone?" Something like "they went to the shop"

I probably half the time say he/she and half they just in reference to people in general.

I think this whole none binary thing is stupid but I don't understand peoples problem with saying they generally.

Sometimes it’s fine, sometimes it sounds really unnatural and ambiguous depending on the sentence (I live with a “they”!)
terryleather · 15/02/2022 17:41

They is very upset by the mistakes. I don't really know how these people are actually able to function.

Oh they and their Cluster B siblings in arms function just fine while they are able to weaponise their fragile identities to control and dominate all interactions, including interactions with children which is beyond the pale quite frankly.

Trying to facilitate these individuals is a fools errand as they will never be satisfied - that's the whole point.

Lostinafjord · 15/02/2022 17:41

@TheKeatingFive

I think it just means they feel neutral, neither male or female. How they dress may be because they feel a split between their body and their mind/soul? So presenting the body in a feminine way is fine to them, it's their mind/soul/sense of self that feels non-binary.

And we think it's reasonable to ask teenagers to absorb and act on all of that? 😵‍💫

No.
Lostinafjord · 15/02/2022 17:40

@DdraigGoch
OK, I was just trying to guess where they could be coming from

RoseslnTheHospital · 15/02/2022 17:39

"They" isn't always plural, no. As I said, you can use it to refer to an unidentified person or a person whose sex you don't know.

I don't know about grammatically incorrect, but it isn't usual to use "they" to refer to someone who you know and know the sex of. You could use their name, or he/she as matches their sex. The point oh pronouns in language is to help indicate who you are referring to, for clarity.

UsernameIsNotAvailableRightNow · 15/02/2022 17:31

I'd mostly use she too but saying they wouldn't be wrong would it? It doesn't always mean plural?

I could be wrong, I'm not the smartest person Grin

RoseslnTheHospital · 15/02/2022 17:25

I would say "she's gone to the shop" in your example because either I know that Sarah is female or I have made a judgement that she is likely female. I would only use "they" as a singular for an unidentified person who I didn't know the sex of and had no indicators either way.

UsernameIsNotAvailableRightNow · 15/02/2022 17:21

People saying things like "they is plural" do you never say in response to a question like "where's Sarah gone?" Something like "they went to the shop"

I probably half the time say he/she and half they just in reference to people in general.

I think this whole none binary thing is stupid but I don't understand peoples problem with saying they generally.

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 15/02/2022 17:02

According to TikTok, the saying is "even when I'm fem, I'm still a them".

Also: "non-binary people don't owe you androgyny".

babyjellyfish · 15/02/2022 17:02

@FOJN

Oh don't worry, India didn't show her cervix on TV. But she offered to.

To be fair if India had a cervix and had shown it on TV it would have added something new to the discussion!

Frankly, the only people who need to see anyone's cervixes are gynaecologists and midwives, none of whom have any trans women as patients.
montysma1 · 15/02/2022 16:54

What a crashing bore this individual sounds.
They is plural.

Larryyourwaiter · 15/02/2022 16:51

You must work in a very different school to me. If someone tried this where I worked it would not work at all. I imagine the students would use it as a challenge to mis gender them constantly and wind them up.

SexyLittleNosferatu · 15/02/2022 16:47

There is a doctor, yes a medical doctor, on tiktok who repeatedly tells people that she isn't a she and is non-binary. If doctors are telling young people this is possible, what hope does average Joanne Bloggs have?