Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To complain to school about this?

57 replies

TripExclusionComplain · 14/02/2022 09:21

DD aged 6 year 2, just watched all her classmates (bar 1 or 2 but all of her friends) get on a bus to go on a school trip.

The letters where sent out 4 weeks ago when DD was off with covid, they were not emailed and there was no option on ParentPay to pay for it.

I only learned about the trip on Friday at a classmates birthday party. The deadline was last Monday and despite me offering there was no option for me to pay and send DD.

The letters where apparently put in DDs tray but as she was off for over a fortnight and the trays are emptied on a Friday so DD never got the letter.

According to the teacher (who I mentioned it to) places weren’t limited as there’s 2 year groups going.

There’s no provision in school for those who aren’t going on the trip as it was assumed that everyone would go. There’s about 5 kids (out of 180ish) left across the two year groups, none of DDs friends and she’s gutted. I’ve been told DD will be put in a class that has room and made to follow their lessons, she has some SN and an adjusted curriculum due to that so will not be getting anything out of a lesson with another year group (It’s years 1 and 2 going, she won’t be put in Reception so it’ll be Year 3, 4 or 5 she’s put with)

All previous trips the letters have been emailed as well as sent out via trays/bags and even when DDs been off over the deadline, an email giving permission has always been accepted and I always had the option of paying via parentpay (and they’d accept payment as permission to go) or cash to the receptionist.

So AIBU to complain about how unfair this was handled?

To add DDs SN does not cause behaviour issues, her teacher labels her a sweetheart, everyones friend and a bit chatty but nothing unusual for this age. I do not think that her SN is the reason she’s been excluded as she’s been on previous trips (admittedly in Reception) which were pre-diagnosis and she behaved incredibly well her teacher at the time said she was less trouble than some of the NT DC on the trip (school suspected her SN before she was diagnosed).

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Rewritethestars1 · 15/02/2022 14:00

Their

Rewritethestars1 · 15/02/2022 14:00

You do not book a school trip with limited numbers which means some children cannot go. Unless the trip can include and cater for every single child in the class/year group, including those with additional needs, free school meals, financial constraints etc you do not book it. Who in there right mind would book a trip that can cater for 170 when there are 180 in the group. Id questions the intelligence of the person booking this to be honest. Hope its not the class teacher. Id be angry if I were you op. Nothing can be done now the day has passed but id want a satisfactory explanation as to why someone thought it was sensible to book a limited numbers trip and why only one letter was sent and not chased up.

TheHoptimist · 15/02/2022 13:17

Educational visit

TheHoptimist · 15/02/2022 13:16

It is not a trip but an educational isn’t to support curriculum delivery
I would email the head( ex Head) and ask why part of the curriculum was planned without enough provision for every child

Some nice quotes from the Ofsted handbook about an inclusive curriculum

TripExclusionComplain · 15/02/2022 12:47

Have emailed the headteacher but also CCed in the chair of governors.

I said that while a deadline to respond is fine because of transport/confirming with the venue/lunches for those who're on FSM, it's not on to not give parents the choice to go and that I think reminder texts or emails should go out a few days before the deadline to give parents the chance.

DD isn't autistic but she is very set in her ways, she can and does cope with changes and absolutely loves experiencing new things. I know she'd have loved 99% of the trip and been on her best behaviour - she doesn't behave badly at school anyway - the only part she'd probably not take part in where the dressing up but I know her and I know she'd be cheering her friends on or helping the teacher take photos like she does on dress up days in school.

She's been left confused thinking she'd been punished for catching covid or worse something she's done in school - she has memory issues so won't remember - but having spoken to her teacher there was no reason she was aware of that DD couldn't go (I have already checked this).

OP posts:
ballsdeep · 14/02/2022 20:00

Awful. I would complain to the head. It is the teachers responsibility to give these letters out and chase too. I have a list of letters, invites etc for children who are absent then give to their parents when they are back in.

Notoschool · 14/02/2022 19:58

@TripExclusionComplain

Update:

The teacher organising the trip spoke to me, she insisted places where limited and that's why there was no email or parentpay. It was "unfortunate" that DD missed out but one of those things.

Still feels a bit unfair on DD. They all came back at about 3pm talking about what they'd done.

It still feels a bit like it was deliberate. DDs got activities tonight so that should distract her.

She's had a bit of a boring day, apparently she was in Year 5 (the worst year she could of been put in) and didn't understand anything.

I would find that hard to believe. Limited spaces but yet 2 year groups could go apart from 5 children. Seems odd .
MrsTophamHat · 14/02/2022 19:56

I'm normally quick to defend schools but this is poor. There should have been ideally a phonecall or at least an email from the admin staff chasing it up. I say that as someone working in secondary - I've gone and knocked on doors trying to get permission slips signed before.

I do think communication can be inconsistent though. I've had a letter about an upcoming trip sent home in the book bag. There's been nothing on the app or parentpay about it. I can see how things get missed.

TripExclusionComplain · 14/02/2022 19:49

@endlesssighing

The situation is appalling and I think the response makes it worse.

Respond and state you appreciate the spaces are limited but can she direct you to the policies that outline where absent children are to be immediately stricken from the trip's consideration.

Because that's what she's essentially said.

Additionally, outline how this has caused extreme distress to your child, both on an emotional level and confused her and frustrated her in relation to her additional needs as her daily routine was completely turned on its head both in her educational setting and by having no social contact as all her friends were on the trip she had been purposely excluded from. What policy are they going to implement so this doesn't happen again.

You've been given a pack of lies. Someone's fucked up, not sent an email and is now desperately trying to cover their tracks.

@endlesssighing That's what I suspect, they either only counted the number of responses and didn't chase up or they forgot or had a technical issue that meant they didn't send the email out so those that were absent when the letters went out missed out.
OP posts:
endlesssighing · 14/02/2022 19:44

The situation is appalling and I think the response makes it worse.

Respond and state you appreciate the spaces are limited but can she direct you to the policies that outline where absent children are to be immediately stricken from the trip's consideration.

Because that's what she's essentially said.

Additionally, outline how this has caused extreme distress to your child, both on an emotional level and confused her and frustrated her in relation to her additional needs as her daily routine was completely turned on its head both in her educational setting and by having no social contact as all her friends were on the trip she had been purposely excluded from. What policy are they going to implement so this doesn't happen again.

You've been given a pack of lies. Someone's fucked up, not sent an email and is now desperately trying to cover their tracks.

Headteacher415 · 14/02/2022 19:33

Yes, I can't see any scenario where this trip wasn't booked not knowing that there would be a limit. Make an appointment to speak to headteacher, as your child has missed out on learning. Year 5 is not the right place for a KS1 child either!

TripExclusionComplain · 14/02/2022 18:03

@Headteacher415

What was the trip? It's highly unusual for a school to not be able to take extra children. We've only had this once ... theatre trip booked months in advance and suddenly 5 extra children joined. The newbies were the ones who couldn't go. The communication is an oversight and needs tightening up. Booking not enough places is the real complaint ... someone was always going to be disappointed
@Headteacher415 It was to a local history re-enactment, Year 2 are currently studying it and Year 1 will do it next year so they both go. They do the trip every 2 years for that reason.

The kids get involved in it and get to dress up and things.

OP posts:
Headteacher415 · 14/02/2022 17:54

What was the trip? It's highly unusual for a school to not be able to take extra children. We've only had this once ... theatre trip booked months in advance and suddenly 5 extra children joined. The newbies were the ones who couldn't go. The communication is an oversight and needs tightening up. Booking not enough places is the real complaint ... someone was always going to be disappointed

ouch321 · 14/02/2022 17:43

It's really not that big a deal. It's not like missing a class trip in year 2 is going to ruin her life chances.

NellyDElephant · 14/02/2022 17:38

Speaking from the opposite side of the fence, so to speak, it is incredibly annoying to have to chase and chase and nag and remind parents who don’t give permission for their child to go on trips - however, we haven’t yet left a single child behind. It’s a small primary school I work at, we are relentless at chasing for permission - we really don’t want the child to miss out, we are on the phone on the morning of trips, chasing up the last few, for, at the very least, verbal permission to take them. We send an email version of the trip letter, a paper copy of letter, electronic version on classdojo and then individual reminders x 3 at least, in the weeks/days before the trip. It’s a full-time job!
Op, in this instance, I think your school have been really crap, and I would complain. I’d like to see their criteria for choosing the places!

Oblomov22 · 14/02/2022 17:37

This is disgusting. So poor.

TripExclusionComplain · 14/02/2022 17:31

@CristinaYangismySpiritAnimal

I appreciate it’s a bit late now, but I wouldn’t have left her in school if I was you, she would have come straight back home with me. We’ve recently taken the entire school On a trip and we chased and chased every single family to make sure no one missed out, including all of those who were off with Covid and those who couldn’t afford it. What your school has done is awful.
@CristinaYangismySpiritAnimal Unfortunately I had to work so had no choice but to leave her as I have no childcare, and I don't get paid if i don't work.
OP posts:
CristinaYangismySpiritAnimal · 14/02/2022 17:26

I appreciate it’s a bit late now, but I wouldn’t have left her in school if I was you, she would have come straight back home with me. We’ve recently taken the entire school
On a trip and we chased and chased every single family to make sure no one missed out, including all of those who were off with Covid and those who couldn’t afford it. What your school has done is awful.

lumpofcomfort · 14/02/2022 17:21

trips

lumpofcomfort · 14/02/2022 17:21

Teachers should not rely on letters being taken home for trips etc, especially when children have been off poorly

Administrative arrangements for trios should not be the responsibility of class teachers at all. It should be managed by the office staff who keep track of responses.

Userno574328537 · 14/02/2022 17:04

Shocking. Teachers should not rely on letters being taken home for trips etc, especially when children have been off poorly. My kids school tend to send texts about it to check for letters, emails or parent pay as you say.

The school should have chased you up about it if no consent form or payment had been taken from you - because she was off!!

Shocking organisation and management from the school!

I would definitely complain! I mean it won't change anything now but might teach them to be more organised.

TripExclusionComplain · 14/02/2022 17:03

@Butteredtoast55

Why on earth would you be removed from a contact list because your DD had Covid? That makes no sense at all.
@Butteredtoast55 Thats what I'm assuming it might not be true, but I didn't get a single text or email at all while she was off, the texts are usually every few days to remind about pick up points when it's raining or because they need to take some yogurt pots in or because they need to dress like a pirate (not real examples).
OP posts:
Butteredtoast55 · 14/02/2022 17:01

Why on earth would you be removed from a contact list because your DD had Covid? That makes no sense at all.

TripExclusionComplain · 14/02/2022 16:58

@SliceOfCakeCupOfTea

I would have been furious.

Does your school not do a weekly newsletter or anything where they put basic info about upcoming trips or special days?

They should have sent out letters and emails to cover the all the bases and let those who wanted to go go. Not good enough.

@SliceOfCakeCupOfTea We usually get a newsletter every 2 weeks or so, sometimes more often but I got nothing at all while she was off with Covid, not even the usual texts about pick up points when it's raining.

I've had emails and texts since she went back so I'm assuming we were temporarily removed from the lists due to having covid.

OP posts:
lumpofcomfort · 14/02/2022 16:57

Primary schools should not be booking trips where a handful of kids have been left out. If someone did that it was a mistake. Probably someone counted up the numbers who had replied and decided they would get fewer coaches based on that without checking. Whatever has happened, it's not acceptable.