Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for a half slice of cake?

162 replies

GretaGip · 14/02/2022 11:26

Ive got disordered eating, sometimes eating something with no low nutritional value (but plenty of pleasure) will start me off on a binge.

I'd done slimming world and lost a lot of weight but am now in the sad position of having put half of it back on.

So im trying a different approach. Using my fitness pal im slowly losing 1 pound a week. Currently 14 down since November.

I bloody love cake. The conception, construction, the aesthetic, and to a lesser degree, the consumption.

Quite often im happy just looking at cakes and have no yearning to eat them, intellectually I know there's better calories out there. I don't feel deprived.

Occasionally I just really really want cake. It's hormonal im sure. So I have some, but want it to be controlled.

I tend to share with very accommodating friends. This will be considered in my calories for the day.

I'm in a lovely cafe on my own and really fancied cake, so I asked for half, and said I was happy to pay full price.

The staff member gave the impression that they thought I was very odd.

Wibu to ask?

OP posts:
Blossomtoes · 14/02/2022 13:49

@diddl

I think that some slices of cake are just about big enough to be a light meal!

I cook at lunch & have been known to have just a slice of cake for tea!

A lot of people ordering cake in a cafe are having it instead of a meal. I’m one of them.
TheOldLadyOfThreadneedleStreet · 14/02/2022 13:48

Oh this thread depresses me cos I have never found a slice of cake in a cafe too big and often choose the type of cake which has the biggest slices! Though coffee and walnut is the best.

But there is absolutely nothing wrong with wanting a half slice and OP please feel happy about it.

When I’m cutting cake for people at home I generally ask how big a slice each person wants and cut slices varying from tiny to huge. Perhaps cafes should do the same and stop pre-portioning everything up.

SocksAndTheCity · 14/02/2022 13:48

@GretaGip

Just wanted to ask all those saying your preference is smaller portions.

Have you ever NOT bought a slice because it was too big?

If cafes realised they were losing out on revenue because their portions were overwhelming, maybe they'd start to offer half sizes and increase sales?

I have - there have been more occasions than I can count where I would have bought some cake had the slice been smaller. Most cakes in cafes are preportioned and the slices are enormous, ditto the muffins which are always huge now.

I can't leave food on my plate, so I don't buy the giant slices because I don't want to eat that much. So they definitely miss out on sales from me, and I daresay I'd have a couple a week.

HairyScaryMonster · 14/02/2022 13:47

Our independent cafe does half slices for half price. I'm sure they tempt people to have something sweet after lunch when they wouldn't stretch to a full piece.

BarbaraofSeville · 14/02/2022 13:43

@TooExtraImmatureCheddar

Food that’s eaten isn’t food waste! Food waste is food that goes in the bin. Food exists to be eaten, and people need to eat to survive. Some people overdo it but they still need to eat.
Of course food that's eaten when you don't want it or are too full/feel sick already is wasted. It's no less wasted if eaten when you don't want it than if it goes in the bin. And even more so when eating too much causes people to be unhealthy or gain weight.

For the PP that says some pieces of cake are like meals, on the Costa website, the coffee cake has 600 calories and most others have around 400 calories. That's lunch, not a little snack with coffee.

TooExtraImmatureCheddar · 14/02/2022 13:41

Portion sizes can be crazy. My kids ordered brownies and ice cream for pudding in a pub a couple of months ago, and what they got was two slabs 4 inches x 4 inches each, with two scoops of ice cream. One each with one scoop of ice cream would have been plenty! As it was they couldn’t eat even half of it, so DH, PIL and I all wound up eating some and we still didn’t finish it. I wish there was some indication of portion sizes, because if we’d known how big that was going to be, we’d have just ordered one to share.

EmbarrassingHadrosaurus · 14/02/2022 13:41

Have you ever NOT bought a slice because it was too big?

Yes. I never buy one when I'm by myself. I'll buy one if I'm with someone else and they're happy to share.

I don't know if they're still popular but I couldn't believe that anyone short of an athlete could cope with the size of a portion that the popular triple layer cakes offered a while back.

SpiderinaWingMirror · 14/02/2022 13:39

Asking for what you want is a huge part of advocating for yourself and being healthy.

BungleandGeorge · 14/02/2022 13:37

I can’t see how people are saying this is unreasonable or weird at all. The slices in many cafes are way too big. Many people are dieting etc I can’t see why anyone would think it odd. I presumed you were going to say that you only wanted to pay half price which possibly would be unreasonable! If the cake hasn’t left the display why on Earth can’t they give it to a member of staff or another customer, most of them accept monetary tips!

TooExtraImmatureCheddar · 14/02/2022 13:35

Food that’s eaten isn’t food waste! Food waste is food that goes in the bin. Food exists to be eaten, and people need to eat to survive. Some people overdo it but they still need to eat.

Elphame · 14/02/2022 13:33

@GretaGip

Just wanted to ask all those saying your preference is smaller portions.

Have you ever NOT bought a slice because it was too big?

If cafes realised they were losing out on revenue because their portions were overwhelming, maybe they'd start to offer half sizes and increase sales?

Actually yes I have!

Whilst I am able (and often do) to leave food on my plate, I look at these giant slices of cake and my desire for it evaporates.

I'm in a minority though. I believe that lack of portion control is fueling the obesity crisis and food establishments have a major role in this.

I would rather have a smaller piece of cake with fat/sugar/chocolate/cream etc which tastes nice than a bigger piece made with sweeteners and all the other artificial calorie reducing ingredients that are about to be forced on us. I haven't been able to have a fizzy canned drink since the sugar tax arrived although I'd happily pay extra for a can of real Dr Pepper. Mexico is a long way t o go for one though!

BoogieFeet · 14/02/2022 13:31

Yes, smaller portions would tempt me to have some cake with my coffee. As it is I just think ‘I won’t enjoy that because I know that has as many calories in it as my evening meal and I’ll be bored of it/full before it’s finished’. They often look more like a challenge than a treat!

diddl · 14/02/2022 13:26

I think that some slices of cake are just about big enough to be a light meal!

I cook at lunch & have been known to have just a slice of cake for tea!

GretaGip · 14/02/2022 13:21

@Goatinthegarden

I think that was a sensible decision OP.

There’s a lovely little coffee shop next to my work that sells ridiculously huge portions of cake for £5. Some days, I say to myself that £5 is ridiculous for a piece of cake and it’s too big and I don’t need it anyway. Some days, I buy the cake and shovel it down sideways (even though I’ve usually stopped enjoying it by 2/3s of the way through).

I also often walk past that cafe to a bakery where things are sold in more reasonably sized portions.

If the cafe sold smaller portions for cheaper prices, I’d buy cake from them more regularly.

Ahha

Perfection of cross post there Cake

OP posts:
strawberrydonuts · 14/02/2022 13:20

How is this creating more food waste? Not snippy, just curious

Probably because the other half is most likely to get thrown away.

Doesn't mean you shouldn't make the request. But the staff probably won't eat it.

GretaGip · 14/02/2022 13:20

Just wanted to ask all those saying your preference is smaller portions.

Have you ever NOT bought a slice because it was too big?

If cafes realised they were losing out on revenue because their portions were overwhelming, maybe they'd start to offer half sizes and increase sales?

OP posts:
Elphame · 14/02/2022 13:20

Good for you. Slices of cake in cafés have got bigger and bigger over the years and some are now ridiculous.

If I go out for coffee and cake with a friend we will often order one slice and two forks. It's never been a problem. We take it in turns to choose the flavour!

Goatinthegarden · 14/02/2022 13:19

I think that was a sensible decision OP.

There’s a lovely little coffee shop next to my work that sells ridiculously huge portions of cake for £5. Some days, I say to myself that £5 is ridiculous for a piece of cake and it’s too big and I don’t need it anyway. Some days, I buy the cake and shovel it down sideways (even though I’ve usually stopped enjoying it by 2/3s of the way through).

I also often walk past that cafe to a bakery where things are sold in more reasonably sized portions.

If the cafe sold smaller portions for cheaper prices, I’d buy cake from them more regularly.

strawberrydonuts · 14/02/2022 13:18

YANBU, however it's not a common request, so I'm not that surprised at the reaction.

Best way to deal with this situation? Don't care so much what people think and do what you need to do :)

user1493494961 · 14/02/2022 13:18

I would have wrapped it in a serviette and taken it home.

appleturnovers · 14/02/2022 13:17

I often wish I could buy half a slice of cake - the servings they sell in cafes these days are enormous, way too big for me!

I wish I'd thought about asking for half a slice before. Maybe if more people ask for it, they'll start offering smaller portions?

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 14/02/2022 13:16

Portions are getting larger because you can get away with higher prices for only a slight increase in costs. If you double the portion size of something with mainly cheap ingredients, like cake, it will probably only cost you 20% more, even allowing for the additional labour of making more cake, but youcan charge 50-80% more.

There is nothing wrong with asking for a smaller bit. I used to live in the US, where portion sizes are ridiculously large, and it's quite common to get a half portion, e.g. half a sandwich (which will still be twice the size of a UK one!).

Blossomtoes · 14/02/2022 13:16

@PickledOnionSandwich

YABU. Who were they going to give the other half to? Just eat half and leave the rest Hmm
They could always eat it themselves. OP’s approach is far better than wasting it as you suggest.
SweetFelicityArkright · 14/02/2022 13:13

When I worked in hospitality I would have done this without comment, but made sure I was understanding you correctly and definitely offered you a box to have the other half in to take with you.

I wouldn't have thought it 'odd' but rather unusual because the majority of the time people want more for their money, not less. I'd have been more worried I misunderstood what you were asking and would seek to clarify the situation because I'd be concerned that if I had misunderstood I'd be accused of ripping you off by serving half a slice of cake instead of the full one you were paying for.

Though when I was sure that I wasn't misunderstanding you I'd have gratefully accepted the other slice! (If I'd been allowed, which in some places I wouldn't have been 😒)

SleepingStandingUp · 14/02/2022 13:13

Ooh yes please, public recipe Wandering 😁😁