Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder where the money is coming from to buy houses?

616 replies

00100001 · 13/02/2022 22:35

So, if houses used to be (say) 4-5x average annual salary back in the olden days of the boomers.

And now house prices are 10 X average salary... Bit they're still being bought, and people want to buy...

Where is this money coming from?

Are boomer parents artificially inflating house prices by giving huge sums of money by releasing equity etc?

Who is buying the expensive houses??

OP posts:
UniversalAunt · 14/02/2022 15:26

One of the interesting elements of the post-COVID return to work is the absence of the over 55 employee.

As many of us may know from personal experience that the UK workplace is not that fond of the over 55s. They often have found them selves slowly managed out of the UK workforce on a variety of legally sound reasons but not that ethically good.

What this has meant is a socially acceptable ‘early retirement’ & from that an adjustment of income & savings. This is a time when people take their occupational pensions & the opportunity for a 25% lump sum, & also many downsize. Both of these financial events release lumps sums. Return on savings & annuities are not attractive, so the cash lump sums may become available to get their children on to the property ladder or for a while there was an efficiency in being a BTL landlord. This throws some kindling into the hot market.

Iamthewombat · 14/02/2022 15:18

[quote Yeahthat]@Mollysocks

Yup; it's lazy and stupid. Do the maths and it's objectively far more difficult for young people nowadays to buy homes, including when you work out the potential savings from not buying the mythical avocado toast, or reducing Starbucks coffees.[/quote]
The mention of avocados - poncy food for people who think they are better than the rest of us, bloody snowflakes etc etc - plays really well with the ‘four Yorkshiremen’ slant of some of the posts, though.

“Avocados only cost 70p you say? Well, I didn’t spend 70p on an avocado. I worked two twelve hour shifts every day. I didn’t take the bus to work, I WALKED so that I didn’t have to spend money at the gym. When I got back to my parents’ garage, where I was living rent free to save up, I didn’t put the light on, to save putting 50p in the meter. I ate roots and berries I scavenged on the way home. Now tell me that you couldn’t afford a house if you did the same as me!”

WindyState · 14/02/2022 15:16

@Couchpotato3

It's completely possible for a young person or a couple to save for a deposit, even without help from parents. However it is a slog and means making sacrifices, whether that is holding back on holidays, cars, socialising etc. owning a house isn't the be all and end all for everyone, but it feels like the grown up thing to do and a safe investment, even in these troubled times.
For many, no, it's not.

If house prices rise significantly faster than wages then no matter how long people save for they will never have enough for a deposit - even if they do manage to save say 20k over 5 years, at the end of those five years they will need a deposit of 30k for the exact same property.

I also think that most people do not realise how much harder it is to get a mortgage compared to 10 years ago. The lenders have significantly tightened up their criteria for lending which is why so many people are stuck on expensive mortgages but are unable to remortgage onto cheaper rates.

Couchpotato3 · 14/02/2022 15:08

It's completely possible for a young person or a couple to save for a deposit, even without help from parents. However it is a slog and means making sacrifices, whether that is holding back on holidays, cars, socialising etc. owning a house isn't the be all and end all for everyone, but it feels like the grown up thing to do and a safe investment, even in these troubled times.

INeedNewShoes · 14/02/2022 15:06

I was so lucky to buy my first property in 2007. Just in time. I had to make significant sacrifices to do it and my first flat was a huge compromise (a small flat in a very grotty tower block). I see me being on the property ladder as a mixture of luck, determination and willingness to be compromise and be frugal.

However, I am under no illusion whatsoever that in 2022 if I was starting over, in the same level job I was in in 2007 and same circumstances that there is no chance at all that any combination of luck & sacrifices would be sufficient for me to buy a property in the area of the country that I did on one income.

No one who bought pre-2008 is in a position to comment on young adults not succeeding in getting on the property ladder in 2022. I definitely don't think that if they give up their takeaway coffee and manicures that it would make the difference. It's just not true.

DrSbaitso · 14/02/2022 15:02

@nancybotwinbloom

I had to start again at 38. Ex husband left the country and refused to pay the mortgage on the house we jointly owned.

I sold it for a £13k profit as he'd ripped the bathrooms and kitchen out and not replaced either.
We lost so much money because of this.

I couldn't afford to live there as it was 30 miles away from my family who helped me with child care whilst I worked full time. The petrol costs were unaffordable for me.

When it sold he took the £13k profit as he wouldn't sell without me agreeing. I would have lost my half and more by going to court and still been liable for the full mortgage.

I was living in council housing at the time so I bought that when I got the right to buy/right to acquire.

There isn't a shortage in my area. This was the only way I could back on the ladder.

I've got mixed feelings about right to buy as a scheme, but I definitely 100000% don't blame ANYONE who was offered it and accepted. I bought a house largely with inheritance; I didn't spend my 20s in my parents' cellar and never socialising or having any fun.

You have to work with the system as it is and if right to buy benefited you, you didn't do anything wrong in taking advantage of it, any more than I contributed to the housing market issue by using money I didn't earn as my deposit.

Yeahthat · 14/02/2022 15:01

@Windystate

I agree. You would have to he drinking an extreme amount of Starbucks if the mere act of reducing it were able to compensate for housing market inflation.

WindyState · 14/02/2022 14:53

@OpheliaThrupps

So what people are saying then, is that people shouldn’t eat to afford a house??

I think what they're saying is that is more people lived more frugally then more people would have more money for a deposit. They are not saying that if Diesel and Zoozoo give up avocados a loft apartment in Dalston will be theirs.

But that fundamentally ignores the fact that house prices are rising faster than wages.

In such a situation no matter how long or hard you save for you will NEVER have enough for a deposit and to meet lending criteria, because it's a target which is constantly accelerating away.

YukoandHiro · 14/02/2022 14:50

I know what you mean OP. In our case it's inheritance as DH has no surviving relatives and we've piled everything he was passed on into a nice family home. But I often wonder how on Earth others manage

nancybotwinbloom · 14/02/2022 14:45

I had to start again at 38. Ex husband left the country and refused to pay the mortgage on the house we jointly owned.

I sold it for a £13k profit as he'd ripped the bathrooms and kitchen out and not replaced either.
We lost so much money because of this.

I couldn't afford to live there as it was 30 miles away from my family who helped me with child care whilst I worked full time. The petrol costs were unaffordable for me.

When it sold he took the £13k profit as he wouldn't sell without me agreeing. I would have lost my half and more by going to court and still been liable for the full mortgage.

I was living in council housing at the time so I bought that when I got the right to buy/right to acquire.

There isn't a shortage in my area. This was the only way I could back on the ladder.

ManicPixie · 14/02/2022 14:43

@Blossomtoes

We’ll that’s the problem isn’t it - for anyone over 50 there isn’t a housing crisis, just a growing mountain of passive wealth accumulation. And that’s why nothing will happen, even though economic mechanisms are there.

Anyone who bought a house before 2008 actually. There are plenty of people over 50 who don’t own houses. And plenty aged less than 50 who bought before the crash.

Fine, if you want to nitpick, replace ‘anyone over 50’ with ‘anyone who bought before the crash’. Point still stands - enough people from certain cohorts gain from it that nothing will change on the supply side. For many it’s working exactly as it should.
DrSbaitso · 14/02/2022 14:40

You may be able to afford a house if you can live with your parents for ten years while having no fun, and doubled up with a partner doing the same, but you really shouldn't bloody have to.

witheringrowan · 14/02/2022 14:40

@Yeahthat Agreed. I think it's important to remember that a political choice was made in 2008 not to allow house prices to fall too much (banks encouraged not to repossess in the way they did in 1992, so fewer forced sales and the correction wasn't as big as it could have been), political decision to commit to QE and keep interest rates low, which led to investors piling in to property as one of the only sectors that has decent yields, and a political decision to cut social housing provision. So you have to expect that at some point there will be a political retribution from those now shut out of the system. Good article on this in the LRB from John Lanchester a few years ago: www.lrb.co.uk/the-paper/v40/n13/john-lanchester/after-the-fall

gogohm · 14/02/2022 14:39

Inheritance does come into it, my parents inherited £100k and bought a bigger house , one day (hopefully not soon) I stand to inherit £300k based on todays value and assuming care costs are horrific. I already own a house so I could in theory buy a bigger one or give to my (now) young adult kids.

Itsnotdeep · 14/02/2022 14:38

I completely agree that both the private rental system and the social housing situation are completely horrendous and need reform @ManicPixie . Also agree that a system that allows buy to lets and the like which are allowing some people to get (very) asset rich at the expense of others is pretty immoral too.

Blossomtoes · 14/02/2022 14:36

We’ll that’s the problem isn’t it - for anyone over 50 there isn’t a housing crisis, just a growing mountain of passive wealth accumulation. And that’s why nothing will happen, even though economic mechanisms are there.

Anyone who bought a house before 2008 actually. There are plenty of people over 50 who don’t own houses. And plenty aged less than 50 who bought before the crash.

OpheliaThrupps · 14/02/2022 14:36

So what people are saying then, is that people shouldn’t eat to afford a house??

I think what they're saying is that is more people lived more frugally then more people would have more money for a deposit. They are not saying that if Diesel and Zoozoo give up avocados a loft apartment in Dalston will be theirs.

Yeahthat · 14/02/2022 14:34

@Mollysocks

Yup; it's lazy and stupid. Do the maths and it's objectively far more difficult for young people nowadays to buy homes, including when you work out the potential savings from not buying the mythical avocado toast, or reducing Starbucks coffees.

Mollysocks · 14/02/2022 14:29

Yeah those avocados are so expensive 🙄

This has been my thought throughout! Where did this ‘avocado on toast’ thing come from? I’d understand if people were saying they’re spending their money on caviar and champagne but avocado? An avocado costs 70p and a tin of baked beans, with the little pork sausages in, costs 70p. So what people are saying then, is that people shouldn’t eat to afford a house??

ManicPixie · 14/02/2022 14:28

@Zilla1

Regarding politicians 'doing nothing', how would a government that engineered a significant reduction in average house prices be rewarded? With a hearty thanks by those looking to buy and those with DCs who are not home owners? Or by fury by the average homeowner? And then take into account what happens to the availability of mortgages and the availability of property when house prices do crash/significantly reduce in the UK?
We’ll that’s the problem isn’t it - for anyone over 50 there isn’t a housing crisis, just a growing mountain of passive wealth accumulation. And that’s why nothing will happen, even though economic mechanisms are there.
Lampzade · 14/02/2022 14:22

@Iamthewombat

When I read these threads (and Kirstie Allsopp’s online musings) I feel so sorry for younger people.

It would infuriate me to read endless bits of advice from people who lived on soup made from grass clippings whilst living in their parents’ box room drinking tap water for ten years to save up enough deposit to get a 35 year mortgage on some overpriced pile of bricks. Yes, I am exaggerating for comic effect.

However, why do we persist in telling younger people that they can’t have any fun AT ALL, and if they go out for brunch involving an avocado once a month, or go to the gym, or go on holiday, or buy new clothes to go clubbing in, or move out of home to find their independence, they just haven’t earned the right to own a home of their own, ever? Oh yeah, and their expectations are too high an’ all! Think you’re special, do ya? Snowflakes, the lot of you! No wonder they get annoyed. So would I be.

All this ‘I did it and so can you if you try hard enough’ bollocks! I wouldn’t say that. I’m 50, generation X. I had it very easy compared to today’s twentysomethings, and I wouldn’t have the brass neck to pretend otherwise.

I could buy a 3 bed house in a suburb of Manchester on a salary not much above average when I was 26, in 1998. Sheer luck. I went clubbing all the time and went on holiday and bought new clothes too. I didn’t have to pay for my degree, more luck because I was born at the right time. I got windfalls from building societies that became banks: sheer luck. It’s insulting to younger people to pretend that it was anything other than dumb luck.

This
Yeahthat · 14/02/2022 14:21

@Itsnotdeep

I earned alot of money and was able to buy a flat with my then boyfriend in 1994. No help.

I don't understand these threads - surely instead of complaining about "boomers" (and why the constant bitterness? I don't get it) the young people today (and I include my children in that) just need to adapt their expectations? Property ownership isn't a right and most people won't be able to do it unless they have substantial parental help (whether it's in the form of cash, inheritance or being able to live at home to save up).

Most people won't (and why should they?) adapt their expectations in order to happily maintain a system that they have no stake in.

When property ownership becomes increasingly impossible, with people at the mercy of a rental market largely governed by the rent-seeking behaviour of those who regard housing not as a right, but a resource to be hoovered up, hoarded and inflated - then they will begin to look and vote for more radical solutions.

There are myriad examples - just from recent times, Brexit and Trump; when people feel that mainstream politics won't address their issues, they will look for more extreme solutions.

A young person starting out now, presented with the option that home ownership is out of reach, and they must simply work for decades to pay back the money that someone else borrowed, with little security while they do so - why would they continue to vote to perpetuate such a system?

Scarlettpixie · 14/02/2022 14:21

You can still get houses in the midlands for 4-5 times average annual salary and if you consider lots of people buy with someone else…

.

Zilla1 · 14/02/2022 14:15

Regarding politicians 'doing nothing', how would a government that engineered a significant reduction in average house prices be rewarded? With a hearty thanks by those looking to buy and those with DCs who are not home owners? Or by fury by the average homeowner? And then take into account what happens to the availability of mortgages and the availability of property when house prices do crash/significantly reduce in the UK?

LuckyAmy1986 · 14/02/2022 14:09

@Seashor saving up while both living at home isn’t as much of an achievement as you think it us!!!