Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not see them again?

513 replies

SplitStep · 14/02/2022 13:30

Try to keep it short.

Was with stbeh for just under 6 years. We have one 2 year old together and he has a 8 and 11 year old from previous relationship. I left because I just wasn't happy with a few things in the relationship that never seemed to change. One of which was the step parenting relationship was too much for me, I didn't enjoy it and I regularly felt put upon.

Now living on my own with 2 yo and much happier.

My exH keeps asking if I'll see the kids (his kids). Like when he drops off 2yo can he bring them up to see our new place, hangout for a bit or whatever. He's suggested a few times that we do some days out with all the kids too.

I know it sounds selfish but I don't want this. I think it's just better for everyone that it's kept as clean as possible and we don't continue a relationship (me and his older DC). I don't really have any desire to and I think it will just be harder the more I agree to in respect of seeing them.

I want mine and 2yo's home to be ours, I don't want H or SC in it. I just want the space to ourselves.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TheCountessOfGrantham · 16/02/2022 15:31

No, it's not unreasonable. I had stepchildren that I had a very tricky relationship with. One had numerous issues with attachment, was physically violent and destructive and caused me a lot of misery. Their father and I split up many years ago and I have not seen them since, nor do I want to, despite them living with us full time and me bringing them up for almost seven years. They were a huge weight on my shoulders and I was glad to be rid of all of them.

JustUseTheDoorSanta · 16/02/2022 08:53

@AllOfUsAreDead - you're just imagining reasonable behaviour. OP mentioned "our DC" for the birthday and has been very clear multiple times that except being polite at the door she wants no relationship or other contact with the children herself. As I said, by all means argue that it's her right to cut the kids off, but stop arguing that OP has said she'll do the opposite of what she actually said.

AllOfUsAreDead · 16/02/2022 08:22

@Linning

I think you are selling your services as a nanny short to be honest. You're working underpaid and then completely free for parents you don't even like just to hang out with the kids? You're being completely screwed over there by the parents and letting yourself get taken advantage of.

AllOfUsAreDead · 16/02/2022 08:17

[quote JustUseTheDoorSanta]@AllOfUsAreDead - I already explained. It isn't about the words used, it's the actual actions. Being allowed to attend the sibling birthday party is in no way the same as being given a card for your own birthday. If you're invited to someone's birthday, you wouldn't see that as exactly the same as being given a birthday card on your own. The first is allowing them to be acquaintances, the second is actually spending a minute thinking about them. Remember, these are very young children.[/quote]
Prove that she isn't going to do that. Where did she show specifically that she isn't going to give them a card or even a present? You are assuming based on what's she said. But I would assume that if she is taking her child to a birthday party she would take a card and most likely a present. Because that's just what you do.

mumtoallbhoys · 16/02/2022 07:45

Sorry I haven't read the whole thread.

Do you think your ex wants you to mind them or do you think the children generally miss you? If it is the latter I don't think I could break their hearts. They are only primary school age and it might affect their self esteem and self worth. If you really don't want them I hope you can at least remember their birthdays or something.

Marvellousmadness · 16/02/2022 07:35

Tell him no
And no again
And again

MintyFreshBreath · 16/02/2022 07:33

I’ve never had to navigate this but I know I’d find it hard not to see DSS again if the worst happened. DSD, not so much as she’s a pain in the arse. Maybe it’s best that whilst things are raw, your ex sees all the kids together at his place and (if you feel up to it) in a few months, maybe you could see the older ones for lunch out with your 2 year old?

GiantHaystacks2021 · 16/02/2022 07:29

YANBU.

There are some real worthies on here.

Your ex is clearly looking to palm his other kids off on you. It won't be long till he'll leave them with you on your own.

Tell him to jog on.

JustUseTheDoorSanta · 16/02/2022 06:36

@AllOfUsAreDead - I already explained. It isn't about the words used, it's the actual actions. Being allowed to attend the sibling birthday party is in no way the same as being given a card for your own birthday. If you're invited to someone's birthday, you wouldn't see that as exactly the same as being given a birthday card on your own. The first is allowing them to be acquaintances, the second is actually spending a minute thinking about them. Remember, these are very young children.

Linning · 15/02/2022 23:30

[quote Bonheurdupasse]@linning the point is that OP didn't know most of those things when she started the relationship or when she moved in.
Similarly to when women/ people in abusive relationships don't know that at the start (and end up having one or more children with the abuser).[/quote]
She had about 4 years though between the time the relationship started and being used by her ex husband and despised by their bio mom and her having her own child with him. Surely she had plenty of time to realize she didn’t enjoy the kids, and her ex-husband was a bit of a prick and probably not best dad material out there? Not blaming OP for being resentful of the position she was put in as it sucks but you won’t make me change my mind that I personally find it sad that she never found it in her to bond with her step children and that she didn’t remove herself from the situation as soon as she started feeling this way rather than wait a couple more years.

You can feel sad for something and still understand why people might still do that. I can understand (on a conceptual level as I cannot effectively relate) why she might feel the way she does and made/is making the choices she is making, but I still ultimately find it a sad outcome for everyone involved. Considering it was a 6 years relationship that started when one of the step-child was still a toddler, and I will always find it sad when blended families can spend near a decade together and still be happy to walk away with no contact whatsoever because it clearly mean there was a fundamental failure somewhere and there is no way there would have been no impact on all involved, especially the kids in this scenario when that’s the case.

Like I said, as a kid who grew up with a stepdad, I would have been utterly distraught if after even 6 years with us, he would have been happy to walk away from us and actually actively wanted to not have any contact with us at all and would have despised even seeing us once a month. Of course he would have been entitled to do so and feel that way but it would have still been utterly emotionally heartbreaking for us as people who grew up with him and who had nothing to do with the adult relationships in that scenario.

As an adult now. I would have absolutely no way to reject a child on the basis of how other adults made me feel. Especially if they wanted contact. It’s just not something I can (and honestly don’t think ever will) relate to.

Krabapple · 15/02/2022 23:12

You sound delightful op

Bonheurdupasse · 15/02/2022 23:11

@linning the point is that OP didn't know most of those things when she started the relationship or when she moved in.
Similarly to when women/ people in abusive relationships don't know that at the start (and end up having one or more children with the abuser).

Linning · 15/02/2022 22:58

Forgot to tag you @Bonheurdupasse

Linning · 15/02/2022 22:56

I probably wouldn’t have moved in with someone I felt despised by, and who had made it clear I wouldn’t be part of his kids life, let alone have a child with him (their half siblings) though.

As a matter of fact I have worked as a nanny for many years (very often extremely underpaid), and not always for parents I liked, but yes I still volunteered post job to hang out with them (for free) because again I can’t imagine not getting attached to kids I see on a regular basis. Kids are not responsible for their parents behavior and attitude towards me or others and I would never let a parents attitude get in the way of my bonding with a child and doing what’s right by them when given the choice. So no I can’t relate to OP but then again I still baby sit for free 9 years on after leaving some of the families I worked for. So no, i absolutely cannot relate to OP (again not meaning she is wrong for feeling or acting differently to me) as in my world becoming a stepmom would mean I only take on the relationship with the expectation that I am in it for the long-haul and doing it in a way that benefits the kids most both during and after the relationship. Otherwise I would simply not get involved as there is nothing less appealing than dating someone who doesn’t have the best interest of his kids at heart and is willing to introduce new people to their kids on repeat and remove them with no care for the emotional impact on them and I would have zero interest being a part of that process, let alone bringing in an additional kid into that scenario by having my own with said individual.

Bonheurdupasse · 15/02/2022 22:40

@Linning

YANBU to feel the way that you feel as those are your feelings and therefore can’t be argued but I find it incredibly sad personally.

I couldn’t imagine not getting attached to kids I have lived with or been around to on a regular basis for 6 years irrelevant of my relationship with their bio mom or my ex.

My stepdad came into my life when I was 4 and split with my mother when I was around 18 thankfully, he never gave up on me and actually I ended up living partially with him for a bit. He never ever made me feel like an inconvenience and he always always takes the time to check ip on me and ask for news if he doesn’t hear for me within 2 weeks. Now I am a full grown adult and when I go home (I live abroad) it’s him I visit rather than my mother and I make sure I pay him back ten folds for stepping in the way he did and not discarding me the second his relationship with my mom went south. I am so so beyond grateful for him and would have been absolutely heartbroken if his reaction and instinct would have been akin to yours.

I personally think stepparents who aren’t keen to take on a partner’s children as their own should avoid becoming step parents and should either settle for someone without kids or keep living arrangements separate as to not be included in the kids lives and avoid any major upheaval in case of relationship breakdown.

@linning OP was clearly used as an unpaid - and despised - nanny by her ExH and his ex the mum. See earlier in the thread where the ex the mum made it clear OP was not to have any relationship with the kids, and then was used for the menial childcare tasks by them.

Would you expect a nanny - especially one despised by the parents - to keep up the childcare after she's left the job?

Linning · 15/02/2022 21:36

YANBU to feel the way that you feel as those are your feelings and therefore can’t be argued but I find it incredibly sad personally.

I couldn’t imagine not getting attached to kids I have lived with or been around to on a regular basis for 6 years irrelevant of my relationship with their bio mom or my ex.

My stepdad came into my life when I was 4 and split with my mother when I was around 18 thankfully, he never gave up on me and actually I ended up living partially with him for a bit. He never ever made me feel like an inconvenience and he always always takes the time to check ip on me and ask for news if he doesn’t hear for me within 2 weeks. Now I am a full grown adult and when I go home (I live abroad) it’s him I visit rather than my mother and I make sure I pay him back ten folds for stepping in the way he did and not discarding me the second his relationship with my mom went south. I am so so beyond grateful for him and would have been absolutely heartbroken if his reaction and instinct would have been akin to yours.

I personally think stepparents who aren’t keen to take on a partner’s children as their own should avoid becoming step parents and should either settle for someone without kids or keep living arrangements separate as to not be included in the kids lives and avoid any major upheaval in case of relationship breakdown.

SockFluffInTheBath · 15/02/2022 20:57

[quote needmoresheep]@SplitStep Be careful you will be end up being lumbered with childcare. Roped into providing holiday childcare.

Okay for birthday hellos etc but not okay for any ‘do you mind picking up/dropping off at school / minding as x has a cold / whatever’.[/quote]
This. It’s a very slippery slope. They have 2 parents and you’re not one of them. Of course stbex wants to keep a handle on his childminder using a pretence of family, of course he does.

AllOfUsAreDead · 15/02/2022 20:07

[quote JustUseTheDoorSanta]@AllOfUsAreDead - if you select "see all" then you can see OP's posts. She has been extremely clear actually that her intent is not to do any of that. E.g.
I'd be kind if / when I ever do see them (maybe at DCs birthdays and drop offs or whatever) but I don't really feel any need to go any further than that.

By all means argue that is her right, but my entire point is that there is a hell of a difference between saying hello politely like strangers at the front door, and having the kids on whole days out. To me, balancing the children's needs would include a few short meet-ups to reassure them that nothing was their fault and they have value in and of themselves, plus some cards (cheap, quick, no bother at all). Such tiny effort to bolster the self esteem of kids who are in the middle now of two broken homes. OP claims to even have liked the older one, it seems unnecessary to leave little kids confused and upset when a few small steps might avert much of the upset while OP fades off into the background.[/quote]
Yep and if you read that (I'm assuming you can since you copied and pasted it) plus more like this:

Yes I would assume at some point I will see them again because we share a child so for example if our DC has a birthday party, I'm sure they will be there, if I go to pick up DC one day and they are in the garden/answer the door or whatever I obviously won't blank them. But I don't feel the need to plan or force any meet up.

Then you would see she is planning on doing that. Not your exact wording but it's never going to be is it? She's a different person to you. She hasn't said she will blank them, ignore them or anything bad.

And she doesn't have to meet up and tell them it wasn't their fault. Why can't their father do that? They are his kids, he is the one who should be explaining the situation, like he would/should have before introducing her. It's not her job to reassure them, that's their parents job. Why are you trying to push their fathers job onto her? Think he isn't capable? Kind of not really ops problem if he is useless. Being in the middle of now two broken homes is completely on their parents to talk to them about. Their spouses or ex spouses shouldn't be doing that job for them.

needmoresheep · 15/02/2022 19:54

@SplitStep Be careful you will be end up being lumbered with childcare. Roped into providing holiday childcare.

Okay for birthday hellos etc but not okay for any ‘do you mind picking up/dropping off at school / minding as x has a cold / whatever’.

2Gen · 15/02/2022 19:43

@SplitStep

But this is why you shouldn’t have married your EXH or had a child with him. Sorry. But that’s the reality.

Okay are you going to lend me your time machine then?

What do you want me to do about that? I married him when they were 2. This is a gradual situation that has got steadily worse and more obvious as they have gotten older.

Yes, you need to build a time machine and go back and "unmarry" your ex OP! Or perhaps the PP can dig up H.G. Wells, re-animate him and ask him to make one for you??! It really annoys me when posters say this sort of thing! It's basically rubbishing someone for making a mistake- marrying an unpleasant or useless man, having a child with him- and implying they are such superior beings that they NEVER make mistakes, which is obviously total BS! There ain't none of us who's perfect!
2Gen · 15/02/2022 19:28

@mrshoho

Fast forward a few years and your own dc could be in the same situation as your ex step children. Your ex meets a new partner who becomes step mum to your child forming a relationship and then through no fault of the child the relationship ends. You'll see a different perspective. I'm sure you'd want your child to be considered and respected.
In such case it would be the OP and her ex's job to help their DC cope with and come to terms with the change in circumstances! If the ex treats the next woman as badly as he did the OP, then it probably will happen but it'd be as wrong to force his next ex to have a relationship with a child who wasn't hers and whose father she wanted a clean break from as it is to try and force, manipulate or guilt-trip the OP into it now!
JustUseTheDoorSanta · 15/02/2022 19:25

@AllOfUsAreDead - if you select "see all" then you can see OP's posts. She has been extremely clear actually that her intent is not to do any of that. E.g.
I'd be kind if / when I ever do see them (maybe at DCs birthdays and drop offs or whatever) but I don't really feel any need to go any further than that.

By all means argue that is her right, but my entire point is that there is a hell of a difference between saying hello politely like strangers at the front door, and having the kids on whole days out. To me, balancing the children's needs would include a few short meet-ups to reassure them that nothing was their fault and they have value in and of themselves, plus some cards (cheap, quick, no bother at all). Such tiny effort to bolster the self esteem of kids who are in the middle now of two broken homes. OP claims to even have liked the older one, it seems unnecessary to leave little kids confused and upset when a few small steps might avert much of the upset while OP fades off into the background.

2Gen · 15/02/2022 19:10

@SplitStep- Sorry OP, I wrote this before I'd read all your posts and found out the main reason for the split was your ex's behaviour and treatment of you, with the youngest child's behaviour being an added strain, but not the cause. I'm sorry for that and for the way some PPs have been so self-righteously condemning of you. You're a single mum now; I've been there and it's hard enough without this ex of yours putting more burden on you and also without self-righteous busybodies trying to make you feel guilty! I wish you all the best and ignore all the guilt tripping!

2Gen · 15/02/2022 19:04

@ancientgran

My DH had a step child, when he and his ex split she wouldn't allow him to see the child and he had no legal rights. One day a young man came to our door, he wanted to know why my husband had disappeared from his life. They talked and he went away seeming happier.

DH didn't blame his ex, he said she felt it was better and he'd agreed (he didn't) but the point is the step child came back 15 years later because he still felt the need to understand why DH had just disappeared and to reassure himself that his memories of the positive time they had together were true.

Poor kids with people just disappearing from their lives. Adults need to take responsibility for their decisions.

I agree that PARENTS need to ( suchas in the case you describe it was
a son who came looking for his FATHER and needed answers. OP is not the mother though- those children have a mother and a father and are being reared by both. The emotional damage will have been caused by their parents splitting up and it was and continues to be theIr parents job to help them with it, not the OP's. I also suspect that, as the OP's ex sounds quite selfish, that he bears most of the blame for his first divorce so most of the burden of helping HIS children heal from his inability (or refusal- he probably thinks it's a woman's job to make her man happy but that men have no such responsibility to their women!) to keep a woman happy falls on him! If the OP and her ex's children had been close, I'm sure she would be missing them but she didn't say that- in fact, she said that step-parenting was one of the main causes of the marriage breakdown, so it doesn't sound as if she is. I don't know if she was a wicked SM or the children were difficult but she is on her own with her own child now and needs to focus on him or her. The ex's children have both parents, which is more than some kids have! What about when he reels in some other poor woman; is the OP supposed to carry on seeing them then as well? When they have their mum, their dad AND an new SM? The only responsibility the OP has s to co-operate with enabling her DC's relationship with their half-siblings! That's it! It's up to their own parents now and their dad needs to learn a lesson because that's TWO marriages he's failed at now! She does NOT want that man in her home or her life either and how else is she going to see his kids unless she has them on her own? And why on Earth should she be made to feel she has to do that? I think you're being too hard on her. Give the poor woman time to get over her marriage breakdown and adjust to being a single mum FFS- that's hard enough without ex's trying to inveigle their way into your home and make you feel you owe his kids, especially as the OP was made to be just a sort of joey for exH na his exW for their children!
AllOfUsAreDead · 15/02/2022 18:46

[quote JustUseTheDoorSanta]@AllOfUsAreDead - Being polite at the door while collecting her own child is the bare minimum, you'd expect as much from a postman who've never met them. Greeting them at her child's birthday party, again you'd expect that towards a mum she's never met who's dropping off. Nothing at all like meeting the children specifically to ask how THEY are, nor giving a card for THEIR birthday. Totally different things.[/quote]
Don't recall seeing op say she won't be doing those things. All she doesn't want to deal with any more is the children's bad behaviour or taking them to school or handling them alone. And why should she do any of those things? She is no longer a step parent. Their parents should be doing those things, not that they seem to bother.

Imagine if both parents get married, do you expect both step parents to stick around and be involved in the kids lives forever even if they split up? So the kids could end up with several step parents on both mum and dad's side. That's just stupid.

All op has to do is be civil with them, talk to them when she sees them, give a card, help if THEY ask for it. And that's it, no more.

Again, what more do you expect from her?