Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Lawyers - thoughts please

92 replies

HuntyGirl · 14/02/2022 19:53

I am a solicitor, I qualified late 2020. There have obviously been massive pay increases of recent and pay wars between firms. I am at a large regional firm and on £47k currently.
Firms such as Eversheds and DLA have just announced regional NQ salary will be going up to £62k and £65k respectively.

AIBU to have a discussion with my partner soon(ish) to say that when salaries increase in September, as a 2 year PQE by then I will expect c. £65k? That's taking into consideration that Eversheds and DLA are obviously international and have a higher turnover.

The current NQ salary at my firm is £46k. Please can I have some advice around how to broach this with my partner and what my salary expectations realistically should be. (I am regionally based so not taking the crazy London salaries into consideration!)

Thanks in advance

OP posts:
Minibea · 15/02/2022 10:40

I used to work at Eversheds in one of their regional offices in a litigation team. I think if you’ve got a reasonable work/life balance at your current firm, your salary is reasonable for your targets and the work and team is good then I’d be very wary at jumping ship to go somewhere like Eversheds / DLA. The salaries are higher but so are the expectations - especially at 2-5 years PQE as that’s the time the partners are basically deciding whether you’re on the progression track or not. If TTC is something that is on your timeline in the next few years then I’d avoid the likes of Eversheds like the plague as the hours are looonnnggg. I went back full time after I had DD and I pretty much didn’t see her at all during the week which no salary makes up for IMO.

babyjellyfish · 15/02/2022 10:20

I'm a litigator

How compatible do you think that is with working part time?

When I was a trainee in litigation my supervisor (who was a senior associate at the time) worked part time and left at 2:30pm several times per week to collect her children from school.

She did leave during the afternoon without fail, but she would always be working in the evenings. It seemed to me that she was working a full time job for part time pay.

If you're in a practice area where you have to respond to things at short notice including court deadlines, either you need a really slick team where several people are equally up to speed and any of them can pick up matters in someone else's absence, or you will end up working on your days off.

As a junior lawyer, I think this will be impossible to manage.

You're still pretty young and so in your shoes I would do some real soul searching about what kind of job you would like you be in when you have children, in terms of specialism, work life balance, pay etc. You won't get paid a six figure salary for a 9-5 job in the regions. So you need to think about what your priorities are, and what working conditions would be the best fit. Then I would try to get that job before you TTC.

At 27 you still have time on your side.

Gardenista · 15/02/2022 09:55

post on rollonfriday for advice fromlawyers

HuntyGirl · 15/02/2022 09:54

@babyjellyfish

What practice area are you in, OP?
I'm a litigator
OP posts:
babyjellyfish · 15/02/2022 09:40

What practice area are you in, OP?

RainbowSprinklesAndUnicorns · 15/02/2022 09:25

Personally I would wait before TTC. The more senior you are, the more flexibility you have and the more you can delegate and WFH and the like. You're still very young.

The women at my old firm with children who made it work were either senior or well established in their career or came back full time and didn't see their children. A lot of mums and mums to be were made redundant in the last recession.

I left law as it was just not compatible with family life. The money was not worth the stress (and £ wasn't all that good either, large regional).

Sorry, I have a real downer on law from my own experience. But it can work. I probably wasn't determined enough.

eurochick · 15/02/2022 09:00

Bear in mind that these pay rises are going to have to be funded somehow. Client rates can only be pushed so far and partners are not going to want to pay for them out of the equity pot and see their drawings go down. So that means more hours.

ZenNudist · 15/02/2022 08:59

I'm not a lawyer but at a mid tier professional services firm dealing with lawyers all the time.

My juniors knew they could get more at a pwc or KPMG. They also know it would be long hours, not always interesting work and treated like crap, lots of stress. Everyone they know who made that move out of our team reports back unhappy so fortunately they have stayed at the lower salary.

I actually think that at z junior levelits worth getting a bug firm on your cv so you can prove your calibre. But you can't do that if you're going to TTC

ZenNudist · 15/02/2022 08:55

I think leaving is the best option. It's unrealistic to think you can negotiate such a pay hike. The reason lawyers move a lot is they get paid better that way and its good experience. Is there a health issue which means you have to TTC so early? You'd be better waiting 3-4 years. It could make a real difference to your long term career prospects.

Janesmom · 15/02/2022 08:37

OP, before you have this chat I think you need to ensure you’re “comparing apples with apples”.

DLA and ‘sheds are both very good regional firms and, putting aside London, they tend to be considered to attract the best work and best talent, so charge (and pay) a premium for that.

Does your firm do similar commercial work? Would it be considered similar clients/value/complexity? How do your charge out rates and target hours compare? Do you recruit from the same universities?

In other words, the strength of argument depends on your firm.

In London, there are MC firms paying nearly 200k to nqs and there are high street firms paying near minimum wage. For the reasons above, they’re simply not comparable and there are good reasons for the differences in pay (even though some high street lawyers are undoubtedly underpaid).

PenguindreamsofDraco · 15/02/2022 08:36

If you have panic attacks doing London-style work and hours and you want to be off on maternity within a couple of years, you're not worth Eversheds-style salary, put bluntly.
You get the pay for the hours and the work and the commitment, not for the fast track to the mummy track.
Sounds like you have a good work-life balance and that is important to you, which for someone 18 months in is unusual, in both respects. Don't fuck it up Grin

HuntyGirl · 15/02/2022 08:33

@gogohm

Asking is fine but it can have repercussions later so it's a balancing act. Are you prepared to leave? Are there jobs actually available at the proposed salary?

I know people doing my job that are paid more but they are in a different location or have worse t&c's weigh that up too

I would be prepared to leave for the right job. Yes, jobs are available at those salaries.

Will update my CV this weekend and then start having a proper look and be open to the recruiters contacting me

OP posts:
eurochick · 15/02/2022 08:30

[quote HuntyGirl]@Chessie678 agreed it would be difficult at a city firm. My colleague has a friend who is at a city firm and on her return to work after mat leave her partner asked her what her non negotiables were. She said 'I need to see my child at least once a day, whether that be in the morning to give them breakfast and drop them to nursery or pick them up in the evening and do bedtime, that's what I want.' I was shocked to say the least. That's not how I see myself as a parent so would never consider a city firm as I think that's ridiculous.

I agree that those things matter much more. I think this thread has helped me get some perspective back. I love my firm and was adamant that I didn't want to move but when I saw those salary hikes I couldn't believe it!

I imagine that is also true, going back to this job would be easy I feel as I love the work, have great support and a great team. Thank you for your helpful post[/quote]
That's the reality with most full time jobs though. I usually get to see my daughter at both ends of the day but the mornings are are just about running around the house looking for bits of uniform whilst nagging her to eat breakfast. Not exactly quality time!

I'm a partner at a big law firm. For salaries we are very much constrained by the bands and at the lower levels these are quite narrow. How it works at my firm is that each year the team is given a pot of money for pay rises and a pot of money for bonuses. We are told the pay bands and then have to distribute the pots. We have more leeway with bonuses - the salary bands mean there isn't a lot of wriggle room on pay. Your best bet would be to try to argue for a banding move across the board. Do you have an associate body to raise these kinds of things? Your firm won't be oblivious to the current pay wars. Eversheds and DLA only announced their increases in the past few days so give them a chance to discuss it.

Boombastic22 · 15/02/2022 08:18

I’d not be getting too carried away with salaries.

If you want to TTC at only 4PQE that is very early in your career. Where can you work which will give you flexibility (if you want any) and where you won’t find blatant sex discrimination (when you’re out for the year you may find you get all your clients given away).

Hate to say it but junior lawyers are pretty replaceable. Leave to get a higher salary by all means but you need to think of the long games. Most lawyers who are serious about their careers wait longer to have babies. Sad but true.

GOODCAT · 15/02/2022 08:12

Say you want to speak to your line manager before salaries are settled. You need market evidence of salaries, plus the performance in all aspects to make it worth their while to break bands. Most regional firms are under salary pressure. My firm will break bands but only for the really exceptional e.g. smashing targets, fantastic attitude, building relationships all round etc.

I have had people speak to me about salaries over the years. The ones that make it easy for me to agree and enable me to present proper evidence to HR, finance and the managing partner are most successful.

I did get a trainee ask me for more than I am on with 20PQE, responsible for managing a large segment of the firm plus central management responsibilities. He was unlikely to ever stay with us and his expectations were unaffordable so although I passed on the information it was always going to be a no.

HuntyGirl · 15/02/2022 08:10

@dynamitegirl yes, most of my training was pre-covid. I have better seniors! The ones at my old firm were truly horrid people. They were rude, derogatory, condescending, would ignore me when I spoke etc. Used to shout at me (not yet me - others too) in front of a room full of people. Genuinely just a vile place to work.

Also, I have now learnt to manage my own workload much better. I struggled with this as a trainee as felt I couldn't say no so quite often had many urgent things and little time. Oftentimes worked late into the late night and early morning. Was just a dreadful experience.

I take your point about being able to do and enjoy my job. I am good at my job and love it. I suppose that is priceless

OP posts:
HuntyGirl · 15/02/2022 08:04

@babyjellyfish I'm 27 nearly 28 and DH is 29 nearly 30.

That's great advice, thank you. Will have a think

OP posts:
HuntyGirl · 15/02/2022 08:00

@D0lphine that's true. We would like to try and have kids close together so I think once I start having kids I would like to stay at the same firm to keep it simple.

That's true, as were young so pushing back by a year wouldn't be the end of the world. It's not my preference at all but have to consider everything and would want to be in the best financial position prior to starting our family.

I would rather take the full year! I look forward to it and I know a lot of women who have really enjoyed that time with their babies.

OP posts:
HuntyGirl · 15/02/2022 07:57

@Chessie678 agreed it would be difficult at a city firm. My colleague has a friend who is at a city firm and on her return to work after mat leave her partner asked her what her non negotiables were. She said 'I need to see my child at least once a day, whether that be in the morning to give them breakfast and drop them to nursery or pick them up in the evening and do bedtime, that's what I want.' I was shocked to say the least. That's not how I see myself as a parent so would never consider a city firm as I think that's ridiculous.

I agree that those things matter much more. I think this thread has helped me get some perspective back. I love my firm and was adamant that I didn't want to move but when I saw those salary hikes I couldn't believe it!

I imagine that is also true, going back to this job would be easy I feel as I love the work, have great support and a great team. Thank you for your helpful post

OP posts:
HuntyGirl · 15/02/2022 07:53

@CayrolBaaaskin

https://www.lawgazette.co.uk/news/dla-piper-wades-into-nq-salary-war/5111430.article

https://www.thelawyer.com/eversheds-nqs-regional-salaries-rise-by-a-quarter-in-latest-hike/

Most recent articles.

I think when people start TTC or choose to have kids is a very personal decision. PP on this thread have also highlighted that TTC doesn't always follow a schedule and could take longer than expected. In my opinion, it's not too early and may even be prudent to do so knowing that many couples can struggle to conceive. I know that many female lawyers choose to wait until mid-late 30s which is understandable and completely their prerogative. I understand it in terms of security, career progression and pay etc but DH and I have decided we don't want to wait until then and that's our decision to make, no one elses.

I didn't realise they did so much in debt collection! Definitely not what I would want to be doing.

I agree, I won't ask my partner for a £20k pay rise. I think a good way to approach it is by saying that I expect to be on £5-6k more than the revised NQ salary (as it will be going up in September) as I know my firm does £2-3k pay rises for each year of PQE. What do people think of that approach?

I note your point about part time working and that is an important point. All the mums in my team (bar one) work 3 or 4 days a week and my partners seem to be OK with it! But you never really know until hard times I suppose

OP posts:
gogohm · 15/02/2022 07:50

Asking is fine but it can have repercussions later so it's a balancing act. Are you prepared to leave? Are there jobs actually available at the proposed salary?

I know people doing my job that are paid more but they are in a different location or have worse t&c's weigh that up too

HuntyGirl · 15/02/2022 07:45

@Fusillage I completely accept that and understand TTC won't always go to schedule.

Satisfaction is more important to me. However, I do want to be paid market rate for my level. Profits have gone up, it was our best year last year. Exactly - partners will be reticent to increase everyone by so much as it directly affects them. But so will losing a lot of talent in the current market. I imagine it's a balancing act for them.

I put in more than is expected of me which my partners pick up on and kindly praise me for. I regularly record around 30-45mins extra above my target everyday, I am involved in other initiatives within the firm, do lots of BD etc and I know they appreciate it. It's also nice having them be so vocal about the appreciation.

Lots of associates and senior associates (we also have a level above SA but below partner) are moving due to the market. I think they are going to have to address it.

OP posts:
HuntyGirl · 15/02/2022 07:40

[quote DragonMamma]@HuntyGirl the thing is, if smaller, regional firms paid multinational firm salaries, then they wouldn’t last for very long unless they hiked up their hourly rates and started going for the huge deals.

Nicely, I think you’re being naive if you think your salary has to match Eversheds or DLA, just because they pay more. The extra salary comes at a cost (usually work life/balance).

You’ve said yourself, you like your job a lot? Why are you looking at what everybody else is getting paid? We can always find somebody who’s getting paid more…Wink[/quote]
It's one of the larger regional firms though and usually has the highest NQ salary for regional firms. I only expect my salary to go up in relation to the raised NQ salary (to recognise being 2 years ahead at that point in September).

I absolutely love my job and that is a massive consideration as I feel very fulfilled, challenged, supported etc. It's a great firm with a great environment and I'm really happy. Just want a pay increase that ensures I'm not left behind my peers!

OP posts:
HuntyGirl · 15/02/2022 07:38

@mrsmalcolmreynolds

Depending on how attractive you and colleagues are to the likes of Eversheds etc it might well be your current firm is seriously considering pay increases anyway - I'm a partner (not any of the firms named but we do compete with them) and we are v conscious that associates are getting called by agents all the time.

Totally agree with PP though that at 2PQE you will not get more than top of band - no-one is valuable enough when that junior to risk word getting out amongst your peers, pissing them off and creating mayhem in the 2-5PQE cohort.

That's true, I know the other juniors are being contacted just as much as I am!

I agree completely with your last point and I want them to move everyone up so it remains competitive. It's a bit demoralising having friends at other firms who are just qualifying (March) or did in September and are already on more than me. That's regionally too. And at directly comparable firms (also regional)

OP posts:
HuntyGirl · 15/02/2022 07:36

@Spinner12345

I think it partly depends on whether your firm wants to compete with Eversheds/DLA for talent or not. You don’t say if you do similar work to Eversheds/DLA so the partners may not think it’s an issue. Another key factor is how many people have been moving in your firm recently, the jobs market is very hot in a lot of legal sectors so I’d expect if you were competing with the larger firms you’ll have seen that internally. Your partner won’t have the authority to give you that much of a rise but if enough of you ask they might change the salary bands for everyone. Are you close enough to your colleagues to discuss salary to see if they’re willing to ask for the same?
Sorry, didn't reply to the last bit! The other juniors in my team don't really share apart from one so that's helpful as we will keep each other updated.

Agree on banding and sorry if I haven't been clear, I don't expect my salary to be ahead of my peers, not at all! I think the bandings should be adjusted upwards for everyone

OP posts: