Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder where the money is coming from to buy houses?

616 replies

00100001 · 13/02/2022 22:35

So, if houses used to be (say) 4-5x average annual salary back in the olden days of the boomers.

And now house prices are 10 X average salary... Bit they're still being bought, and people want to buy...

Where is this money coming from?

Are boomer parents artificially inflating house prices by giving huge sums of money by releasing equity etc?

Who is buying the expensive houses??

OP posts:
Mumoblue · 14/02/2022 17:32

Lots of people get help from their parents.

And yes, living at home rent free (or for very low keep) is help!
Some of us couldn’t live at home to save up.

And, no, I don’t eat avocado either!

OpheliaThrupps · 14/02/2022 17:32

Hello @WindyState,

We're going round in circles, but how do you explain how people have been saving deposits and buying houses all through this time of alarming house-price inflation. You earlier said it was impossible.

(Incidentally, the graph doesn't prove your second (different) point either! Use the graph to turn the clock back to 2003. Or 1985. Look at the alarming gap that has opened up between wages and house prices. It very obviously can't possibly go on like that ...)

WindyState · 14/02/2022 17:24

@OpheliaThrupps

Ah, Ok, thanks *@WindyState*, I think your point may have subtly changed Grin
Well, no, it hasn't.

The basic fact is that as house prices go up the amount of money you need for a deposit goes up, it's not as simple as saving x per month for x years and you are all sorted, you effectively need to start saving more than you actually think you will need, and if you are on the limit of what you can save the only way to compensate for that is if your wage goes up a corresponding amount to house prices.

Kinko · 14/02/2022 17:13

@DrSbaitso

If you go to buy another house that is £150k then you now have £80k deposit to put down (more than 50%, giving you better interest rates and terms) - you will of course have stamp duty, legal costs, removals etc - but there comes a point where the increase value in your home covers this.

But you're buying a house that's worth the same as the house you're living in now.

I realise you might be moving to change areas and you might get different bang for your buck between cities. But generally, if people move to "climb the ladder", they're moving to a more expensive/valuable property than the one they're living in is worth now. So yes, they get the deposit but they also get a stonking new mortgage on top of it.

Not necessarily - the more deposit you have the better the interest rate.

If you have a 90% mortgage vs a 75% mortgage - your rate will be better. Of course, an individual may go and get a stonking new mortgage putting them back to a 90% rate but I'd say most don't. Point is with increase value in your home you have more options.

OpheliaThrupps · 14/02/2022 17:12

Ah, Ok, thanks @WindyState, I think your point may have subtly changed Grin

WindyState · 14/02/2022 16:43

@OpheliaThrupps

You've literally proved my point for me. The issue is the gap between average salaries and average house prices. See how much bigger it is now compared to 20/30/40 years ago? See how faster house prices have increased over wages since around 2000?

Combine that with lenders who are now massively more cautious and you've got way, way more people who are completely priced out compared to the 70s/80s/90s/2000s.

Bouledeneige · 14/02/2022 16:34

I recently bought a large flat for £1 million. I'm divorced and 57. 80 percent of the price was equity built up on house moves. The majority was made on one house in a very desirable area of London which I'd done up over the years - it was a wreck when I bought it and it was tough going for the first couple of years finding the money to do it up (it never was in tip top condition). I had £800k equity from that house built up over 20 years (after paying off my XH's remaining stake and an additional interest only mortgage). My move was a downsize but to a higher spec period home that has everything done.

Since I wanted to stay in the area to be close to friends I had to pay a lot and still have a 10 year mortgage to pay off. I may inherit some money when my elderly father dies that might pay off up to half of that and I'm going to try to accelerate payments myself. I've never had any family help, saved my own deposits etc. I've worked hard over the years and it was a juggle when my DC were little but I built a good career and my earning potential. I have good pensions too.

OpheliaThrupps · 14/02/2022 16:32

@WindyState

"But this is demonstrably wrong - property has outstripped wage inflation for as long as I can remember! "

No, it hasn't. The gap has increased massively in recent years.

In the early 90s an average salary for a 21 y/o was around 11k, with average house prices being around 50k -> So 4x annual salary.

In 2022 those figures have changed to around 20k and 255k. See the problem?

Hello @WindyState

Here's the graph. Property prices have grown at a greater rate than wages for most of recent history. People have nevertheless saved deposits and bought property. But you seem to be saying that at the moment because property prices are growing faster than wages it's somehow arithmetically impossible to save a deposit.

In fact looking back you said:
But that fundamentally ignores the fact that house prices are rising faster than wages.

In such a situation no matter how long or hard you save for you will NEVER have enough for a deposit and to meet lending criteria, because it's a target which is constantly accelerating away.

Which history (and other reasoning) suggests is wrong!

To wonder where the money is coming from to buy houses?
tinkywinkyshandbag · 14/02/2022 16:31

@Plumface actually the number of private landlords in the UK has stayed pretty much constant over recent years. In fact, there is a shortage of rental property which is white rents in general are going up.

This is largely thanks to the government doing their very best to make it hard to be a private landlord, with all the recent legislative and tax changes. Many landlords are in fact selling up (thus reducing the amount of housing stock available to rent)

At the same time, lenders are now making 90% mortgages available to 1st time buyers again, which has stimsted demand at the bottom
end which then permeates to the chain, plus the stamp duty holiday massively inflated demand and inflated prices at the same time.

The estate agents I'm speaking to are saying that there is a real shortage of property coming onto the market for sale, for various reasons. This is therefore reducing the amount of stock available for people to buy, which again pushes up the prices.

As to who is able to afford those prices, that's a whole other matter, I certainly couldn't!

nordica · 14/02/2022 16:22

I had money from an inheritance to get me onto the property ladder - people seem to react to that angrily but frankly I'd rather my father had been alive for another 20 years even if it meant no house...

Other friends around my age have also mostly used money from inheritance for their deposits. And people are climbing up the property ladder - my first flat was £155k, had a short lease and hadn't been modernised for years, but was in an "up and coming" area. It was just pure luck though as I know I wouldn't be able to get anything for that price now.

WindyState · 14/02/2022 16:21

"But this is demonstrably wrong - property has outstripped wage inflation for as long as I can remember! "

No, it hasn't. The gap has increased massively in recent years.

In the early 90s an average salary for a 21 y/o was around 11k, with average house prices being around 50k -> So 4x annual salary.

In 2022 those figures have changed to around 20k and 255k. See the problem?

OpheliaThrupps · 14/02/2022 16:16

@WindyState

Fundamentally if the price of property available goes up faster than wage inflation then there isn't going to be a property they can afford with that 20k deposit.

But this is demonstrably wrong - property has outstripped wage inflation for as long as I can remember!

no matter how long people save for they will never have enough for a deposit

People have managed to save deposits over all that period of roaring property inflation.

Bringsexyback · 14/02/2022 16:16

@Billandben444

My stepson and his wife have just bought a 2-bedroom flat for £85k on the Wirral. His salary is £23k and her part-time one is £10k. They both work in Liverpool and it's an easy commute for them. They saved up for the deposit while in rented accommodation (I think it took them 3 years) and have managed it without asking the family for financial help. It is still possible in certain parts of the UK.
Knowing the Wirral, a 2 bed flat that isn’t like living in beruit would be £250,000. Good luck to them theyll need it, i hope they dont have nice cars parked outside
daimbarsatemydogsbone · 14/02/2022 16:16

@Itsnotdeep

But everyone over 50 isn't fine. There's a view on here that it's all ok being over 50. Many people over 50 don't own a house. Many are in lower value houses with no pension, or no job. Many aren't going to inherit anything from parents, so can't pass onto their children. Many are supporting their parents, financially or otherwise (all boomers aren't ok either).

There's a tendency to see owning houses as the be all and end all, but the over 50s aren't all ok.

Exactly - and even if it was true - it's fucking insulting.

There's an implication that there the have been regular referendums with the question "do you want to steal all the money of the young people?" in which everyone over 50 voted yes 100% of the time.
Many of us didn't vote for this - and we didn't buy cheap council houses even if we had the had the chance etc etc - yet every single thread on here has a least one cunt writing us all off as greedy bastards.

Tunnocks34 · 14/02/2022 16:14

I will say if I hadn’t have had help off my parents in the form of 10k - we’d never have been able to buy because we were naive, silly and had children young. We couldn’t save a deposit and pay for childcare. Yes, eventually we would have done it, but not in time for the house price increase which means we actually wouldn’t be able to buy our own house now - and we have an combined income of over 80k so we’re not in poverty, or even struggling. Houses at the price we bought our house (in our area) for now, are two bed terraced needed a lot of work. We bought a 3 bed detached in almost perfect condition save for a mirrored ceiling in the master bedroom

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 14/02/2022 16:13

We’ll that’s the problem isn’t it - for anyone over 50 there isn’t a housing crisis, just a growing mountain of passive wealth accumulation. And that’s why nothing will happen, even though economic mechanisms are there.
What an ignorant pile of ageist shite.

Itsnotdeep · 14/02/2022 16:12

But everyone over 50 isn't fine. There's a view on here that it's all ok being over 50. Many people over 50 don't own a house. Many are in lower value houses with no pension, or no job. Many aren't going to inherit anything from parents, so can't pass onto their children. Many are supporting their parents, financially or otherwise (all boomers aren't ok either).

There's a tendency to see owning houses as the be all and end all, but the over 50s aren't all ok.

Whammyyammy · 14/02/2022 16:11

@DrSbaitso

You may be able to afford a house if you can live with your parents for ten years while having no fun, and doubled up with a partner doing the same, but you really shouldn't bloody have to.
You mean save money by making persinal sacrifices? I recall my parents and grandparents saying that is what they done, us too to afford to buy a house. Home ownership is not an entitlement, it takes commitment.
WindyState · 14/02/2022 16:10

@OpheliaThrupps

Hello *@WindyState*

Am I being dim? I'm not really getting your logic here. As far as I can see people can certainly save a deposit, no matter what inflation is doing.

If house prices rise significantly faster than wages then no matter how long people save for they will never have enough for a deposit - even if they do manage to save say 20k over 5 years, at the end of those five years they will need a deposit of 30k for the exact same property.

So they buy what they can with a deposit of £20k.

Fundamentally if the price of property available goes up faster than wage inflation then there isn't going to be a property they can afford with that 20k deposit. The price of everything from the top of the tree to shitty little flats will have gone up faster than they can save.

So the choice is our FTB need to save a higher percentage of their wages - which for many people isn't possible - or they need some sort of extra help from parents/inheritence etc.

Tunnocks34 · 14/02/2022 16:09

Not sure but it’s mental. I live in Salford - a decent part (but not Worsley prices) but let’s be honest, Salford is Salford. Three years ago we bought our three bed house for £185k - it’s now ‘worth’ £300k and the identical house next door to ours sold for £350k this week.

It’s absolutely mental.

OpheliaThrupps · 14/02/2022 16:04

Hello @WindyState

Am I being dim? I'm not really getting your logic here. As far as I can see people can certainly save a deposit, no matter what inflation is doing.

If house prices rise significantly faster than wages then no matter how long people save for they will never have enough for a deposit - even if they do manage to save say 20k over 5 years, at the end of those five years they will need a deposit of 30k for the exact same property.

So they buy what they can with a deposit of £20k.

XingMing · 14/02/2022 15:46

UniversalAunt's theory about the over-55s being managed out of employment has substance, especially with using the lump sum for investment. Annuities and cash savings rates are dreadful, so yes, lots of people bought a BTL as property was the only investment they understood and could see yielding 7-10% return. I think that advantage is evaporating fast.

Certainly when we retire which means selling a business, we shall give DC a hefty chunk of the proceeds towards a property. The industry they want to join is mostly freelance and, though decently paid, there will be patches when there's no work happening.

nancybotwinbloom · 14/02/2022 15:42

@DrSbaitso

I agree. I also had mixed feelings about how I bought our home.

When I weighed it up I thought about the state it was handed to me in.

No floors in any room. Just bare floorboards. Rat infested garden we couldn't use. Every wall needed replastering. It was like a hovel to be honest. Kitchen was dog chewed on all the bottom doors. Every single interior door had a punch mark in or a kick through.

I got a £75 voucher to re paint. No other assistance because I work full time.

I paid for it to become what it is now over the last few years and I've paid more in the renovations it needed than the 9k discount I received.

It's took hard graft, saving up when I could and hours of weekend and evening to get my home nice. It's a three bed terrace. It's in a so so area.

We are in the northwest and the housing situation is not what it is in say london. They are literally throwing up council housing all over where I am.

However I know how lucky I am to live where I do and to have had the opportunity to have the chance to buy from the council.

I didn't buy this house to turn a profit or rent out I bought it for the security and because I was lucky enough to be offered the chance to.

Ultimately when I die, it's for my Dd so she never gets in the positron I found myself in with her dad.

Iamthewombat · 14/02/2022 15:42

It really hasn’t always been like that. It certainly wasn’t like that for my generation, who bought in the 1990s and early 2000s. Loads of people bought as single twenty and thirty somethings, and I didn’t have to live at home to save up.

Kazzyhoward · 14/02/2022 15:37

@DrSbaitso

You may be able to afford a house if you can live with your parents for ten years while having no fun, and doubled up with a partner doing the same, but you really shouldn't bloody have to.
It's always been like that, though. My parents married in the 60s and started their married life living with Dad's parents in their front room to save money for a deposit and spent a few years there without much "fun" as it's what you had to do even in the 1960's, so it's nothing new at all. Although it was, of course, "easier" in the intervening period mostly due to high inflation causing high wage rises (70s/80s).