Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not see them again?

513 replies

SplitStep · 14/02/2022 13:30

Try to keep it short.

Was with stbeh for just under 6 years. We have one 2 year old together and he has a 8 and 11 year old from previous relationship. I left because I just wasn't happy with a few things in the relationship that never seemed to change. One of which was the step parenting relationship was too much for me, I didn't enjoy it and I regularly felt put upon.

Now living on my own with 2 yo and much happier.

My exH keeps asking if I'll see the kids (his kids). Like when he drops off 2yo can he bring them up to see our new place, hangout for a bit or whatever. He's suggested a few times that we do some days out with all the kids too.

I know it sounds selfish but I don't want this. I think it's just better for everyone that it's kept as clean as possible and we don't continue a relationship (me and his older DC). I don't really have any desire to and I think it will just be harder the more I agree to in respect of seeing them.

I want mine and 2yo's home to be ours, I don't want H or SC in it. I just want the space to ourselves.

OP posts:
ChateauxNeufDePoop · 15/02/2022 18:38

@SliceOfCakeCupOfTea

I'm just reading back over the last few pages and I'm rather confused about what people think OP should be doing...she isn't facilitating a relationship neither she nor the kids wants...surely, if anything, she's making it easier for everyone by not pretending?

She has said she'll be civil when she does see them, so hardly blanking them all together, she just won't be making plans to spend time with them.

Yup - have the "harsh to walk away" brigade not read about OP's intention to be civil? She just doesn't want to continue in a role as step parent and being separated from the dad is surely as good a reason as any!
ChateauxNeufDePoop · 15/02/2022 18:35

@Happylittlethoughts

Very harsh OP. You may not want any step parent responsibility and that's understandable. However, what I find harsh is your lack of any consideration for anyone but your own feelings and wants. Your child has a right to a develop a sibling relationship, as do their step siblings. Consider that carefully. Whether you felt it or not you have disappeared from children's lives without a backward glance. Harsh
This point about the step siblings is the most ludicrous one that keeps getting repeated. The DH/exDH has three biological children and will still (or at least should) develop a relationship between the two sets of siblings. Why are people equating this to the kids never seeing each other again?
2Gen · 15/02/2022 18:21

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

T00Ts · 15/02/2022 18:04

Are* not see.

T00Ts · 15/02/2022 18:03

This reply has been deleted

Post references deleted post Talk guidelines.

whumpthereitis · 15/02/2022 18:01

Anyone that would do it differently is of course welcome to do so when they’re in OP’s situation. That kids have no choice is really something that the father should consider, both parents actually. I don’t suppose the kids had much choice in their parents splitting up either, yet it still happened. The father really needs to be the one to consider his children’s needs when they’re with him, and hopefully he does so before he dumps his next girlfriend into the role of unpaid nanny.

The children have two people that are obliged to centre their needs, otherwise known as ‘their parents’. The OP has to depend on herself to make her needs a priority, and good for her for doing so.

2Gen · 15/02/2022 17:59

@Bonheurdupasse

Pfft people here believe there are no arseholes in the world. There are, and conversely, they didn't just become arseholes at 35 / 25 / 18 years of age, having been perfectly nice people beforehand. No, they were probably unpleasant as children as well. Biology means that their parents especially mothers will love them despite their unpleasantness / arseholness, but that's not the case with other people, who don't enjoy being subjected to unpleasant behaviour. And hence are delighted to not have anything more to do with such unpleasantness when they don't have to.
Yes indeed! I like kids and have found most kids have something to like in them and will respond well to you looking for the good in them BUT, nevertheless, I have still come across a very small handful that I would not want to be minding nor have in my house and am not at all sorry to have not seen again! If a child have behavioural problems, it's difficult to impossible for anyone else to help them behave well if the PARENTS aren't committed to helping their child behave! The OP has said neither their mum nor dad wanted to deal with the behaviour problems so she would have had little to no chance of helping the child to behave well yet was being manipulated or coerced into doing most of the minding when they were at their father's. That would have been extremely stressful and draining for the OP! That's my experience from working as nurse in Child and Family Mental Health for 7 years anyway and, parental co-operation and commitment was one of the conditions of Child and Family Guidance working with a family at the centres I worked in ! The PARENTS must be committed or even a professional, even a Child Psychiatrist, can do very little for a behaviourally difficult child!
funinthesun19 · 15/02/2022 17:35

I read ops posts and she has said herself that she won't be ignoring them and will chat to them, see them at birthday parties etc. So what exactly is the problem then?

Exactly. Little things like that are obviously fine.

Her ex is obviously expecting more of her than that though. People’s problem with the OP is that they are clearly in agreement with him.

mrshoho · 15/02/2022 17:19

You don't have to answer op but just wondered about how you and your ex explained to the children you were splitting up. Did you all sit down and say you were leaving and what the reasons were? Did you and your ex ask them how they felt and whether they were upset that they would no longer have any contact with you? Was it a calm departure where everyone was involved? You say you were not involved in raising the children but rather just landed with the 'boring' aspects of parenthood. But believe me the mundane caring, cooking, cleaning, homework, school drops are the most meaningful to small children so you would have been a big part of their lives. I'm sure you wouldn't want to deliberately cause them emotional harm and you have every right to say who enters your new home but did you prepare them for the end of their relationship with you? You may feel that as the non biological step parent you had no obligation but personally as the adult I would feel the need to put the children's feelings as a priority. As adults we choose our relationships but kids have no choice.

TicTacHoh · 15/02/2022 17:18

nd obviously, the OP can do what she likes going forward. But I’m allowed to express sympathy for those children having nobody on their team for six years (including their biological parents).

How has this escalated into the children having 'nobody on their team'. This thread is batshit.

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 15/02/2022 17:11

I'm just reading back over the last few pages and I'm rather confused about what people think OP should be doing...she isn't facilitating a relationship neither she nor the kids wants...surely, if anything, she's making it easier for everyone by not pretending?

She has said she'll be civil when she does see them, so hardly blanking them all together, she just won't be making plans to spend time with them.

Arabellla · 15/02/2022 17:00

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 15/02/2022 16:56

OP I don't think YABU.

It's unfortunate that the relationship broke down and that there were children involved. Ultimately you're not their parent. You don't have an obligation to them. If you were going to maintain a life long relationship with them then any future partners you had would have to take them onboard as well as your own child and your ex. It's just too much.

If your ex begins a new relationship with someone then they will fill the role of step parent. How would that work if you were still in the picture anyways?

It's a completely different situation if both you and the children WANTED a relationship now and in the future.

whumpthereitis · 15/02/2022 16:53

[quote JustUseTheDoorSanta]@AllOfUsAreDead - Being polite at the door while collecting her own child is the bare minimum, you'd expect as much from a postman who've never met them. Greeting them at her child's birthday party, again you'd expect that towards a mum she's never met who's dropping off. Nothing at all like meeting the children specifically to ask how THEY are, nor giving a card for THEIR birthday. Totally different things.[/quote]
And that’s fine. She doesn’t need to offer any more, and nor should she if she doesn’t want to.

2Gen · 15/02/2022 16:43

@Bonheurdupasse

You're very right to defend your space OP. I doubt I'm being cynical here as I'm imaging your ExH is missing the practical support you were giving him with his kids and wants to use you again.
That's exactly what I suspect too! He might well end up dumping them on you if you give in too! Not straight away but if you allowed it, he'd keep inviting himself and his kids and gradually eroding your privacy and boundaries. It'd probably start with him "just nipping to the shop" and then one day, he'd just not come back for hours! No way should you ever allow even the possibility of him doing that to you OP! In your place I'd say a firm and clear NO! If he says his kids want to see your DC, then tell him he can have DC at his place when they're there but what he's suggesting does not work for you! Be firm, no apologies, no explanations and don't let him play you for a fool because that's what I suspect he'll try to do! It's your home OP , you get to decide who visits, when and for how long! YANBU!!!
JustUseTheDoorSanta · 15/02/2022 16:42

@AllOfUsAreDead - Being polite at the door while collecting her own child is the bare minimum, you'd expect as much from a postman who've never met them. Greeting them at her child's birthday party, again you'd expect that towards a mum she's never met who's dropping off. Nothing at all like meeting the children specifically to ask how THEY are, nor giving a card for THEIR birthday. Totally different things.

Theroughoperator · 15/02/2022 16:11

The above was for @Pumperthepumper

Theroughoperator · 15/02/2022 16:09

No, I’m still struggling

Yes you really are aren’t you? The OP has explained all of this quite clearly. You seem to have a lot of time on your hands. Maybe see all her posts again and read them properly. ....Although I doubt that will help. You seem to want to portray her as the heartless evil stepmother no matter what she says.

AllOfUsAreDead · 15/02/2022 15:56

[quote JustUseTheDoorSanta]@AllOfUsAreDead - maybe it's hard for you to understand because you aren't reading what people have said. I haven't seen anybody suggesting that OP take the children on her own. People have said it's very harsh to walk away without meeting them to chat a few times, being nice with a birthday card etc. It isn't necessary to cut them off without regard to their feelings when they are just children who have done nothing wrong. Escalating that into regular childminding would be strange, but nobody suggested OP should do that.[/quote]
I read ops posts and she has said herself that she won't be ignoring them and will chat to them, see them at birthday parties etc. So what exactly is the problem then?

JustUseTheDoorSanta · 15/02/2022 15:40

@AllOfUsAreDead - maybe it's hard for you to understand because you aren't reading what people have said. I haven't seen anybody suggesting that OP take the children on her own. People have said it's very harsh to walk away without meeting them to chat a few times, being nice with a birthday card etc. It isn't necessary to cut them off without regard to their feelings when they are just children who have done nothing wrong. Escalating that into regular childminding would be strange, but nobody suggested OP should do that.

AllOfUsAreDead · 15/02/2022 15:29

I don't get why this is difficult for people to understand.

If this was a mum on here saying, I've just split up with my husband, my kids aren't his but I think he should still see them. Should I force him to? There would be uproar about how dare she leave her kids with a man they aren't related to. I've seen it happen. Why is it fine because op is a woman?

She has been in their lives for a while. But now is no longer their family, why does she need to be a childminder now? Because daddy is too fucking useless? That's not her fault, that's his fault. Why is no one annoyed at the actual parents in this scenario who just want to palm off their kids onto someone else?

As I said before, if fuckwit daddy couldn't figure out how to count to 3 when he was producing children, he shouldn't have done it. Assuming he is an actual functioning human adult, he can count to 3, so it is not beyond him that he cannot care for his 3 children together. It won't kill him, and it's not like he'll have this every day either, probably once every two weeks and he'll no doubt get his mummy to do the work for him. No reason for op to be involved at all.

T00Ts · 15/02/2022 15:28

But I’m allowed to express sympathy for those children having nobody on their team for six years (including their biological parents).

What is it you think the OP should be doing here @Pumperthepumper? You’ve needed to be told the same things over and over and deliberately (I hope) misunderstood them time and again.

You’ve made your judgemental position that the OP is wrong, quite clear. But what exactly do you think she should be doing?

AllOfUsAreDead · 15/02/2022 15:19

@Pumperthepumper

You should have just ended your last post here: "No, I’m still struggling"

whumpthereitis · 15/02/2022 15:08

🦜🦜🦜

OP has already explained, ad nauseam. Feel free to check back on pretty much any of the 19 previous pages. It’s not information you lack, it’s reading comprehension.

Just as well OP is standing up for herself. For all the talk of how women should be able to enforce boundaries and make sure their own needs are met, as soon as one does there’ll be someone who wants to come along and shove her back in her box.

youvegottenminuteslynn · 15/02/2022 15:03

And obviously, the OP can do what she likes going forward.

Phew she'll be relieved to hear that.

But I’m allowed to express sympathy for those children having nobody on their team for six years (including their biological parents).

I think you've done that in spades now, job done.

Swipe left for the next trending thread