Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

7 coming to stay! Invited themselves ! To very elderly relatives !

511 replies

2beesornot2beesthatisthehoney · 14/02/2022 10:51

So some younger relatives contacted my mum to announce that they were coming to stay with my parents. 7 of them including 2 children. To celebrate her 90th birthday! For 10 days!

She will have to get food in , contemplating a caravan in the garden, (because their quite large house is not really big enough for 7 extra) and do all sorts of stuff in preparation and whilst they are there. My parents go to bed relatively early these days , so their sleeping habits no doubt will be disturbed. When I heard , I suggested I would look at alternative accommodation Air B&B etc . Trouble is they live in a very rural area away from public transport but I did find one possibility.

Then another bomb shell . They are not intending to hire a car because they don’t like British roads . ( not from uk) . So the property I found is unsuitable as it’s a few miles away with no public transport links.

My parents now have 2 unreliable cars hardly go anywhere now and been shielding for the last 2 years anyhow because mum is CEV . (Explaining unreliable cars but that is another thread in itself) . So these relatives expect to be driven everywhere and collected from the airport too. And the 2 children are young enough to need car seats I think ( youngest at least , not sure of height of older one) .

It’s utter madness! Mum feels compelled to say yes because over the years they have stayed with that family though not them personally.

I think she should be saying no! Dad says “ they will muddle through” .

AIBU to somehow step in without it causing WW3 in the family?

OP posts:
2Gen · 17/02/2022 11:27

@Peaseblossum22- Ah, that's my mistake and I copped to it after I wrote that post. I'm new to MN but am now going to read OP's posts first before commenting so I don't make that sort of mistake again. I live and learn!
@2beesornot2beesthatisthehoney- Have they replied yet? I keeping my fingers crossed they'll be gracious about it ( they should be ashamed of themselves!) but even if they're not, feck 'em, they're bang out of order and you have done the right thing! Let us know anyway!

Fudgemonkeys · 16/02/2022 19:26

Your parents are from an era where they accept whatever is chucked at them, never complaining and as you say will "muddle" through. Definitely step in, cause WW3, they clearly don't have any consideration for your parents they're obviously looking for free b&b. Good luck 👍

Justanotherobserver · 16/02/2022 16:49

Oh the great wisdom of those in their 20s. I hope I wasn't like that, but I probably was, at least a bit.

2beesornot2beesthatisthehoney - been following this and wish you well in protecting your parents, it all sounds massively infuriating!

Newestname002 · 16/02/2022 16:20

@PrincessNutella

How very rude of your visitors, enjoying your hospitality whilst lecturing you and the place you live. And as for the comment about your wedding dress!. I'm not sure how you didn't eject them long before their unwelcome visit. 🌹

PrincessNutella · 16/02/2022 15:55

We had two 20ish visitors once visit us in New York from Germany. Little did we know that we had invited them to stay for three weeks. Three weeks of lectures. Lectures about how America is bad--why do we not study the Vietnam war in high school (we do), why do we use air conditioning because it is wasteful (took them one day to figure out), etc; lectures about me such as why did I wear a white wedding dress when I was not a virgin when I got married, why did I have the planks on the deck cut diagonal instead of straight (again, wasteful), etc. Three longest weeks of my life. I'm very proud of you for saying a firm no now, OP. This must not and cannot happen.

Juniper68 · 16/02/2022 15:20

[quote 2beesornot2beesthatisthehoney]@Silvers11
In my last email I told them it was neither fair nor feasible and couldn’t happen .
I also said I didn’t care what they had been told by my parents but I was saying no to protect their health.

Hope that did the trick.[/quote]
Excellent

BoodleBug51 · 16/02/2022 14:45

Blimey, I had a feeling there would be a reason behind their sudden "kind" offer of coming over to celebrate.

That's a whole new level of CF'ery.

whiteworldgettingwhiter · 16/02/2022 14:33

Your relatives are unbelievably cheeky!!

We have stopped staying at my parents' house when we visit - they're in their early 80s. It's too much for them. So we book a cottage and they come to stay with us for a mini-break instead!

Hosting 9 people they don't even know that well for 10 days, including kids? Madness.

billy1966 · 16/02/2022 14:09

Well done OP.

They sound awful.

Silvers11 · 16/02/2022 13:48

[quote 2beesornot2beesthatisthehoney]@Silvers11
In my last email I told them it was neither fair nor feasible and couldn’t happen .
I also said I didn’t care what they had been told by my parents but I was saying no to protect their health.

Hope that did the trick.[/quote]
Sorry - we were posting at the same time!!

Silvers11 · 16/02/2022 13:47

Sorry @2beesornot2beesthatisthehoney

I thought I had read all your posts before I posted my comment -well I did - but I didn't get all the context. I see you have told them straight. Good on you. You may still also need to tell your parents though, as they may try to contact them instead and put pressure on for them to say yes? I liked the suggestion from someone that if you have to, you tell your cousins no matter what your Mum and Dad say it simply won't happen. Will be interesting to see what kind of response you will now get from the US family.

I should add. My Mother was great until she was 89 and a few months. Driving, going out, visiting places locally, enjoying life. Then she got pneumonia, initially undiagnosed and was in hospital for 2 weeks from Christmas Day 2018. She began to recover but her health has never been the same since. Preparations for her 90th Birthday ( an immediate family meal for 10 people in a local restaurant organised by others) over-excited her and she was back in hospital a few days later, because it was all too much for her. She has become ever more frail in the intervening (almost) 3 years. Lots more hospital stays and she now has carers. Once a very elderly person gets 'pulled down' by something which causes stress, or whatever, they are very unlikely to get back to where they were before the event so you are absolutely right to be stopping these relatives - even if WW£ ensues

2beesornot2beesthatisthehoney · 16/02/2022 13:46

@Silvers11
In my last email I told them it was neither fair nor feasible and couldn’t happen .
I also said I didn’t care what they had been told by my parents but I was saying no to protect their health.

Hope that did the trick.

OP posts:
Silvers11 · 16/02/2022 12:36

Ok I have read all your posts @2beesornot2beesthatisthehoney2beesornot2beesthatisthehoney. Sadly haven't the time to read all of the comments by the people replying to your original posts - but here is my take (as someone with a 92 - nearly 93 year old Mother):

It isn't clear to me exactly what you have said to the family members. Did a strongly worded email include the words 'NO you absolutely cannot stay with my parents' or did it simply state all the very good reasons why it wouldn't be a good idea? There is a difference?

Do you actually really know these people yourself and want to stay in touch with them? We all have more distant relatives who we hardly ever see. Does it matter if they never speak to you again? And would it be a matter of grief to your parents if they didn't speak to them either?

If you haven't already done so, you need to actually say 'No' to the US relatives. In BIG letters. End of. Stop trying to find them accomodation elsewhere and tell them ( for all the very good reasons you have explained on this thread) that the suggestion is simply a non-starter and that while your parents are not the ones saying 'no' , you as the daughter have to make the decision for them to protect them

I think you also need to tell your parents that you care about them far too much to let them be put upon like this, That you would never forgive yourself if the strain of entertaining these people or ill health as a result of catching Covid from them while they are out and about killed them or made them very ill - and you are putting your foot down about the whole thing to protect them. They may be a bit miffed with you - or they may be secretly grateful - but I do think if the less strongly worded stuff hasn't worked with the relatives you need to tell your parents what you are doing/intending to do

Good Luck. Not an easy situation to be in

affairsofdragons · 16/02/2022 11:50

@2beesornot2beesthatisthehoney

Spoke to my English cousin this evening . She has already told them that she was unavailable thinking it was only 2 but her sister said she was happy to have them.

She had heard the young couple with children had been invited to a party in Italy and were going to leave young kids with another cousin at my parents house and fly out for a couple of days . So total absolute bullshit that they want to celebrate my mums birthday ( 2 months early ) but looking at their house as the boarding school for the kids as they swan off!

I am speechless and I think another strongly worded message may be in order.

My English cousin Agreed with me it would be too much for my parents and also not to involve them as they would offer to muddle through! Said a similar event probably was the demise of her mum years ago.

Screw stern messages.

Tell them they will be turned away at the door, end of. And you will involve the police to remove them if you have to, cheeky fuckers.

Peaseblossum22 · 16/02/2022 11:48

The visitors are coming from the US but are of Irish descent

2Gen · 16/02/2022 11:24

@BlackAmericanoNoSugar

What? They're Irish and don't like British roads? What a load of bollocks that is. I can imagine someone having a problem the other way because some Irish roads are seriously tricky, like needing to reverse to a gateway when you meet oncoming traffic, but British roads are fine. I was assuming that they were coming from a country that drives on the other side and with different traffic rules, which would definitely be tricky for some people, but even then it wouldn't be fair to expect your parents to be their taxi.
This! I've lived in both countries and driven on the roads of both and although where the OP's parents live is remote and the roads may not be great, if they live here in Ireland they should be MORE than well able to cope as most of our roads are windy and narrow, and full of potholes too! Unless they live in Dublin and NEVER drive anywhere else in Ireland this is just bs and I would be doubtful and it still wouldn't be a good enough excuse to put upon 2 very elderly relations that aren't even that close!
UniversalAunt · 16/02/2022 11:10

‘ UniversalAunt
We found that when staying with elderly cousins who knew my Gparents well - in a land far far away & many time zones to count - we were frequently questioned by younger members of the family, sometimes directly & sometimes stealthily - about our home. Where it was, how close to London, how to long to get there and how many people could sleep there.

Once we’d twigged, my standard answer was that the family were welcome to sleep in the bathroom & the bus came though twice a week.

Went strangely quiet after that…
So you were happy to stay with family but didnt want to reciprocate?’

Good point. The hosting family were strongly connected to my branch through decades of letter writing after emigration, so the relationship & invitation to stay for a few days, during a long holiday most spent travelling, in hotels & with other close rellies, was staying with family for a long weekend in a spare room. It was a lovely getting to know that branch of the family & we became letter writers as well.

Whereas the curious set were not people who we had stayed with but had heard we were there for a few days & dropped by to scope us out as potential hosts.

2Gen · 16/02/2022 10:57

@2beesornot2beesthatisthehoney

Actually I think they just want a free holiday! Angry
Yes I suspect that too and they mustn't be allowed to take advantage of your elderly parents to get one! Oh no! I wasn't sure what to say at first but I've realised that in your shoes, I would have to step in to protect my parents and let the relatives kick off if they wanted too! They are being incredibly self-centred and cheeky and it seems to me they haven't considered the effect on your parents at all and need to be made to think about it. Lay it on a bit and see if they feel any bit guilty at all. If they do, they'll back off! If they don't, well then they are heartless bastards and you are well within your rights to tell them to feck right off...or however you want to phrase it!!! Good luck OP and happy birthday to your mother. Thank God your parents have you!
Ineke · 16/02/2022 10:48

No way…They should hire cars and arrange own accommodation. And pay for caterers to come in. This is far too much for 99 year old celebration. Utterly inconsiderate.

gingerbiscuits · 16/02/2022 10:36

@steppemum

Step in. Write to them and say that now your parents are 90 they are not able to cope with this, but they will never admit it. Staying with them is out fo the question. Expecting them to drive them anywhere is out of the question.

Your parents will never tell them as they are struggling to acknowledge this change, but at 90 they are now pretty elderly since the last time they saw them.

So as a good daughter you are stepping in.

Suggest they need to up their game and drive and stay in B&B, or not come.

100% this! ⬆️
StargazerAli · 16/02/2022 10:34

At 90?! Absolutely not on - what a bloody cheek some people have. People like this only learn if you tell them straight. Don't feel guilty; they don't.

rainbowstardrops · 16/02/2022 10:32

Bloody hell, it gets even worse!!!

Who in their right mind from all the cousins etc (I can't work out who's who either!) would think their self invite would be in any shape or form acceptable or feasible?!!!

Especially as the trip isn't even close to your mum's 90th and the younger ones were intending to drop the kids off and pop over to Italy! Bloody hell! 🙈

Pipsquiggle · 16/02/2022 10:15

@Integrity7

OP doesn't have to organise anything for CF relatives.
The CF relatives need to stop taking the piss - pretending they are there to celebrate a big birthday when they are not.
I don't know what OP is saying to her parents but she is obviously protecting them from this CFery.
I am sure if the CF relatives do want to pop in to see OPs DPs, OP will be asking everyone to be taking the appropriate measures to mitigate covid transmission.

Integrity7 · 16/02/2022 09:55

[quote Pipsquiggle]@Integrity7 are you being deliberately obtuse?

Your comments are so random and really not adding anything. You are going on about quarantine and OP 'delivering' CF relatives to alternative accommodation - I mean FFS RTFT.

OP's DPs are in their 90s and in no physical state to host anyone - let alone 7 people for 10 days.
OP lives 200 miles away and is CEV - she can't just pop round
CF rellies have an ulterior motive of a wedding in Italy and using DPs home as a base
OP has said CF rellies are welcome to visit DP but for tea and cake or take them out to lunch.[/quote]
No but it appears you are. Yes I did read them did you understand mine?
Possibly you have not understood the science.

I will explain it for you to clarify.

  1. Her parents are adults, why isn't she discussing it with them - perhaps she is..
  2. They are her parents. 3)They need help.
  3. Covid is a thing. Tea following a Wedding without a quarantine period puts them at potentially greater risk than making them quarantine. 5)It also forces them to deal with reality - has she explained to them about the clinically extremely vulnerable bit.
  4. if she cant get holiday / quarantine accommodation ready she could organise this with the person providing it.
  5. If she cares about her parents then why not visit for a couple of days or organise a carer - though this might put them at greater risk as carers work with multiple people.
  6. My betting is they will back out once a quarantine period is discussed and measures (masks, social distancing, bubbles) agreed with her parents or her parents will change their minds if they do not.
Pipsquiggle · 16/02/2022 09:35

@Integrity7 are you being deliberately obtuse?

Your comments are so random and really not adding anything. You are going on about quarantine and OP 'delivering' CF relatives to alternative accommodation - I mean FFS RTFT.

OP's DPs are in their 90s and in no physical state to host anyone - let alone 7 people for 10 days.
OP lives 200 miles away and is CEV - she can't just pop round
CF rellies have an ulterior motive of a wedding in Italy and using DPs home as a base
OP has said CF rellies are welcome to visit DP but for tea and cake or take them out to lunch.