Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder where the money is coming from to buy houses?

616 replies

00100001 · 13/02/2022 22:35

So, if houses used to be (say) 4-5x average annual salary back in the olden days of the boomers.

And now house prices are 10 X average salary... Bit they're still being bought, and people want to buy...

Where is this money coming from?

Are boomer parents artificially inflating house prices by giving huge sums of money by releasing equity etc?

Who is buying the expensive houses??

OP posts:
malificent7 · 15/02/2022 12:24

Inheritance here.

StEval · 15/02/2022 12:22

[quote 00100001]@OpheliaThrupps

But where's the money coming from? It would seem... Parents/grandparents neither directly by giving them money, or indirectly by letting them love with them for next to nothing.

This all artificially boosts spending power, surely?

Joe Bloggs just cannot afford to pay £650k for that 4 bed house.... but actually he, his wife and his parents can

.
If people weren't giving this money ...would house prices be this expensive? I'd say no. Because people just can't magic up an extra £50k so the houses wouldn't sell, so the prices wouldn't be so high...[/quote]
You seem very set on blaming baby boomers here.
They give to their children and its inflating house prices, they dont give and they are selfish, money grabbersConfused

House prices have been inflated by demand outstripping supply, the hold on stamp duty caused a rush to buy and the H2B scheme which has kept the demand for new homes going.

PrincessSpanky · 14/02/2022 21:30

We bought 15y ago with a 100% mortgage with Northern Rock and sold our flat 1y later and bought this house. Still with Northern Rock at that time and no deposit. The market literally crashed just after we moved into our house.

We have no plans to move. We do co own a 2nd property with land through inheritance mortgage free.

Without a 100% mortgage, there is no way we could have bought as easily.

Blossomtoes · 14/02/2022 21:21

@User0458832

Retirement flats are where you go to die
Yes. But a perfectly reasonable option if you’re 85. Like @XingMing, I suspect that’s where we’ll end up in our mid to late 80s - my genes indicate that I’ll probably go on well into my 90s.
User0458832 · 14/02/2022 21:12

Retirement flats are where you go to die

XingMing · 14/02/2022 20:56

I should probably add, we're 65, not 85, and in good health. A retirement flat may be the best option one day, but that's probably 15 years away given our genes... we have three living parents, two in their 80s and one aged 92.

XingMing · 14/02/2022 20:51

I am the problem. We plan our retirement. We like our house but it's bigger than we need now since the DC flew the nest. But we don't want to live in a poky retirement property with tiny rooms and no storage space which is what seems to be expected of us. You are old and now irrelevant so move out and let someone else live in your (very nice) house. But I'm not trying to release money to live... I sorted that out 20 years ago, because I thought long and hard about how to achieve my goals.

I have a clear picture of what we want and need to buy as our last home and it has b*gger all to do with what McCarthy & Stone think I ought to want, but it still leaves us frantically reading Right Move several times a week.

Xenia · 14/02/2022 20:43

IN the case of my profession (law) the salaries after you had done 4 years (or 5 years) studying and 2 years training are about double in real terms what I got in the same job decades ago. (after allowing for inflation) because of student loan costs, wages jsut going up sky high (for the very few of us able to get those jobs) and presumably also because rents and house prices are so much higher in London than in the past.

So a £40k house we bought in 1984 with 2 full time professional salaries may be about £400k today (outer London) but the wage of each in the couple might well be £100k each in my profession so it remains doable. That is not the case in all jobs of course. Also we were paying interest rates up to over 13% a year and my current mortgage rate is 1.44% - a vast vast vastly smaller percentage.

I have also helped all 5 children to buy a first place.

00100001 · 14/02/2022 20:38

@OpheliaThrupps

But where's the money coming from? It would seem... Parents/grandparents neither directly by giving them money, or indirectly by letting them love with them for next to nothing.

This all artificially boosts spending power, surely?

Joe Bloggs just cannot afford to pay £650k for that 4 bed house.... but actually he, his wife and his parents can

.
If people weren't giving this money ...would house prices be this expensive? I'd say no. Because people just can't magic up an extra £50k so the houses wouldn't sell, so the prices wouldn't be so high...

OP posts:
OfstedOffred · 14/02/2022 20:23

So so many factors.

  • parental help/inheritance
  • people buying later, when their salaries are at peak in 30s and 40s.
  • inequality. Average wages reflect lots of people on very low incomes balancing out some people on much higher. The gap between low & higher earners has risen big time and the high earners are buying.
  • disparity around the country. plenty of 3 beds in the Midlands for 200k.
  • people moving from more expensive areas to cheaper ones
  • two incomes, and two good ones at that not a man in a decent job and a woman doing a few hours as a dinner lady which was more the norm years ago
PuttingOutFires · 14/02/2022 20:15

My husband and I losing all 4 of out parents by the time we were 32.

I'd swap the house for some grandparents for our kids 😔

Billandben444 · 14/02/2022 20:04

@Bringsexyback
Well, they've had their sporty Fiesta parked outside for a year and it's still got all its wheels and neither of them has been stabbed as yet - you're just being rude now about someone else's lifestyle choice so I'll leave you to it.

BulletTrain · 14/02/2022 19:39

This is the thing. Previously a 1 bed flat was fine for a couple, with one of the two people working from home in some sort of dedicated desk area/dining table. 2 though? It's got to be big enough for either 2 desks in the living room (lack of privacy) or have room for a desk in the bedroom.

Yabyboda · 14/02/2022 19:26

Like some PPs I lived in horrendous but cheap househsares so I could save more money, if I travelled home it was on the megabus so cheap but very bloody long and unsavoury. I ate like a student even though I had a (modest) full time wage coming in, didn't drink so night's out were cheap, cycled everywhere rather than take public transport; all stuff that isn't possible for everyone but I did everything I could to string a deposit together. I met DH and we ended up buying together, he was military so although he had to pay for accommodation and food it was cheaper than privately renting I suppose- but he avoided acting like a payday millionaire. Neither of us had any help from parents, we bought only a few years ago and made a lot of compromises on location and the house itself but are happy. Securing a mortgage was always important to me as we lived in rented accommodation growing up and I hated moving several times at the whim of the landlord.

00100001 · 14/02/2022 19:22

@TwoCoffeesPlease

My FTB is a 3 bed semi just me and my partner and I don’t for one second think that’s it is larger than “needed”.

It’s a small 3 bed and we have a kitchen, open plan lounge diner, WC and then the three bedrooms upstairs: one we sleep in and the other two we use as home offices for WFH/guest room.

Which bit of our house don’t we need?

If you'd said "It’s a small 3 bed and we have a kitchen, open plan lounge diner, WC and then the three bedrooms upstairs: one we sleep in and the other two; ONE is used as a home office and one a guest bedroom" then the guest bedroom would be a nice to have.

However, of you both need an office space, then it's needed...

Calm down

OP posts:
peaceanddove · 14/02/2022 18:39

Last year, DH inherited a very large sum when his Mum passed away. So, we're going to use some of it to give both our DDs very substantial house deposits when they leave university.

FloBot7 · 14/02/2022 18:31

@OpheliaThrupps

Hello *@WindyState*,

We're going round in circles, but how do you explain how people have been saving deposits and buying houses all through this time of alarming house-price inflation. You earlier said it was impossible.

(Incidentally, the graph doesn't prove your second (different) point either! Use the graph to turn the clock back to 2003. Or 1985. Look at the alarming gap that has opened up between wages and house prices. It very obviously can't possibly go on like that ...)

I obviously can't speak for everyone but for my DH he lost his mum when he was in his early 20s. His DF gifted him and his sister £30,000 from his mum's pension for a deposit. Traditionally I'd expect a father in his position to put that towards his own pension and then pass any inheritance to the next generation when the time comes. Instead DH was able to buy a 2 bed flat for 100k and 5 or 6 years later it was worth 180k. We then used the equity to buy a 3 bed house for 235k. It's been just over 5 years and it's about to go on the market for 290k.
TwoCoffeesPlease · 14/02/2022 18:23

My FTB is a 3 bed semi just me and my partner and I don’t for one second think that’s it is larger than “needed”.

It’s a small 3 bed and we have a kitchen, open plan lounge diner, WC and then the three bedrooms upstairs: one we sleep in and the other two we use as home offices for WFH/guest room.

Which bit of our house don’t we need?

MischievousBiscuits · 14/02/2022 17:53

We moved in with ILs to have a hope of being able to gather up a deposit, but in saying that I'm in NI where house prices are much lower than England, but still significantly higher than 5 or 10 years ago. Saving literally every penny, bar housekeeping, food, phone bills. A lot of people I speak to are in the exact same boat, or are getting gifts from parents to help out.

Bringsexyback · 14/02/2022 17:42

[quote Billandben444]@Bringsexyback
Knowing the Wirral, a 2 bed flat that isn’t like living in beruit would be £250,000. Good luck to them theyll need it, i hope they dont have nice cars parked outside
It's in Birkenhead where they both grew up and though not posh it's certainly not like Beirut! What a strange thing to say.[/quote]
Are used to live in Cleveland Street in Birkenhead I hope to goodness they’ve got a stab proof vest, Full of heroin attic‘s and just zombies walking around look Like that Robbie was soon as look at your last Halloween and bonfire night kids from Liskeard were driving over the bonnet of cars around the park people were getting the windows put end there’s a bloody good reason why that two bedroom flat was only 85 grand

WindyState · 14/02/2022 17:39

@OpheliaThrupps

Hello *@WindyState*,

We're going round in circles, but how do you explain how people have been saving deposits and buying houses all through this time of alarming house-price inflation. You earlier said it was impossible.

(Incidentally, the graph doesn't prove your second (different) point either! Use the graph to turn the clock back to 2003. Or 1985. Look at the alarming gap that has opened up between wages and house prices. It very obviously can't possibly go on like that ...)

Yes, we are going around in circles. For a start, I didn't say it was impossible for everyone.

If you have help you can manage. If you have a high enough salary you can manage. However, it is completely undeniable that young people have a much, much harder time of it now than they did 20 years ago and the massive discrepency between house price growth and wage growth (which is far wider now than it has ever been) is the key factor in all of this.

Home ownership has halved for the under 25s compared to 20 years ago. There is a reason for this and it's not because young people can't be arsed to save money.

Billandben444 · 14/02/2022 17:39

@Bringsexyback
Knowing the Wirral, a 2 bed flat that isn’t like living in beruit would be £250,000. Good luck to them theyll need it, i hope they dont have nice cars parked outside
It's in Birkenhead where they both grew up and though not posh it's certainly not like Beirut! What a strange thing to say.

FateHasRedesignedMost · 14/02/2022 17:39

I think a lot of buyers save up for the deposit and work their way up in their careers until in their 30s/40s, then buy the large house.

It’s not unusual amongst my social circle, we all had our first babies when living in small rental flats and bought houses when we were earning enough to afford the mortgages.

onedayoranother · 14/02/2022 17:34

I think more houses are bought by two working people, whereas a generation or more ago it was one.
Also it's who is buying: my husband (a well paid city lawyer) and I ought our family home from two teachers. I sold it to bankers. We couldn't have afforded to buy it at what we sold it for, and the teachers couldn't have afforded to buy it for what they sold it to us for.
I now live in a small, comfortable (now, as it was not built with indoor plumbing) terraced house that cost just under £1m (sw London), it was probably originally built for lower middle class workers.
My friends and I all bought as soon as we had jobs in the 80s. Some had a deposit from parents, some bought with friends. 20 years later not one of the same age group could afford to buy the equivalent until much later in their careers, but they still bought.

BulletTrain · 14/02/2022 17:34

*Not necessarily - the more deposit you have the better the interest rate.

If you have a 90% mortgage vs a 75% mortgage - your rate will be better. Of course, an individual may go and get a stonking new mortgage putting them back to a 90% rate but I'd say most don't. Point is with increase value in your home you have more options.*

I don't understand.
The person in the original house that has gone up to £150k would just remortgage onto a new rate at 75% LTV or whatever it may be. If you change lender, it gets valued. You don't need to move.

Swipe left for the next trending thread