Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think that the Police Federation's statement is tone deaf?

56 replies

SunnyKlara · 14/02/2022 14:58

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-london-60375845

After all the bad press and seemingly institutional racism, sexism and homophobia we have seen coming from the Met over the past few years, I can't help but feel that the Police Federation declaring they have "no faith" in Sadiq Kahn just completely tone deaf and missing the point? It's all tit for tat rather than accepting the need for change. I at least expected them to play lip service to it!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TimeFlysWhenYoureHavingRum · 16/02/2022 10:55

Ken Marsh is always wheeled out by the BBC to provide "balance" when the police are accused of various incidents of appalling misconduct. He is usually on the wrong side of the argument, circling the wagons and blaming victims.

formalineadeline · 16/02/2022 10:16

It is what I would expect from Police Fed. I am glad they made that statement to make it clearer to the public how they operate and view the public.

Policing has a very strong very toxic "us vs the world" culture. It's what creates and protect many od the corrupt and abusive practices that have been exposed.

Go on any policing forum or Twitter community and you will find hundreds more spouting off about how special and hard done by they are and how they should be immune from consequences for "banter" , abuse and general lawbreaking.

In the wake of Dick resigning, there was even one with a large following - in his own name and rank as a member of police - crowing about how killing Jean Charles de Menezes was the right thing to do, there should never have been NY legal consequences for police killing someone, and we should be thanking her.

This is what our police are really like.

EatSleepRantRepeat · 16/02/2022 10:06

The Fed need to ask their own members why so many stories came out from their female officers during the Everard case about a culture of sexual harassment and sexism. Plenty of female officers came forward and said that they were told if they complained about sexual assault, no-one would answer their radio alarm next time they needed backup, and other personal threats to their safety.

Having worked for a public sector trade union I'd say its quite typical - protecting the positions of their own union stewards and union officers over that of their members and service users.

SpinningTheSeedsOfLove · 16/02/2022 09:52

What if the failings of the Met are so great that they started to emerge despite Cressida Dick, not because of her?

I find the Police Federation's position on this rather worrying. It's at best politically inept and, as pp have said, tone deaf; and at worst, an attempt to be politically manipulative.

It's going to be a long, hot, fractious summer ahead ... the police in London say they don't want an alienated populace, and then do this.

Brefugee · 16/02/2022 09:36

I liked Cressida Dick and I suspect we’ll never know about the awful things that she and her force stopped happening

but we know some of the awful things that their awful policing and their awful culture allowed to happen, repeatedly. The buck should have stopped with her being the Gold Commander when Jean Charles da Silva e de Menezes was shot. She should have been demoted or fired then.

GreenDressRedWine · 16/02/2022 09:24

YANBU, my thoughts exactly. The mayor is elected to represent the people of London and hold the Met to account, it’s not a 2 way street. I liked Cressida Dick and I suspect we’ll never know about the awful things that she and her force stopped happening, but change was too slow. If stamping out racism and misogyny is bad for morale then that’s too fucking bad, individual police officers are going to have to stand up and be counted and call out the BS.

DePfeffoff · 16/02/2022 09:14

Alfie Moore, the ex policeman who does the "It's a Fair Cop" radio programme, is moaning that the media are unfair to the police and don't post enough positive stories, and that people don't clap them the way they clap the NHS.

It really does demonstrate the weird sense of themselves some police officers have. Yes, they do a very valuable and difficult job, but the same could be said of thousands of others. I doubt that Alfie feels he should be clapping people who work in essential services like electricity and water supply and sewage.

Chasingaftermidnight · 16/02/2022 08:12

@Brefugee

pfffttt... it's tone def to you guys but it makes perfect sense to me -- and probably to many. I'd say you guys are as out of touch with policing reality as you think the police federation is.

are you a police officer @YeOldeTrout? can you possibly understand why so many sections of society have zero trust or faith in the met? I'd really like to hear your thinking here

Khan is "jumped up"? he is the directly elected Mayor of a metropolitan city. He didn't jump up, he has been put there because people want him there. He is vastly superior to Johnson as mayor.

’m truly amazed at the jubilation on this site that a women has been effectively sacked for not being able to change the behaviour of men in 5 years

Why should we support her? Just because she's a woman? Fuck that shit. She is being treated absolutely in the same way a man would be for being a dangerous (since being Gold Commander when the chap was shot in the underground) menace, to being absolutely tone deaf in the misogyny and sexism (not to mention the homophobia and racism) in the ranks she commands. She's a lesbian, FFS, but has she done women or lesbians any favours to deserve sympathy in return? nope. NOPE. A big resounding no she hasn't.

She should never have been able to keep her job beyond 2005, tbh, that she rose as high as she did has done other women doing excellent work no favours because it looks as though she has been promoted because she's an easy won: a gay woman. Look how progressive the Met is! We are all tarred with her brush of incompetence and now have to work even harder to get our promotions and change things.

Agreed. I’m not jubilant at her resignation at all. What infuriates me is not that she failed to ‘fix’ the Met (which is a mammoth task) but that she repeatedly refused even to acknowledge the culture of misogyny, sexism, racism and homophobia within the ranks she commanded. That culture of misogyny allowed Wayne Couzens to hide in plain sight. That culture of homophobia allowed Stephen Port to continue his killing spree. Along with countless other examples. If the head of the Met won’t admit there’s a problem, it can’t possibly be fixed.

Even her resignation statement refused to acknowledge it. ‘The murder of Sarah Everard and many other awful cases recently have, I know, damaged confidence in this fantastic police service.’ It’s not a fantastic police service. I’m sure there are some fantastic individuals in it but as an institution it’s plagued by dangerous problems. And how dare she say Sarah Everard’s name and ‘fantastic police service’ in the same sentence? It’s another attempt to absolve the police force from any responsibility for what happened.

longwayoff · 16/02/2022 07:34

Of course it is. The Police Federation isn't famed for its ability to be rational and form a neutral unbiased opinion. It's the coppers union and reinforces all those stereotypes that make people take a step back from the Met and its well deserved reputation.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 16/02/2022 07:28

@Brefugee

that makes him a twat, possibly, *@PinkSparklyPussyCat* but it doesn't demonstrate jumped-upness.
OK, I'll rephrase it.

'Yes it is tone deaf but I don't understand why anyone would have faith in the unfeeling, also tone deaf dickhead that is Sadiq Khan.'

Better?

VashtaNerada · 16/02/2022 07:18

I thought it was odd too. DH is with the MPS and is one of their biggest critics (which begs the question why he’s still with them but I think the fact that he’s a good person and can see its faults are exactly the reasons why he should stay) but I’ve never heard him criticise the mayor specifically. He’s angry at the reduced funding from central government, he’s angry at his colleagues’ incompetence, he’s angry at his commissioner (although understands how hard it is to run a functional service with the reduction in funding), but not the mayor. It seems like a very odd and unhelpful right wing comment. The federation isn’t a proper union anyway. If police officers were allowed to unionise and belonged to Unison or similar I think it would do them the world of good.

Brefugee · 16/02/2022 07:09

that makes him a twat, possibly, @PinkSparklyPussyCat but it doesn't demonstrate jumped-upness.

VestaTilley · 15/02/2022 22:53

Agree. They loved Cressida because she was their biggest champion.

The federation are a disgrace - they don’t give a damn about the public and victims, just how well their members can line their own pockets. Despicable, especially given all the recent scandals.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 15/02/2022 22:34

In what way is he a "jumped up little twat"?

I’m particularly pissed off at him for the way he’s treating one of my favourite charities, Dogs on the Streets by refusing to allow them an exemption from the ULEZ and congestion charges. They do amazing work with the homeless in London and that idiots answer was for them to buy new vehicles with not even a temporary exemption to allow them to fund raise. It just goes to show he doesn’t give a shit about the homeless. And breathe!

Saltyquiche · 15/02/2022 08:50

For the force to change they first need to admit there’s a culture problem. Denial isn’t helpful. Zero tolerance is the way forward, weeding out the officers who fall short rather then promoting them. Recruitment has to be ruthless and through. Good officers need to feel compelled to confidently challenge, whistle blow and report. Ignoring poor behaviour has fed into the poor police culture of the met

DePfeffoff · 15/02/2022 08:42

Those things didn't arise under CD, but they were beginning to come out in to the open, and so could be dealt with. It was always going to take some time, but at least this boss had started

She took five years to start? And much of her action appears to have been only in reaction to some of the more appalling events being publicised, not something that was generated independently by her. How long was she supposed to be given?

Brefugee · 15/02/2022 08:40

pfffttt... it's tone def to you guys but it makes perfect sense to me -- and probably to many. I'd say you guys are as out of touch with policing reality as you think the police federation is.

are you a police officer @YeOldeTrout? can you possibly understand why so many sections of society have zero trust or faith in the met? I'd really like to hear your thinking here

Khan is "jumped up"? he is the directly elected Mayor of a metropolitan city. He didn't jump up, he has been put there because people want him there. He is vastly superior to Johnson as mayor.

’m truly amazed at the jubilation on this site that a women has been effectively sacked for not being able to change the behaviour of men in 5 years

Why should we support her? Just because she's a woman? Fuck that shit. She is being treated absolutely in the same way a man would be for being a dangerous (since being Gold Commander when the chap was shot in the underground) menace, to being absolutely tone deaf in the misogyny and sexism (not to mention the homophobia and racism) in the ranks she commands. She's a lesbian, FFS, but has she done women or lesbians any favours to deserve sympathy in return? nope. NOPE. A big resounding no she hasn't.

She should never have been able to keep her job beyond 2005, tbh, that she rose as high as she did has done other women doing excellent work no favours because it looks as though she has been promoted because she's an easy won: a gay woman. Look how progressive the Met is! We are all tarred with her brush of incompetence and now have to work even harder to get our promotions and change things.

LyricalBlowToTheJaw · 15/02/2022 08:30

@ClaudineClare

If Khan should have gone, then so should Patel. The Met Commissioner is accountable to the Mayor and the Home Secretary and both have a role in the appointment of the Met Commissioner.
Good point.
Noname99 · 15/02/2022 08:30

SquirmOfEels

Totally agree. I’m truly amazed at the jubilation on this site that a women has been effectively sacked for not being able to change the behaviour of men in 5 years. But things were changing ….. as you said people were speaking out and being heard rather than ignored or actually silenced. That will end now. The next commissioner will just ensure it’s all covered back up so as not to loose their job. Because misogyny can’t be solved in a couple of years.

And Cressida Dick is not responsible for the death of Sarah Everard. Wayne Couzens is. But let’s blame a women for a violent man’s actions.

SquirmOfEels · 15/02/2022 08:14

seemingly institutional racism, sexism and homophobia we have seen coming from the Met over the past few years, I can't help but feel that the Police Federation declaring they have "no faith" in Sadiq Kahn just completely tone deaf and missing the point

I see it totally differently.

Those things didn't arise under CD, but they were beginning to come out in to the open, and so could be dealt with. It was always going to take some time, but at least this boss had started.

We'll be back to how things were before - not because there's nothing wrong, but because no-one will be making sure it surfaces.

The Mayor of course has the power to de facto sack the head of the Met, but I don't really get the timing

ClaudineClare · 15/02/2022 08:09

@PinkSparklyPussyCat

Yes it is tone deaf but I don't understand why anyone would have faith in the jumped up little twat that is Sadiq Khan.
In what way is he a "jumped up little twat"?
ClaudineClare · 15/02/2022 08:08

urbanbuddha that is appalling.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 15/02/2022 08:00

Yes it is tone deaf but I don't understand why anyone would have faith in the jumped up little twat that is Sadiq Khan.

itrytomakemyway · 15/02/2022 07:42

I have no faith in the Met. I really don't give a damn what they think about the mayor who was elected in a democratic vote. They need to put their own house in order.

Hoardasurass · 15/02/2022 07:36

I have absolutely no faith in either the police or Khan.
Khan is no friend to women as he has completely drunk the woke-ade please see the 2nd half of this article.
www.spectator.co.uk/article/stormont-s-stonewall-spend