Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

7 coming to stay! Invited themselves ! To very elderly relatives !

511 replies

2beesornot2beesthatisthehoney · 14/02/2022 10:51

So some younger relatives contacted my mum to announce that they were coming to stay with my parents. 7 of them including 2 children. To celebrate her 90th birthday! For 10 days!

She will have to get food in , contemplating a caravan in the garden, (because their quite large house is not really big enough for 7 extra) and do all sorts of stuff in preparation and whilst they are there. My parents go to bed relatively early these days , so their sleeping habits no doubt will be disturbed. When I heard , I suggested I would look at alternative accommodation Air B&B etc . Trouble is they live in a very rural area away from public transport but I did find one possibility.

Then another bomb shell . They are not intending to hire a car because they don’t like British roads . ( not from uk) . So the property I found is unsuitable as it’s a few miles away with no public transport links.

My parents now have 2 unreliable cars hardly go anywhere now and been shielding for the last 2 years anyhow because mum is CEV . (Explaining unreliable cars but that is another thread in itself) . So these relatives expect to be driven everywhere and collected from the airport too. And the 2 children are young enough to need car seats I think ( youngest at least , not sure of height of older one) .

It’s utter madness! Mum feels compelled to say yes because over the years they have stayed with that family though not them personally.

I think she should be saying no! Dad says “ they will muddle through” .

AIBU to somehow step in without it causing WW3 in the family?

OP posts:
nozbottheblue · 15/02/2022 21:08

Yes you must step in. They can stay in a nearby town and get a taxi to take them over for visits. I know how my 92 year old mum would be , she wouldn’t say no but she’d get herself into such a tizz even for just a visit from anyone other than close family, never mind so many expecting to stay.
Just remind the visitors that 90 year olds can’t do all they used to be able to, as they seem to need it pointing out.
I’m getting quite worked up on your behalf!

Flatwhitetostayin · 15/02/2022 20:42

Am glad she's got you looking out for her. She's very fortunate. X

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 15/02/2022 20:35

@2beesornot2beesthatisthehoney - well done for stepping in!

littlefireseverywhere · 15/02/2022 20:27

So unreasonable, you’re right to put them off!

Iziz · 15/02/2022 20:21

Blimey 10 days ? I think it’s a free holiday they want ,I think two max if you really have to say yes I would suggest you write them an email explaining it’s too much work for your parents they are elderly and it’s way too costly they have to find a better option themselves and not rely on your parents for anything except the birthday party nothing else .

Jack80 · 15/02/2022 20:07

I would say your welcome to come to celebrate my mums birthday but you need to sort out your own food, accommodation and transport.

Tzimi · 15/02/2022 19:59

I don't blame them for not wanting to drive here, it's carnage out there!

Loreleigh · 15/02/2022 19:44

Intervene..try, as others have suggested, a polite explanation of why it is unreasonable of them to expect to park 7 people on an elderly couple and then expect full hospitality, chauffeur service, room service, waitress service and everything in between...sounds like they would even expect babysitting services/childminding!

If they try to insist, be blunt, tell them no way, not going to happen, if they land at the airport they will be stranded there because nobody will be collecting them, and no doubt a whole ton of luggage (probably need at least 2 cars for all those people, 10 days worth of luggage, child seats etc - more like a bloody minibus! WW3, bring it on! You have common sense on your side.

Personally the damn cheek of these CF's would see all my politeness sailing off into the sunset and they would get a resounding FK OFF Good luck, but don't let this happen - it would take over your parents house, lives and probably ruin the 90th birthday. Let them send a card instead - that may be appreciated more than being unpaid servants to unwanted, uninvited guests. Never ceases to amaze me how many entitled twats populate Mumsnet/Gransnet threads - and we wonder why the world is in such a mess!

Mandyjack · 15/02/2022 19:16

You need to step in & tell them that it's not practical and they will have to make other arrangements

GreekGod · 15/02/2022 19:13

My goodness - this is awful OP and i really feel for you.

we had this problem growing up during my childhood - house was always full of relatives coming from overseas and who expected my poor DM and DF to taxi them everywhere. The irony was that we always stayed in hotels and never stayed with anyone but other relatives stayed with them and we were just dragged into it all especially as my father was the baby of the family and youngest of 5 so everyone took advantage of him. If it helps, we recently discussed this with my DM who is now in her 70s and she said to me that she wishes she was more assertive about this - said that she had awful arguments with my DF about this (I can't remember these at all )

So, I would suggest if you don't want them there - just tell them. Life is too short but be prepared to fall out with them. My DM said she wished she had fallen out with relatives - it would have made her life a lot less stressful and drama free

hope that helps

Ikeptgoing · 15/02/2022 19:05

I would text or email your US cousins and copy in the UK cousins they plan to stay with or their UK closer relatives

" Mum and Dad told me you (US cousins) plan to visit and stay with them for 10 days - all 7 of you including 2 toddlers- and don't plan to hire any car, as a plan to celebrate mums 90th.

That's not really a celebration for mum who'd prefer being taken out for a pub lunch for a couple hours instead!

As you know Mum is now 90 and amazing for it! But like all 90 year olds she no longer as fit as she was in her 70s, they are CEV and they cannot host anyone at their house like this, not 7 people and young children, ,let alone drive people around when they no longer drive !

Please don't put my parents in this position, as they'd love to see US cousins for a couple hours, not 10 days.

Can you please make a better plan- here is tourist information link for their area - so you can find local accomodation, where to eat, and will probably have link's to hire cars or taxis.
Thankyou , 2bees"

Datafan55 · 15/02/2022 19:02

I absolutely agree there can be NO WAY they stay with your parents, both because they’re frail and tired and would be exhausted from one day never mind ten, and because of the covid risk. Good and necessary that you are getting involved to point out the reality of the situation.

HOWEVER there is a lot of hate for these people on this thread when their motives might be quite different to what is being attributed to them.

As some PPs have said, they are probably unaware of how age has kicked in. They might be planning to pull their weight (eg meals on a rota), to contribute costs etc: of course the hosts will still feel a huge expectation on them, so the reality is different, but the thought might have been there. And everyone I know in the US seems to drive a long way for basics as per the bigger country, so maybe they’re thinking the airport doesn’t seem that far away etc - v different in practice when people and cars are old, but again…

Maybe they have long wanted to visit and often have wondered how the trans-Atlantic family are doing. Maybe they are doing it this year rather than x years ago simply because it is your mum’s milestone birthday. They might even be thinking that they want to celebrate with your mum but don’t want to take up her time round her actual birthday as she might have plans with closer family etc. Of course it’s nicer to visit somewhere in summer, rather than October. And you’re not going to pop half way across the world and not want to catch up with as many sights and relatives as possible – it doesn’t mean you’re taking advantage of people.

If you’re spending many hundreds on flights and you know family/good friends (especially family who have liked to host previously), the accommodation might be the difference between coming/seeing them or not. You also get more time with people if you stay with them; real time, quality time, and down-time - like taking a holiday with people instead of meeting (all too) briefly – you get to connect or reconnect and feel like you’ve really SEEN them.

I don’t know them nor what they are thinking. However I have travelled across continents and spent hundreds in order to see good friends/to meet distant family – to catch up, to explore their home areas with them - and I’d have been a bit hurt if they thought suggesting an odd lunch was enough. Leaving the issue of age/fragility and what your parents can manage aside, it doesn’t scream ‘we’d love to see you, thanks for making the effort’.

NotJustACigar · 15/02/2022 19:01

I think you have said and done exactly the right thing, OP. Speaking as an American sometimes you have to tell them things quite forcefully for them to get the message! And that goes for long term expats as well. They don't tend to do the tiptoeing around people dropping hints and expecting them to guess thing that people do here. My husband and his family are the worst for this being from Scotland and I find the guessing games quite confusing sometimes!

myrtleWilson · 15/02/2022 18:54

It's not only or even primarily about the £ though @IcingandSlicing - it's about the strain on the OPs parents Hmm

Knickerbokas · 15/02/2022 18:53

@5YearsLeft

I don’t want to be hyperbolic, but I do feel you absolutely must step in and not give a fig if it causes WW3. I’ve seen quite a few elderly people in the 85-92 age range “put up with” or “muddle through” either some huge family visit or a huge trip that they truly weren’t up for, and then at that age, they never completely recover their energy again. Especially if your mum was already CEV, they’re living rurally, two unreliable cars. I’m afraid you must get involved. It’s completely ridiculous, and utterly insane when it’s your host’s 90th birthday (!!!!) to expect this. I’m not sure what’s wrong with your relatives (have they forgotten she’s 90? Are they just so tight they don’t care? Having elder relatives come and visit is not an exchange of hospitalities - you must accept they will NOT be up for hosting your whole family, very obviously) as I can’t really imagine anyone else ever planning this and thinking it’s acceptable.

And IF WW3 threatens to kick off, I’d ask them if they’d feel comfortable telling their friends exactly what they’re doing, since it’s so acceptable - “Oh yes, we’re supposed to celebrate Gran’s 90th birthday so all seven of us are going to stay with her. Yes, we’re expecting her to get in all the food and beds and everything for us since we won’t be driving when we get there; in fact, we’re not going to have a car at all since we don’t like UK roads, so she’ll have to sort out two car seats and all that. And I’m not sure all seven of us will fit in the house but she’s going to have to sort that, too. Sure, she’s CEV and been shielding for two years but… Wait, why do you have that horrified look on your face? You don’t think it’s a nice 90th birthday present?”

This 👆

With bells on

Sparticuscaticus · 15/02/2022 18:49

OP
I think its fine for you to contact the other UK cousins and say did they realise what their US cousins were planning to do?! 😮😮

And its too much for your mum and Dad who are in their 90s to be able to accommodate, cater for or even be asked to drive around around these 7 visiting relatives when they are CEV and frail, but they didn't feel they could say, so they (UK cousins) need to support you redirect their US family. Thankyou , as they are not staying with mum and Dad

Feeascotime · 15/02/2022 18:47

I'm astounded! Not only to invite themselves but no driving???
How young are they that they don't figure this out for themselves?
Your parents will definitely try and pull out the stops and do too much. Sure they accommodated them years ago but the situation is very different. Also, Covid/omicron is still an issue. No ways! Step in! Or at least put down the ground rules - they drive, they cook they clean and leave house as found and they respect quiet time after bedtime.

Nanny0gg · 15/02/2022 18:43

@BoredZelda

I thiklbk I said upthread my mum is passive and finds it hard to say no

If you are going to comment on this thread, please at least have the good grace to read my posts before jumping in with both feet

I did read that. Still doesn't change the fact that it is her or your father's responsibility to decline people who "invite themselves" to their home.

Well, some people can't do that. Whether you think they should do or not.

And as you get older, you feel weaker and not always able to deal with confilct

So the OP's jumped in.

EmmaH2022 · 15/02/2022 18:40

@2beesornot2beesthatisthehoney

Well still no reply to my last message .

I have now found out that this is not a single trip to “celebrate” a milestone birthday 2 months early but they are also visiting other younger relatives after.

So this is definitely them looking for free holiday accommodation to visit tourist sites rather than the fictional celebration for my mum.

Contemplating contacting another cousin apparently playing one of several hosts to see if she has heard anything. I am thinking my name is now muck in the States.

That cousin could maybe accommodate by using adult childrens’ , houses not sure . And they are only staying there a few nights too.

Getting my hard hat ready for WW3

Do you have to engage in WW3?

Could you just say no and ignore the phone for a while or are your parents not okay with that?

IcingandSlicing · 15/02/2022 18:39

I don't understand the extreme self-centeredness of people nowadays, or has it always been like that?
Every human interaction is evaluated in money and calculated if it can be afforded ot not. Maybe we can't afford having family at all after all? Because £££££

Tulips21 · 15/02/2022 18:22

100% agree.
I care for elderly people and this is 100% on your relatives.
I would happily tell relatives no and if they have an issue- shame on them

Pinkyantelope · 15/02/2022 18:19

@BoredZelda

I thiklbk I said upthread my mum is passive and finds it hard to say no

If you are going to comment on this thread, please at least have the good grace to read my posts before jumping in with both feet

I did read that. Still doesn't change the fact that it is her or your father's responsibility to decline people who "invite themselves" to their home.

Don't be ridiculous. You're obviously extremely assertive and never let anything drop, on this or other threads.

Not everyone is as assertive as you clearly are. Especially people in their 90s.

Sometimes it's the kind and responsible thing to do to step in when more vulnerable people need help to stand up to CFs.

Yespresh · 15/02/2022 18:17

My 90 year old triple jabbed Mum is currently in bed with Covid. They need to stay elsewhere and meet up with her in a well ventilated area. They are being selfish.

wellstopdoingitthen · 15/02/2022 18:12

Perhaps they could stay in the Airbnb & get cabs when they want to go out & about. We've done that on holiday abroad & doesn't work out much different to cost of hire car without the stress of driving.

They are very selfish to expect to land in an elderly couple like this.

A very stressful situation for you.

godmum56 · 15/02/2022 18:11

@Dragonsmother

Sounds like my side of the family from India!! My parents have this all tue time. They Come over unannounced, stay as long as they like and expect us to become tour guides. All without putting their hands in their pocket!!! Then we all get roped into being taxi drivers and taking them across the country as London and Yorkshire are a 10 minute drive and I piss in my tank to keep the car going!!

I am sorry you are in this position. But at 90yrs old this is way too much for your parents.

why do you do it?